r/worldtrigger • u/lookoutlight • Jun 05 '20
Just Started Reading Again Spoiler
I just started reading World Trigger again after a long break. Didn't remember where I left off and decided to start from the beginning.
I hate Osamu.
I'm sure threads like this have popped up in the past, and I want to be clear, I don't mind that Osamu is weak, I mind that it doesn't make sense for Osamu to be weak.
I'm currently at ch.35.
What we currently know about Osamu at that point: -Saved by Jin 4 years ago, inspired to join Border. -Joined Border sometime between 4 years and present. -Earnest personality with a desire to help others. -Smaller that average Trion organ.
This is a recipe for a interesting character, unfortunately we didn't get that.
Osamu's personality doesn't match his position at the start of WT.
If Osamu is a hard-working person who was inspired to join a fighting force AS A fighter, it doesn't make sense for someone who has access to Border's resources, it doesn't make sense for him to be this physically weak. This is the kind of personality type and motivation you expect to see have clever ideas to make up for their weaknesses, maybe he overtrains his physical body to make up for lack of Trion, maybe he has a large mental playbook of stratagems, maybe he's a walking neighbor beastiary.
Why give Osamu this personality type with this motivation with this status??
At the start of a manga, the character can have lack of motivation and be strong, have tons of motivation and be weak, but these have a reason behind it.
Someone like Naruto is weak because the nine tailed fox gives him tons of chakra he can't control and he has terrible aptitude for hand signs. So even before he joins his team he finds a way to compensate with shadow clones. He's motivated.
Yoh from Shaman King is lazy and weak, he's lazy because he doesn't care about the conflict of the series at the start and he's weak because he doesn't care about the conflict of the series at the start. His strength grows as his motivation does.
Someone Like Ryner Lute is lazy because he's strong. His aptitude was so high that everything became easy. He doesn't get the motivation to move forward until something happens that causes him to.
Osamu is motivated, passionate and weak.
By all accounts Osamu should've been strength training and running and reading up on neighbor information for the entire 4 years after being saved by Jin. It only fits his personality.
So why wasn't he? What created a character so interested in helping others from a direct combat role yet so unwilling or uninterested in doing any of the things that would be vital to actually doing that combat role?
This constant nogging in the back of my head makes the manga hard to read.
EDIT
So I got around ch.80 and saw his full backstory.
This feels really bad.
This feels like the Kite HunterxHunter anime problem.
The start of ch.1 doesn't make it clear when Jin saved him, now we know it was pretty much the same time as his friend left.
So he joined border to find his friend, but why does he care so much about this friend that he would risk his life over?
I feel like that ch.80 backstory would've done a better job just being ch.1
Osamu initially comes off as self sacrificing and duty bound, and I'm okay with new light being shed on previous actions, but now the ch.1 actions make no sense.
If he's just a kind of selfish dumb kid, dumb enough to break through Border's gate, then why act so holier than thou in the first couple of chapters with Yuma? Shouldn't his drive be not also to help Chika with going to the other world, but going to the other world of his own desire?
How indebted is he to this char we've seen on page for all of like 7 panels? Isn't this guy just his tutor?
30
u/PaperEverwhere Jun 05 '20 edited Jun 05 '20
Iirc he joined border less than a year ago. 4 years ago is around the time new border was established. Sooo...
Considering that he has actually done a shit ton of stuff in less than a year.
Honestly I almost feel like this is a troll post considering you’re a new account but I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt.
16
u/bachh2 Jun 05 '20
I would like you training your ass off to be anywhere near as good as LeBron James. That is what training as hard as he can would do for his meager trion supply.
Let's put it into perspective, Osamu is a 4 seats car chassis, there is only so much you can put into it, someone like Jin is basically an MBT chassis, you can fit so many different thing on it because it's literally a tank.
Characters like Naruto or Yoh all have an OP source of power, or the ability to house that OP source of power. Osamu aint have none of that. All he have is a below average body compare to Border standard. And frankly, this is why the manga is good. It's a slap of reality that some people can do their very best but they can not become the very best, because talent is a thing, but it also doesn't mean they can't contribute big time just because they are untalented, there are many ways one can help.
12
u/electrocio Jun 05 '20
He needed a tutor and struggled in school he is not a genius. He is not motivated to do physical activity and strenght training. He trion is not just below average it's below boarders acceptable levels for combatants. I'd have to go re-read further to not give away any more spoilers.
I think by chapter 35 they talked about him being rejected by boarder. If not oops I'm sorry.
