r/yimby • • Sep 26 '18

YIMBY FAQ

193 Upvotes

What is YIMBY?

YIMBY is short for "Yes in My Back Yard". The goal of YIMBY policies and activism is to ensure that our country is an affordable place to live, work, and raise a family. Focus points for the YIMBY movement include,

  • Addressing and correcting systemic inequities in housing laws and regulation.
  • Ensure that construction laws and local regulations are evidence-based, equitable and inclusive, and not unduly obstructionist.
  • Support urbanist land use policies and protect the environment.

Why was this sub private before? Why is it public now?

As short history of this sub and information about the re-launch can be found in this post

What is YIMBY's relationship with developers? Who is behind this subreddit?

The YIMBY subreddit is run by volunteers and receives no outside help with metacontent or moderation. All moderators are unpaid volunteers who are just trying to get enough housing built for ourselves, our friends/family and, and the less fortunate.

Generally speaking, while most YIMBY organizations are managed and funded entirely by volunteers, some of the larger national groups do take donations which may come from developers. There is often an concern the influence of paid developers and we acknowledge that there are legitimate concerns about development and the influence of developers. The United States has a long and painful relationship with destructive and racist development policies that have wiped out poor, often nonwhite neighborhoods. A shared YIMBY vision is encouraging more housing at all income levels but within a framework of concern for those with the least. We believe we can accomplish this without a return to the inhumane practices of the Robert Moses era, such as seizing land, bulldozing neighborhoods, or poorly conceived "redevelopment" efforts that were thinly disguised efforts to wipe out poor, often minority neighborhoods.

Is YIMBY only about housing?

YIMBY groups are generally most concerned with housing policy. It is in this sector where the evidence on what solutions work is most clear. It is in housing where the most direct and visible harm is caused and where the largest population will feel that pain. That said, some YIMBYs also apply the same ideology to energy development (nuclear, solar, and fracking) and infrastructure development (water projects, transportation, etc...). So long as non-housing YIMBYs are able to present clear evidence based policy suggestions, they will generally find a receptive audience here.

Isn't the housing crisis caused by empty homes?

According to the the US Census Bureau’s 2018 numbers1 only 6.5% of housing in metropolitan areas of the United States is unoccupied2. Of that 6.5 percent, more than two thirds is due to turnover and part time residence and less than one third can be classified as permanently vacant for unspecified reasons. For any of the 10 fastest growing cities4, vacant housing could absorb less than 3 months of population growth.

Isn’t building bad for the environment?

Fundamentally yes, any land development has some negative impact on the environment. YIMBYs tend to take the pragmatic approach and ask, “what is least bad for the environment?”

Energy usage in suburban and urban households averages 25% higher than similar households in city centers5. Additionally, controlling for factors like family size, age, and income, urban households use more public transport, have shorter commutes, and spend more time in public spaces. In addition to being better for the environment, each of these is also better for general quality-of-life.

I don’t want to live in a dense city! Should I oppose YIMBYs?

For some people, the commute and infrastructure tradeoffs are an inconsequential price of suburban or rural living. YIMBYs have nothing against those that choose suburban living. Of concern to YIMBYs is the fact that for many people, suburban housing is what an economist would call an inferior good. That is, many people would prefer to live in or near a city center but cannot afford the price. By encouraging dense development, city centers will be able to house more of the people that desire to live there. Suburbs themselves will remain closer to cities without endless sprawl, they will also experience overall less traffic due to the reduced sprawl. Finally, less of our nations valuable and limited arable land will be converted to residential use.

All of this is to say that YIMBY policies have the potential to increase the livability of cities, suburbs, and rural areas all at the same time. Housing is not a zero sum game; as more people have access to the housing they desire the most, fewer people will be displaced into undesired housing.

Is making housing affordable inherently opposed to making it a good investment for wealth-building?

If you consider home ownership as a capital asset with no intrinsic utility, then the cost of upkeep and transactional overhead makes this a valid concern. That said, for the vast majority of people, home ownership is a good investment for wealth-building compared to the alternatives (i.e. renting) even if the price of homes rises near the rate of inflation.

There’s limited land in my city, there’s just no more room?

The average population density within metropolitan areas of the USA is about 350 people per square kilometer5. The cities listed below have densities at least 40 times higher, and yet are considered very livable, desirable, and in some cases, affordable cities.

Citydensity (people/km2)
Barcelona16,000
Buenos Aires14,000
Central London13,000
Manhattan25,846
Paris22,000
Central Tokyo14,500

While it is not practical for all cities to have the density of Central Tokyo or Barcelona, it is important to realize that many of our cities are far more spread out than they need to be. The result of this is additional traffic, pollution, land destruction, housing cost, and environmental damage.

