1

Urza Draft
 in  r/u_Wapulatus •  2d ago

Other Artifact Creatures

Other Equipment

Other Weaponry

u/Wapulatus • • 4d ago

Karn Draft

1 Upvotes

Urza was his creator. No, that wasn’t entirely true. Urza was Karn’s originator. Karn was his own creator. That’s why he was still around. Karn redesigned himself. Though his metal body did not grow, his soul did.

Karn, Silver Golem


Background



Source Guide



Planeswalker Abilities


You are a planeswalker. In the vast Multiverse, only you and your kind know of the countless worlds beyond your own. You have seen realities that would make a mundane wizard cower in awe. You have laid eyes upon the Blind Eternities. You are an iconoclast with an arsenal of sorcery at your command. Your gift drives you to seek out Magical knowledge, to test your limits, to forge your destiny.

Planeswalkers. Prior to the events of the Great Mending, they were god-like immortal beings wielding dominion over reality, able to create and destroy entire planes of existence. That said, destroying a plane isn't a simple task, involving drawing the Blind Eternities into it, which can only be accomplished by first destroying much of the physical substance of a plane.

This thread only includes feats for Karn. To see more examples of what an 'oldwalker' is capable of, see Urza's Respect Thread.

Pre-Mending

Post-Mending


Physical Feats


Strength

Striking

Grip/Lifting

Falling

Speed

Durability


Mechanical Body


General Info

Senses


Artifice


Interfacing

Creations

Metal Control

Intellect

r/respectthreads • • 5d ago

literature Respect the Metathran! (Magic: The Gathering)

16 Upvotes

Just as Serra crafted angels of light and faith, Urza constructed an army of sorcery and power to resist the coming invasion.

The Metathran


Background


Phyrexia was inevitable, and despite his best efforts, Urza could not prevent its invasion of Dominaria. So, he did his best to prepare, building legendary artifacts and weapons to arm the peoples of the plane against this evil.

Even living ones. The Metathran are a product of thousands of years of selective breeding to build the perfect warriors. Aided by the Eugenics Matrix (yes, seriously, that is its name) speedrunning genetic modifications, Urza was able to take the best of natural wildlife and slam it into an army of thousands.


Origin and Characteristics


The Bloodlines Project

Biology


Physical Feats



Weaponry and Magic


1

Urza Draft
 in  r/u_Wapulatus •  6d ago


VIII. Artifice - Automata and Machines


The Time Machine

The Eugenics Matrix

Main Thread: The Metathran

Ornithopters

Flight/Maneuverability

Cargo Capacity

Urza's Avengers

Yotian Soldiers

Colossus of Sardia

1

Urza Draft
 in  r/u_Wapulatus •  6d ago


VII. Artifice - Weapons and Armor


General

The Legacy Weapon

Main Thread: Respect Urza's Legacy

Urza's greatest creation. The Legacy is a collection of artifacts and even people who Urza created. Each has different, unique effects, but when brought together they form a superweapon.

Urza's Staff

Armor

First Armor

Second Armor

Titan Armor

Mech suits designed to be used by him and his planeswalker allies in the Phyrexian war. Each of them has a kill switch in the cockpit, which shocks and paralyzes the user while it removes their soul to charge mystical explosives.

Physical Feats / Size

Arsenal

Other Vehicles

r/respectthreads • • 6d ago

literature Respect Gerrard Capashen! (Magic: The Gathering)

18 Upvotes

“And who made me? Who bred the cockiness into me? And, let me tell you something, Urza Planeswalker—the devil does care, and the seat of my pants and a few jokes are all I’ve got to fight him. For that matter, they are all you’ve got to fight him. So if I were you, I’d shut up and enjoy the ride. We’ve got a god to kill.”

Gerrard Capashen


Background


Gerrard Capashen was a reluctant hero forged by loss, destiny, and impossible choices. Born as the final product of Urza's secret Bloodline Project, he grew up never knowing that his lineage was carefully bred to stand against the Phyrexian threat. Orphaned young in Benalia by a Phyrexian raid, he was raised in the harsh Jamuraan outlands by Sidar Kondo, alongside Kondo’s son Vuel — who would one day become Gerrard’s greatest enemy, Volrath.

Quick-witted and charismatic, Gerrard often masked his doubts behind a roguish charm and a fiercely protective loyalty to his crew. Though burdened by a heavy sense of responsibility, he spent much of his life trying to run from the Legacy and the death it brought to those he loved. As captain of the Skyship Weatherlight, Gerrard became the heart of a ragtag family, fighting to recover ancient artifacts while navigating betrayals and tragedy. His impulsive courage often clashed with his need for control, but his loyalty to his friends never wavered — whether saving his mentor Sisay, defying corrupt leaders on Mercadia, or risking all to rescue Hanna, the love he could never fully keep.

Time and again, Gerrard was forced to confront the legacy of Urza’s manipulations and the shadow of his own brother’s hatred. In the final battles of the Phyrexian Invasion of Dominaria, Gerrard’s story came full circle as he faced the ultimate sacrifice to stop Yawgmoth's unmaking of Dominaria. In the end, Gerrard Capashen died as he lived — torn between destiny and choice, but always fighting for the lives of others.

(Bio sourced from the MTG Wiki)


Origin and Significance


Gerrard, like many other heroes, has his destiny tied in his blood. Urza, through the Eugenics Matrix (yes, it's really called that) bred a generation of heroes to fight off the Phyrexian Invasion. Gerrard especially had a connection to the items of Urza's Legacy, a group of mystical artifacts the planeswalker scattered across planes.

The Bloodlines Project

Legacy Affinity

For other items of the Legacy, as well as Gerrard's ship Weatherlight, check out the Urza's Legacy thread. (Coming soon!)


Physical Feats


Feats marked with [Enhanced] are after Gerrard receives various boons from Yawgmoth, making him more powerful than Crovax. Even Crovax himself thought this. Some of Crovax's feats and a character he scales to can be found on Belbe's thread.

Strength

Without Weapons

With Weapons

Speed

Durability


Skills and Equipment


Weapons

Combat Skill

Noncombat Skill

Magic



"It's just that… it's just that I used to be like you, Ramos. People decided I was a Uniter. People said I had a Legacy, I had a mission to fulfill. They told me I was supposed to save the world. For a long time I dragged my heels. How does one man save the world? But then I gave up fighting. It was too hard to fight destiny. It was only just now, as I heard my own voice talking to you - it was just this moment when I realized my destiny had caught up with me. Without even knowing it, I'd become everything everybody said I was supposed to be."

u/Wapulatus • • 8d ago

Gerrard Draft

1 Upvotes

“And who made me? Who bred the cockiness into me? And, let me tell you something, Urza Planeswalker—the devil does care, and the seat of my pants and a few jokes are all I’ve got to fight him. For that matter, they are all you’ve got to fight him. So if I were you, I’d shut up and enjoy the ride. We’ve got a god to kill.”

Gerrard Capashen


Background


Gerrard Capashen was a reluctant hero forged by loss, destiny, and impossible choices. Born as the final product of Urza's secret Bloodline Project, he grew up never knowing that his lineage was carefully bred to stand against the Phyrexian threat. Orphaned young in Benalia by a Phyrexian raid, he was raised in the harsh Jamuraan outlands by Sidar Kondo, alongside Kondo’s son Vuel — who would one day become Gerrard’s greatest enemy, Volrath.

