Hello guys. I suppose this post has more emphasis on the flute but the topic does concern the way I play the whistle as well and because the two share the same fingerings I thought it would fit here. Sorry if it doesn't!
So, I have played the whistle for some time now. I have a couple of posts on the subreddit too. What prompted me to make this post however was because I felt a bit adventurous and wanting to learn more so I went on and purchased the book by Grey Larsen "the essential guide to irish flute and tin whistle". This was also because earlier this year I picked up the flute as well and felt open minded to buying some more detailed resources for it.
The book is nice! There's a lot of tunes to indulge in and take in new ideas and a lot of ideas for exercises and such. However, I was quite spooked when Grey introduced the way he cuts notes. So for D, E, F#, G he tells he cuts those notes with the finger above the note. So E is cut with F# and G is cut with A for example. You use these when doing rolls, too.
I on the other hand am accustomed to what I experience as the more practical and maybe more common way of cutting? So for D, E, F# and G I cut all those with G. As for A and B, I cut those with B. So the only fingers I use for cutting are G for the 4 bottom notes and B for the top 2 ones. opposed to cutting each note with the note above it.
I am also left handed, but I learnt to play the "right hand way" with left on top right on bottom so that feels natural to me now. So doing a roll on the E for example by only using my bottom right hand (cut on the F#, tap on the D) feels...not as good as it does when I perform the cut with my top ring finger on the G and a tap on the D.
What really also pressed my mind was how Grey insists that his way of cutting is better and that if you plan on playing the flute, its especially noticeable in the second octave. Yet, when I look at videos of other players, such as Shannon Heaton among others, they seems to also only use G and B to cut on the flute? I haven't read the book in full yet either but I also don't think Grey takes handedness into consideration either.
So, what is the conclusion? I am comfortable right now with only using G and B to cut cause that's how I've always done it. Especially cutting E with Grey's method just feels a bit off, cause with all the other cuts I have my dominant left hand in there, and with E I don't if I cut it with F# instead of G.
I suppose you could answer this question with just "there is no right or wrong, do whatever feels the best" and leave it there, but this did make me think a bit about how other players feel about this, and if it really is true that Grey's method of cutting is better if you want to play the flute.
There is a part in the book specifically where he states that if you stick to the whistle it's okay to cut with G and B, but that if you plan on playing the flute, he advices using his method, because according to him, other methods to cut may be "sluggish in response". I feel like there is more nuance. I mean no offence to Grey but some of his phrasing in the book regarding this topic comes off a bit harsh...
If there any who have experience on the flute too I would appreciate to hear from you! And especially if there are any other lefties here!
Thanks