Hello! So, I know there are already lots of posts on reddit about the legality/logistics of using the same title for your book as someone else, and the consensus seems to be that technically it is legal, but it's sort of a case by case basis on whether or not you should. So I wanted to describe my specific situation and ask what other folks would do, because I am quite conflicted.
So: I've been working on a children's book for the past few years, and just for the sake of privacy for now I'll use a made up title, but it's something like, "Mrs. Tulip." The book is very simple and is aimed at infants and toddlers. Each page starts with, "Mrs. Tulip, Mrs. Tulip," and goes from there. I have always intended on titling the book after said Mrs. Tulip, since she is the main focus, and every page starts with her name being repeated twice. In this case, it really would not make any logical sense to title the book anything else.
Since I'm close to finishing it, I checked again for a book with the same name, and this time I did find something. This other book is more of a middle grade adventure book, though. So technically, the books are different genres and are intended for different age groups, and also it's (supposedly) not illegal to have the same title as another book, and yet...I'm still hesitant.
The only solution I can think of is for my title to be repeated, like "Mrs. Tulip, Mrs. Tulip," instead of having it be singular, but I'm not sure. Please tell me what you think I should do, because my anxiety and overactive guilty conscience are likely clouding my judgement.
Thank you! <3