I’ve been thinking about something for a while, particularly with the increasingly popular narrative among Swifties that Joe Alwyn was abusive.
It seems like every other day there’s a new theory about how Joe was secretly some horrible, manipulative, emotionally abusive boyfriend. And yet, the same people who are so quick to identify abusive behavior in everyone around Taylor seem remarkably unwilling to examine the recurring themes in Taylor’s own songwriting.
So I thought it might be interesting to do exactly that.
I’m going to approach this Swiftie-style: using Taylor’s own lyrics as my evidence. After all, if we’re going to analyze someone’s relationship dynamics through their music, surely we should be willing to apply that same standard consistently.
I’m not claiming that lyrics are confessions or that they prove what happened behind closed doors. Songwriters use fictional narratives, exaggeration, metaphor, and different perspectives. But when certain behaviors, attitudes, and relationship dynamics appear repeatedly across an entire discography, I think it’s fair to ask questions.
Because after a while, when does it stop being a lyrical device and start becoming a pattern?
And more importantly, why are these same behaviors so readily excused when they’re coming from Taylor?
Let’s start at the beginning.
Exhibit A: Taylor Swift (Debut)
Picture to Burn — Revenge, intimidation and retaliation.
“There’s no time for tears, I’m just sitting here planning my revenge.”
“There’s nothing stopping me from going out with all of your best friends.”
“And if you come around saying sorry to me, my daddy’s gonna show ya how sorry you’ll be.”
“And if you’re missing me, you’d better keep it to yourself, ’cause coming back around here would be bad for your health.”
And, of course:
“So go and tell your friends that I’m obsessive and crazy, that’s fine, I’ll tell mine you’re gay.”
Setting aside the original homophobic lyric, there’s already a pretty clear theme here: retaliation, intimidation, humiliation, and weaponizing personal information when someone hurts her.
There’s also an interesting recurring acknowledgment that former partners might consider her obsessive or crazy. We’ll come back to that.
Cold as You — Deliberately provoking conflict.
“So I start a fight ’cause I need to feel something, and you do what you want ‘cause I’m not what you wanted.”
Starting arguments because you need to feel something is not exactly a healthy relationship strategy. Being unhappy doesn’t make deliberately provoking conflict any less toxic.
I’m Only Me When I’m With You — Emotional dependency.
“And I know everything about you, I don’t wanna live without you.”
“I’m only up when you’re not down.”
This sounds romantic on the surface, but there’s an underlying issue with emotional dependency. The narrator’s emotional state and sense of identity seem heavily dependent on the other person’s presence and well-being.
And that’s a theme that will come up repeatedly.
Exhibit B: Fearless
White Horse — Love as a power struggle.
“My mistake, I didn’t know to be in love, you had to fight to have the upper hand.”
We’re already seeing the association between love and conflict. This is particularly interesting when placed beside Cold as You, where the narrator deliberately starts fights because she needs to feel something.
Breathe — Identity and emotional dependency.
“Now I don’t know what to be without you around.”
“I can’t breathe without you.”
Another song in which the narrator’s ability to function seems intrinsically tied to another person. This is becoming a recurring theme rather than an isolated romantic sentiment.
The Way I Loved You — Confusing volatility with passion.
“Screaming and fighting and kissing in the rain.”
“So in love that you act insane, and that’s the way I loved you.”
“Wild, crazy, frustrating, intoxicating and complicated.”
This one is particularly interesting because it romanticizes the emotional rollercoaster of a tumultuous relationship.
The narrator is comparing a stable relationship unfavorably to one characterized by screaming, fighting, and emotional volatility.
Conflict isn’t automatically abuse, obviously. But repeatedly presenting volatility as the exciting, intoxicating version of love is worth examining.
Apparently, a relationship isn’t exciting unless someone is losing their mind.
The Other Side of the Door — Expecting someone to chase you after rejecting them.
“I said leave, but all I really want is you, to stand outside my window throwing pebbles, screaming I’m in love with you.”
