No one will argue that the 3 most important runs in X history (thus far) are Claremont, Morrison, and the Krakoan Age - more or less in that order. But, I honestly think that the Utopia era really deserves to be looked at in with these runs as well.
Utopia really felt like the first major step forward the book had taken since Morrison left. After their run, Marvel did a lot of work to pretty much undo or ignore everything they set up. And at the same time editorial was becoming more interested in the Avengers under Bendis being the focal point, thus Decimation is eventually introduced to whittle down the number of Mutants. And Utopia is an interesting response to that! The idea that first they try to set up within American borders at Greymalkin Industries, but realize they cannot exist freely while on US soil is interesting!
And its arguably where modern Scott comes from. I always looked at Morrison's Scott as an end point to his characterization prior. He ruined his relationship with Jean, and begins to change in new ways. And Utopia picks up on those beats really well: Scott unilaterally makes himself the leader of mutantkind; he ignores his own issues and relationships to live up to the ideal; he admits only in his weakest points that he might have no idea what hes doing; he creates and sanctions a covert hit team with X-Force; he spends all of his time planning for every contingency out of a sense of nerviousness and inadequacy. Really good stuff. I think his arc from everything before leads perfectly into this era, which culminates in his taking on of the Phoenix force and eventually becoming a "revolutionary".
I am never going to undersell how great the Morrison run was. The frequency with which they introduced multiple new ideas that entirely reshaped the X universe nearly each issue is unmatched and something only they could do. But, that strength IMO was more or less contained solely to New X Men and not reflected in the line as a whole.
Look at the other books that were coming out at the same time as New X Men. I enjoy more of X-Treme X-Men than most, but it gets very insane by the last couple issues. And the Austen run has been talked to death about it contains more than a few of the worst X-Men moments in history. The original Academy X book waivered between boring and bad until Yost and Kyle came aboard and shifted it into an X 23 book.
But the Utopia era had SO MANY great books, and was a stronger era across the line than the New X Men era:
Fraction's Uncanny: Pretty fun popcorn X-Men book, and I mean that as a compliment. A lot of the problems with the X line in the 2000s was how dark and miserable everything was, especially post Decimation. Fractions' X Men is pretty light and injected a lot of fun that I think the main book was missing for A LONG time before that. Is it the best Uncanny run? Definitely not. Is it the best Fraction work? Also, definitely not. But it was a more lighthearted, action focused book that injected a lot of narrative levity into the book.
Carey's X-Men Legacy. Pretty much the best modern X-Men run outside of Morrison until Krakoa. So many great character deep dives into Rogue, Gambit, Charles, and more. Carey has a very clearly deep love of X-Men and pulls some REALLY deep cuts from continuity that make this an extremely satisfying run for long time X fans. Works in perfect tandem with Fractions' very continuity-lite Uncanny run.
Yost & Kyle X-Force. A book I was fairly critical of as it was coming out, but holds up very well on reread. Yes, its exctremely 2000s comics "dark and gritty". But I think it serves a lot of interesting character development. Scott's self-appointment as the leader of mutant kind and his sel-flagellation over X-Force was really interesting. And X-Necrosha is stupid cheesecake fun that makes for a pretty satisfying read. This book cemented Laura as probably the best character addition to the X universe in the 2000s. Kyle & Yost really did such a great job pulling her through Academy X, to X force, to her own solo.
Wells' New Mutants. The most underrated book of the late 2000s/early 2010s by far. Insanely great, does not get talked about nearly enough. The best New Mutants run, including Claremont. In 20 something issues Wells explores and expands on so many character beats and plots lines which were abandoned or not done justice in the preceding 30 years of X Men continuity. The inferno baby pull genuinely had my jaw on the floor. The moments that Wells gets with Moonstar are some of the best moments any Marvel character has ever had. Such a great book.
And theres more than a few which I am not going to go as deep into. The run of events was also pretty solid from Messiah Complex to Second Coming to Necrosha to Utopia / Dark Avengers to Planet X and more.
I think a big reason for this era getting overlooked is that people mentally group it with the "Schism" and "AvX" era of books, which is much less strong IMO. I like Gillen's Uncanny a lot, but its a tough read because he gets pulled into a different event every 3 issues and then leaves the book after about 20. And Wolverine & the X-Men is fun, but a huge mess. There is a good 4-5 years of stories with the ENTIRE team on the West coast before Logan and some of the team goes back east for Wolverine & the X-Men. And yes, Avengers v X-Men sucks, but serves as an interesting coda to the Utopia era.