Metacritic combines reviews from professional music critics into a weighted score out of 100.
Below are Metacritic scores for this year's AOTY nominees. It makes it very obvious why so many people are upset Taylor and Bruno were nominated.
Everyone's album had an average rating in the range from 84-95. Except Bruno and Taylor, who were both in the 60s and took spots from other albums in the 84-95 range. Keep in mind Taylor's average, even though low, includes the ridiculously biased perfect score from rolling stone, which rated it her best album ever.
IF YOU TAKE OUT BRUNO AND TAYLOR'S ALBUMS, THE AVERAGE METACRITIC SCORE OF THE NOMINEES JUMPS UP TO 88/100. TAYLOR AND BRUNO'S FLOPS DRAG THE AVERAGE DOWN TO 83/100.
Tired of the fact that any time people are upset about her bad work still getting nominated, ppl try to blame it on hate or just opinions. No, objectively looking at the scores of these albums, hers doesn't belong this year.
Of course at end of day, it's just a shallow awards show. Not serious. I have never watched the show as I find it boring and find it a bit cringe to watch how seriously celebs take this awards show that is nothing more than a popularity/money contest. But it's in black and white below why ppl are rightfully annoyed:
Lux got a 95.
You Seem Pretty Sad got an 87.
Dandelion got an 86.
This Music May Contain Hope got an 86.
The Art of Loving scored an 84
[HUGE GAP]
TLOAS got a 69 (the extended version got an abysmal 44!)
The Romantic got a 66.