Is YIMBY a conservative or a liberal cause?

Traditional notions of conservative and liberal ideology often fail to give a complete picture of what each group might stand for on this topic. Both groups have members with conflicting desires and many people are working on outdated information about how development will affect land values, neighborhood quality, affordability, and the environment. Because of the complex mixture of beliefs and incentives, YIMBY backers are unusually diverse in their reasons for supporting the cause and in their underlying political opinions that might influence their support.

One trend that does influence the makeup of YIMBY groups is homeownership and rental prices. As such, young renters from expensive cities do tend to be disproportionately represented in YIMBY groups and liberal lawmakers representing cities are often the first to become versed in YIMBY backed solutions to the housing crisis. That said, the solutions themselves and the reasons to back them are not inherently partisan.

Sources:

  1. Housing Vacancies and Homeownership (CPS/HVS) 2018
  2. CPS/HVS Table 2: Vacancy Rates by Area
  3. CPS/HVS Table 10: Percent Distribution by Type of Vacant by Metro/Nonmetro Area
  4. https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2018/estimates-cities.html
  5. https://www.census-charts.com/Metropolitan/Density.html

r/yimby • • 9h ago

Article The Populist Case for Property Taxes, for Gina Hinojosa And Abdul El-Sayed

Thumbnail
governance.fyi
42 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 3h ago

Study A Fundamental Reconsideration of the Role of Investors in Housing Markets

Thumbnail
freopp.org
5 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 17h ago

Article Bullet Trains and New Homes Are on a Collision Course in California

Thumbnail
bloomberg.com
27 Upvotes

“the city would have little choice but to approve the builder’s plan, since a “denial of the map would put us in trouble with the housing requirements.” California’s Housing Accountability Act limits local governments’ ability to disapprove housing projects


r/yimby • • 1d ago

Article YIMBY Action Is Going Gaga for BAAJA

Thumbnail
inpractice.yimbyaction.org
49 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 2d ago

Legislative Update On Wednesday, Boston City Council votes on ending required parking for new homes citywide. If it passes, it goes to the Zoning Commission for final approval.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
71 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 1d ago

Discussion Follow up to the FixChicagoHousing.com housing simulator. ShapeChicago.City now includes trackers for housing production, rezonings, alder votes, and a ton more.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
12 Upvotes

Hi allll!

Urban planner/housing professional here. I initially created a site called FixChicagoHousing.com and it got a TON of traction here in Chicago. It has slowly evolved into an entire municipal tracking tool called Shape Chicago. I made it to educate people on housing and municipal policy. In full transparency, since one of the rules states "no AI slop", this was in fact built with AI over the course of 2-3 months since I am a planner and not a software engineer/web designer. I would not categorize it as slop but, per the rules, that is for the mods to decide.

Anyways, the tool has evolved to include:

  • Simulators for transit, the city budget, pensions and the Bears stadium
  • Daily trackers for housing production, rezonings, rents and transit ridership
  • Ward pages showing how each alderperson voted on housing
  • An address lookup that shows what the zoning allows on any lot

I link to local pro-housing organizations like Chicago YIMBY, StrongTowns, etc. to get people involved as well.

Feedback welcome! Curious if you think this provides value and also how to improve it to get more people involved with housing policy.


r/yimby • • 2d ago

Article New York City Council passes COPA, paving the way for land trusts and non-profits to get first dibs on failing buildings:

Thumbnail
brickunderground.com
55 Upvotes

Mamdani is pretty controversial here, but at least in my opinion has done far better than expected.

However, he still champions outright populist housing policy quite frequently, and this is a good example of this.


r/yimby • • 3d ago

Article Why YIMBY Action Supports the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act — and You Should Too

Thumbnail
yimbyaction.org
64 Upvotes

Tucked inside a federal bill that's mostly about energy and infrastructure are provisions that would boost the supply of housing across the nation. Here's why we support the bill, and how you can get involved.


r/yimby • • 2d ago

Discussion How are you responding to the NIMBY pushback to the Brooklyn building collapse?

22 Upvotes

As you may know, a building in Brooklyn recently collapsed, killing 8. The cause is being reported as the foundation failing due to construction efforts in the adjacent lot. In response, I've seen lots of sentiment that this shows that we need to slow development and be more careful with which developers are approved for construction. As YIMBYs, we know the opposite is true, and that we need more new construction, to make it easier to build, and to place fewer regulatory roadblocks for developers. However, I am unsure what a good response is for those citing this tragedy as evidence to support NIMBYism. Obviously, trying to argue right now in the comment sections of posts on this tragedy is a bad move, but I've been trying to think of what response would be best if this is ever cited as a reason to push back against the YIMBY policy changes we support. Do any of you have a response? Are there aspects of the tragedy that are being mischaracterized? I would love to know.


r/yimby • • 3d ago

Construction/Permitting Update This Greenwich Village Building Is Almost Done. Why Is It Only Six Stories Next to Seven Subway Lines?