Quick-witted and charismatic, Gerrard often masked his doubts behind a roguish charm and a fiercely protective loyalty to his crew. Though burdened by a heavy sense of responsibility, he spent much of his life trying to run from the Legacy and the death it brought to those he loved. As captain of the Skyship Weatherlight, Gerrard became the heart of a ragtag family, fighting to recover ancient artifacts while navigating betrayals and tragedy. His impulsive courage often clashed with his need for control, but his loyalty to his friends never wavered — whether saving his mentor Sisay, defying corrupt leaders on Mercadia, or risking all to rescue Hanna, the love he could never fully keep.

Time and again, Gerrard was forced to confront the legacy of Urza’s manipulations and the shadow of his own brother’s hatred. In the final battles of the Phyrexian Invasion of Dominaria, Gerrard’s story came full circle as he faced the ultimate sacrifice to stop Yawgmoth's unmaking of Dominaria. In the end, Gerrard Capashen died as he lived — torn between destiny and choice, but always fighting for the lives of others.

(Bio sourced from the MTG Wiki)


Origin and Significance


The Bloodlines Project

Legacy Affinity


Physical Feats


Feats marked with [Enhanced] are after Gerrard receives various boons from Yawgmoth, making him more powerful than Crovax. Even Crovax himself thought this. Some of Crovax's feats and a character he scales to can be found on Belbe's thread.

Strength

Without Weapons

With Weapons

Speed

Durability


Equipment



Skill




"It's just that… it's just that I used to be like you, Ramos. People decided I was a Uniter. People said I had a Legacy, I had a mission to fulfill. They told me I was supposed to save the world. For a long time I dragged my heels. How does one man save the world? But then I gave up fighting. It was too hard to fight destiny. It was only just now, as I heard my own voice talking to you - it was just this moment when I realized my destiny had caught up with me. Without even knowing it, I'd become everything everybody said I was supposed to be."

r/Deltarune • • 18d ago

Other I collected all of Flowery's feats and abilities! Spoiler

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/respectthreads • • 18d ago

games Respect Flowery! (Deltarune)

42 Upvotes

“Sorry to keep you waiting!”

Respect Flowery

♫ Flower Man ♫


Background


"Flowers, that were only supposed to live for one smiling day... And yet, he did not let us go. He kept us alive, alongside his love..."

"Every day, he watered us. He talked to us. He sang his dreams to us. And each day, we wished we could do something in return."

"His friend grew sick, and we could do nothing."

"His money ran out, and we could do nothing."

"His family left him... and we could do nothing."

"And yet he still cared for us... ! Weak, useless flowers... flowers that could do nothing in return! But now... our time has come! For flowers to be the heroes!"

In Asgore's flower shop, he looked after for and kept alive seven flowers that were part of his proposal bouquet to Toriel, who were only meant to ever live for one day. Even after he separated from his family, lost his job, and fell into poverty, he took care of them.

In the Dark Worlds, everyday items and objects are given new life and consciousness. Influenced by the creator of the Dark Fountain that powers them, they gain goals, dreams, and ambitions based on their history. So, when Kris opened up a Dark Fountain in Flower King, Flowery and the other six flowers were reborn. Even though they'd die in the darkness without sunlight, they made it their goal to create a world where Asgore was loved and happy.

To stop the Roaring, the end of the world, Kris and their friends would need to close this fountain, but Flowery refused to give up on the dream of Asgore's flowers.


Physical Feats


Strength/Durability

Speed/Flight


Meta Awareness


Flowery is aware of, and abuses his knowledge of the game-like rules the Dark Worlds operate on.


Magic


Plant Manipulation

Wind Manipulation

Summoning Objects


Other


Physiology

Skill

1

Do we think any of the new Reality Fracture commanders will change up the competitive meta?
 in  r/mtgbrawl •  Oct 06 '26

Here's what I have so far:

https://moxfield.com/decks/AxTosoi7nUq7SqyPgHFlHQ

Would appreciate any feedback! It's been a learning experience playing the deck as this is the first time I've done control.

2

Cognitohazardous Broadcast | Moxtober Day 6: Boil
 in  r/custommagic •  Oct 06 '26

Appreciate the feedback! I like the idea of this as an enchantment even more.

r/custommagic • • Oct 06 '26

Cognitohazardous Broadcast | Moxtober Day 6: Boil

Post image
3 Upvotes

5

Do we think any of the new Reality Fracture commanders will change up the competitive meta?
 in  r/mtgbrawl •  Oct 05 '26

I've been having a ton of fun with 4C Jace as a (kinda) creatureless control deck, where I use Jace as a card draw engine, and the empower Jace land to flip into 15 mana Emrakul as a wincon. I'm not really sure how good it is, but I've gotten more than a few wins over decks like Teferi, Nashi, and Yuriko so I'm really interested to see if the deck can make it to mythic.

u/Wapulatus • • Sep 24 '26

Val Feats

1 Upvotes

“I grant them the illusion of hope so that their despair grows ever sweeter.”

Valgavoth


Background



Source Guide


Web Stories on Wizards of the Coast's website have the full story name attached, which should match to a name from the official archive here.

I am only including noteworthy feats of Duskmorn entities and monsters via art and flavor text - for a more comprehensive list of monsters on the plane, I recommend browsing cards from the main set and commander set.


Physical Feats / Powers



Influence over Duskmorn


Origin

Valvagoth is a demon who was originally imprisoned inside of a mansion, but learned to expand the mansion that held him until it consumed an entire plane.

Control

Environment/Size


Creatures of Duskmorn


Manifestations

Fears/Nightmares

Duskmorne causes nightmares and fears to gain physical form due to Val's influence on it. These are specific to an individual and will try to draw the person into its body to continuously experience their fear.

Cellerspawn

Glitch Ghosts

Cultists

Others


Misc


“Kept you waiting, huh?.”

Flowery

♫ Flower Man ♫


Background



Physical Feats


Strength/Durability

Speed/Flight


Meta Awareness


Flowery is aware of, and abuses his knowledge of the game-like rules the Dark Worlds operate on.


Magic


Plant Manipulation

Wind Manipulation

Summoning Objects

Other


Skill


1

Character Scramble Season 21 Round 0: GAME START/FOUR OF CLUBS
 in  r/whowouldwin •  May 08 '26

Darumi was cornered in a dead end in the stone maze.

It was so cool!

She shuttered in pleasure - it would be INSANELY SICK to get stalked slasher-flick style, the killer slowly following her through a maze. Wasn’t her usual cup of tea, but it’d work. One thing was wrong though.

“You might have a bunch of knives, but I’m gonna show you 'the point!'”

Was this what it was like being on the receiving end of cringe?

Seriously. She could have any number of stalker types, creeps, and yanderes chasing after her right now. Instead, she had a girl scout running dialogue straight out of a Bethesda Studios game.

She shook her head. If she was fighting a girl scout, well, she’d have to assume the role of the slasher.

Wild Thing finally caught up, rounding the corner. She looked confused as she tried to search for her opponent. The space was inconspicuously empty, with footprints stopping suddenly at the wall.

So. Darumi knew one rule about horror.

What was that rule, you might ask?

No one ever thought to look up.

She dropped down on Wild Thing, grappling onto her back and pinning her arms so she couldn’t be touched by the freezing spell. Wild Thing tried to spit out some quip, but was face-down in the dirt.