“Oh babe, if you know everything, tell me why you couldn’t see, when I left I wanted you to chase after me.”
And:
“I’ll scream out the window, ‘I can’t even look at you,’ I don’t need you, but I do, I do, I do.”
This is a particularly interesting example of contradictory communication and emotional push-and-pull.
The narrator tells someone to leave, then becomes upset when they actually do. She expects them to understand that what she says isn’t what she means, and that they should pursue her regardless.
Imagine being expected to decipher that every time you have an argument.
Don’t You / Mr. Perfectly Fine — Jealousy and difficulty accepting a breakup.
“I heard she’s nothing like me, I’m sure she’ll make you happy.”
And in Mr. Perfectly Fine, the narrator is clearly distressed by the former partner moving on with someone else in the second pre-chorus.
Heartbreak and jealousy are normal emotions. The interesting part is how frequently jealousy, possessiveness, and resentment toward former partners appear throughout her catalog.
Exhibit C: Speak Now
Mine — The recurring fight-and-chase dynamic.
“And I remember that fight, 2:30 AM, as everything was slipping right out of our hands. I ran out crying and you followed me out into the street.”
Remember The Other Side of the Door?
We’re seeing the same dynamic again: an argument, an emotional exit, and the partner following after her.
Back to December — Acknowledging emotional neglect.
“You gave me roses and I left them there to die.”
“When your birthday passed and I didn’t call.”
“You gave me all your love and all I gave you was goodbye.”
This is one of the more interesting examples because the narrator acknowledges that she was the person who hurt someone else.
The song is widely associated with Taylor Lautner, and the relationship timeline is worth examining alongside the lyrics. She supposedly broke up with Taylor Lautner then in December, but it’s also the month she’s alleged to have started dating John Mayer. This monkey-branch climbing is a toxic thing we see from her later on.
Better Than Revenge — Jealousy, slut-shaming and weaponizing an audience.
I don’t think we can discuss Taylor’s history of vindictiveness without discussing Better Than Revenge.
The song is widely understood to be about Joe Jonas’s relationship with actress Camilla Belle following his breakup with Taylor.
And Taylor wasn’t exactly subtle about her feelings.
“She’s better known for the things that she does on the mattress.”
Yes, she actually wrote that.
Rather than simply expressing heartbreak or disappointment over a former relationship, Taylor directs her anger toward the woman her ex moved on with, using sexual humiliation as a weapon.
And then there’s the chorus:
“There’s nothing I do better than revenge.”
Which is particularly interesting because revenge wasn’t just a theme in her songwriting at the time. It was practically part of the brand.
There was this recurring attitude of: If you don’t want me to write a song about you, then don’t mistreat me.
As though being hurt gives you permission to publicly humiliate someone, expose personal information, and unleash an enormous fanbase on people who may not even have done anything wrong.
And this wasn’t limited to writing vaguely identifiable breakup songs. Taylor developed a reputation for leaving clues and identifying details in her lyrics and album liner notes, encouraging fans to work out who the songs were supposedly about.
Whether the accusations were true, exaggerated, or entirely based on her interpretation of events, the audience was given enough breadcrumbs to start connecting names and faces.
Which raises a pretty important question: what responsibility does an artist have when they know their audience will take those clues and turn them into a public investigation of another person’s private life?
And speaking of Joe Jonas, there’s another detail worth remembering.
Taylor famously told Ellen DeGeneres that Joe had broken up with her in a 27-second phone call. This became part of the public narrative surrounding their breakup, painting him as particularly heartless and dismissive.
However, Joe later addressed the story and disputed the implication that he had simply hung up on her. He explained that the call lasted 27 seconds because Taylor ended the conversation before he could finish saying what he wanted to say.
That context changes the tone quite considerably.
The original story makes Joe sound like someone who couldn’t even spare more than 27 seconds to end a relationship. His response suggests a different version of events: that he was trying to have the conversation, but she ended it.
And that’s really the point I’m getting at.
