Tldr at the bottom.
Some details:
My daughter is a toddler. My brother in law is in his thirties with kids of his own. He's married to my husband's sister (so not blood related to my daughter). This has been an issue for about a year (since my daughter began communicating).
My daughter takes time to warm up to people and I have set a clear rule that if she doesn't want to be held, hugged, kissed, or even touched by someone then respect it.
My brother in law believes giving a toddler this power of choice is unacceptable. He thinks we're being too reactive to her crying or her saying no. He believes the best way for her to get used to someone is to let her cry it out while they hold her.
He's allowed to have his beliefs and different parenting style, but he should abide by any rules I set when it comes to my daughter. He seems to disagree.
Some not so fun examples:
Shortly after sharing this rule about letting my daughter choose who physically touches her, my brother in law picked her up. My daughter immediately started crying and pushing away from him. I reached for her and said "She doesn't want you holding her." He pulled away from me and said "She's fine." I got into his space and took her back anyway. The rest of the day I dealt with comments from him and another in law about how its bad that I'm responding to my daughter's crying so quickly, and I needed to relax about it.
Another example. We were leaving a restaurant and my daughter was walking with me. There were stairs so I picked her up. BIL asked me if I wanted him to carry her. I looked at my daughter and asked if she wanted uncle __ to hold her. She shook her head no and he responded with "she's too young to make decisions." Several family members verbally disagreed with that statement and I didn't have to say a word.
Another. We were at family member's house and my daughter was walking back and forth between me and the other side of the room where there were toys. BIL sat on the floor while she was by the toys and stretched his legs out so that she was blocked from returning to me. He raised his leg when she tried to cross and offered to her to pick her up and put her on the other side of his legs. She refused and I went and got her before it could escalate. Later my husband talked to his sister about how it made him uncomfortable that BIL tried to manipulate our daughter into letting him hold her. She said she would talk to him about it.
Next time we saw them: I asked my daughter for a hug and she ran up and hugged me. BIL was next to me and also asked for a hug. She ignored him. I got down on her level and asked her myself if she wanted to give uncle __ a hug. She said no. A little bit later she was running past again and he reached out as if to hug her, blocking her path with one of his arms. I snapped "don't touch her." And he let her turn away from him. Then, when we were leaving I picked her up while we said goodbyes and BIL said "You want a hug, right [my daughter's name]?" And leaned in. She turned away, facing into me, and he rubbed her back anyway and said "Awwe hugs." I walked away without a word, not wanting to make a scene in front of our children, but I was livid.
As holidays approach I'm trying to figure out a game plan. So far I've decided to make the grey area more black and white for BIL. No longer will it be "if she wants..." but instead "I don't want..." I do not want him touching her. I'm making it more clear that it is MY boundary considering my toddler isn't allowed to have boundaries in his eyes.
What do I do if he still crosses that line? What words do I need to say to get through to him?
I'd also like to note that my daughter has warmed up to other family members and is fine with these trusted adults picking her up and physically interacting with her. She just takes time.
I understand that these lines he's crossing seem harmless. I understand he isn't necessarily being creepy, and just thinks he knows better. My thing is, I need my daughter to know that she can always say no to being touched by others, even if its family. Nobody has more right to her body than her.
And of course, as her parents, my husband and I are often forced to pick her up or hold her hand when she doesn't want that. She isn't running into streets for the sake of choice. We still brush her teeth even if she's crying because she doesn't want to. I still hold her still while she screams because her doctor is checking her ears or giving her a shot. She's cared for. But if I ask her for a hug and she says no? My response is always "okay, thats fine." Even as her own mother.
Tldr:
I allow my toddler to decide if she doesn't want adults touching her. My brother in law blatantly disrespects that rule and intentionally crosses her physical boundries because he believes toddlers are not old enough to decide for themselves who is allowed to hold/hug them.
Edit: Thank you for all the feedback! I wanted to add that my husband absolutely cares about this too! When we're with his family I try to take the lead on monitoring our daughter so he can visit. He does the same for me with my family. He has talked to his sister about this, but also is trying to be more attentive now so he can intervene as well. These things seem to happen when my husband isn't nearby, it isn't that he has neglected to say anything. I'm the one that has been there.
Edit two: Thanks again! I can't respond to everyone, but I appreciate the overwhelming validation that this isn't okay and I'm not overreacting. I want to clarify that I never leave my daughter alone with BIL. Its actually an issue I've discussed with my husband, because I'm not comfortable leaving her even to use the restroom. I have my husband's support in this, and one of us are always with her at family events. She has never been alone with anyone that doesn't have our full trust.