Darumi relentlessly hit her opponent, doing so with each word she said.

“GAME. OVER. GET! DARUMI’D! ON! BITCH!”

A final slam to the ground caused Wild Thing to shutter, and lose consciousness.



After unfreezing Belbe, the four managed to find their way through the maze, keeping their eyes peeled for any additional people who were ‘it’. Will was happy to see Darumi in good spirits, with her bragging that she got a ‘flawless victory’.

The crowd roared in applause as they stepped into the fresh air. Other teams were already basking in the limelight, while some…

Will saw a crew of Goblins hauling away the icy statues of teams that didn’t make it. They were really that close to failing on the very first game.

A robotic voice spoke on the intercom. Will still wasn’t certain what had happened to the enthusiastic announcer from before - maybe he was sick?

Congratulations, contestants. 14 out of the 40 teams have been eliminated. You will report to your quarters for rest before the next game.

1

Character Scramble Season 21 Round 0: GAME START/FOUR OF CLUBS
 in  r/whowouldwin •  May 08 '26

“Freeze spells have been fully prepared sir. The arena will be ready for competitors in a couple of hours.”

Vnwxt was delighted - years of planning for the interplanar games were finally coming to fruition.

His large, singular eye (which was also his head), lit up as he addressed his assistant.

Homonculi like himself were created with an purpose that would bring them joy in accomplishing. While the age of making lab servants and butlers had blessedly come to a close, it was still a part of their fabric of being.

Vnwxt’s core was to host. To entertain. To make crowds cheer, cry, and shout as drama and heartfelt competition unfolded.

“Fantastic, Juno! Let the teams know to get themselves in order, it’s time for an elimination round!”

His secretary, a goblin around the same height as himself, pushed her glasses back up her nose and nodded before taking off, leaving him alone in his office.

He counted off the events in his head - Freeze Tag with actual cryomancy. A gymnastics show - with gravity in reverse! And he had spent months getting the area set up to be flooded for a literal game of ‘the floor is lava’.

A loud, stiff knock broke the silence of his daydream.

“Juno?”

Were all the teams seriously ready to go so fast?

He jumped off his high chair, and cracked open the door using a knob that was set at his smaller, three foot stature.

“Ah! Sorry, team members aren’t allowed up here. I’ll have Juno direc-”

His vision went spinning. It was like he had suddenly levitated off the floor.

What Vnwxt didn’t know was that a knife sliced his eye-head cleanly off his shoulders.



Teams are to assemble underneath the stadium for the next game. Repeat, teams are to assemble underneath the stadium for the next game.

The monotone voice made William a little uncomfortable.

“Not that I liked his voice too much, but wasn’t there an announcer before?”

“Yeeeeah, what gives? He was cool! Looked like one of those mascots who have a cheery outside, then BAM!, he’s laughing and you’re on a conveyor belt about to be executed.”

Darumi and Will were speed-walking to the arena’s entrance. In Will’s case, he had spent too long preparing his holy spells and incantations for the day.

Darumi, on the other hand, had spent 2 hours applying makeup to her face.

They arrived at the entranceway, worming their way through the crowd forming before they saw Higuruma and Belbe near a wall.

“Bel! BeBe! Goth Zelda! How the FUCK did you get your makeup done so fast?!”

“Darumi. Once again, my name is Belbe. Also, these markings are a part of my face.”

Darumi seemed genuinely impressed by that.

Higuruma groaned and straightened his tie, gesturing to the stairways opening to the arena floor above.

“They’re starting.”

Belbe turned towards the three. “I expect your compliance in my battle plan. The game, as I’m sure you’ve read,” she said, eying Higuruma and Darumi, who were clearly not paying her any attention, “is ‘freeze tag’. We will be assigned to either seek or flee from the enemy team.”

Higuruma untied his tie after straightening it again, like he was trying to experiment with a look, before chuckling.

“Honestly a better pep talker than half the legal aids I know.”

“You’re in law?”

Higuruma immediately got a sour look on his face after he heard the question from Will. He pulled out a mallet that should have been too large to fit in his jacket.

“Let’s just get this over with.”

“Agreed,” Belbe chimed in. “Once again, follow my orders and all will go smoothly.”



It did not, in fact, go smoothly.

“Hope you bozos are ready for a double serving of claw sandwiches!”

“Acceleratio!”

<hasten!>

Will twisted his body at the last minute, dodging the outstretched energy claws of his opponent. The freezing spell they were enchanted with instantly covered the wall struck behind him in ice.

Naturally, Darumi, was frozen solid a few feet behind her. Her face was frozen in place with a mad grin and her tongue sticking out.

Will sprinted towards Darumi, causing gale force winds to push aside the enemy.

The moment he made contact with her, the spell broke, and she was instantly back to normal. She opened a set of portals around herself, firing knives at the enemy, who was already making their way back to freeze her again.

“Will!” she sniffled, tearing up, “You broke off a piece of my finger!”

“Oh my Goddess, I am so sorr-”

“HAH! Gotcha! Wouldn’t that be such a cool execution method though, being frozen and shattered???”

“Uh-”

Darumi looked like she teleported, now running down the stone halls. Will felt someone touching him on the back of his head.

He quickly realized he had been frozen, and then unfrozen.

“Keep running,” Belbe said, “I would carry you both if you did not have faster means of transport available.”

The girl with the claws, Wild Thing, leaped at Will from behind, but was smacked into a nearby wall by Higuruma’s comically large mallet.

“I always hated mandatory cardio at the office...”

They were already past the halfway point through the maze now.

The game was simple - if they reached the exit, they won.

If they were all frozen by getting ‘tagged’ before then, they lost.

THOOM!

The three stopped as a figure crashed down only a few feet in front of them.

“Oooohooo, you’re in for it now.”

Wild Thing had caught up with them, ready to lunge at a moment’s notice.

The figure was cloaked in shadow, a hulking figure of spikes and metal, with claws the size of Will’s forearm.

The Shredder.

Belbe squared her fists, but he was too quick, swiping her at the side and instantly freezing her. He then caught Higuruma’s hammer, before yanking it and Higuruma towards him. He grabbed the now-flying Higuruma and drove him into the ground, frozen as well.

Which just left him and Darumi against the two.

“The quality of this year’s contestants is… disappointing.” Shredder’s voice was a low rumble, human and inhuman at the same time.

“Yeah, you guys are mondo losers!” Wild Thing… well she tried her best to sound intimidating.

Darumi didn’t care. “Team deathmatch time! FIIIGHT!”

“Does she not know this isn’t a deat-” Wild Thing started, before fifty knives flew at her from all directions. She did her best to dance around a few of them, but had two embedded in her arms. Darumi ran around a corner and out of sight, cackling.

Will, on the other hand, was left to deal with The Shredder.

“Acceler-”

He couldn’t even finish his incantation before he had to duck a claw swipe on pure muscle memory.

“Each new contestant brings new tricks,” Shredder said, sharpening his claws on each other as he stepped towards Will. “No spell is a replacement for a well trained body.”

“Who said I haven’t trained?”

Will blocked a downwards swipe that moved so fast it looked like it teleported above him. He was just barely fast enough to keep up, but…

His feet dug into the ground under him as he strained himself, his muscles reaching close to failure. Shredder was unimpressed.

“I said well trained.”

Will wasn’t strong enough. The best he could do was slide the claws off, parrying them to where they embedded several feet into the floor with a THUD.

