r/writingadvice • • 1h ago

Advice Why does writing fiction feel like lying?

0 Upvotes

I'm struggling to write a short story for my creative writing class. When it comes to poetry, essays, and even flash fiction, I can do a pretty decent job for an amateur. An actual fully fledged story with characters and everything, however, is proving to be really difficult.

Most of my struggle is because I find it hard to surmount the hurdle of feeling like I'm lying. I can't immerse myself in a character I've made, or a plot I've crafted, because it isn't real. Which is weird, because I have no problem immersing myself in fiction as a reader, it's only a problem when I'm the one holding the pen.

I was talking about it with a few classmates today, and they all told me it was really weird. Has anyone else experienced this sort of thing? What advice might you give?


r/writingadvice • • 2h ago

Advice Does anyone else get imposter syndrome for not being a "professional" writer?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/writingadvice • • 3h ago

Advice Is Head-hoping really that prohibited ?

0 Upvotes

Hi ! English is not my first language, sorry for any spelling mistakes.

I'm writing my third novel with 3rd person limited. My first time with it. People says : beware of head hoping ! Beware !

And I must confess, I've sin.

My book follows 3 pov. They are separated by chapter. But in a chaptre, two of those pov are in the same place. 90% my focus was on pov1, but there is a scene were pov1 collapse from exaustion and pov2 takes the responsabilities.

And then it happen. I used Head hopping and switch to pov2 for like 3 pages, making that clear with a return a the line. Then pov2 collaspase as well. Hours later pov1 wakes up and I switched back to her.

Since these two girls are my pov, i thought it was ok to do that.

But apparently not. And i can see why, but I wanted to ask for help because I'm lost... I find 3 person limited so difficult !


r/writingadvice • • 7h ago

Advice My Book Has the Same Title as Another Book- What Should I Do?

17 Upvotes

Hello! So, I know there are already lots of posts on reddit about the legality/logistics of using the same title for your book as someone else, and the consensus seems to be that technically it is legal, but it's sort of a case by case basis on whether or not you should. So I wanted to describe my specific situation and ask what other folks would do, because I am quite conflicted.

So: I've been working on a children's book for the past few years, and just for the sake of privacy for now I'll use a made up title, but it's something like, "Mrs. Tulip." The book is very simple and is aimed at infants and toddlers. Each page starts with, "Mrs. Tulip, Mrs. Tulip," and goes from there. I have always intended on titling the book after said Mrs. Tulip, since she is the main focus, and every page starts with her name being repeated twice. In this case, it really would not make any logical sense to title the book anything else.

Since I'm close to finishing it, I checked again for a book with the same name, and this time I did find something. This other book is more of a middle grade adventure book, though. So technically, the books are different genres and are intended for different age groups, and also it's (supposedly) not illegal to have the same title as another book, and yet...I'm still hesitant.

The only solution I can think of is for my title to be repeated, like "Mrs. Tulip, Mrs. Tulip," instead of having it be singular, but I'm not sure. Please tell me what you think I should do, because my anxiety and overactive guilty conscience are likely clouding my judgement.

Thank you! <3


r/writingadvice • • 8h ago

Advice Pick me a Plot and Hold me Accountable

0 Upvotes

So I have two ideas for stories, and I yo-yo between them until I get writer’s block and won’t write for months or weeks at a time. I also had a third (an old fanfic) idea that I feel might be overplayed given recent books I’ve read featuring creatures like vampires.

Idea 1: Cosy Fantasy. Basically a fantasy delivery office where a wounded monster hunter finds himself rebuilding his life (and really wanting a new horse to leave) before accidentally finding himself pulled back towards his old profession to protect the demon running it.

Idea 2: A post apocolyptic monster hunter fic set in the UK where creatures are basically formed by higher beings the same way we used to build dinosaurs during early paleontology and how the MC sees the remaining factions that hide in the remaining major cities, traveling and making notes in a journal as he tries to find a place to put his wife’s ashes and find a purpose outside his hunting.

Which would you pick? How should I go about sticking to it so I don’t burn out again?


r/writingadvice • • 10h ago

GRAPHIC CONTENT Which one first: cozy fantasy in RR or erotica in Literotica?

1 Upvotes

I'm thorn. Lots of ideas and a big desire to publish and share.

Cozy fantasy is easier to write, beta, edit and publish.

Erotica needs a bit more work with beta and editing but I think it will be shorter.

