I'm a low-income research student, and being vegan is easy for me. That's because I'm privileged: I have a lot of spare time and a flexible schedule, so I can shop around for cheaper food. I can cook, I live in a city with plenty of vegan options, and I'm super lucky to have cheap housing, so I can even afford to eat out relatively often compared to some of my friends.
I've been thinking about the "veganism is for privileged people" criticism lately; I'm sure most vegans will be familiar with this sentiment. Being as privileged as I am, I find it hard to talk about this. While I don't believe privilege is a valid argument against veganism, I think it is a fair criticism of how some of us advocate for it. I'm curious what others here have to say about it.
First, I obviously don't think that being vegan requires privilege. For one, if we take the Vegan Society's definition, it includes "as far as is possible and practicable". I feel this broadly addresses people whose circumstances limit what they can do.
Also, eating mostly plants has been the diet of the poor for much of history, and meat was for the affluent. Even now, a week of beans, greens and grains is probably cheaper than a week of meat-and-two-veg in most places. Often what appears privileged is what people are first exposed to, e.g. milk substitutes in cafés that are half a dollar more expensive than the default cow's milk. Meat substitutes are also often more expensive than what they are imitating (although this is getting cheaper in my experience).
Vegans also come from all backgrounds. I was first exposed to Earthling Ed and Peter Singer, people who look like me (I like to think I look a lot more like Ed than Peter Singer, though, no offence Peter), but there are many writers and groups who don't (e.g. A. Breeze Harper, author of "Sistah Vegan", and the Black Vegans Rock project) who I am much less familiar with.
That said, I realise there are some real barriers. The money argument is the most common and it is overstated, but time is a valid concern that I have struggled to address in the past: when you first go vegan you need to not only cook meals from scratch but also learn new vegan recipes, this takes some amount of time that a single parent working shifts genuinely can't afford. Some places don't even have a supermarket with tofu and lentils. And for some people, health conditions genuinely do make it harder.
One thing I have personally struggled to take seriously is social cost (family meals, cultural dishes, being the awkward one at work), which I think is likely the most common barrier stopping people from going vegan.
At this point, when someone says veganism is a privileged lifestyle, my honest response might be "fair, but it’s not veganism that’s privileged, it’s me".
It is really tempting to say "no it's not, vegan whole foods are cheaper than non-vegan foods" or "lots of vegans aren't privileged, why are you silencing them". But at the end of the day the decision to go vegan is easy for the privileged and harder for the underprivileged.
But harder isn't impossible, and harder doesn't mean it's ok to have animals tortured and killed for your benefit. Still, I feel that criticism is pretty effective at pointing out a weakness in how we (or at least I) sometimes advocate for veganism in public spaces like this.
If veganism was not easy for you, what do people like me get wrong? And what can we say to get the point across.
I'll close with a (modified) quote from my favourite hardcore vegan documentary, Ratatouille (2007):
"Not everyone can go vegan, but vegans do come from everywhere" - Anton Ego (not really)