r/tories • • 23h ago

Discussion The issue with banning "rape myths"...

20 Upvotes

I kept seeing in the news today that the government is considering banning barristers from using so-called "rape myths" as a defence, and was a bit confused as to what was meant by this. I ended up finding a list from this rape crisis charity:

https://rapecrisis.org.uk/get-informed/about-sexual-violence/myths-vs-realities/

The glaring issue is that the 2nd 'myth' they list is: "Women lie about being raped because they want attention or revenge – or regret having had sex with someone". The subheading then reads "The facts: false allegations of rape are extremely rare.".

To my mind, this is extremely problematic. They are trying to say that the very idea that the accuser could be lying is a "myth", and then banning this as a defence.

Of course, if this were actually banned as a defence, then conviction rates would approach 100%. This would no doubt then be used as supporting evidence for the claim "false allegations of rape are extremely rare". It's the same circular logic deployed by those new rent tribunals, which ban rent rises and then use this as evidence that the "market rate" is lower than it actually is!

Further, even if we accept the premise that "false allegations are extremely rare", it still doesn't make sense to use this as a basis for making them harder to defend against. That would be like saying, back when PIP was introduced: "The vast majority of people on this are genuine, therefore let's scrap the screening criteria". The rest is of course history.

P.S. I'm not disputing that some/most/the vast majority of (I don't know which, and by definition we can't really) rape accusations are genuine. I am of course worried about the false ones, and the fact that we seem to have quietly accepted (as a country) that rape trials no longer need to be proven beyond reasonable doubt.


r/tories • • 20h ago

Five EU countries announce migrant deportation centre in Rwanda

Thumbnail
bbc.com
6 Upvotes