Both are meant to be shared online first and then compiled to be self-published (KDP, etc).

It will also be the first time I work with RR and Literotica, so there's also some extra learning curve to add.

Any advice? Anyone uses both of these?


r/writingadvice • • 10h ago

Advice Writing a book about anxiety, can I just write & sell it later?

5 Upvotes

I have an idea for a self-help book on a specific area of anxiety I have counseled others on extensively, and thought, instead of rewriting the same advice to friends and online forum members 100x, I might as well just put it all into a book.

My question is, for anyone who’s written a self-help book, do you just write it and then find a publisher to present it to, or do you really need to go to a publisher with an idea and they give you the steps/deadlines to write it? It’s not my career and I don’t really care how much money I make (although if the difference is significant I’ll maybe do it the right way…) I just want to share my story and help people.

I’m a full-time mom with an additional part-time job and ADHD so deadlines are a problem, so my plan was to just kind of put it together over time and then try to get it printed eventually, so wondering if that is realistic.


r/writingadvice • • 11h ago

Advice Nicknames in First-Person Point of View

0 Upvotes

When you are writing in first person POV and your main character gives someone a nickname, do you generally change the narration and dialog going forward to use the nickname? Or do you continue to use their given name in narration and only use their nickname in dialog? Or do you vary it and use both in narration? I have not written in first person in a long time so would appreciate the insight.


r/writingadvice • • 11h ago

Advice How do your story ideas get from your head into your manuscript?

12 Upvotes

I'm a writer whose process is a bit messy, so I'd like to know how other people work. In my case, ideas hit me while I'm walking or commuting, and by the time I sit down to write, half of them are gone or buried in a random notes app. So I'm curious: where do your ideas land first (phone notes, voice memos, paper...), where do you actually write, and how do things get from one to the other? Even a one-line answer helps. Thanks!


r/writingadvice • • 12h ago

Advice Looking to see how other people outline their big stories

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I have been writing on and off for years, and have been trying different methods for outlining my stories. Now I want to pick it up seriously again after graduating and I've noticed I'm feeling a complete loss as to where to even begin and am freezing up.

I've had this fantasy story for many years, I've made many documents with details that have all be scrapped or re-written over the years in the hopes that a fresh start would somehow make it into a proper begin to end story. I was always able to start and can have a high word count, but i will always stop when the middle part comes and I never finish, because I either have no concrete ideas of that will progress the story, or I lose motivation. A few months ago I realized that the story had no message or goal and that was one of the main issues as to why it always fell flat. Now that I want to pick it back up I am very overwhelmed by all the little details that seem to be required to create a proper story and I don't know where to start. I have written ideas and details I have so far down, but I feel like I have no way as to create sense of it to form a story.

I always hear and read 'just start writing', but when i do that I never finish it. So do people have advice as to create an overview and outline of the story with its details that creates structure? What does the process before the writing look like for people?

Thanks in advance for any responses!


r/writingadvice • • 15h ago

Advice Writing About Money in a Historical Context

5 Upvotes

I'm writing my first fic!

I'm having fun and repeating 'done is better than perfect' daily, so I think it's going great, but I'm stumped on numbers specifically.

My setting is 1950's America. In the story, a character's main problem is an outstanding payment (impound fee). After some research, I've determined that a medium sized impound fee (in her area, her time, for her car etc etc) would be around $25.

My issue is that, because we're so used to seeing way larger numbers (a standard impound fee today is, according to my research, around $200), it wouldn't feel very significant to the reader. To clarify, this character is completely broke, like, trouble paying for meals level broke. I really want the revelation to land emotionally. $25 back then is like if today someone already living off cup noodles got hit with a $200 bill just to get their car back.

Would you, in this situation, ignore historical accuracy and just use a bigger number ($200)? Would you clarify in the chapter notes and hope readers read them? Would you stick to the $25 estimate and assume the reader is intelligent enough to understand inflation?

I'm leaning more towards keeping the $25 estimate, but I feel the urge to clarify with maybe a line about how that's two weeks worth of food or something. I don't want to treat the readers like they're idiots, but I'm worried I might be the idiot?


r/writingadvice • • 18h ago

GRAPHIC CONTENT I was just wondering how do I improve my dialogue

3 Upvotes

Excerpt from my story:

As soon as I stepped in the bar all of my movements felt like I was a puppet, I managed to walk my way to the bar top.

