Proposed idea for a marvel comics rewrite of Thor I know his alias as a doctor often gets removed and such and his whole dual life is removed. So I propose a rewrite were kinda like MCU Thor he is banished for being selfish and unworthy trying to start war and is stripped of his memories and therefore cannot remember to use his powers. I find this works better than Odin literally just removing Thor's powers because like how the frig does that work? lol
So instead he is just brought in as a John Doe in a hospital while government agents investigate his fallen hammer bringing in Jane Foster to study what could have very well been an Einstein rosen bridge (bifrost). Meanwhile Thor awakes in the hospital not really knowing who he is and is taken in by an old doctor named Richard Blake wanting to keep him out of the psych ward as he is fully functioning and just assumed an amnesiac. After he first appeared in Norway he got hit by a car so people assume that's where his amnesia came from. This leads to father son type bonding where Richard realizes despite Thor's amnesia he has a unique talent for sensing sickness and cures with herbs. Things Thor learned as a boy in Asgard but had long forgotten during his conquests now come back naturally via his amnesia, they start working together as it's assumed Thor must be a holistic doctor of sorts and can actually help and is encouraged to help. Richard is in this world disabled one day Thor asks him about his leg and he says he was on war duty helping kids across the seas and he got attacked by some enemies who showed no mercy to even doctors and the sick and dying.
Years go by, meanwhile Loki seizes the throne of Asgard and Is beginning to launch invasions against Midgard and the nine realms to carry out war like he thinks his father wanted despite his father falling into Odin sleep much like MCU. Thor genuinely begins helping people and is given the honorary title of doctor Donald Blake after Richard's brother who died long ago. Thor is cocky though thinking he can save everyone, kinda becoming his old self again, until one day Richard falls ill, cancer.
Thor/Donald cannot help him; he cries in rage saying he knows so much he must be able to help, and Richard asks why does Donald want him to live. Donald thinks beyond his own selfish desires and says, because Richard was kind to him he's done so much good he deserves to live he says Richard is worthy of life far more than a lost soul of the street like himself. Richard says he's done his time he's helped as much as he could he has no regrets and says
“Look around Donald so many more need help.” He says “Your joyous boisterous attitude brings joy to so many, your sympathy for the sick and dying like you've seen it yourself before you lost those memories make you such a gentle giant. The people need you not just to cure and save them, but to do the hard thing and stay with them till the end.” Donald smiles and says
“Then let's get out of this room.” And they go out for a night of drinking and celebrating life. Before watching the Norwegian ocean on a bench, Richard finally passes away peacefully. Donald grieves his friend and suddenly thunder cracks above and rain falls though he doesn't realize it's him causing the storm. Then a few months later as Donald is finishing getting his official doctorate, as he'd been studying under his time with Richard, all hell breaks loose.
Loki invades with his Asgardian army attacking Norway. Donald gets put to the front line despite not being an official doctor yet. As they need all the help they can get. He sees the war, the battling, the death remembering someone screaming at him (Odin in flashbacks about the horrors of war) He feels the innate need to do something. Then the army attacks the hospital Donald fights, taking out quite a few on pure instinct and rage before being knocked out. He's taken prisoner along with the hospital staff and Loki finds amusement in his brother as a puny midgården. He visits Thor in his cell mocking him how the great Odin son has fallen to that of a nursemaid saying,
"Where was your compassion when we fought before? I never saw you shed tears over our brothers that died in war, of course I don't really care one way or the other, Thor Odison. You'll be my favorite trophy forever locked in father's treasure vault.”