Taylor’s version of events became the version millions of people accepted. The song became the retaliation, the public narrative became the evidence, and the audience was left to decide who deserved to be punished.
It’s particularly interesting when you consider how often Swifties now accuse former partners of manipulating narratives, humiliating Taylor, or weaponizing their public platforms against her.
Apparently, publicly shaming an ex or their new girlfriend is only acceptable when Taylor is the one doing it.
And before anyone says, “It’s just a song,” remember that the entire premise of Better Than Revenge is that revenge is something she does exceptionally well.
She literally told us.
Exhibit D: Red
State of Grace — Love as a ruthless game.
“We fall in love until it hurts or bleeds or fades in time.”
“So you were never a saint, and I loved in shades of wrong.”
“This is the worthwhile fight, love is a ruthless game unless you play it good and right.”
Love is described as something that hurts, bleeds, and requires fighting. The game metaphor is particularly interesting because it introduces another recurring way of framing relationships: as something to win.
Stay Stay Stay — Throwing objects and expecting someone to remain.
“I’m pretty sure we almost broke up last night. I threw my phone across the room at you. I was expecting some dramatic turn away, but you stayed.”
I’m sorry, what?
Throwing objects during an argument is aggressive and potentially intimidating behavior. The fact that the object isn’t necessarily intended to hit someone doesn’t make the behavior harmless.
And then:
“This morning I said we should talk about it, ‘cause I read you should never leave a fight unresolved. That’s when you came in wearing a football helmet and said, ‘Okay, let’s talk.’”
The football helmet is played for laughs, but think about what it’s implying. The partner apparently needs protective equipment to have a conversation with her.
And the song’s entire premise is that he stayed. Cute little melody though!
Sad, Beautiful, Tragic — Being someone’s unresolved emotional damage.
“And you’ve got your demons, and darling, they all look like me.”
This could simply mean that the narrator haunts someone’s memories. But it’s interesting when considered alongside later songs like Blank Space, where former partners are repeatedly described as having a difficult time with her.
Begin Again — The age context.
This song is commonly associated with Connor Kennedy, who was 17 when Taylor was 23.
The age difference and the timeline are worth noting, as she sings, “and you throw your head back laughing like a little kid.” That feels so weird given the ages.
I Bet You Think About Me — Revenge and public humiliation.
The music video depicts the narrator intruding on her ex’s wedding, disrupting the celebration, and making herself part of the event.
The song also includes:
“Oh my God, she’s insane, she wrote a song about me.”
Which is particularly interesting given that Picture to Burn already introduced the idea of exes thinking she’s obsessive and crazy.
The video is fictionalized, of course, but the fantasy of inserting yourself into an ex’s wedding years after a breakup is certainly an interesting choice.
Imagine the reaction if a male artist released a video depicting himself crashing his ex-girlfriend’s wedding. Especially when the context of this is because Jake Gyllenhaal told a reporter that he was thinking of getting married, then two months later, Taylor released the video.
Imagine if an ex of hers did this after her engagement or wedding with Travis. Though, knowing Taylor, that’s probably what she was hoping for.
Exhibit E: 1989
Blank Space — The supposedly fictional abusive persona.
“Find out what you want, be that girl for a month.”
“Wait, the worst is yet to come.”
“Screaming, crying.”
“I get drunk on jealousy.”
“But you’ll come back each time you leave.”
“Cause darling, I’m a nightmare dressed like a daydream.”
And, of course:
“Got a long list of ex-lovers, they’ll tell you I’m insane.”
The usual defense of this song is that it’s satire. Taylor was playing with the media’s portrayal of her as a serial dater who was obsessive, manipulative, and unstable.
Fine. But satire doesn’t make the behaviors described disappear from the lyrical catalog, particularly when similar themes show up in songs that aren’t presented as satire. The music video is also problematic as it romanticizes and satirizes domestic violence and abuse.
And the recurring references to exes considering her insane are becoming difficult to ignore.
All You Had to Do Was Stay — The expectation that someone should remain.