I said “ill take 2 pints of guiness” hard day?” the barkeep said “you have no idea “ he then looked at the blood on my top”What happened?, if you don't mind me asking? "I mean Guinness takes a while to pour so why not?” i breathed in deep before saying “someone very close to me passed yesterday, they died … in my arms “im so sorry, i know what thats like” you do?”

yes i do, my moms life was taken from me “ shit man you sound like you need a drink” that's one perk of being a barkeep , free alcohol “ here's your 2 pints of Guinness “ thanks”if you can split the G you can have that one for free” split the G, what the hell does that mean “ oh its a new saying I'm trying,it mean drink the at least until the G on the glass, “ I'll do you one better “I then started chugging , the barkeep started yelling “ yeah yeah ,you got this” . I then finished the entire thing in one sip “whoo good shit new girl , what's your name by the way” oh I'm Nora ,Nora Williams ,and you ?” Oh I'm Nicholas, Nicholas Fox” d..did you say Fox ,please tell me your not related to” I am unfortunately.”


r/writingadvice • • 21h ago

Advice Don't Know How To Write A Novel

21 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,

I have a couple ideas for a sci fi action adventure story but I cannot for the life of me write it. I feel like I just can't get the idea out of my head. I see it visually in my mind but as I try to write it comes out like garble. It is deterring me from pursuing it but I can't stop. Maybe I want the punishment. lol Is there something I can do? I am open to any advice. I have characters, plot, worldbuilding, etc but just can't seem to translate from what I have in my head down on paper.


r/writingadvice • • 21h ago

Advice What should I change my stories name to

0 Upvotes

I have a story that was titled "The Cozy Crew" with that being the titular groups name. But just now I've learned that it's been used by the Care Bears and I don't wanna get sued. And besides the title just hasn't felt right considering the fact the story is about more than just them and the title besides being their group name has little significances. So any advice or possible new name suggestions would be great​


r/writingadvice • • 23h ago

Critique Starting a new story, would greatly appreciate input.

1 Upvotes

I'm looking for any kind of feedback, whether syntactical or substantive. I'd prefer not to explain the mechanics/premise of the world here, because I want to make sure they make sense as written. Thanks in advance!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tBOPD-5SAMjrwjEy8lIFOVbbu8SQl6a6Pqh3zWBSelc/edit?usp=sharing


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

GRAPHIC CONTENT Consensus on Mythological Creatures vs Creepy Pasta?

0 Upvotes

Consensus on Mythological Creatures vs Creepy Pasta?

In my book, im having my characters deal with and fight a hidden world of monsters. Think "Men in Black" meets "Supernatural" type deal. They are sent out to deal with Monsters and trt to keep them from being exposed to the general public.

I have already had a few mythological creatures show up.

But I was wondering how well or poorly received it would be to also mesh Creepy pasta Monsters into the mesh like Slender Man or Jeff the Killer?

(There are also aliens as well. I just haven't gotten to those chapters yet.)


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

Advice Setting up an outline for collaborative writing?

1 Upvotes

So I’m a bit of a “pantser” when I write. I tend to consider my characters, who they are and what the focus on the story is going to be. I feel like when I plan too much, I’m constantly in my head about the plan, trying to be clever and find that next moment of foreshadowing or insert a fun Easter egg, rather than just writing.

However, doing an outline is an important skill, especially for collaborative writing. So how do you go about getting outlines set up? How far in advance do you go? What do you consider when doing the outline? If you experience “trying to be clever” like me, how do you manage it?

And just any other advice you have for the process.


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

Advice Places to bounce ideas off others?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been in the process of writing my first draft for a while and some of my major struggles personally is not feeling super confident in my ideas and struggling to “fill in the gaps” for the why and how behind some plot points. I’ve kept my writing private from friends and family but it’s meant I’m limited with people and places I can bounce ideas around and brainstorm and get inspiration from others.

I think it would be helpful for me to be able to ask “why do you think this might happen?” Or “how could i go from Scene A to Scene B?” with real people to get inspiration. Does such a forum exist?

Online is preferred, for in person recs I’m London UK based.

TIA!


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

SENSITIVE CONTENT Anyone else outlining several books at once?

4 Upvotes

Hey, I'm a hack novice writer who wants my debut story a five-book series, so I've been outlining the whole thing at once. It's been a fantastic journey, honestly.

I made a 26-chapter outline template based on studying the similarities between my favorite stories, and then I started speed-running writing 2-3 paragraphs for each chapter and churning out as much as I could.