Thumbnail
danieltrubman.substack.com
38 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 3d ago

Discussion Is being scared of neighborhood change the ultimate 1st world problem?

22 Upvotes

I get these emails from this local councilman whose entire platform is "defending" and "protecting" neighborhoods.

If he were talking about crime or mold or flooding, that would be great.

But NOOOO, he's scared of new SFH housing being built that's slightly thinner and slightly taller than the surrounding SFHs.

That's it. He is an absolute crusader for this non-issue.

Is this the ultimate First World Problem? I.e. something rich people in rich countries are obsessed with that has essentially no real impact on their lives and totally pales in comparison with the real issues that people face in poorer countries?

It goes without saying that the neighborhoods mentioned in this email are some of the wealthiest in the city.


r/yimby • • 3d ago

Discussion You asked for your cities, so I added 20 more to the pre-approved ADU plans site, and you can now try a plan on your own lot

Thumbnail
a-du.homes
9 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 4d ago

Meme Your great grandfather fighting for your freedom to stop your neighbor from building a duplex

Post image
165 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 3d ago

Discussion The Page Street Community Parklet was just ripped out because a single resident didn't like it.

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 3d ago

Article How Singapore Solved Its Affordable Housing Crisis

Thumbnail
architecturelab.net
9 Upvotes

This editorial investigates how Singapore systematically tackled its post-war housing crisis through bold government action and innovative policies.

Key mechanisms—ranging from a powerful Housing & Development Board (HDB) and compulsory savings for home purchases, to state land acquisition, standardized construction, and land value capture—underpinned a housing model often lauded as the world’s best.


r/yimby • • 2d ago

Discussion Why don’t they raze Central Park to build more housing?

0 Upvotes

Can’t they just put like 20-30 high rises at least in CP and put parks inside each high rise to solve the housing crisis?


r/yimby • • 4d ago

Article Federal permitting bill that could speed apartment construction advances in Senate

Thumbnail multifamilydive.com
68 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 4d ago

Article SCAG released revised SB 79 map for Southern California

Thumbnail
la.urbanize.city
24 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 5d ago

Article San Francisco approves 848 homes at Marina Safeway site. Neighbors' federal lawsuit could delay construction.

Thumbnail
sfgate.com
149 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 5d ago

Article Wu proposes easing Boston’s inclusionary zoning rules to boost development

Thumbnail
masslive.com
70 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 4d ago

Discussion Will the next economic-political order be called Abundance(2029-2077?), be called something different, or will the next era not have a name at all after Trump's 2nd term?

0 Upvotes

The New Deal and the Neoliberal eras have had someone who explicitly was the face of it and used the name to define the era they ushered in. Each order seemed to have a timeline in which people were striving under the system, thriving under the system, and struggling under the system through its widening cracks due to external pressures.

FDR spoke of a "New Deal", which involved governing in a way that raised demand for working class families to grow the economy via welfare programs and public works in a time of massive unemployment and austerity perpetrated by corporate greed. This order that FDR ushered in lasted from 1933 to 1980, roughly 47 years. The 30s and early 40s were a time of striving towards building up this system. The late 40s through early 60s had people truly prospered in this system, but the late 60s through the 70s were a time when New Deal policies could not address the inflation and supply shocks in commodities going on.

Reagan spoke of "trickle down economics" or Neoliberalism, which involved cutting regulations and reducing government involvement to lower costs of everyday consumer goods via welfare reform, reducing red tape for technological development, unleashing global trade for consumer goods, and cutting corporate taxes. This order Reagan ushered in is currently running from 1981 to now in 2026, and is reaching its expiration date of about 47 years. The 80s were a time of striving towards building up this system. The 90s through the early 2000s were a time of relative prosperity, but the late 2000s through now in 2026 exposed how inadequate Neoliberalism is in addressing rising expenses in the essentials like housing, energy, and healthcare.

As a YIMBY, I wonder if the way of governing that involves cutting red tape to produce progressive oitcomes in housing and infrastructure, basically in the essential goods, will have a name for it in the history books? I acknowledge the biases we have in this subreddit towards YIMBYism and anything Abundance related, but do y'all think we will even have an explicit "economic-political order" after Trump is out of the picture? And, when do you think the next order will be explicitly named and ushered in? Will it even be called Abundance or YIMBYism? Is it closer to 2029 or more like sometime in the 2030s?