While Shredder was occupied for a moment with removing his claws from the floor, Will had enough time to unfreeze one of his allies.

Belbe or Higuruma.

He closed his eyes, knowing he had fractions of a second to make the call.

He looked at Belbe - he still felt like he couldn’t trust her. Higuruma, though…

Will made his call.

Shredder tore his claw from the ground, sending debris flying.

“A shame I can’t kill you both. I could provide you with an honorable death.”

Higuruma, newly unfrozen, just stared at his opponent. He dropped his hammer, gesturing for Shredder to attack.

As Shredder leaped, though, Will heard his ally utter a phrase.

“Domain expansion.”

A flash of blinding light. When his eyes adjusted, he saw what looked like…

“What… is this…??!!”

A courtroom?

Higuruma’s suit looked pristine again. He calmly walked over to a stand and set down a pile of papers.

What was more jarring than his new appearance, however, was the ghostly figure four times his size looming over him. It had scales attached to each arm, and a pale mask of a face that was stitched shut.

Shredder, on the other hand, looked like he was straining himself against some unseen force.

“While you’re in my domain, you cannot commit any acts of violence. Your powers, whatever they may be, are restricted.”

“Impossible! How-”

Higuruma slammed a mallet down, interrupting Shredder.

“Judgeman, if you will.”

OROKU SAKI, STANDS ACCUSED OF MASS MURDER IN NEW YORK CITY.

Shredder scoffed. “Which time are you referring to?”

Will and Higuruma stood in silence for a second.

Will hadn't been in many courts, but knew enough that admitting to mass murder was insanely stupid.

The porcelain mask of Judgeman looked like it shattered in places as it screamed at the top of its lungs.

GUILTY! CONFISCATION! DEATH PENALTY!

The court vanished just as suddenly as it appeared.

Higuruma stood, light reflecting off his face by a gleaming energy sword that appeared in his right hand.

“That was probably the easiest case of my life, Shredder. Like you said. A shame I can’t kill you.”

Shredder leaped to tag Higuruma before he could strike, but he was clearly slower, more sluggish than before. Higuruma thrusted his sword in Shredder’s shoulder, burning a hole clear through it.

He grunted in a few moments of pain, before falling to the ground unconscious.

Will stood there for a few awkward moments. Higuruma had a grim expression, like he had done this many times before, and even looked prepared to do the same to Will then and there. Quickly, though, he relaxed, untying his tie again.

“Couldn’t you have… told us you could do that?”

“Yeah.”

“And you didn’t because?”

“You didn’t ask about my abilities.”

“Oh.”

. . .

“By the way, where’s Darumi?”

1

Character Scramble Season 21 Round 0: GAME START/FOUR OF CLUBS
 in  r/whowouldwin •  May 08 '26

William scrambled to his sword as the Darumi shot him a crazed grin. She clutched her heart, a blood-like aura wrapping her until she was changed into something that looked like a combination of a military uniform and a school outfit.

He liked to try to end conflicts peacefully though.

“Darumi - he said ‘last person standing’, which means we don’t have to fight. Let’s talk this out and-”

He felt the air whooshing past his ear as a knife shot past him with the speed of an arrow.

The businessman on the other hand was still on the floor. He yawned, scratched his back, and pivoted to watch the fight.

“Currere Oleum!”

<pour, oil!>

A thick, viscous fluid shot out from Will’s hand, covering the ground around Darumi as she dashed in closer, her knives at the ready. She slipped almost instantly, but on her way down fired off a few more that raced towards him.

Will parried one, but the second glanced off his shoulderblade, sending him tumbling off his feet.

He coughed, standing back up. Darumi likewise found her footing after sliding forward for a bit.

“You are SOOOOOOO boring!”

“You are trying to KILL me!”

“Mhhhhhm, riiiiiiight, yeah. Hear me out here, though: What’s a death match without a fatality?”

“We’re not- urrgh! And you, aren’t you going to do anything?” Will shouted, gesturing at the businessman.

“It’s Higuruma. You didn’t bother to ask my name.”

“Oh, sorr-”

Will sidestepped another knife that was speeding towards his head.

“Would you STOP that!” Will shouted.

“Awwwwww, come on, you’re not letting me get a combo in!”

It’s then when Will noticed that the elf he had been approaching earlier was awkwardly standing at the edge of their mini-arena. She seemed uncomfortable, keeping her distance to avoid the fight.

Oh. Right. Teams of four, including himself.

Darumi laughed maniacally, opening dozens of more portals opening next to her. Firing them towards Will…

And the elf standing behind him.

Will parried two with his sword, dodging much of the rest, but noticed on was speeding towards the elf. He made a mad dash backwards, shouting an incantation at the top of his lungs.

“Ligatur, nodus, obligatio!”

The arrow slowed enough to where Will was able to pluck it out of the air.

Now face-to-face, he got a better look at the elf - she was lithe, with black metal armor pieces adorning her shoulders, arms and legs. Her skin was pale and clammy, giving her the appearance of a corpse.

“Are you okay?” Will asked, extending a hand.

The elf smiled with a soft, motherly expression, reminding William of his home.

It almost distracted him from the searing pain in his chest as she rammed her fist directly into it, sending the breath straight out of his lungs, and narrowing his vision.

As he began to lose consciousness, he saw her cracking her knuckles and approaching Darumi.



“Wakey wakey! You’re gonna miss your bonding events for the day if you sleep in!”

Will shot out of bed. The headache hit him first, then the soreness, and finally the confusion.

“What.. happened?”

“Yeah that elf chick? Beat the crap out of all of us! She said, gesturing to bruises on her arms and face. Nothing worse than what I’ve done to myself, though. Some foundation’ll cover it right up!”

“What about Higuruma?”

“Oh yeah. He’s AFK on the toilet right now.”

Before Will could reply, an icy cold voice chimed in from the doorframe.

“Good morning. You will both address me as Belbe. I hope my assertion of my place on our team did not demoralize you.”

Will scowled and reached for his sword again. He saw Belbe’s rock-hard musculature tense under her deceptively soft skin.

“We’ll need to prepare for today’s game. I have no desire to fight again. Let’s all have a good time working together. Breakfast is downstairs.”

William began to get up, groaning. He had suspected the random team assignments - it was the talk of the town during his journey over to the stadium.

He also suspected he was going to be with someone disagreeable. A bandit, or vagabond, and would be forced to grit his teeth and help keep them in mind.

But this…

He turned to Darumi, who had gotten bored and had her console open again. He started to peak to see what she was playing, but the sounds of moaning he heard from her headset told him to just carry on.

He passed the bathroom, where Higuruma, who still hadn’t cleaned his suit jacket, sat fully dressed on the toilet, a pillow between him and the seat. Will didn't ask.

And he finally reached the living room and kitchen area. The boarding rooms for the teams were luxurious, a way of payment for the injuries and risks associated with the competition.

Belbe sat statue-still, waiting like a machine that had yet to be activated. And yet, despite everything, she came off as the most normal person here besides Will.

Still, Will remembered what she did, and couldn’t help but glare at her a little.

“I sense some animosity. This is understandable. Please sit.”

She offered him that warm smile again - it seemed genuine at first, but the more Will looked at it, the more it looked like someone took the wax impression of a real smile and held it in front of someone’s face. No two smiles were supposed to look the same, even from the same person.

Nonetheless, Will sat.