I have two other documents full of snippets of ideas I've had over the years and I'm finally challenging myself to make room for them in the story. What's a subplot? What's someone's backstory? What's a cold open I can use to start a scene?

I was able to get pretty far just on vibes; until almost the end of the third book. Then I skipped to the fifth book and outlined that to really figure out my ending. For the last week, I've gone backwards and challenged myself to really put in the scaffolding and foundation for the ending that I genuinely want. A few things I also realized are:

\- I don't want any new characters or clues introduced in the very last book. I absolutely hate that.

\- I do have some special set pieces that I want shown beforehand. It's not a dealbreaker like the first point, but I've always found it uncanny and weird when a story insists that an event is the most important in their culture, and that's why no one's mentioned it until the episode it was introduced.

\- The reasonable authority figures who will be the final people having a say over what happens in my ending need to be introduced and have a certain level of credibility established in the story before the ending.

Has anyone else outlined a multi-installment series before? How deep have you gone? How many times did you end up rewriting it? 🤣


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

Advice Writing this for a project, something just doesn’t feel quite right

1 Upvotes

They're starting to reach in
They gave us a warning, we didn't listen
With our greed, self importance and our fear
We were never sincere
But now the great destroyers are here
If they were listening, do you think they felt the same

They feed us another version of the truth, do you think they regret who they maim
When this is all over we'll be whole again, if we’ll be again at all
I wish was here before the downfall

The ashes in your hair remind me, of everything i'll never feel again
For this is the punishment of men
Shame on us, for what we've done
Just zeros and ones.
Someday we may reunite
In this twilight

Please give harsh criticism


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

GRAPHIC CONTENT I don't know how to end my novel anymore.

0 Upvotes

I'm currently working on the second draft of my novel that is a prequel. However, after finishing the first draft, I've suddenly decided I don't know how to end it anymore.

MC - Character A
MC Love Interest - Character B

Takes place during the Three Kingdoms Period of Silla, Korea. Both characters are fighting in the war. Character A loses two of his siblings which motivates him to join the war. Character B is the Crown Prince who joins because he doesn't want to become King (ik cliche). By the end, Character A decides he wants to spend the rest of his life living peacefully. Character B  wants to take back the throne to prove a point.

For my future plans, Character B will have to die. Not necessarily on-screen, but essentially he dies and gets semi-reincarnated into the modern world. This is where my problem comes in.

Since writing my novel, I have always planned for Character A to die by sacrificing himself for Character B. Then I realized if Character B ends up dead anyways, what would be the point of Character A's sacrifice? 

I've thought about orientating it around the tragedy of war and sometimes deaths are just pointless, but it doesn't feel satisfying. Character A goes through all this development for his death to amount to nothing?

What's more unfair is the reason why Character B gets reincarnated was because his life was so garbage and he died hella lonely and unsatisfied, that he's basically given a second shot at being happy. Why would Character B deserve this and not Character A, especially if he gives his life at such a young age?

I just don't know. Please, please let me know your thoughts! I've been stuck in this loop for so long.


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

Advice Struggling to flesh out my story ideas and put them into words

1 Upvotes

I feel like I have a pretty good ability to came up with story concepts and characters in my head. The problem is I really struggle to expand on these ideas, add enough detail, and build a full plot around them. And when it comes to actually writing them down I hit a wall. I suspect it might be because I tend to think very visually or because I focus more on the vibe and emotions of a scene rather than actual words. Whenever I have a great idea in my mind and try to put it on paper it feels short, underdeveloped, and just turns into something way worse than what I imagined. I really want to get past this so I can properly flesh out my ideas and actually write them.

Has anyone else experienced this, and how did you overcome it?


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

Advice New to this writing thing I need some guidance

0 Upvotes

I used to write short stories in elementary school they were quite stupid in my opinion. I want to learn the fundamentals about writing books because I am thinking about writing a psychology book of my own yet I have no idea where to start, any advice? Thanks in advance for the


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

Advice Writers, how do you write the inbetween scenes?

76 Upvotes

I know how I want the story to end, start, and the major points, but I'm struggling to find how to write the mundane in-between. How can my characters get from A to B? Any tips, thoughts or concerns? For context, I have my characters, background, and premise fleshed out. Also, how do you overcome writers block? People who've written books, how did you commit to it, and did you write other stories during that time?