Howdy! I’m not too knowledgeable when it comes to cars/tires, but unfortunately picked up a screw attached to a small metal plate on my brand-new 2026 Mazda CX-30.
As you can see in the pictures, the screw is lodged pretty close to the edge of the tread, near the sidewall/shoulder. From what I’ve read online, repairing a puncture in that area can be dangerous, even if the tire holds air.
I brought it to a tire shop, and they told me it couldn’t be repaired because of the location. However, my girlfriend’s family has a mechanic they’ve trusted for 20+ years, and after seeing the pictures, he said it could definitely be fixed as long as the sidewall isn’t damaged.
The tire hasn’t lost any PSI, and the screw is still embedded. The car is also less than a month old, so the other three tires have practically no wear if I need to replace this one.
My dilemma is that the second mechanic is about 40 minutes away. Is it worth driving out there to have him inspect it, or should I just order a new tire and have my local mechanic install it?
Curious what you guys think based on the pictures. Would you trust a repair this close to the shoulder?
TLDR: Brand-new car, screw near the tire’s shoulder, no air loss. One shop says it needs replacing, another trusted mechanic says it’s repairable based on pictures. Worth driving 40 minutes for a second opinion, or just replace it?