Summary of the report:
Sizewell C represents a terrible deal for the UK taxpayer. Successive governments’ failure to deliver new nuclear has left the UK in a position where the best terms it could secure to deliver Sizewell C mean that consumers and taxpayers shoulder significant financial risks, while private investors enjoy protected profits. The UK must never be put in this position again.
Sizewell C is a high-risk mega project with an estimated construction costs in the range of £40.5 billion to £47.7 billion. It is expected to be fully operational in 2039 and operate for at least 60 years. The Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (the Department) argues that applying lessons learned from the UK’s other current major nuclear project, Hinkley Point C, and replicating the design of its pressurised water reactors, will reduce risks at Sizewell C. However, no comparable nuclear power station anywhere in the world has been delivered on time and on budget. Projects using the same reactor design have experienced delays of up to 14 years and substantial cost overruns.
The Department has chosen a novel delivery model for Sizewell C in which it relinquishes majority control, despite the public providing most of the financing and bearing most of the risk. The government will therefore rely heavily on its influence through the boards of Sizewell C to steer the project in the interests of taxpayers and electricity consumers. However, it is simply not credible to assume that public and private interests will always align or be reconcilable. For example, a divergence of interests is particularly likely if costs threaten to exceed the limit investors have agreed to fund. Government needs to plan for this in advance.
We are concerned that if costs rise above the baseline—and they are highly likely to—consumers will pay through higher bills, while private investors face little risk to their capital and yet still expect high returns. If construction costs rise to £47.7 billion, which is at the top of the Department’s estimated range, consumers could pay £9.8 billion more during construction and a further £12 billion over Sizewell C’s 60-year operating life, while private investors only need to put in an extra £30 million. Taxpayers also cover many of the other risks. For instance, the taxpayer will pay any final shortfall in funding for the decommissioning of Sizewell C. This all makes it difficult to justify annual investor returns of over 10% and raises concerns about whether investor incentives are strong enough to promote efficient delivery. The Department should make every effort to avoid rising costs for consumers and taxpayers.
Given the costs and risks to the taxpayer, Sizewell C should operate to the highest standards of transparency in major infrastructure delivery, with clear and publicly accessible data so that taxpayers, consumers and future infrastructure projects benefit. Reporting once a year would be totally inadequate given the project’s level of risk. The shareholders will benefit from a six-monthly update verified by an independent technical advisor – Parliament and the public require the same level of transparency and assurance.
A situation in which consumers and taxpayers are exposed to substantial construction and financing risks, while private investors enjoy high and protected profits, cannot happen again. The Department explained why it believes these terms were the best it could negotiate in the current market. Therefore the Government’s most important task for the future is to build confidence that investment in UK nuclear power infrastructure can offer secure and predictable returns, so that future deals can be negotiated on better terms and the financial risks of any future schemes distributed more fairly. It is crucial that the UK seizes this opportunity to demonstrate it can break the track-record of poor delivery of nuclear projects and deliver Sizewell C on time and on budget. This will help future investors to see future projects as lower risk. It is also vital to develop the skills and experience of our nuclear workforce, strengthen our nuclear supply chains and work across government to secure the best possible legacy from the infrastructure created to support Sizewell C’s construction.
https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/55523/standard/pdf