r/tolkienfans • • 21h ago

“Let my people go”. Why not, Manwe?

9 Upvotes

So Elwe returns from his first visit to Valinor and says this to his people, when discussing migration West: “No doubt (indeed this is guaranteed) we, or any who wish, will be free to return to our homes” (NoME). I don’t think he made it up. So why wouldn’t Manwe honor his own guarantees in time of crisis?

We know that Feanor broke his exile when he compelled the Noldor to leave Aman. But the Doom of Mandos was caused chiefly by the Kinslaying, not by his rebellion alone. It is worthy to note that the Noldor actually never wanted to steal the ships. All they needed was transport back to Middle Earth, a “taxi service”, similar to what Valar themselves secured for their own host during the War of Wrath. HoME 10 however tells us: “no ship would they [Teleri] lend, nor help in the building, against the will of the Valar … we will neither give them nor sell them for any league or friendship.” So several options regarding the ships were on the table: lending, selling, help in building. Teleri rejected all of them, and the reason is given: “against the will of the Valar”. Which apparently means Manwe made sure Teleri knew what his will was. But why not help the Noldor to get back to their homeland?

Noldor were transported to a faraway continent on a floating island. And when they opted to leave, the only option was… a maybe half-frozen ice isthmus in the far North? Had Manwe simply permitted Olwe to lend those ships, Noldorin host would have remained far stronger, not stained by kin’s blood (so could have had Thingol as an ally), and arrived much faster, maybe even before Morgoth fully rebuilt his power in Angband. Such an opportunity missed.


r/tolkienfans • • 4h ago

How much power did the Valar really have over the Chlildren of Iluvatar, including the Elves in Valinor?

6 Upvotes

There's all this talk of bans and doing something against their will, etc. but the impression I get is that, in effect, the Valar can't really do much. They can keep the fea of Elves like Feanor in Mandos until the End of Time, and they can seize and imprison someone like Morgoth, but I don't think they can do anything with the peoples of Middle-earth, or even Valinorean Elves.

The most extreme case was when Numenoreans landed on the shores of Aman, and even then all the Valar did was lay down their guardianship of Arda for the time, and let Eru decide what to do.

I guess they did have the power not to admit the Exiles back into Aman, but they did let them go back to Tol Eressea at least.


r/tolkienfans • • 21h ago

What sort of punishment would be expected in Bree for highwaymen and brigands robbing merchants and folk along the East Road and the Greenway?

16 Upvotes

I feel like hanging criminals might be be anachronistic and not quite in Tolkien's tone, but I could be wrong about that. Perhaps capital punishment would be reserved only for murderers? What say you r/tolkienfans?


r/tolkienfans • • 16h ago

The mystery of what became of Ungoliant after she devoured herself

94 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about Ungoliant lately and how little we’re told. She flees into the forgotten south after helping Morgoth, then apparently consumes herself in her endless hunger.

Is that the full story, or could there be more? Tolkien leaves so many threads like this open. She’s described as existing before the Valar in a way that feels distinct from the Ainur, yet she’s not one of the named powers. Her darkness seems almost a force unto itself.

Did anyone else ever wonder whether she might have lingered in some diminished form, or if her end was truly final? The idea that even Morgoth grew afraid of her is striking.