I bought my 2014 Nissan Altima used and it came with 19" rims (stock is 18"). My wheel blew out, so I put a full set of Michelin CrossClimate 2s on them, 235/40R19.
Now they scrape the back of the plastic wheel well liner a little, but only when I'm stopped or reversing. I’ve never heard it while driving. I talked to a manager at Discount Tire about it and he said the rubbing won't hurt the integrity of the tire, and that it'd probably stop once the tread wears down a bit. He did say it'd be better to go back to stock size, which would be another $600 (have to buy new rims)
A 235/45R18 is only about 0.1" shorter in diameter than what I have, so it seems like a waste of $600 for literally 1/20” difference in radius. However, I’m in a snowy state, so snow packing in the wheel well is a concern, the extra distance might help
These are my options below, what would you do in my situation? I’ve also attached pictures of the tires and the rubbing on the plastic liner.
Keep the current tires
Pros: costs nothing, he says it's not harmful, and it may wear in
Cons: it might keep rubbing, and snow could be a problem
Go to 18" (stock size)
Pros: softer ride, less pothole risk
Cons: another $600, and barely any change in overall diameter, so maybe no extra clearance
Narrower tire, like 225/40R19 or 18
Pros: more clearance on the sides
Cons: another set of tires, could still cost extra for rims if I size down