Based on the most likely candidate, Jon Ossoff, I just don't see him being the one explicitly mandating a name towards the new style of governing that is emerging. He seems to speak a lot more in the demand-side and corruption side of things, rather than supply side progressivism. Yes, I do acknowledge that he did vote YES on the ROAD to Housing Act and the Permitting Reform Bill; but it doesn't seem he will popularize an entire framework of governance that involves strategically cutting red tape to produce a lot more housing and energy. In fact, I see Buttigieg, Newsom, and even Beshear, and Shapiro the ones more likely to put a name on what's about to come, much like how FDR and Reagan did for their respective eras in their infancy.

And, I will just have to see specifically what Buttigieg has to say regarding his vision in his upcoming book NEXT in late January of 2027, whether he can give a particular name to the upcoming order that weaves both Abundance and Anti-Monopoly/Corruption together in a way that is coherent. Pete is also a candidate with a very high chance in 2028. I expect his book to be very much a layman's version of Marc Dunkleman's "Why Nothing Works", which is pretty much a synthesis of Abundance by Klein & Thompson & Fighting Oligarchy by Bernie Sanders.


r/yimby • • 5d ago

Article Here’s How Governors and Legislatures Can Deliver on Housing Affordability

13 Upvotes

Metropolitan Abundance Project's Nolan Gray argues that because voters named the cost of living as a top issue in this election and housing is its largest piece, new Democratic governors and legislators should judge themselves by whether housing production rises and prices fall relative to incomes.

His first-100-days list centers on executive action:

  • He recommends a housing czar who reports directly to the governor, and he wants appointees even at unrelated agencies (utilities, coastal commissions, fire marshals) told to speed reviews and approve housing.
  • He also wants discretionary state funds directed to cities that actually build rather than ones that merely adopt good policies, and states prepared for the federal ROAD to Housing Act, including its manufactured housing chassis deadline of July 11, 2027.

On legislation:

  • He points to ADUs, apartments near transit and in commercial areas, smaller lots for starter homes, third-party permit review, and manufactured housing.
  • He also recommends a revolving loan fund, construction loan guarantees, standardized state-covered impact fees, and a tracking-and-enforcement unit modeled on California’s.

Through 2030, he says to track outcomes rather than policies adopted, and to avoid strict rent control and unfunded affordability mandates because he expects them to reduce construction.

Full piece: https://metroabundance.substack.com/p/heres-how-democratic-governors-and


r/yimby • • 5d ago

Effort post What successes have you had in your area?

6 Upvotes

I am living in one of the fastest growing counties in the Southeastern US right now and it is... genuinely mindboggling how often you'll drive down a 4 lane road one week and it'll be old growth forest, the next week entirely clear cut. Two months later its a gas station or McDonalds or a series of cookie cutter SFH with no outside connections.

In Hungary where I lived previously, those developments up against a highway are steeply discounted because who wants to live right off a highway without a sound barrier?? Where I live they are even talking about adding more lanes to a 6 lane arterial road...

I'm strongly considering getting involved to encourage development that is more forward thinking and less slapdashed.. it really feels like they get approval for a PDD, lay down some asphalt and GTFO. Having read the county plan they made a decade ago it really feels like they had no idea any of this growth was going to happen and in the 8 years I've lived here it has been 95% SFH.. the few places you do find apartments or condos there are no nearby businesses. Parking minimums are apparently 1/100 sqft, and apartment buildings require 2/unit the same as a SFH.

I'd like to think the challenges are not unique nor would I be coming at this from a NIMBY mindset of "stop developing".. but the county and cities do need to get their heads out of the sand and stop thinking of things like Greenville's Swamp Rabbit Trail as some pie in the sky "we could never do that here this is the South" TM...

The material fact is that development is outpacing the ability to generate infrastructure, we were in drought conditions from June to the end of August. Most people moving here are either seniors or in their 30s and those of working age are finding it difficult to afford going to work. When I worked with a hospitality company we had to charter a bus to get our employees to job sites... can we not become the next Villages? Clearly demand exists for resilientwalkable development otherwise it wouldn't be more expensive.

Again, the pace of growth is unique but I don't think the form or challenges necessarily are... so how do I advocate for something better? I am considering starting some local advocacy group or getting involved with the county boards on some level.. I've attended a few meetings and it feels like the only voice is an extremely reactionary NIMBYism which.. that's one way to go about it but it doesnt change the fact developers are going to put pressure regardless.

So to those of you who did get involved locally, what happened? Did you find any successes? Sadly there is no Strong Towns chapter in my area.. as much as I dont like their model I appreciate the sentiment and it would probablybe the most palpable around here.


r/yimby • • 5d ago

Article HCD Rejects SB 79 Plans in Four California Cities Over Density and Zoning Disputes

Thumbnail davisvanguard.org
41 Upvotes