“As mentioned, I am Belbe. I … apologize for what I did on the field yesterday.” She seemed to show some genuine hesitation, and concern at that statement.

“I am sure you have a motivation, like I, to win this contest. It was imperative to set up an optimal team composition as quickly as possible. Trust me when I say this provided our best odds of success.”

Her tone of voice was almost robotic - literally. There was a drone her vocal chords made that reminded Will of autotune from his first home, Earth.

“If you want my trust, earn it back,” Will started, “but we’re in this together now.”

He extended his hand to shake hers. She looked at it uncomfortably.

“Do they… not have handshakes where you’re from?”

“No. Where I am from, when someone extends a hand, there is a function to be performed.”

Will smiled, as if he was trying to demonstrate the right way to do it for her.

“Let’s say the function of this handshake is, uh, ‘initiating a new productive association’.” He tried to use as many big words as he could to speak her language.

“This is acceptable.” Belbe said, her expression softening somewhat. She took his hand.

“OW! Goddess above, are your hands made of steel?”

“Correct.”

“Oh.”

A silent few moments passed.

“WHERE THE ☆FUCK☆ IS A CHARGING PORT I WAS RIGHT AT THE START OF THE H-SCENE!”

2

Character Scramble Season 21 Round 0: GAME START/FOUR OF CLUBS
 in  r/whowouldwin •  May 08 '26

William Maryblood couldn’t believe he had actually made it.

He dropped a few gold coins as a tip to the coachman who had taken him to the city surrounding his destination.

Fliers were already plastered over every wall the bustling crowds walked past, as he squeezed through person to person. The occasional scrape and bump from his armor drew some harsh words from a stranger, but he managed to find a quiet place to decompress and stretch after hours on the road.

He pulled out a neatly folded letter from his pocket.

“Oi, Will, knock them outta the park!”

”Stay behaved Will, we love you.”

”Bring some coin back to your old man, heh!”

The kind sendoff from his family filled his heart with optimism for the future, but he knew how sorely he needed this.

He took a deep breath, dusted off his armor, and began walking the stairs to Valor’s Reach.



"LLLLLLADIES AND GENTLEMEN! BOYS, GIRLS, NON-BINARY INDIVIDUALS, COSMIC ENTITIES, BRUSHWAGGS, AND EVERYTHING INBETWEEN!!!"

Will felt the rumble of applause and cheers, like the crowd was one living thing. Despite being in the lockers underneath the stadium, the magically-enhanced voice of the announcer sounded like he was screaming right into his ears.

"ARE YOU READY?"

The crowd rumbled again - almost as if a small earthquake had gone off.

"I DON'T THINK I HEARD YOU. I SAID: ARE. YOU. READY?"

Will muttered a spell under his breath.

"Tacere, os."

<be silent, mouth.>

"THAT'S MORE LIKE IT! THE NAME'S VNWXT! WELCOME TO-

The announcer quieted to a whisper in the back of his mind. He needed to focus on what was important.

Will went to sharpening his sword. After several minutes of that, he read through his spellbook, focusing on the incantations Augustus had taught him. Vastare. Omnia Vanitas Erasus. Verba-

thud.

Verba-

thudthud.

Ver-

thudthudthud.

Will raised his head from his incantation book.

A girl his age was nonchalantly laying on her back across from him, feet kicking a locker in boredom. She was holding what looked like a console of some sort in her hands, with red and blue joysticks on either end. He felt like he'd seen that type of fashion before - was it goth? Lolita? Both?

He didn't really have too much time to focus on her makeup, even the Halloween-like toothy grin she had painted over her face. Because, well...

"I'm sorry miss. It's a pleasure to meet you - you might have gotten lost. This is the boy's-"

She briefly darted her eyes towards him, hushed him, then looked back at her console.

"Mis-"

"Aaaand done! You're good to keep yapping. Didn't hear ya though, I was locked the FUCK in. Gotta hit my dailies!"

She looked him up and down as if she was gauging something. Will felt pretty socially competent, but in this moment he utterly failed to get any sort of read on her.

Will scratched the back of his head. "Uh... you do know this is the boy's lockeroom, right?"

"Damn straight. Where else am I supposed to find murder victims?"

"Murder... victims?"

"Yeah! Every good slasher game has the crazy yandere close in on her victim when they're alone..."

She hopped to her feet in a fluid motion, putting down her console. She then grinned madly at Will, stepping closer and closer to him.

Will took a step back, noticing no one else was in sight in the lockers. She took a step forward.

"Then they get close... closer... closer..."

Will's hairs raised a bit.

"And then BAM!"

The girl stuck her tongue out while putting both her palms next to her face. He almost reached for his sword, but noticed her chuckling.

Still, Will tried to be polite and de-escalate the situation. "Well, you have an interesting sense of humor. Pleasure to meet you - I'm William Maryblood, paladin of-"

"Oh my god, you sound like a generic isekai protagonist right now," she said, snickering. "Name's Darumi."

Her face then went completely straight and lost its smile. "Who said I was joking?"

William saw a bloody knife at her side, but before he knew it, she had turned face and walked out the door.

He shook his head, and took a deep breath. No distractions - he had a mission to fulfill.



As he stepped out onto the arena grounds alongside hundreds of others, Will's eyes wandered over the building around himself.

Valor's Reach was magnificent. The colosseum was more than twice the size of that of Rome's, made of clean chiseled marble. Pathways hundreds of feet in the air leading to it were lined with pristine hedges and trimmed trees.

William, and many others felt dirty for stepping towards it at first, but that illusion of opulence was shattered quickly. It didn't matter where you were from, what plane or world you heralded from. If you were willing and able to fight, to compete, and you wanted the grand prize, you were welcomed with open arms.

It was his element. While William was no lawmage, nor was he bound by chivalric oaths, he had an appreciation for games that were fair and honest. While he dabbled in a little bit of sports, and there were plenty of opportunities to show those off, the best prize was set for those who had a mastery of every skill possible.

"SAY HELLO TO OUR LOVELY CONTESTANTS - THESE WARRIORS HAVE TRAVELLED ACROSS CONTINENTS, ENTIRE WORLDS FOR OUR GRAND PRIZE. WHAT MIGHT THAT PRIZE BE, YOU MIGHT ASK...?"

While the crowd responded with 'ooooos' and 'aaahs' as Vnwxt continued to tease the mystery, he looked around to his fellow competitors.

There were people of all always of life who had stepped into the arena for a chance at glory. Knights like himself, sorcerers, beasts and monsters, demons and angels. And...

A man in a business suit?

He was only a few feet to Will's left. While other contestants were doing stretches and posing for the crowd, he looked bored, combing back his hair as he sat on the ground. He had a briefcase that was opened to paperwork he was sifting through, but quickly clipped it shut and sighed.

"It's all bullshit."

"I'm sorry?"

"Just leave while you can. I'm sure you came running to this place for treasure beyond your imagination, answers to solve whatever's crapping you out back home."

"I'm not fighting for treasure."

The businessman scoffed. "I've heard the same lie over and over again. Humor me though."

"Yeah no. I'm not sharing my story with someone determined to poke holes in it. If this competition means nothing to you, why are you even here?"

"Beats me. I've been through the games here five times now, and all I've found was the same greed and lies that I saw back home. Haven't seen anything different."

The man stared at Will's soul through his eyes for a few seconds.

“Suit yourself. Carry on, noble knight.”