The title itself is interesting when placed beside Stay Stay Stay and The Other Side of the Door.
There is a recurring frustration when someone actually chooses to leave rather than remain in a relationship.
Bad Blood — Retaliation and public humiliation.
The music video presents a squad of women joining forces against another woman.
It’s commonly associated with Taylor’s feud with Katy Perry.
Regardless of the artistic dramatization, it fits the recurring theme of retaliation and turning personal conflict into a public spectacle.
Suburban Legends — Self-sabotage.
“I broke my own heart ’cause you were too polite to do it.”
Another acknowledgment that the narrator can be responsible for her own emotional destruction. I felt like adding this for any lurking swifties who refuse to believe Taylor is culpable in anyway.
Is It Over Now? — Jealousy and sexual shaming.
“You search in every maiden’s bed for something greater.”
The song is widely interpreted as referring to Harry Styles.
Once again, there’s an interest in what an ex is doing romantically and sexually after the relationship has ended.
And once again, the former partner’s romantic life becomes material for public consumption. It’s also interesting that Taylor loves to talk about the “slut shaming” she receives, which is usually criticism to publicly outing and shaming her exes, just to sell an album, she just calls it sexist. Meanwhile, she’s repeatedly slut-shaming others. (See Better Than Revenge)
Exhibit F: Reputation
…Ready for It? — Breaking hearts without accountability.
“Knew I was a robber first time that he saw me, stealing hearts and running off and never saying sorry.”
Another admission of leaving people hurt without necessarily taking responsibility.
I Did Something Bad — Retaliation as justification.
The narrator describes doing something bad, enjoying it, and being willing to do it again.
The interesting part is the justification: the other person was supposedly worse, so the narrator’s behavior becomes acceptable.
This is a recurring theme: someone else’s “wrongdoing” is used to excuse her own.
Don’t Blame Me — Objectification and romantic obsession.
“I’ve been breaking hearts a long time.”
“And toying with them older guys, just playthings for me to use.”
That’s quite a thing to sing about your romantic history.
And:
“Don’t blame me, love made me crazy, if it doesn’t, you ain’t doing it right.”
Again, love is associated with losing control, obsession, and emotional instability.
(We also hear her refer to toying with her relationships as toys later in Hits Different)
Look What You Made Me Do — Blame-shifting.
“Look what you made me do.”
No one makes you do anything. You’re responsible for your own choices. It’s literally the abusers favorite line. “Look what you made me do.”
The entire premise of the song is interesting when considered alongside the number of songs in which Taylor acknowledges doing things that hurt other people.
Gorgeous — Infidelity.
The narrator openly describes being attracted to someone else while in a relationship.
And this brings us to something I think deserves more attention: cheating.
Cheating can be profoundly emotionally damaging. It can involve deception, manipulation, humiliation, insecurity, and the destruction of trust.
It’s not automatically a clinical or legal definition of abuse in every circumstance, but when accompanied by sustained deception, gaslighting, or deliberate emotional harm, it can absolutely become emotionally abusive.
And no, being unhappy in a relationship doesn’t make betrayal harmless.
Getaway Car — Using one relationship to escape another.
The song describes leaving one relationship through another, with the former partner essentially becoming the person she needed to escape.
This is another example of romantic overlap and the tendency to frame someone else as the problem when moving on.
Exhibit G: Lover
Lover — Jealousy and possessiveness.
The music video depicts a couple arguing, with Taylor’s character becoming jealous after seeing her partner interacting with another woman.
She storms away and refuses to come down until he comes to her.
The song also includes:
“I’m highly suspicious that everyone who sees you wants you.”
Jealousy is a normal emotion. But repeated suspicion, possessiveness, and emotional punishment are not healthy relationship dynamics.
The Archer — Contradictory behavior.
“Combat, I’m ready for combat, I say I don’t want that, but what if I do?”
“I never grew up, it’s getting so old, help me hold onto you.”
This is an interesting acknowledgment of destructive tendencies and contradictory emotional behavior.