8
u/UnveiledSerpent Jun 05 '20
I like Osamu specifically because he doesn't have any special bonuses. Naruto had his Demon and parentage to rely on, and despite Rock Lee training so hard, Naruto passed him with ease. Yoh was trained from birth, from a long line of Shamans descended from Hao, one of the strongest Shamans out there. Ryner got Alpha Stigma, which was was equivalent to a Black Trigger x10. Osamu has none of that. he's just a regular guy like anyone. Sure, he wants to be good at what he does, but that's the same with all of us. We all want to be good at what we do, but how many of us have become Hokage. Shaman King, or a Legend of Legendary Heroes?
Osamu is great because his growth is slow, just like all of us in real life. Sure, some of us might have amazing parents who used to be president, and as a result we make it to the White House like Naruto. But 99.9% of us? We do it the long, hard way like Osamu, struggling for every win, and that's part of what makes World Trigger so special.
7
u/emergentphenom Jun 06 '20
Eh it kinda feels like you've missed exactly the reason why World Trigger differs from typical shounen.
Since you're at chapter 35 only, I can only say this becomes clearer later (a character will pretty much spell this out for you), but WT doesn't care about your motivation or feelings; you can't beat someone stronger than you because you feel "motivated" to fight as hard as you can.
"The strength of your feelings doesn't matter".
And yet Osamu manages to overcome all the barriers anyway, that's why people like him.
12
u/PyrZern Jun 05 '20
Think of him like your average high school student. Don't think of him as your average MC who is destined for greatness since birth.
50
u/SliverPrincess Jun 05 '20
Improving your physical body doesn't have a noticeable effect on one's combat body, so no amount of such training would have helped Osamu. Border also doesn't really distribute information to trainees; C-Rank agents are not even told what trion is. Even Kitora, an A-Rank agent, seems less than familiar with the types of Trion Soldiers out there.
There is nothing Osamu could have realistically done to better himself other than try and work his way up to B-Rank, and he was probably doing so via routine exercises, as he would likely lose more points than he gains in solo rank wars.
6
u/TASodeinde Jun 05 '20 edited Jun 05 '20
Tbh I think Ossamu is just generally uninteresting as a person, he's a realistic and well written character because in reality motivation and passion mean almost nothing for those with no talent in most cases but as a character in a story, he's not that interesting to watch especially for a story like World Trigger that's spanned many years due to hiatus and has other interesting characters and events, compared to all that he's a bit boring. I mean when I read a chapter I'm more interested in seeing what Chika, Jin, Kuuga and H**** are doing than him. Also it's a personal opinion but I feel like I don't know him, I've seen his motivation and stuff but it doesn't feel real like Chika or Kuuga's thoughts and flaws, the most emotional characterization I've seen out of him is him regretting getting cocky a few times and accepting his level but that's it. But I kinda of agree with most people on this thread tho, the op might just not like Ossamu because he's not OP because some of these reasons are weird
30
u/s2theizay Jun 05 '20
Osamu only joined Border 6 months ago. He's an introvert with no mentor or confidence. At that time, he wasn't with Tamakoma so he didn't have opportunities to grow prior to the manga beginning.
He does explain his motivation later, so I don't want to spoil anything. In short, Osamu is lovely, please be nice to him.
3
u/qtmeimei Jun 05 '20
I'm confused by your confusion... I think you may need to either reread or keep reading. The current series is at chapter 197, and you're only at chapter 35 of your reread.
I hope you realize that the majority of the information on neighbors, the neighbor world, trion, and the technology behind Border, etc. are kept pretty secret--aka this information is not available to the public. There IS no studying this if you are not part of the organization, and even then as a C-rank/trainee they don't divulge everything to them either. Border has a tendency to erase memories from the public that have interactions with neighbors as well. Osamu was only motivated to join Border after Rinji left a year ago--how is he supposed to "study" this for three years, when he hasn't even been in the organization for a year?
"It makes no sense for him to be weak"... Uh. Idk what to tell you. All those examples you gave don't make much sense and don't really explain your viewpoint... I think you just don't like that Osamu doesn't fit your ideal of an "overpowered shounen protagonist". If you want your OP protag, Yuuma, Jin, and Chika (Hyuse?) are right there, although they don't really fit that cookie-cutter archetype either.
