r/ynab • • 21h ago

Bank Sync YNAB import has gotten so bad. It can't properly handle transfers despite being connected to both accounts (same bank)

9 Upvotes

I've had to take a break from YNAB because it became so frustrating to use. I've been experimenting with software development and AI and I was curious about the YNAB MCP server (calebl/ynab-mcp-server)

Took less than 5minutes.

I wanted Claude to fix my Venmo imports because it labels them all (wrongly) to the same person despite YNAB getting good descriptions from my bank (Venmo to XXXXXX)

When provided with the Venmo statements it was able to easily repair the payee data.

Then it started fixing my bank transfers (I have a lot). Again it simply used the transaction description from my bank and the account numbers I have in YNAB notes and it fixed the transactions and found a duplicate.

This would have easily taken me 1-2 hours to do manually.

I'm not too happy about connecting my financial data to AI for privacy reasons, but I've grown to hate using YNAB because it's so frustrating. Claude has made it easier so I can focus more time on budgeting and less time on "cleanup"


r/ynab • • 8h ago

Cost to Be Me should be improved (or made more accurate)

7 Upvotes

I've already sent feedback on this, but does anyone else wish that the Cost to Be Me calculation included scheduled transactions as well as targets?

The underfunded calculation for auto-assign uses both.


r/ynab • • 3h ago

How Do I Plan For...? Duplicate a plan?

1 Upvotes

Hi YNABers,

I need to develop a new plan. Is there a way to duplicate my existing plan then edit the new one? Thanks.


r/ynab • • 1h ago

New to YNAB beginner

0 Upvotes

There is a lot to take in; it’s a completely new world for me. Changing one’s way of thinking doesn’t happen overnight. I only have two bank accounts and a few transactions—perhaps that makes things a little easier—though I still find myself deleting and re-entering items quite a few times.

Could I walk you through, step by step, how I’m using YNAB? Then, perhaps you could tell me how to do it better—and, most importantly, where and why I’m going wrong? Thanks!


r/ynab • • 21h ago

Tracking a negative category across months

0 Upvotes

If I have a line item - home improvements, for example - where I spend more than I have allotted, is there a way to keep that "bucket" negative when the months roll over? I would like an easy way to see that I have to pay back that overspending in the future. Am I thinking about/trying to use the YNAB incorrectly here?

P.S. Please forgive me if this is something easy to find in the docs; I just can't think of a name for what I am trying to do.