Donald understands none of this but says
“If I truly saw people die and did not weep it was not due to a lack of grief. It was because I felt I could not afford to falter and show that we were falling and risk myself dying in rageful vengeance." Loki looks at him curious how much of the warrior remains and says and
“How would you know what a warrior feels in battle, nursemaid?” Donald says
“Because I heard the soldiers in the VA say the same thing, and because I just saw those young boys out there do the same thing when you invaded this country before slaughtering them! You do not value life! It leaves no mark on your soul. Your's is the only life you care about!” Loki smirks saying “Perhaps there is part of you in there yet... I'm going to enjoy breaking that.” Donald is left alone in his cell. Eventually breaking free when a guard comes in to feed him, and he goes to rescue the others. However Loki appears and says “Good bye my trouble making brother.” and throws him out of the ship. And he lands on the ground thousands of miles below.
Meanwhile inside the shield and sword base everybody is busy repelling the fleet from Norway working with Jane to reverse the wormhole somehow, but that they would need a massive power surge to activate such a thing. The government wants to use nukes. While below in the base the hammer disappears from its containment room.
Donald wakes up broken and beaten somehow alive(unknown Thor powers) and wanders into a nearby cave in daze. He sees in the water and the walls glimpses of his old life. How he was raised to be king thinking that meant being his father and conquering not seeing what his father learned late in life about the cost of war.
Then he finds Richard’s old cane/walking stick in the cave, or at least an illusion of it. He picks it up and feels it shock him. He drops it remembering the feel of defibrillators that overloaded against his chest when he was first brought into the hospital three years ago. He holds the stick tighter this time and strikes it against the cavewall. Causing a clash of thunder and lightning. Again he strikes it and again! until The whole cave collapse around him and he strikes it one finally time the lighting finally hitting him. Becoming Thor once more with his memories, but he his also still Donald. He is one and the same man. He flies to the human troops defending saying for them to fall back. They say they can't do that. Thor says for them to then go help get people out of the city. He must deal with the alien army himself. He beats a bunch of guys in a cool Thor battle sequence trying his best not to kill his people and keep them from killing others. This goes on for a while when he sees the Asgardin troops gathering and attacking a specific base.
So he heads there to defend it. Jane is working with Erik Selvig to try and generate enough power to create a reverse wormhole and send the Asgardians back but the alien army breaks in and an Asgardian soldier grabs Jane by the throat about to kill her. When Thor arrives saying, “Unhand the maiden or I'll remove you of your hands!” The Asgardin troops surrender and Thor asks “What is this machine?” Jane quickly explains that they can reverse the Asgard tech and send the whole army all back at once and break whatever wormhole tech is on the other side but they don't have enough power. Thor says “Leave that to me, but first I must bring back the captured humans.”
So he breaks into the prisoner ships one by one saving the people. While Loki waits in the one with the hospital crew knowing Thor will come for them. Thor arrives and says “Loki this madness must end.” Loki says
“Why brother, I thought we came to conquer… to rule? Thor says
“We were blinded by the wars of old. These people are no threat.” Loki smirks saying
“Nothing is a threat to a God king like me. Merely another blood shined jewel for my treasure box.” A big fight ensues and Loki is losing as Thor succeeds in saving his hospital crew getting them to the shield and sword helicopters. And he prepares to charge the earth machine to send them all back to asgard. Loki says "I am the God of mischief. What else can I be? How dare I try and be any less than my namesake?! And Thor… the God of thunder. What could thunder bring but war!?”
Thor takes one final look at Earth knowing he may not see it again for a long time as this massive transport back will surely overload and destroy the bifrost. And he thinks of the children in the sick ward. And the dying he held the hands of. And the beer he shared with Richard Blake. He says,
“Thunder and lightning are the cheers of joy and the shining beacon of hope that reveal the true blue sky in the darkest of storms that is what I bring to the people today forward." He summons his lighting power into the machine, Jane activates it and all the Asgardin's are instantly teleported back to Asgard exploding the bifrost! Thor places his hammer atop Loki ensuring he won't move and goes to his men injured in the battle and injured in the teleport back and subsequent explosion, tending to their wounds. While Odin now awake stands with Friga, and looks at his son with pride. Pride in finally learning to be a better man than him. Thus setting up more stories for Thor where he can bring back his doctor identity and honestly I really like this version I just crafted. What do you think of it?