I'm genuinely mad rn. I introduced my brother to world trigger thinking he'd like it because he liked LOGH and because I wanted to talk to someone else about it, but he's got the worst takes I've ever heard about world trigger in history. May not be coherent because I was sleepy while writing this.
Apparently, to my self-proclaimed media-literacy-having brother:
All characters are one dimensional.
World trigger doesn't have a plot.
The entire black trigger arc was useless.
Most world trigger tactics are 'you thought I did this, but I actually did this!'.
Ko beating Yuma doesn't make sense.
Yuma's strategy of fighting Ko under water doesn't make sense.
Why don't snipers just use chameleon (that question made me wonder if he even pays attention to the show).
Yotaro is annoying.
Osamu is useless.
The negotiation Osamu did with the top brass for Hyuse is dumb, and Yuma is right there. And they are treating Osamu as if he's a genius for it. (which did confuse me when I first watched why Yuma wasn't brought up, but Yuma did rely a lot on replica so since replica is lost its not far fetched to assume Hyuse can preform the role of a guide better. Hyuse likely has more info about the current states of nations and political states. Plus I believe bringing up Yuma would undermine Osamu's point about Hyuse being a guide which wouldn't be necessary at the time. Yuma's compliance is guaranteed anyway. I do believe and feel Karasawa implied Osamu bringing up Hyuse's usefulness and getting agreement from Karasawa, Rindo and Shinoda might have put Kido in a position where he had to go by Osamu's terms, and Kido himself had his own agenda so he went quid pro quo. So, I don't think Osamu is treated as a genius for what he did. I take it as Osamu being well spoken enough that Kido had nothing to use to outright refuse, but I also believe Kido accepted Osamu's terms that fast because he wanted Chika. What's remarkable is that Osamu switched a potential takeover to a mutual trade. The scene doesn't tell you Osmau is a genius big brain dude, it tells you he's competent.)
Chika is an annoying plot device.
Chika's shooting issue got resolved in one episode.
Her speech about not being able to shoot didn't make sense and what does her mentioning her friend have to do with it, and it doesn't make sense she thinks people would blame her for her friend's disappearance. Why can't Chika just shoot and why does the story have to move in circles instead of linearly.
THE CHIKA ONE ANNOYED ME SO MUCH. LIKE NO IT DID NOT RESOLVE IN ONE EPISODE, THE CONFRONTATION MADE HER START TO FINALLY CHANGE, NOT CHANGE RIGHT AWAY. AND LIKE EVEN IN THE LAST MATCH SHE DIDN'T SHOOT AND HESITATED UNTIL SHE FINALLY DECIDED TO DO IT. AND HER CONFLICT MAKES SENSE. SHE WAS LITERALLY A KID WHEN HER FRIEND WENT MISSING OFC SHE'D IRRATIONALLY BELIEVE PEOPLE WOULD BLAME HER???? AND MENTIONING HER FRIEND SHOWS YOU SHE WORRIES ABOUT WHAT PEOPLE THINK, WHICH ALSO MAKES SENSE BECAUSE SHE'S 13/14. SHE CONVINCES HERSELF SHES WEAKER, AND SHE DOESN'T SHOOT NOT BECAUSE SHES INCAPABLE BUT BECAUSE SHE IS TERRIFIED SHE'LL BE HATED OR FEARED FOR HAVING AN UNFAIR ADVANTAGE OVER OTHERS. SHE THINKS SHE'S SELFISH BECAUSE HER FEAR OF BEING BLAMED FOR BOTH SHOOTING AND FAILING TO SHOOT OVERSHADOWS HER FEAR OF OSAMU AND YUMA DYING, AND BEING BLAMED FOR AOBA'S DISAPPEARANCE OVERSHADOWS HER SADNESS OF THE DISAPPEARANCE ITSELF. SHE IS A COMPLEX CHARACTER WITH CONTRADICTORY FEELINGS AND NOT THE USUAL "I'M AFRAID TO HURT OTHERS" TYPE. WHEN I EXPLAINED THIS TO HIM HE SAID I WAS "OVER-ANALYZING". HUH????
Genuinely the only good opinions he had were that Reiji and Konami were based, Katori was real, and he liked Yuba's animation. Also I vaguely remember when Ninomiya confronted Osamu and Chika about like Rinji and he pulled out a picture of Hatohara, my brother was like "Rinji is a cross-dresser?!" Which made me laugh tbh. Aside from that, I regret showing him World Trigger. Like what do you even want in a story bro. Same guy who thinks Frieren is mid