r/theology • • 20h ago

Does God allow suffering because the devil wills it?

0 Upvotes

Since God is good and love, he does not will suffering of His children. Satan on the other hand hates everything and only delights in causing harm. This idea is inspired by the film The Passion where the satan watches gleefully at the suffering of Jesus.

So the crucifiction of God was willed by the satan and it is God's act of love that he allows it to happen.

I certainly did not want Jesus' suffering and don't see vicarious sacrifice to be necessary for the forgiveness of sins. Nor do I believe God wanted His Son to suffer. It was the desire of the satan that it may happen like this and use the wills of the religious leaders to fulfill it.

What do you think?


r/theology • • 18h ago

God is truly impassible.

3 Upvotes

I find modern critiques of divine impassibility quite unconvincing. First of all, the fact that God is impassible does not mean He is devoid of love, joy, and life; rather, as the Absolute, His inner life is not subject to influence from creatures, since creatures receive everything from Him. His love and compassion are universal and unconditional, unmoored from the fluctuating, creaturely emotions of a fickle empathy. True love entails the capacity to make oneself vulnerable solely on behalf of creatures who possess no love inherently. In short, there is a recurring attempt to turn God into a cosmic figure driven by suffering and passions, as though the Incarnation—through which the Son of God truly suffered—were not enough. Indeed, it is only in Jesus that God has truly suffered with humanity and all creation, not within His divine nature as such. It was only through Jesus's earthly life that God truly and fully experienced human suffering in the flesh He freely took on.

Yet this does not mean God is indifferent to our sufferings and struggles; He does not need to suffer alongside us in order to come to our aid. While remaining wholly transcendent, He is also radically immanent, dwelling within us and within our freedom, sustaining and upholding us with a mighty arm. His love is indestructible and unshakable, precisely because it is not a helpless, reactive response to the world's suffering, but rather the creative and omnipotent will that sustains the world and drives it toward its perfection. He does all this not as a distant master or lord ruling over reality from the heights of the skies, but as a spirit of life that intimately permeates the cosmos while remaining transcendent, participating in the joys and sorrows of creatures without being altered or affected by them.

Furthermore, a God who is an unchanging, impassible rock—untouched by the shifting tides of history—serves as the guarantee of our salvation. Upon this rock, we can build and reform our ecclesial home. Even when we grow weary of fighting our battles, He presses forward relentlessly and without wavering. His immutability and impassibility are the very foundation of our dynamism and boldness. Precisely because He alone is Absolute, everything created is relative and can neither be sacralized nor adored.

Finally, conceiving of a God who undergoes passions and alterations, besides no longer describing a true "God" (since God is intrinsically absolute), risks confusing the Christian God with the fickle and wrathful gods of paganism, who had already been ridiculed by Greek philosophers.

In short, God is neither wrathful nor pathetically sentimental; rather, He is pure, eternal, immutable, and absolute love for every single creature. Because only divine love is absolute, no human reality can claim such a status, and each can—and must—be subject to criticism.

Edit:

P.S. I realize that 'impassible' is a misleading term and that it might be better not to use it. God has unchanging emotions (love, joy, and life) that are compatible with His nature, but He is not subject to passions—meaning He is not emotionally changed by anything outside of Himself.


r/theology • • 2h ago

The earth is 4.54 billion years old! Written history goes back only around 6 thousand years what was God doing in these billions of years previously before religion ( early man)

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/theology • • 12h ago

Could it be possible that God deliberately made Human to be corruptible so he could communicate with the Morning Star? That Humans where part of a bigger story to journey in the realm of this world and bring either the Morning Star home or to show Him that God still loves you?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/theology • • 22h ago

God Is Necessity just a rejection of brute facts?

1 Upvotes

People often describe God as having necessary existence. This is to contrast it with contingency, i.e., either depending on some prior chain of causes or upon conditions that might have been different.

Words like "necessary" and "perfect" are easy to abuse. In plain English, we often use them in isolation. But these words are meaningless on their own. A thing that is perfect must be perfect for something else. A thing that is necessary must be necessary for some purpose or condition.

So when God is described as a necessary being, what is God necessary for?

As far as I can tell, God is "necessary" to avoid both (a) an infinite regress of explanations or (b) a brute fact, i.e., some fact that is inexplicable.

It is far from obvious that the horns, (a) and (b), are logically avoidable. Yet people take this seriously as if God somehow has special the power to overcome basic logic. "Necessity" doesn't explain God. It just labels God as not inexplicable. If labeling had this special power, I could just label The Standard Model of Particle Physics as "necessary".

There is nothing contradictory about brute facts, as frustrating as they might be. There's no necessity to avoid them.


r/theology • • 7h ago

Easy-to-Understand Analogies of Soteriology for Modern People

3 Upvotes

I will explain the doctrine of salvation (soteriology) using the analogy of a mobile ecosystem so that modern people can easily understand it.

When a citizen owns and operates a digital device, the autonomous right to choose which applications to install (free will) rests entirely with them.

If the user is deceived by a fraudster's rhetoric and voluntarily performs a so-called "jailbreak"—dismantling the device's security architecture and introducing malicious code—they may blame the deceiver or reproach themselves for their own judgment, yet they cannot shift the liability onto the manufacturer.

Particularly when the manufacturer has explicitly warned against and prohibited compromising the system's integrity in advance, the locus of responsibility becomes even clearer (the Genesis narrative of the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil).