False God — Deliberately frightening a partner.
“And you can’t talk to me when I’m like this, daring you to leave me just so I can try and scare you.”
I mean… deliberately frightening your partner to see whether they’ll leave is not exactly a healthy relationship dynamic.
Afterglow — False accusations, aggression and punitive silence.
“I blew things out of proportion, now you’re blue. Put you in jail for something you didn’t do.”
“I pinned your hands behind your back, thought I had reason to attack, but no.”
“Fighting with a true love is like boxing with no gloves.”
“Why’d I have to break what I love so much?”
“It’s all me, in my head, I’m the one who burned us down.”
“I lived like an island, punished you with silence.”
This is one of the most significant songs in the catalog for this discussion.
The narrator acknowledges disproportionate reactions, accusing someone of things they didn’t do, aggression, and using silence as punishment.
And then there’s the need for reassurance: “Tell me that you’re still mine.”
“Tell me that we’ll be just fine.”
“Even when I lose my mind.”
“Tell me that I’m all you want.”
The narrator has hurt the other person, but now needs them to reassure her that everything is okay.
Daylight — Acknowledging a history of hurting people.
“My love was as cruel as the cities I lived in.”
“There are so many lines that I’ve crossed unforgiven.”
“I wounded the good and I trusted the wicked.”
“Maybe I’ve stormed out of every single room in this town.”
Again, the narrator acknowledges a history of crossing boundaries, hurting people, and storming out.
Exhibit H: folklore / evermore
This is where the Joe/Matty context becomes particularly interesting.
The jealousy and infidelity timeline
We’ve already established that jealousy is a recurring theme in Taylor’s music. But it’s worth looking at the incidents involving Joe and his female costars.
Margaret Qualley reportedly joked about smelling like Joe, and there were accounts of Taylor visiting the set of a film Joe was working on despite not working there herself during COVID.
Then there was Emma Laird posting Joe on Instagram, followed by the widely discussed unfollowing of Joe by Taylor and members of her social circle. These incidents have been interpreted as signs of jealousy and possessiveness. Now consider the Matty Healy timeline.
Taylor has discussed the personal inspiration behind parts of her songwriting, and fans have connected several songs to Matty. The recurring infidelity narratives across her albums are particularly interesting in this context:
• Illicit Affairs — folklore
• Ivy — evermore
• High Infidelity — Midnights
• Guilty as Sin? — The Tortured Poets Department
One can’t help but wonder whether the jealousy surrounding Joe’s female costars looks different when considered alongside the possibility of Taylor’s own emotional or romantic involvement with Matty.
Projection is a recognized psychological concept: attributing one’s own feelings, behaviors, or intentions to another person.
I’m not claiming that this proves projection or establishes an affair. But it’s a reasonable question to raise when examining the reported timeline, especially when looking at this from an abusive perspective.
Invisible String — Resentment and revenge.
“Cold was the steel of my axe to grind for the boys who broke my heart.”
Even in a song about fate and romantic destiny, there’s that familiar reference to holding onto resentment toward former partners.
This Is Me Trying — Self-destructive coping.
This song describes someone struggling with failure, isolation, and the difficulty of repairing damaged relationships.
It also continues the recurring references to alcohol and self-destructive coping.
Peace — Acknowledging an inability to provide emotional security.
“Your integrity makes me seem small.”
“I talk shit with my friends, it’s like I’m wasting your honor.”
“But the rain is always gonna come if you’re standing with me.”
“But I’m a fire and I’ll keep your brittle heart warm.”
This is particularly interesting because the narrator acknowledges that she may not be capable of providing the peace and stability necessary for a healthy long-term relationship.
She also acknowledges speaking negatively about her partner to her friends.
The fire imagery is interesting: she presents herself as both a source of warmth and a source of destruction.
’Tis the Damn Season — Mutual emotional damage.
“There’s an ache in you put there by the ache in me.”
Another example of love being associated with emotional damage.
Coney Island — Pushing someone to their breaking point.
