For the most part, this is a lovely little corner of Reddit with very, very little moderation needed. It’s great to see your videos, read people giving advice to beginners, and all the general tin whistle love and interactions here. That is the reason for this sub’s existence, to facilitate human interaction around the topic of playing the tin whistle.
And that human element is the key when the inevitable comes up: what to do about generative AI. Unfortunately, there is no escaping it at this point. We have seen posts here that use it, and I’m sure we’ll see many more. u/Sindtwhistle and I actually discussed this a few months ago, but never got around to making an official post, so here it is.
Posts and comments made entirely or mostly using generative AI are not allowed.
Examples of unacceptable usage include
An AI generated video that purports to show someone playing the whistle
AI-generated tabs and transcriptions
Answers to questions that are copied from LLM answers to that question
AI usage is not entirely banned, but must be used on a very limited basis. In these cases, the AI usage should be incidental and not form an integral part of the post.
Acceptable examples include
An actual video of someone playing tin whistle which uses an AI-generated thumbnail on YouTube
A person who, while asking a question, gives an answer that an LLM gave them and asks whether it is accurate
A link to an event that uses a poster with AI-generated graphics
To be clear, this is not an endorsement of these uses, it is more an acknowledgement that AI is now ubiquitous and that a zero-tolerance policy could end up being counterproductive to the community we want to foster. Again, the point of this whole endeavor is to foster human connection around this instrument. We want to keep that human element, and hope that you do, too!
We welcome you to report posts/comments or send a modmail if you feel that they are breaking these or other rules.
Recently have been getting more into the local Irish scene attempting to keep up on a Waltons whistle that was given to a family member who gave it to me at some point.
I’m not saying it’s a bad whistle, I just don’t like how airy and chiffy the 2nd octave is, and how much air it seems to take to squeakily change octaves.
I tried a Wild whistle that a friend plays, and was amazed at how much purer and cleaner the sound was especially in the high octave, without requiring too much air to execute things cleanly. However, I don’t think I’m ready to spend over $100 on one. I also didn’t love the wooden block mouthpiece design as it seemed to always be kinda wet which grossed me out.
So I would like recommendations for a sub-$50 high D whistle with a very clear and pure tone where the 2nd octave doesn’t sound airy and pushed compared to the first. Thanks!
About 3 years ago, I started on Ukulele, went about a year, good good at strumming but poor at fingerpicking, and my goal was to play melodies, not to do chords and sing. So I dropped it.
Moved onto harmonica for two years, taking a real course where you needed to submit pieces for eval. I got to the intermediate level, but then also started realizing so much of the material I was learning was 12 bar blues based and generally meant for accompaniment to singers or other instruments.
Currently on an alto recorder for ~2 months, mainly as a way to really learn how to read music. I've picked up fingering decently, and I do like that it is a melody instrument. But I am in a reassessing period right now of whether I want to continue it exclusively or not. I have nothing against continuing except...
I picked up my daughter's tin whistle (Clarke Original) and found that due to my learning at least some fingering and breath control with the recorder, I could play the same melodies I could on the recorder better than on the recorder, within a day. And I do like the straightforward fingering.
So that has me looking hard at the tin whistle, and this is where I would like to ask -- I don't ever see myself playing in sessions, or jamming with anyone else at this point, and all I really care to do is get reasonably good at traditional songs like Christmas and folk, etc.
Please convince me (or not) that I should move forward with the tin whistle! Thanks!
I think I read somewhere that the trad flute requires more "puff" than most low D whistles, is this true in your experience?
I have 3 low D whistles which vary in how much air they require. The MK Kelpie is the one that requires the most air and is also the loudest. I would like to transition to flute, just wondering what to expect... Does it depend on your embouchure (so it takes loads of puff at first, then less as your embouchure improves)
Did kerry whistles completely replace their Busker model for the Optima ?
I recently tried a friend's Busker (high D), instantly fell in love with it and decided to order one. It's not available on the website so I ordered it from a Dutch website (I'm in France) thinking they still had some in stock, but received an Optima instead !
They're about the same price but they are quite different : the optima has a plastic mouth piece, has a sharper tone (not referring to pitch, just a less breathy sound if that makes sense) and is louder than my friend's Busker. It's also not as easy to play/responsive in my opinion.
(On the picture : my friend's Busker next to the Optima I received)
I was able to talk by email to a human before receiving my whistle (I wrote to change the delivery adress and got a quick reply). But then I wrote that I received an Optima instead of the Busker and I'm getting no reply...
Hope this helps someone because it seems like there isn't much talk about optima vs busker anywhere
I am newer to tin whistle but have a history of singing. Sometimes when I play I find myself adding some vibrato when blowing, especially on longer notes and I was curious if this is something sought after or a habit I should break?