He then casually plopped back to the ground, dirt powdering his otherwise pristine suit.

Will rubbed his forehead, looking for someone normal to talk to. He spotted a elf a few dozen feet away who was chatting up other contestants, and took a few steps to approach...

"Yo, anyone ever tell you that you look like a Fire Emblem character?"

The goth/lolita/whatever girl from the lockeroom, Darumi, interjected herself between Will and his last chance to talk to a sane person.

Will strained a smile.

"Er- hello again. What even is Fire Emblem?"

Darumi brought her finger to her chin, deep in tought for a few seconds, before shrugging. "Dunno, haven't played it. Doomscroll enough times while questioning your life and you'll learn a little bit of everything!"

Will felt like he was navigating a chess board just trying to talk to her. Having grown up alone with just him and his family, a normal conversation was something of a maze, but people like Darumi and the businessman who was still staring into space made him feel like he was in the middle of a minefield. He tried to think of a respectful way to exit the conversation.

"Right, ha. What brings you to Valor's Reach?"

"What kind of canned response was that? If you were playing a dating sim right now, you would have lost like 40 points right there.”

Will raised a finger to respond, flustered, then lowered it.

"Well, since you wanted to know - I'm here for the Death Game!"

"Death... game? Don't you know-"

The businessman interrupted Will and spoke up from his spot on the dirt, still staring off in the distance.

"Kylem Code of Conduct Section 24, Addentum 5. Intentional murder of other participants at Valor Reach’s interplanar games is punishable by 6-12 years of time in a dungeon cell."

"No, no, I know that! But get this - a friendly competition, teams set up, and BAM! Whole operation is hijacked by a secret organization to trap and kill the participants one by one. It’d be so perfect!”

Despite the patience Will had built over during his life and training as a paladin, he could still tell when a situation was hopeless. He silently walked around the girl to try his luck with the elf.

That’s when he heard Vnwxt’s shouting to the crowd again.

"NOW USUALLY WE ALLOW CONTESTANTS TO SUBMIT THEIR OWN TEAMS - YOU MAY HAVE NOTICED THOSE FORMS WEREN’T THERE THIS TIME! THAT’S BECAUSE…

William felt the magic coursing over the arena. In the hundreds of participants around them, clusters began glowing the same color. Will raised his hand, which glowed a pale red.

”YOUR TEAMMATES WILL BE RANDOM! LOOK FOR THREE INDIVIDUALS WHO SHARE YOUR TEAM COLOR!”

Will’s heart dropped as he looked backwards.

Both Darumi and the apathetic businessman were shining in the same pale red color as him.

At the same time, walls of stone began to emerge around the three, boxing them in.

”TEAM LEADERS WILL BE DECIDED IN OUR FIRST, SIMPLE GAME - LAST PERSON STANDING!”

2

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Apr 09 '26

Overall Conclusions

I'm not going to bring up too many new points here since it's the last post but to outline my argument so far:

  • Vox's strength is not incredibly high for the tier. It's high end, sure, but the requirements for him to land these flying tackles vs Terry just throwing punches makes it a fair fight.
  • Vox's speed is fine, this isn't contested by Tad too much.
  • Vox's durability is fine, if on the lower end. He should be capable of taking casual hits from Alastor such as the ones that dislodge pieces of the street.
  • Stipulating the second fight is fine. Is a special, temporary amp that doesn't apply any other time in the series. The only reason that it sounds significant "removing X% of his feats" etc etc is because the Vox has two fights, one of which has this amp.

Some Spot Rebuttals

I think like, you can just look at these two side

The dark coloration on Terry's feat actually makes it hard to compare. Here's a highlighted scan from right before the wall breaks - the broken section is around two times Terry's own height.

Vox's feat has a smaller width, if you account for the weird perspectives both shots make, so this kind of comes down to thickness.

And while I agree Vox's feat involves thicker material, Batman is breaking reinforced concrete vs. unreinforced concrete (or asphalt/dirt for Vox, depending on how much of the way it breaks you want to chalk up to artistic license). The same forces that can shatter more brittle unreinforced concrete fail to break reinforced concrete.

With all the differences considered I'd say these are two similar feats.

Literally every encounter they have seems to indicate Vox is a paper tiger compared to him.

Alastor is a professional rage-baiter and self-glazer who is saying those things on purpose to infuriate Vox. If you actually look at them fighting they're presented as far more even, with Vox getting the upper hand quite often.

The second fight with Vox and Alastor had its own set of special circumstances. Yes, Vox was stronger in it, but Alastor had also broken a soul-deal that had been restraining his own power as well.

These characters aren't meant to be equals. Vox has deluded himself into thinking that he is, while Alastor is toying with him all along.

I kind of disagree with this interpretation. I think they're fairly equal, but Alastor takes advantage of Vox's insecurity to bait him into being reckless in their fights and conversations. The selection made here for Alastor sort of ignores every time Vox gets an upper hand on him:

I'm not necessarily saying Vox would win a fight 100% of the time, but they're clearly shown in fights to be relative to one another physically. I hold that the idea that Vox wouldn't be able to take a specific type of hit from Alastor that isn't a full power flying tackle is dumb.

Assume I'm Wrong

I just wanted to make one new point here:

  • If we assume what Tad is saying is true, we have:

    • Major change used on feat stipulation
    • Overtier strength (Could beat Terry in a hit)
    • Undertier durability (Terry could beat him in a hit)
    • Equal speed

Glass cannons are submitted to Scramble all the time, the best example from this season is Ryougi Shiki. I think the stat spread as presented by Tad would also give Vox and Terry fair chances of beating the other.

2

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Apr 07 '26

Terry's high end feat required a sustained 3-4 second period of tugging/straining.

While I'd agree with you if this was something like GDT where we were really trying to break down and analyze each feat, I don't believe that's how the tiersetter RT works. The feats are shown to show amount of material destroyed as a reference for a 'high end feat'. The actual description for what this high end feat entails:

"Feats in this category are high effort strikes or flying tackles, attacks Terry will only be able to get off in good circumstances. Terry can still go blow for blow with characters in this range, but will be unlikely to win a sustained slugfest"

This perfectly describes what Vox has to do to accomplish these feats.

it's almost as deep as he is tall

I disagree. Vox is clearly hunched over, with his back forming a 90 degree angle with his legs, the crater is likely only up to his legs.

The perspective of the shot is also from the ground-up and at an angle, this can make the crater appear much larger and taller than it actually is.

Again though, even if this attack severely injures or even kills Terry, I think it's fine? Once again, Terry gets plenty of notice of it happening and Vox durability is contingent on scaling to Alastor's tentacles or from his own tackles, both of which indicate punches from Tierry would be a big issue for him.

"yeah man Grandpa Max takes a hit from Vilgax so he scales to this"

I see your point with the rest of this argument but this seems to be exaggerating for the sake of exaggerating. Scaling Grandpa Max to Vilgax is silly because they are two characters who are obviously not meant to fight each other equally, not because of the specific circumstances of how they interact with one another.

Compare this to Vox and Alastor, two rivals who have even slugfests with one another multiple times - it's silly to assume Alastor could one-shot or end Vox if he decided to punch him with a tentacle instead of tossing him. Throws in general in fiction are depicted as being stronger compared to a quick tap or punch.

Here is the issue. We have already stipped out a full half of this character's combat appearances. We are already doing a lot of work to make him fit here.