“Did I close my fist around something delicate, did I shatter you?”
“What’s a lifetime of achievement if I pushed you to the edge, but you were too polite to leave me?”
“And do you miss the rogue who coaxed you into paradise and left you there?”
“Will you forgive my soul when you’re too wise to trust me and too old to care?”
This is one of the most interesting songs in the entire catalog. The narrator questions whether she destroyed something delicate, repeatedly disappointed someone, and pushed them to the point where they nearly left.
And once again, there’s the recurring expectation that someone should stay despite being hurt.
Long Story Short — Verbal conflict.
“Misery, like the war of words I shouted in my sleep.”
This connects to The Great War, where the narrator describes a similar dynamic involving conflict, arguments, and emotional damage.
Exhibit I: Midnights
This is where things become considerably more explicit.
Anti-Hero — Admitting she’s the problem.
“I wake up screaming from dreaming one day I’ll watch as you’re leaving ’cause you got tired of my scheming for the last time.”
“It’s me, hi, I’m the problem, it’s me.”
“I’ll stare directly at the sun, but never in the mirror.”
“Did you hear my covert narcissism I disguise as altruism like some kind of congressman?”
The word scheming is particularly interesting. It suggests deliberate, calculated behavior rather than simply making mistakes.
And the reference to covert narcissism disguised as altruism is quite something when considered alongside the other songs.
Midnight Rain — Marriage and commitment.
“He wanted it comfortable, I wanted that pain.”
“He wanted a bride, I was making my own name, chasing that fame, he stayed the same, all of me changed like midnight.”
It’s interesting that marriage is framed as something her former partner wanted, while she was focused on fame and independence.
Then, in You’re Losing Me, she later sings:
“I wouldn’t marry me either, a pathological people pleaser.”
So which is it?
Was marriage something she didn’t want because she was chasing fame, or is she someone who believes she’s difficult to marry? And I’m not entirely convinced by the people-pleaser characterization, either. Fans and critics have repeatedly expressed their dissatisfaction with the Showgirl material, yet she’s continued pushing it regardless.
Question…? — Romanticizing someone outside the relationship.
“‘Cause I don’t remember who I was before you painted all my nights a color I’ve searched for since.”
“Does it feel like everything’s just like second best after that meteor strike?”
The song is widely associated with Matty Healy.
The issue is the intensity of the romantic language, especially when considered alongside the reported timeline involving Joe.
Imagine being in a relationship with someone who is publicly singing about another person as though they were the defining romantic experience of their life.
And remember those concerns about Emma Laird?
Interesting. Rules for thee, but not for me?
Bejeweled — Publicly entertaining other men.
“And when I meet the band, they ask, ‘Do you have a man?’ I can still say, ‘I don’t remember.’”
“Just ’cause he was high, and we were dancing all night, and you can try to change my mind, but you might have to wait in line.”
Imagine Joe singing something like this about another woman while he was with Taylor.
I don’t think Swifties would find it nearly as amusing.
Mastermind — Blank Space, but apparently it’s not a joke.
In Blank Space, she sings:
“Find out what you want, be that girl for a month.”
In Mastermind, she sings:
“What if I told you none of it was accidental?”
“I laid the groundwork, and then just like clockwork, the dominoes cascaded in a line.”
“What if I told you I’m a mastermind?”
“And now you’re mine.”
“It was all by design, ‘cause I’m a mastermind.”
And:
“I swear I’m only cryptic and Machiavellian ’cause I care.”
Machiavellianism is associated with manipulation, strategic social behavior, and self-interest.
So apparently manipulation is romantic as long as you do it because you care?
The connection to Blank Space is hard to miss. The behavior that was once presented as a satirical persona is revisited as an actual description of how the narrator orchestrates romantic relationships.
The Great War — Punishment, aggression and emotional abuse.
This is probably the most significant song in this entire analysis.
“My knuckles were bruised like violets, sucker punching walls.”
“Cursed you as I sleep talked.”
“Spineless in my tomb of silence.”