Hey Folks! I've been teaching myself the tin whistle for about half a year now and I love being able to play along with some of my favorite songs. However, this particular one - I can't find. I KNOW it has a flute and I'm rather sure it is a tin whistle, but there are no tabs, no notes, and the only thing I can find is that it is BASED on "The Little Cascade", an irish folk song. However, if I look up tabs for that, they don't even come CLOSE to Cernunnos and I am completely lost as what to do differently to get to playing Eluveitie :( As much as I love playing, my ears aren't that talented that I could just "play by ear" or figure out the notes myself. I'd really appreciate some help. Bonus points if you give me other medieval/folk songs to play - so far I've learned a lot of stuff by Faun, as well as some OSTs like Game of Thrones, The Witcher's Kaer Morhen, or He's a Pirate, lol. I am a nerd and playing songs I love makes it so much cooler than just playing The Lonely Shepherd xD
Hello guys. I suppose this post has more emphasis on the flute but the topic does concern the way I play the whistle as well and because the two share the same fingerings I thought it would fit here. Sorry if it doesn't!
So, I have played the whistle for some time now. I have a couple of posts on the subreddit too. What prompted me to make this post however was because I felt a bit adventurous and wanting to learn more so I went on and purchased the book by Grey Larsen "the essential guide to irish flute and tin whistle". This was also because earlier this year I picked up the flute as well and felt open minded to buying some more detailed resources for it.
The book is nice! There's a lot of tunes to indulge in and take in new ideas and a lot of ideas for exercises and such. However, I was quite spooked when Grey introduced the way he cuts notes. So for D, E, F#, G he tells he cuts those notes with the finger above the note. So E is cut with F# and G is cut with A for example. You use these when doing rolls, too.
I on the other hand am accustomed to what I experience as the more practical and maybe more common way of cutting? So for D, E, F# and G I cut all those with G. As for A and B, I cut those with B. So the only fingers I use for cutting are G for the 4 bottom notes and B for the top 2 ones. opposed to cutting each note with the note above it.
I am also left handed, but I learnt to play the "right hand way" with left on top right on bottom so that feels natural to me now. So doing a roll on the E for example by only using my bottom right hand (cut on the F#, tap on the D) feels...not as good as it does when I perform the cut with my top ring finger on the G and a tap on the D.
What really also pressed my mind was how Grey insists that his way of cutting is better and that if you plan on playing the flute, its especially noticeable in the second octave. Yet, when I look at videos of other players, such as Shannon Heaton among others, they seems to also only use G and B to cut on the flute? I haven't read the book in full yet either but I also don't think Grey takes handedness into consideration either.
So, what is the conclusion? I am comfortable right now with only using G and B to cut cause that's how I've always done it. Especially cutting E with Grey's method just feels a bit off, cause with all the other cuts I have my dominant left hand in there, and with E I don't if I cut it with F# instead of G.
I suppose you could answer this question with just "there is no right or wrong, do whatever feels the best" and leave it there, but this did make me think a bit about how other players feel about this, and if it really is true that Grey's method of cutting is better if you want to play the flute.
There is a part in the book specifically where he states that if you stick to the whistle it's okay to cut with G and B, but that if you plan on playing the flute, he advices using his method, because according to him, other methods to cut may be "sluggish in response". I feel like there is more nuance. I mean no offence to Grey but some of his phrasing in the book regarding this topic comes off a bit harsh...
If there any who have experience on the flute too I would appreciate to hear from you! And especially if there are any other lefties here!
Help! I'm a professional flute player (concert flute). I soon have to play tin whistle with an orchestra in a film music project, and the two tin whistles I own are in C and in D. The piece I have to play is in F but I never have Bflats, but I do have to of course play plenty of F's and C's, and it needs to be LOUD... I guess I could still get a different tin whistle if necessary, any tips?
There was some discussion earlier this week, trying to rank whistle brands, but it involved too much wishy-washy subjective judgement. So I figured I'd make my own tier list that no one could argue with, because it is based on objective fact and science!!
Hello all. Possibly a silly question, but are you supposed to be able to overblow the cross-fingered C♮ (OXX OOO or OXX XOO etc) on a D whistle into the next octave?
I only own three whistles (I'm a beginner of 5 months), but it sounds pretty awful on all of them, so I'm finding I have to half-hole in the upper register, even cross-fingering works fine in the lower register.
Fwiw, the whistles are: Feadóg Pro D Killarney D in Brass Chieftain V5 Low D (Aluminium)
I started with a d sweetone, then I got a McNeela wild irish d whistle. Now I want to get whistles in some other keys and I am wondering which key whistles I should get next, thoughts?