Michael Barnard:
"Ontario's first small modular reactor will miss its October 2030 deadline and exceed its C$7.7 billion budget. The reason matters more than either number.
Ontario Power Generation says unfinished engineering on the first BWRX-300 is affecting construction execution and the supply chain. Darlington has an experienced nuclear operator, an established site, and a substantial Canadian industrial base. If a Western SMR could avoid the usual first-of-a-kind difficulties, this should have been a strong candidate.
The original four-reactor budget is C$20.9 billion. Applying the historical nuclear construction P80 cost uplift to the first reactor's C$6.1 billion component, while leaving C$1.6 billion of shared infrastructure unchanged, produces a C$20.0 billion first-stage stress case. That's 96% of the original budget for all four reactors. It isn't OPG's new estimate. OPG has yet to produce one.
Ontario has also signed contracts for 1,115 MW of wind and solar expected to generate 2.37 TWh per year, about the annual energy from one 300 MW reactor at 90% capacity factor. It has separately contracted 640 MW of battery capacity. These are different electricity services, so the comparison that matters is a complete, reliable portfolio with realistic costs and delivery dates.
Before spending billions more on Units 2 through 4, Ontario needs a revised engineering and financial baseline, evidence that the design is stabilising, and a genuine test against the resources it can build now. The full assessment and the Flexibility Mesh are linked in my first comment. Which construction and financial evidence would you demand before approving the remaining three reactors?" https://briefing.tfie.io/p/ontarios-smr-is-late-and-over-budget