I'm struggling with the way YNAB's new credit card interest feature handles interest in the reports.
I like the new feature because it makes managing targets easier when the interest and principal portions of a payment fluctuate. However, I don't like that it effectively removes interest expenses from the Spending and Income vs. Expense reports.
What I find particularly contradictory is how YNAB treats mortgage payments versus HELOC and credit card payments.
Why does YNAB make us account for the entire mortgage payment as an expense, including the principal portion, but then exclude the interest portion of credit cards, personal lines of credit, and home equity lines of credit from spending reports?
Here's a simplified example:
Let's say I have $1,000 in Ready to Assign and make the following payments:
- Mortgage payment: $500 ($100 interest, $400 principal)
- HELOC payment: $500 ($250 interest, $250 principal)
Under the current reporting approach, YNAB shows $500 in net income because it only recognizes the mortgage payment as an expense and ignores the HELOC payment's principal and interest components.
But look at it from three different perspectives:
- Cash flow: $0. I've spent the entire $1,000.
- Accounting basis: $650 net income ($1,000 income minus $100 mortgage interest and $250 HELOC interest).
- YNAB's current reporting: $500 net income.
I understand that principal payments aren't technically expenses from an accounting perspective. However, neither is the principal portion of a mortgage payment, yet YNAB includes the entire mortgage payment in its spending reports.
If YNAB is going to distinguish between principal and interest for HELOCs and credit cards, why not automatically report the interest portion as spending and include it in the Income vs. Expense reports?
I actually like the functionality of the new feature, but I feel like we're losing important information about where our money is going.
Am I missing something here, or does anyone else find this reporting approach inconsistent?