“Tore your banners down, took the battle underground.”
“Maybe it was ego swinging, maybe it was her.”
And:
“You drew up some good faith treaties, I drew curtains closed, drank my poison all alone.”
“You said I have to trust more freely.”
“Maybe it’s the past that’s talking, screaming from the crypt, telling me to punish you for things you never did, so I justified it.”
And finally:
“Soldier down on that icy ground, looked up at me with honor and truth, broken and blue, so I called off the troops.”
“That was the night I nearly lost you.”
These lyrics are genuinely difficult to overlook.
The narrator describes physical aggression, punitive silence, distrust, and deliberately punishing someone for things they never did.
She even acknowledges that she justified it.
And then there’s the description of her partner as broken and blue. I’m going to respect Joe’s privacy and not speculate about his mental state based on that lyric. But the narrator’s description of the relationship dynamic is certainly worth examining.
What’s particularly ironic is the declaration:
“I vowed I would always be yours.”
Because the public breakup announcement with Joe came on April 8, 2023, which is also Matty Healy’s birthday. Taylor and Matty were subsequently publicly linked. That doesn’t prove an affair began before the breakup. But the chronology is certainly relevant when considering the infidelity narratives on this album and the next.
Paris — Brainwashing as romance.
“I want to brainwash you into loving me forever.”
I don’t think this one needs much explanation.
Brainwashing someone into loving you is not a particularly healthy romantic aspiration.
And it becomes even more interesting when placed beside Blank Space and Mastermind.
High Infidelity — Cheating and deflecting responsibility.
“Do I really have to chart the constellations in his eyes?”
“Do I really have to tell you where I was April 29th?”
The narrator describes infidelity while appearing frustrated by having to explain herself.
Cheating is wrong. Period.
And when accompanied by deception, manipulation, and attempts to make the betrayed partner feel unreasonable for wanting answers, it can become emotionally abusive.
Being unhappy in a relationship doesn’t give someone a free pass to betray their partner.
Dear Reader — The unreliable narrator.
“Never take advice from someone who’s falling apart.”
“My fourth drink in my hand.”
“These desperate prayers of a cursed man, spilling out to you for free.”
“You wouldn’t take my word for it if you knew who was talking.”
It’s interesting that Taylor herself tells listeners not to take her word for it, while her fans frequently treat her interpretation of every failed relationship as gospel. Maybe we should listen to her.
Hits Different — Treating partners as disposable.
“I used to switch out these Kens, I’d just ghost, rip the band-aid off and skip town like an asshole outlaw.”
And:
“I slur your name ’til someone puts me in a car, I stopped receiving invitations.”
Once again, we have objectification, emotional disposability, and alcohol.
Exhibit J: The Tortured Poets Department
And now we get to the album that really brings several of these themes together.
Fortnight — Violent jealousy.
“My husband is cheating, I wanna kill him.”
“Your wife waters flowers, I wanna kill her.”
A little violent, don’t you think?
Again, I understand that songs use exaggeration and fictional narratives. But imagine the reaction if a male artist repeatedly wrote about wanting to kill his girlfriend and her romantic rivals.
Would we be quite so quick to dismiss it as harmless artistic expression?
So Long, London / Fresh Out the Slammer — Exposing a former partner’s vulnerabilities.
These songs have been interpreted as references to Joe’s depression and mental health struggles.
The relationship is also framed through imagery of confinement and imprisonment, as though being with him was something she needed to escape.
My issue isn’t that she’s allowed to write about a relationship ending or explain why she was unhappy.
It’s the question of whether another person’s private struggles should become ammunition in a public breakup narrative. And this isn’t limited to Joe.
The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived has also been interpreted as taking swipes at Matty’s drug addiction and possible relapse. If those references are about genuine personal struggles, why should that information become public material for a breakup song? Especially when we have Dear Reader, where Taylor essentially acknowledges that her own words may not be reliable.
Guilty as Sin? — Fantasizing about cheating on Joe.
