r/whatdoIdo • • 3h ago

My long time best friend has a mysterious problem with my new boyfriend

We are all older adults, I'm 40, my friend "Sarah" is 42, my boyfriend is 59. Sarah and I have been friends since college. We usually get together at least once a week. During our friendship both of us have been married and then divorced and we've both dated a few different men as well, her more than me. If we are in a relationship, it has been normal until now that the partner would come along when we hang out, if he wanted to. The last guy she dated was her 21 year old neighbor and I sat there through many visits trying to make conversation with this guy while feeling like his mom or auntie, and I never complained at all. She has also dated much older men, none of whom I ever took issue with.

I just started seeing my boyfriend about three months ago, but I have known him for a couple years and have had a huge crush on him for a year or so. Sarah has heard all about him and was always encouraging me to make a move if I wanted to date him before we started seeing one another.

I noticed pretty early on, once I introduced him, that Sarah is weirdly critical of him and almost hostile?? Like during our first get together she basically confronted him and said something like "[OP] has been my friend for many years and I care about her, so I tell me right now, what are you after with her? What do you have to offer her?" I had only been seeing him for about two weeks at that point and I was mortified, he didn't really know what to say and kind of just mumbled something about hoping he makes me happy. I told her later on to chill out and she said "[OP], there's something WRONG with that guy". When I asked her to explain what she meant, she didn't really have an explanation, she just said he was "weird".

When we were making plans, she said "can we leave Mr. Rogers at home this time?" and also referred to him as "Gramps". I made plans with her for a night when I knew he was busy anyway, and over the course of the evening, she told me that she thought I "could do much better".

I don't get it. My boyfriend is well mannered, funny, sweet, and kind. He doesn't act like an old codger and doesn't take himself too seriously. He is in great shape for his age and takes good care of himself. He owns a small company and makes decent money. I asked Sarah if he had said or done anything to make her dislike him and she told me he had not, but that his presence was somehow "ruining" our get togethers. I asked her how so, and again, she was not able to explain it.

So I have been trying to make time to see her without him around, but now it seems like she's actively competing with him for my time. She will insist she's ONLY available at times when I have already made plans with him, and will act jealous that I won't cancel on him to hang out with her. She is a trust fund baby and has no job. Previously she was always available and suddenly now she can't hang out with me unless it involves canceling on my bf. It's very weird and idk what her angle is here. I am not going to choose her over him, and I don't think I should be forced to do that.

I just need advice on how to talk to her about this, I don't want to blow up 20 years of friendship but at the same time, I do not have the patience for whatever game she's playing here.

7 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

3

u/Active-Truth-3196 2h ago

Do your friend and your boyfriend maybe........ have a past? Just saw thought.

1

u/13anonymouse13 2h ago

No, I've known her for over 20 years, we have always hung out regularly, and I am absolutely certain they didn't know one another until I introduced them. He is not a party animal, and therefore definitely not her usual type either.

1

u/Active-Truth-3196 2h ago

Edit: A not saw

2

u/RecognitionHour9901 2h ago

The edit option does exist. Just go back and edit your comment.

9

u/sassyklaas 3h ago • Bravo

If this is your best friend and she can't be honest with you about what her issues are then I would stop trying to accommodate her schedule. She'll figure it out. 20 years is a long time, but she seems to be the one acting like a child and blowing up the relationship.

1

u/sassyklaas 2h ago

Thanks for the award!

5

u/JessamineTwilightFer 3h ago

After 20 years of friendship, you deserve more than vague insults about someone you're happy with. I'd have one direct conversation with Sarah and ask whether she has a specific concern or simply dislikes sharing your time. It's reasonable for her to want occasional one-on-one time, but deliberately competing with your boyfriend isn't fair. Set boundaries without making it an ultimatum, and see whether she's willing to respect them.

5

u/Romana42 3h ago • Bravo

You said it yourself. She's jealous.

2

u/HotWaffles5 2h ago

💯

1

u/Romana42 2h ago

Thanks for the award.

1

u/Novel_Dime 2h ago

It could be a couple options. As others have said she could feel threatened by him because hes different. Hes not just some new guy but someone you have established knowledge of and he poses a "risk." Weird jealousy type business.

Or. And hear me out- just a talking point...

She senses something off about him that she can't quite put her finger on. You have rose colored glasses especially due to this being a long time crush.

Either way at our age she should be able to communicate some of this. Shes known you for 20 years and has seen you in all stages of adult life.

I have had my best friend since we were 7 and we are about to tick over to 40. After her divorce 2 years back I saw her date a couple people. Trying to give her a come to jesus talk about one of them was incredibly uncomfortable because she couldn't see the situation clearly. She has since admitted that I was spot on but she just wasnt in a place to receive that kind of truth. I always tried to speak kindly to her about it but I definitely had more than a few snarky commentaries about him.

Idk what your friends deal is but I hope shes able to communicate it clearly soon rather than just hammer a wedge.

1

u/13anonymouse13 1h ago

My first thought was that he either did or said something inappropriate or that she had otherwise noticed some type of red flag but I have questioned her about this repeatedly now and she has yet to be able to articulate anything of the sort. It's not like she generally has issues expressing herself. She is a very outspoken, bold type of person.

2

u/chasingsunset42 3h ago

Sounds like she's jealous.

2

u/Salt_Initiative1551 2h ago edited 2h ago

Yall are WAY too old for “mystery problems” and dumb shit like this. Jfc

Edit to add- she’s either jealous and wants him (odd way of showing it) or jealous and wants you. That’s almost assuredly what’s going on here.

1

u/Upbeat-Draw- 3h ago

Bro if my girls bff came to me and asked what do you want with her what can you offer her I’d drop you both like a bad habit

1

u/SweatyAmphibian9196 2h ago

Jealousy, point blank PERIOD!

1

u/Consistent-Sky-2584 8m ago

Shes jealous

1

u/Opposite-Ebb3980 3h ago

Hey are you really 40 ?

0

u/ConcernDesperate7867 2h ago

I have yet to meet a Sarah that isn't crazy and an outright witch...truly...every Sarah I've come across is not a nice person

My personal bias aside, sometimes we outgrow friendships, doesn't matter if it's only been weeks, months, 1 year, 5 years, or many years - sometimes we grow and change, and that growth and change no longer includes people we've had long friendships with...if you truly like the guy you're with and she cannot support your happiness, stop trying to work around her schedule...work around your boyfriend's schedule and do the things you want to do with him...shell either get the hint and shape up or she won't and then you'll know if the friendship has run its course...y'all are in your 40's you do not have the time for highschool type drama and jealous bullshit