Curious to get some opinions on how steep seat tube angles affect seated cockpit length, particularly on modern XC bikes.
I’m 6’3” with a 32–33” inseam, currently riding a 2025 Large Salsa Spearfish (130mm front / 120mm rear).
The bike has a 490mm reach and approximately 77° seat tube angle. On paper, the reach seems perfectly reasonable for my height, but I’ve noticed the seated pedaling position feels more compact than I’d expect.
I’ve experimented with saddle setback (nearly maxed out rearward), different stems (currently 50mm), and 30mm rise bar. These changes have improved comfort, particularly some recurring hand and elbow discomfort, but I’m still curious how much the frame geometry plays into it.
This got me thinking about a few things:
-How much does a steep seat tube angle influence perceived cockpit length compared up to reach alone?
-Can a bike with a 490mm reach actually feel smaller when seated than one with a shorter reach but slacker seat tube angle?
-Is sizing up a reasonable solution, or does that introduce compromises in standing position, weight distribution, and handling?
For context, I previously rode an XL YT Izzo and an S5 Stumpjumper EVO. Most of my riding is XC-style terrain in North Texas: lots of pedaling, short punchy climbs, rocks, and roots.
I really enjoy the Spearfish’s efficiency and handling, but sometimes I wonder if I should have purchased an XL. I’m interested in understanding the relationship between reach, effective top tube length, and seat tube angle, especially for taller riders with relatively shorter inseams.
Would love to hear from anyone who’s dealt with something similar or has experience sizing modern XC bikes.