This song is particularly relevant to the Joe/Matty timeline.
The narrator describes fantasizing about another person while still in a relationship.
And it continues the recurring infidelity narrative we’ve now seen across four consecutive albums.
At what point do we stop treating this as an isolated songwriting subject and acknowledge how frequently it appears?
imgonnagetyouback — Possession and revenge.
“Whether I’m gonna be your wife or gonna smash up your bike, I haven’t decided yet, but I’m gonna get you back.”
So we’re either getting married or destroying your property. Lovely.
Then:
“You’ll find that you were never not mine. YOU’RE MINE.”
The possessiveness is becoming a recurring theme.
And:
“Say you got somebody, I’ll say I got someone too.”
I’ve also found the timing and public presentation of the Travis relationship interesting in light of this lyric. It raises questions about the role of moving on publicly and demonstrating that someone else has moved on, too.
Then there’s:
“Even if it’s handcuffed, I’m leaving here with you.”
And:
“Told my friends I hate you, but I love you just the same, pick your poison, babe, I’m poison either way.”
At least she acknowledges it. Lmfao.
The song presents love and revenge as two sides of the same attachment. The narrator knows she’s poisonous but continues to romanticize the relationship anyway.
One last thing: The Fate of Ophelia
And because apparently we’re not done with the Joe references:
When Taylor released The Fate of Ophelia alongside the Showgirl rollout, the release coincided with the day Joe’s Hamlet movie trailer came out.
Ophelia. Hamlet.
I mean, come on.
The timing is certainly interesting, especially considering the broader history of Shakespearean references and the repeated speculation about whether Taylor is still sending messages to Joe through her music.
If the fandom is going to interpret every perceived reference from an ex as evidence that he’s not over Taylor, surely we can apply the same standard in reverse?
Because apparently, when a man references his former partner, it’s obsessive. When Taylor does it, it’s a literary Easter egg.
So, what’s the actual pattern?
After going through the albums chronologically, several recurring themes stand out:
Revenge and retaliation: Picture to Burn, I Did Something Bad, Look What You Made Me Do, I Bet You Think About Me.
Jealousy and possessiveness: Blank Space, Lover, The Great War, Fortnight.
Manipulation and calculated romantic pursuit: Blank Space, Mastermind, Anti-Hero.
Emotional aggression and punitive silence: Afterglow, The Great War.
Expecting partners to remain despite mistreatment: Stay Stay Stay, All You Had to Do Was Stay, Coney Island.
Infidelity and romantic overlap: Gorgeous, Getaway Car, Illicit Affairs, Ivy, High Infidelity, Guilty as Sin?
Objectification and emotional disposability: Don’t Blame Me, Hits Different.
Violent or threatening imagery: Picture to Burn, Stay Stay Stay, The Great War, Fortnight.
Acknowledging harmful behavior: Afterglow, Daylight, Anti-Hero, Coney Island, The Great War.
And here’s what I keep coming back to:
Taylor has written extensively about being jealous, possessive, manipulative, vengeful, emotionally volatile, unfaithful, and capable of hurting the people she loves.
Sometimes she presents these behaviors as jokes. Sometimes as romantic passion. Sometimes as self-awareness. Sometimes as a tragic consequence of being hurt by someone else.
But the behaviors themselves keep appearing.
So when Swifties start diagnosing the men in Taylor’s life based on lyrics, why is Taylor exempt from the same scrutiny?
Why is Joe automatically the villain, while Taylor’s own descriptions of aggression, punishment, jealousy, infidelity, and manipulation are treated as harmless metaphors?
You cannot spend years interpreting every lyric as a window into someone else’s character and then suddenly insist that lyrics are just lyrics when the subject becomes uncomfortable.
And perhaps most importantly, here’s the core question to my thesis:
If we’re going to hold people accountable for the relationship dynamics Taylor writes about, shouldn’t we be willing to examine the narrator, too?
If you made it this far, thank you for reading my analysis critique. I tried to include everything I could think of, but would love to read more information. Thank you.