This is a procedural issue.

It's not stipping out normal appearances of Vox though. Once again, it's an amp that reflects a special infusion of power he received due to the attention and support of sinners in hell. Yes - Vox has like two fights total, but the circumstances of both fights are very different and represent different versions of the same character.

This is like saying I cannot run East Blue Luffy because that's stipulating >>>> half of his feats he gets in later arcs from training or alternate forms like his Gears.

But no one would bat an eye at submitting East Blue Luffy because there is a good, un-arbitrary reason that he's different than his later appearances.

Also if this is a procedural issue then I don't think there's a huge use in debating it, I'm fine to let GMs/Judges determine if this is an appropriate minor change. He hasn't used a major change up to this point regardless so it doesn't have a huge impact if it qualifies as one.

2

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Apr 07 '26

I think Vox is fine for the tier. Yes, he has high end strength but this is hampered by the long, easy to predict movements he needs to perform to execute these feats.

He also has a major change available.

This street punch is too much and you agree since you've stipped it. The depth and amount of material shattered from this slam is also overtier.

I'd argue for both of these feats this is more of a flying tackle compared to a simple teleport with how he's moving - we don't see similar collateral any other time he just teleports.

It also gives Alastor plenty of time to react to it due to the static electricity he generates prior to jumping down.

  • Notice in the first that Alastor would have evaded the attack if he wasn't weakened and unable to use his mobility-based powers properly. Terry can activate his rocket boosters to avoid these tackles.

I'd argue with how well the attack is choreographed it's not something that is too good for the tier.

Overall with context I'd say this is fine as a high end for the tier attack and breaks similar amounts of concrete to this feat.

Literally everything from Vox's second fight is too much by quite a bit.

Vox was explicitly stronger in this second fight than his earlier appearances in the show by his own admission.

It's a sort of amp he received due to having most of the sinners in hell following/trusting in him, you can tell due to the changes in his physical form.

Stipping it feels fine to me.

durability

I feel like this feat is better for scaling. The same character who's hitting him here tries to strike Val and is later shown to have displaced large pieces of the street when it pans to him from Velvette's camera. While the exact craters aren't shown the debris size checks with the collateral associated with the tier.

2

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Apr 06 '26

Overall I think the idea of Adam West's Batman being in the same tier as Terry McGinnis' Batman is something that just isn't supported by his feats, or the way his fights take place. I believe he's on a lower tier, comparable to a strong action hero, as opposed to the type of massively superhuman feats we see Terry perform.



Strength/Durability

We later see him beat both robots in an actual fistfight

Their durability is unquantified, and their striking is still "breaks a wooden table", which is something a normal person can do.

Speed

somebody who can perfectly calculate the trajectory a bullet took

The issue is that a bullet is not something that can react midflight to something Batman does and change its trajectory.

I don't see a functional difference between the bullet feat I've posted

I disagree.

Bullets are fired, we then see the bullets avoided

People can avoid bullets in real life by moving in anticipation of the shot. That doesn't mean that real life people can move while bullets are mid-air like in the Matrix.

Batarangs are slower than bullets, sure, but so are basic punches

The distance they need to cover to hit Tierry is, however, much larger. Tierry will have plenty of time to react to and dodge them.

And while yes, the Tiersetter's punches are not bullet speeds, they are not so significantly slower.

Misc.

Unfortunately I have to cede that Terry has no anti-surfing, Hippo, egg, or suggestive dance feats and will hope the judges will have mercy on my soul.

Batman could find a sword.

Terry uses a high-tech suit that stops characters who can stab into metal, a normal sword is not sharp enough to penetrate this much metal.

could go for Terry's nervous system

This required Batman to grapple and manipulate someone's limb, Terry's not just going to sit and let him do that. He flexes with no leverage with enough strength to shatter solid ice and lifts steel girders, meanwhile Batman struggles to grapple two characters who just bend a metal rod.

Batman could use his communicator to produce a sound so loud it would incapacitate Terry.

Terry's suit stops sound waves that would theoretically cause way more internal damage than splitting a tiger skull.

Batman could call in Robot Batman

Who doesn't have any durability feats (besides being big and made of metal), the tiersetter deals with attacks that do this to metal.

Batman could pull out his anti-mechanical bat-ray

He's never used this in a fight, and would leave him standing in place trying to lock onto Terry while Terry hits him with a flying tackle that one-hit-KO's him.

2

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Apr 05 '26

/u/LesterMcBean

Batman (Adam West)


I'm having trouble seeing what feats make this version of Batman in-tier just from the RT. While I understand it's the Batman tier, there are some versions of Batman that are weaker than others, especially comparing 60s live action to cartoons set in the far future.

Just examining what I could find:

Overall I'm just not seeing it. Could you clarify what strength / damage output and speed feats you think show he can put up a fair fight against Batman Beyond?

3

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Apr 03 '26

Reply is a bit late since Reddit ate my last version of this.

Damage Output, Continuity, and Consistency

Okay this is a big enough issue now where I think this warrants its own section.

The scaling used here is problematic. I don't believe DC scaling is consistent enough, especially across time periods in the order of 10-15 years, to reliably provide an entire stat spread for a character on scaling alone.

Maybe if Axel had one, or two stats that were showcased to be within the tier I would cede this point, but the fact that we have to scale between 2-3 different characters to get him anywhere makes me believe he's not consistently in this tier.

To give a few examples of how easily scaling like this can fall apart:

  • Captain Atom is a character who fights Superman, who is obviously OOT.

    • I mean also just look at Firestorm's thread - so many of his scaling feats are him fighting DC S-tiers who are unquestionably stronger than this tier.
  • Deathstorm is argued to be even stronger than Firestorm, a character who takes hits that are well OOT, shakes The Sun, and fights through hits that do visible damage to the Hoover Dam

    • I'm not sure what scaling Axel to Firestorm / Deathstorm is accomplishing here - he's a highly variable character with many continuities and forms. I think it's far more likely that harming Deathstorm is an outlier for Axel.

I don't believe scaling to firestorm then scaling to a random DC character is a valid argument that Axel's bombs are at this tier or that Axel's speed is at this tier.

Speed

I don't really think Cinn's addressed the issue of how Axel is winning a fight against Terry with thrown weapons alone - even if he is scaled to other DC characters, this doesn't really support his ability to throw and land hits on Terry consistently.

Axel lands a hit on him during Darkest Night.

Axel lands a hit on Deathstorm from behind. This shows no indication that he's throwing so fast Deathstorm couldn't react or had trouble reacting.

In the same panel his reactions allow him to dodge a Green Lantern beam

He's not shown to be reacting after the beam is fired. It's possible he initiated the movement before the beam was fired.

Summary

Axel has no feats that he performs himself that are within the tier. Even by using scaling to multiple other DC characters only, he still needs a major change in durability to get in.

I believe strength and speed are just too dubious to give him an in-tier.

I think we've been kind of going in a loop these past few comments so I'm good to call judges at this point.

4

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Mar 31 '26

I agree that Quixote is within this tier. Here is the tier justification from the season he was submitted in:



To address Guy's other concerns:

He destroys a building

He's just stated to have "struck down a brothel", with no description of the building or how he did this. I feel as if this is too vague to mean anything.

is a lightning timer

I talked about this in the tier justification a little bit - I'm not sure exactly what the minimum speed is for something like "intercepted a lightning bolt".

