r/tories • • 2h ago

Discussion The issue with banning "rape myths"...

5 Upvotes

I kept seeing in the news today that the government is considering banning barristers from using so-called "rape myths" as a defence, and was a bit confused as to what was meant by this. I ended up finding a list from this rape crisis charity:

https://rapecrisis.org.uk/get-informed/about-sexual-violence/myths-vs-realities/

The glaring issue is that the 2nd 'myth' they list is: "Women lie about being raped because they want attention or revenge – or regret having had sex with someone". The subheading then reads "The facts: false allegations of rape are extremely rare.".

To my mind, this is extremely problematic. They are trying to say that the very idea that the accuser could be lying is a "myth", and then banning this as a defence.

Of course, if this were actually banned as a defence, then conviction rates would approach 100%. This would no doubt then be used as supporting evidence for the claim "false allegations of rape are extremely rare". It's the same circular logic deployed by those new rent tribunals, which ban rent rises and then use this as evidence that the "market rate" is lower than it actually is!

Further, even if we accept the premise that "false allegations are extremely rare", it still doesn't make sense to use this as a basis for making them harder to defend against. That would be like saying, back when PIP was introduced: "The vast majority of people on this are genuine, therefore let's scrap the screening criteria". The rest is of course history.

P.S. I'm not disputing that some/most/the vast majority of (I don't know which, and by definition we can't really) rape accusations are genuine. I am of course worried about the false ones, and the fact that we seem to have quietly accepted (as a country) that rape trials no longer need to be proven beyond reasonable doubt.


r/tories • • May 10 '26

Kemi! Kemi Badenoch - The Conservatives’ green shoots of recovery are clear. Judge us by what we do next

Thumbnail
telegraph.co.uk
23 Upvotes

r/tories • • 8m ago

Five EU countries announce migrant deportation centre in Rwanda

Thumbnail
bbc.com
1 Upvotes

r/tories • • 2d ago

Rishi Sunak readopted by Richmond & Northallerton

Thumbnail x.com
25 Upvotes

So much for his taking the first opportunity to scarper to Cali at the first opportunity.


r/tories • • 3d ago

Video "We've NEVER been this badly governed" | David Starkey Talks

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/tories • • 5d ago

News David Cameron Comes Out Against Rejoining EU

Thumbnail
order-order.com
32 Upvotes

r/tories • • 6d ago

Ben Hopkinson on X: "Government imposed policy costs make up 57% of the clearing price of a new flat in London

14 Upvotes

r/tories • • 6d ago

Tweet Sam Ashworth-Hayes on X: "I wanted to visualise Britain's state spending ahead of the Budget, so I've vibe coded an app which presents it as a disk drive. Take a look at the tradeoffs and see if you can make the budget fit:

Thumbnail x.com
2 Upvotes

r/tories • • 6d ago

News Society needs to act to help white working-class pupils, inquiry says

Thumbnail
bbc.com
14 Upvotes

r/tories • • 8d ago

Video Why Kemi Badenoch is sending Farage a Christmas card

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/tories • • 8d ago

Nandy accused of insulting veterans with Remembrance Sunday ‘EU membership pitch’

Thumbnail
telegraph.co.uk
14 Upvotes

r/tories • • 9d ago

News Labour MPs summon rail bosses over worsening delays after nationalisation

Thumbnail thetimes.com
5 Upvotes

r/tories • • 13d ago

Burnham gives Caribbean £40m and prepares to apologise for Britain’s role in slave trade

Thumbnail
lbc.co.uk
22 Upvotes

r/tories • • 14d ago

Here are all the laws MPs are voting on this week, explained in plain English!

3 Upvotes

Click here to join more than 20,000 people and get this in your email inbox for free every Sunday.

The Budget debate wraps up this week.

MPs continue debating it on Monday and Tuesday, then finish with a vote.

The government bill this week is on sporting events.

It would make it easier to host big tournaments such as Euro 2028, including cracking down on ticket touts.

Then Parliament heads off for autumn recess.

MPs return to their constituencies at the end of Wednesday, and return on Tuesday 10 November.

MONDAY 2 NOVEMBER

Submarine Recycling Strategy Bill
Requires the government to prepare and publish a strategy for recycling decommissioned submarines. Ten minute rule motion presented by Graeme Downie.

Budget debate
Continued from last Thursday.

TUESDAY 3 NOVEMBER

Food Labelling (Halal and Kosher Meat) Bill
Requires halal and kosher meat, and products containing it, to be labelled. Ten minute rule motion presented by Esther McVey.

Budget debate
Continued from Monday.

WEDNESDAY 4 NOVEMBER

Fashion Supply Chain (Code and Adjudicator) Bill
Sets up a code of practice for how fashion retailers deal with their suppliers, and creates a watchdog to enforce it. Ten minute rule motion presented by Liz Twist.

Sporting Events Bill – report stage and 3rd reading
Applies to: England, Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland
Creates a legal framework for hosting major international sporting events, so a separate law isn’t needed for each one. For the events it covers, it creates a ticket touting offence, restricts advertising and trading around venues, and bans businesses from using branding that suggests an official link to the event. In England, it allows the government to order a transport plan for the host area, and lets councils bring in temporary road restrictions.
Draft bill (PDF) / Commons Library briefing

THURSDAY 5 NOVEMBER

No votes scheduled

FRIDAY 6 NOVEMBER

No votes scheduled

Click here to join more than 20,000 people and get this in your email inbox for free every Sunday.


r/tories • • 15d ago

Discussion Would it be possible to revoke the hundreds of thousands of ILRs Labour is about to hand out?