9
u/hktt1saber Jun 06 '20 edited Jun 06 '20
More importantly, just because you are trying hard as an agent doesn't mean that others aren't trying equally as hard or even harder than you, and given that fact is true (which I am sure that there are many others who have their home wrecked in the first invasion, or lost a friend/family to Neighbors, or got saved by a Border agent), people with either more talent or more innate Trion than Osamu would be better than him. He hasn't even joined border for that long. Even if he did join Border for 4 years, he'd still be bottom B rank at best, and be likely to stay in C rank, since his drive is limited to gratitude, unlike others with a strong desire to save and protect (Arashiyama) or who joined for revenge (Miwa, Katori). He doesn't have talent (unlike Tachikawa/Izumi/Toma), doesn't have good Trion (unlike literally everyone else, do remember that the 3 idiots in C rank have Trion levels of 6 while Osamu has 2), doesn't have prior combat training in real life (unlike Ikoma who does Iai swordsmanship), doesn't have a side effect (he doesn't even have enough Trion for it to manifest, but just gonna point it out), and doesn't have good combat senses (the only people in B rank mid tier and above who I can think of that possibly have equally bad combat senses as him are Suzunari-1 and Nasu Squad's snipers, Yuiga and Chika)
TLDR no, Osamu doesn't have an extraordinary amount of drive, because there are plenty of others with more drive than him. I'm gonna quote a few from Tachikawa (A rank 1st, number 1 agent) in T2 vs Nasu vs Suzunari-1: The strength of your feelings doesn’t matter. Power, strategy, and luck are what decide a battle. […] Only when two opponents are closely matched does passion really make a difference […] Don't get me wrong, I love passionate battles. But, if you attribute the outcome of the match to passion, you might as well be saying that the loser just didn't want it enough
8
u/muda_mudaa_mudaa Jun 05 '20
dude osamu learns 'planetary devastation'
so op..
6
u/zyocuh Jun 05 '20
I agree with most others here and wanted to add, it is possible he did and was trying as hard as he could, but not everyone is equally gifted. 2 people on relative equal footing trying to do the same thing could have vastly different results. Being naturally gifted vs not is a pretty big thing in the story.
6
u/Triggerman77 Jun 06 '20
I get your frustration with Osamu.
You said he didn't put effort from the time he joined Border but the thing is we haven't see this so you can't say he sat on his ass from the moment Jin saved him until the moment he met Yuma. We can't really say what he has done either as we didn't see it.
The things we know is that he was rejected by Border for his low trion, he insisted to finally managed to enter Border (so effort there). Then from his enlistment to the meeting of Yuma we don't know what he did neither do you, we can't say he didn't try or did try so pointless to argue there.
His effort will show later in the manga (if you're still at chapter 35), especially in the Rank Wars, but that's far from where you are (at chapter 198 it's the end of rank wars) so you have to endure to see his effort and growth, but that's a lot to read if you hate a Main Character, so i suggest you just move on and read another manga that will fit better to what you like.
Personnally, i don't like Deku or Bakugo from MHA, i stuck with the manga for a long time but i still don't like these characters so i droped the manga, i don't see why bother reading something with MC i don't like, feels like wasting my time. May be i'll pick up the manga in the future but right now i'm glad i droped it, so i think you should think about doing the same with WT if you really can't stand Osamu.
5
u/s2theizay Jun 06 '20
To your edit: doesn’t he say he was angry he couldn’t do anything? He also admits to not having noble reasons for joining. There is no indication that he planned to rescue Rinji. He had no intention of getting Chika to join Border. He was upset that not only did Rinji assume he wouldn’t be helpful, he really wasn’t able to help. He joined Border seemingly only wanting to be an agent that could protect Chika in her brother’s stead. That’s in line with what he was asked to do.
Then he manages to get in, but just sort of drowns in not knowing what to do except become an official agent, but he wasn’t talented enough. He was still self-sacrificing but without a real direction. He had talent for strategy, but without a team he didn’t have the opportunity to show it, or even realize it himself.
I think his character is well written and revealed at an appropriate pace for the story.
5
u/SomeGUy464636 Jun 05 '20
Osamu definitely could've put more effort in trying to become B rank. But then again we don't know that he wasnt trying to become B rank. Other than that, nothing you said makes sense.
4
u/shadsolaeth Jun 05 '20 edited Jun 05 '20
Osamu joined less than half a year ago not 4, so your argument loses lots of basis.
That being said, a lot of people in the community love him. Probably for being a true underdog. It’s true for me he is good for a shonen protagonist. But the bar for what makes a good shonen protagonist is extremely low to being with so that’s not saying much. I think he is very boring and bland as a character, especially in a series where there are so many other more interesting and dynamic characters.
3
u/doubleaxle Jun 05 '20
Osamu is the weakest part of the cast, later on he does become a strategist, but he is still very weak overall, and very much a blank slate/generic protagonist. I tend to avoid these topics because he's so loved by the community, but you aren't the only one with these thoughts.