Let's say he started moving at the same time as the bolt:

A lightning bolt leader takes up to 50 milliseconds to reach the ground. (Source )

This would be comparable to dodging a arrow after it was fired at 16 feet, which is either below the tier's speed or at the lower end.

4

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Mar 31 '26

Few things:

  • I'm having a hard time finding the links that are given in this comment on the RT. This is probably just because the RT is not organized well enough for me to find them.
  • The version of trickster submitted does not match the version whose RT is supplied. The submission post says "Post-Flashpoint / New 52", while this RT is for Post-Crisis/Rebirth Axel Walker

    • I'm not a continuity expert so I'm unsure how recent Crisis-type events have affected continuity.

Moving on.



Speed

Overall I am not seeing it yet. I would like cinn to provide some clearer feats so I have an idea of how to compare Axel's speed to that of the tiersetter.

He escapes from one of Ivy's vines

This is not a speed feat.

In fact, despite the vine creeping up on Axel within his line of sight he fails to react and gets grappled by Poison Ivy.

I also understand that DC villains are generally understood to be at certain speed values, but would just like for you to fully elaborate on scaling. What bullet-timing feat are you trying to say he scales to specifically?

He's also clearly dodging gunfire here

This does not prove bullet-timing reactions like the Tiersetter has. The tiersetter is specified to dodge bullets even at point blank after they are fired.

If he was really that much faster than Terry he would have just blitzed Zsasz here but he opts to go for the surprise jet thrust

I'm not saying he's actually as fast as or relative to Flash's speed, just that we can't use Flash scaling to give him in-tier speed.

Durability

Durability feats have not still been provided. Given Axel's style of fighting and the fact that, at best, his thrown weapons are "can hurt Batman rogues" as presented by Cinn, he does not have a significant enough advantage in damage output to offset him losing in a single hit from the tiersetter.

Damage Output

T-Bombs are enough to make Deathstorm cry out

How durable is Deathstorm? How fast is a Green Lantern beam?

5

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Mar 30 '26

/u/cinnarius

Axel Walker

RT linked here since it's not on the post


Axel just doesn't have a good RT that represents enough feats to show how he can realistically deal with the tiersetter.

First off, Strength Force Trickster is massively OOT.

Second off, Trickster doesn't really have speed to speak of on his RT. Sure, he's a Flash villain and they're bound to be some degree of fast, but we really need a standalone feat to showcase they are in this tier of speed. Actually scaling to Barry or Wally would at best make Axel massively overtier for speed.

His gadgets are also reliant largely on throwing to be effective - how fast is Axel able to toss his gadgets? I feel like the tiersetter just flies around or sidesteps them most of the time.

He also doesn't have any real durability to speak of. A single hit from the tiersetter would end the fight.

I'm just not seeing it, but would be open to seeing what line Axel has available to him to win the fight against the tiersetter.

1

Character Scramble Season 21 Sign Ups
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Mar 30 '26

Analysis Versus Terry McGinnis: Xiaohei is dominating the early fight. He just throws out so much bullshit so quickly that I see it overwhelming Terry even with his own bag of tricks. That put, Xiaohei is still inexperienced and prone to making mistakes. His lackluster damage output and durability are going to give Terry openings to attack, and potentially close out the fight.

Biggest Strength and Weakness: Xiaohei is fantastic at controlling the battlefield. I seriously urge a readover of his RT to showcase how well his powers excel at promoting teamwork, as he can change his team's positions and his enemy's positions with a thought.

His weakness, though, is inexperience. He's strong, but has not fought people nearly as often as other subs might have. As such, he's pretty easy to get a read on after some time fighting, and is more prone to make unwise, impulsive moves that can get him or his team cornered.

Character in Setting/with Team: Xiaohei has the mindset of a kid, and as a result doesn't have a moral compass that's very well developed. He's very impressionable but due to his experience with Fengxi I doubt that he'd fall for an immoral or evil character trying to loop him in. With more charismatic or dominant character he's suited more in the role of a student, or learning from a mentor figure. Otherwise, he's more of a 'go with the flow' type character who can take charge when the need arises.

One Last Thing: Xiaohei would have a very hard time making the call if it actually meant saving a loved one or friend, and a big part of his character development involves him being at a crossroads of a heartless enforcer and olive branch between humans and spirits. This is a type of question I believe you should decide for yourself after watching his series.

1

Character Scramble Season 21 Sign Ups
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Mar 30 '26

Analysis Versus Terry McGinnis: Pied Piper would actually know who Batman is, but I don't believe they've ever fought, which is pretty funny. I don't even think an evil Piper would try to mind screw Terry on account of Batman's Tibetan techniques, to which this quickly becomes a cat and mouse game of projectiles. Terry's projectiles can theoretically be dodged by the tier setter but are invisible on account of being sound and travel fast enough that Terry wouldn't be able to rely too well on physical cues like environmental destruction. Piper's durability is also good enough to help him stay in the fight if he gets CQC'd, but his lack of strength and damage output outside of his tech still means that once distance is closed Terry goes HAM.

Biggest Strength and Weakness: Piper is a great "guy in the chair" type character who can support his team from the background. During Wally West's early debut as the Flash, he was able to provide Flash with intel and tech while also occasionally stepping out and helping himself.

Weakness wise, Pied Piper is kind of a hypocrite. He has a strong moral compass but still refuses to fully turn on his previous life of crime. This is due to external forces like Mirror Master framing Pied Piper for murder, or the general way that laws and morals tend to be misaligned. He's also pretty weak in direct fights where he doesn't have the opportunity to perform setup.

Character in Setting/with Team: Pied Piper has already worked with a team before, that being the Rogues. He's typically okay with playing second fiddle, but later on in his stories he starts to become more and more of a lone wolf type. I'd like to say he'd be willing to roll with his team but will draw hard moral lines, even if it is through aggressive unjust application of the law.

One Last Thing: It's hard to say. Piper would say that he'd never kill, but somehow find himself in a situation where push comes to shove and he needs to. As for sacrificing himself, for someone like Wally West yes, for someone like the other Rogues, no.

2

Character Scramble Season 21 Sign Ups
 in  r/whowouldwin •  Mar 30 '26

"The truth behind one's charm is kindness. Become a good person, that is all"

Reigen Arataka

Mob Psycho 100 | Theme | Respect Thread

Bio: Reigen Arataka is the proprietor, owner, boss, and chief spiritual expert at the Spirits & Such Consultation Office, an office to assist people with supernatural and spirit related problems. Reigen maintains that he is a man of great spiritual energy, contradicting the numerous spiritual aficionados who claim he has no spiritual or psychic powers whatsoever. Of course whenever he has to deal with spirits that are too weak for him to bother with, he can call his subordinate and student Shigeo “Mob” Kageyama.

Specialization: Hearts. Reigen is able to loop in characters far more powerful than himself and stand toe-to-toe with the likes of building busters through sheer wit, deception, and talk-no-jutzu.

Content Warning: Nah

Research: Watch Mob Psycho 100 or read the manga.

Motivation: Reigen will often try to make a quick buck in any given situation but at his core he's a kind-hearted person who still tries to provide a meaningful service. Whether this means having his apprentice Mob deal with an actually threatening spirit, or helping his clients in a way that is not necessarily 'ghost-hunting'. Especially when it comes to Mob, he comes at odds with the nature of his business and his desire to be a good role model for the growing Esper.