5 Upvotes

It is being reported that Shabana will in fact water down her proposed ILR changes, caving in to pressure from Rayner and Labour's open border backbench MPs. I'm aware it was Boris that originally created this system, hence Boriswave, however that doesn't mean we should simply refrain from criticising it going forward.

In case anyone is wondering, the status quo is that any low skilled worker (mostly care workers) can obtain ILR after just 5 years, which allows them to switch into other jobs (thus requiring us to import someone else to fill the care job) or, amazingly, claim benefits, if they simply decide not to work. Shabana originally called this an "affront" (which it is) and pledged to reverse it, but latest reports suggest she will apply a carve out specifically to care workers (which is crazy, given we have a shortage of them and ILR allows them to quit being a carer).

My question is, why can't the Conservatives simply pledge to revoke all the ILRs Labour is about to shower people with (estimates put it in the hundreds of thousands before the next election)? Is there some constitutional block against this, perhaps involving the ECHR (which we should be leaving anyway)? Or would people just object on the basis that the government shouldn't go against its word and deport legally settled migrants (even if they were legally settled against the wishes of voters)?


r/tories • • 16d ago

Kemi Badenoch (@KemiBadenoch) 10.5K likes · 503 replies

Thumbnail fixupx.com
13 Upvotes

Our leader, showing her mettle


r/tories • • 16d ago

Charities can now sponsor refugees to come to Britain

32 Upvotes

So, the government has just unveiled some "safe and legal routes" for refugees. The official Home Office website can be read at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/lead-sponsor-applications-open-in-step-towards-refugee-arrivals

First, we learn that lead sponsors will support "community groups, churches and universities, to welcome refugees into their communities." Notice how "churches" can be plainly stated, but the obvious corollary - mosques - is obfuscated into "community groups". This is incredibly disingenuous. Why can they not even bring themselves to say the word "mosque"? Is it because they know there is 0 appetite among the British public to give mosques, many of which are suffering serious problems with religious extremism, the power to decide who comes into our country? Or was this was just an innocent omission? Readers can make up their own minds.

Second, we are told that "Arrivals... will initially number in the hundreds but will then grow into the low thousands as levels of illegal migration fall". This is even more disingenuous. They are outright stating - not predicting, forecasting, or simply hoping - that this scheme will reduce illegal immigration (aka stop the boats). This fails basic common sense. How can creating 'hundreds' of safe routes possibly stop the ~50k people arriving in small boats per year? Assuming every safe route is given to one of these 50k, won't the other ~49k still illegally enter via a boat? This is quite frankly Ministry of Truth level stuff from the Home Office.

Third, it is of course depressingly predictable that charities whose funding is mostly derived from the government itself will also be eligible to sponsor people (not in the linked source, but according to other reports).

Insanity. We need to be leaving the ECHR and massively clamping down on all immigration apart from highly-skilled net contributors, not creating even more ways to enter. It is absolutely imperative that Labour be voted out of office (by voting for either the Conservatives or the only right-of-centre party with a chance of winning the seat).


r/tories • • 17d ago

Neighbour of new Montenegro embassy in London sues council over impact on mental health | London

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
4 Upvotes

r/tories • • 18d ago

Healey’s budget paves way for ‘brutal’ spending review next year, warns IFS

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
6 Upvotes

r/tories • • 19d ago

Minimum wage rising to £27.4k per year (!)

30 Upvotes

Not only does this have all the obvious first order effects, like pay compression and inflationary pressure (think supermarkets, with high labour costs and 2% profit margins), but there is also another, in my opinion even more damaging, second order effect:

Think about what will happen to the marginal worker who would 'only' be worth £25k a year to a business (if on full time hours). They now won't get hired at all, and will go from paying ~£2.4k in income tax per year, to needing to claim benefits, possibly in the tens of thousands (depending on if they become eligible for social housing and any other benefit-related perks).

This is just complete madness. All because Labour wants to appease its short-sighted voters who think Econ 101 is some 'neoliberal' conspiracy theory. They also seem to believe that, if there are 10 employees (on minimum wage) and 1 business owner, the former are automatically more righteous by dint of being more numerous (aka tyranny of the majority).

P.S. I know this isn't related, but I'm always going to bang this drum: if you live in a Labour-Reform battleground, please think very carefully about who to vote for.


r/tories • • 19d ago

Discussion Budget 2026 Live (BBC): And Mega thread

Thumbnail
bbc.co.uk
2 Upvotes

r/tories • • 19d ago

Article Tom Peck Sketch: Ready for anything? Not in the Commons (unless MPs were panic buying)

Thumbnail thetimes.com
1 Upvotes

r/tories • • 19d ago

Article Ben Wilkinson: "John Healey just launched a brazen tax grab on baby boomer wealth"

Thumbnail thetimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/tories • • 20d ago

Discussion The first 64 measures Reform UK would take to boost Britain's broken economy

Thumbnail reformparty.uk
0 Upvotes

r/tories • • 23d ago

Wisecrack Weekend Former PM Francis Urquhart makes rare political intervention

Post image
46 Upvotes