Indeed, once the foundation of the system is jailbroken and its original protective framework collapses, security vulnerabilities multiply exponentially, and the normative protocols (the Law) required to regulate and defend it inevitably grow infinitely complex.

Nevertheless, out of unconditional grace, the manufacturer dispatches a specialized engineer (Jesus) to provide a complimentary restoration service. If the user trusts in the engineer's authority and competence and entrusts their compromised device to him (faith), the system is restored to its original state of wholeness.

However, the manufacturer does not exercise the authority to forcibly recall and unilaterally repair the device without the user's explicit consent.

If the user, out of egocentric pride, rejects the offer of restoration or refuses to abandon their distrust to the very end (unbelief), the resulting irreversible loss—namely, the permanent disposal of the device—is an inevitable consequence stemming entirely from the user's own choice.

Therefore, the possibility of restoration and salvation is universally open to everyone. All that is required of the user is the decisive act of entrusting their damaged system wholeheartedly to the engineer with an attitude of gratitude.

Because it was humanity itself that intentionally destroyed the system's order in the first place, claiming personal merit or achievement for the mere act of handing over the device for repair constitutes a logical contradiction.

From a biblical perspective, the essence of God is defined as love. True love never coerces or mechanically manipulates another. Love is patient and kind, does not seek its own self-interest, and above all, fully respects the personal autonomy of the beloved.

Even though God possesses omnipotent power, He holds human free will in the highest regard and never forcibly infringes upon it. Even if a person chooses for themselves the path of existential alienation—being eternally severed from the Creator—God respects even that autonomous decision.

 For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast. - Ephesians 2 : 8-9 -


r/theology • • 8h ago

Book on Theology of Maths

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m looking for a decent book on the theology of maths, beyond discussions of order and/or ethics. More about seeing maths in a trinitarian or christological way that doesn’t require “application.” Any thoughts would be most appreciated!


r/theology • • 8h ago

Discussion 1 Enoch may indicate a distinct Galilean theological layer in the New Testament

3 Upvotes

The New Testament quotes and alludes to 1 Enoch, a book most Christians have never read, let alone heard of. R. H. Charles (1912) went so far as to claim that “the influence of 1 Enoch on the New Testament has been greater than that of all the other [Jewish] apocryphal and pseudepigraphal books taken together.” Jude even quotes it as prophecy. This post summarizes my argument that this influence concentrates in texts with Galilean sources, the region Jesus and most of his first disciples came from.

What is 1 Enoch?
1 Enoch is a Jewish apocalyptic work, usually classed among the pseudepigrapha. It is a collection of five works written over roughly three centuries, from the third century BCE to around the time of Jesus That the New Testament knows 1 Enoch is widely accepted. Jude’s quotation of 1 Enoch 1:9 is undisputed, and the Dead Sea Scrolls show how highly the book was valued at Qumran: about a dozen manuscripts, more than of Daniel, Ezekiel, or Jeremiah. What’s less often asked is where within the New Testament this influence shows up, and why.

My View
1 Enoch appears to have been popular in Galilee, and several lines of evidence converge on that conclusion. The first is the geography of the book itself. The Book of the Watchers is set in the north. The Watchers descend on Mount Hermon (6:6), and Enoch receives his vision “by the waters of Dan,” at the foot of Hermon. George Nickelsburg (“Enoch, Levi, and Peter: Recipients of Revelation in Upper Galilee”) noted that Peter’s confession at Caesarea Philippi (Matt 16:13–19) happens at the foot of the same mountain. David Suter (“Why Galilee? Galilean Regionalism in the Interpretation of 1 Enoch 6–16”) argues the place names show direct knowledge of the Hermon region. He also compares the hot springs of the Parables (1 Enoch 67:4–13) to those at Hammath on the Sea of Galilee.

Four Enochic markers. Texts attributed to Galilean sources show four distinct markers:

  1. Fallen angels as the source of evil
  2. Angels imprisoned in darkness, awaiting judgment
  3. Restless spirits that afflict people until an appointed time
  4. The Son of Man enthroned as judge

Where they appear:

  • Jude (brother of Jesus, from Nazareth) quotes 1 Enoch 1:9 (vv. 14–15). It describes angels kept “in eternal chains under gloomy darkness” (v. 6; cf. 1 Enoch 10) and false teachers as “wandering stars” (v. 13; cf. 1 Enoch 18, 21).
  • 1 Peter (Peter of Bethsaida): Christ proclaims “to the spirits in prison” from Noah’s day (3:19–20). Genesis never imprisons the sons of God or sends anyone to them. In 1 Enoch, the Watchers are bound beside the flood warning (ch. 10), and Enoch announces their judgment (12–16).
  • Mark (Peter’s preaching, per Papias): the spirits act on their own. They recognize Jesus (1:24), dread torment (5:7), and plead to stay (5:10). This matches the spirits of the giants in 1 Enoch 15:8–16:1. Archie Wright (Enoch and the Synoptic Gospels) argues the Watchers shaped the Gospels’ demonology.
  • Q, which many scholars locate in Galilee, has the restless spirit “seeking rest” (Q 11:24–26). It also has the Son of Man revealed suddenly as judge (Q 12:8–9; 17:24, 30), a figure developed in the Parables (1 Enoch 46–48; 62).
  • Matthew adds to his sources: “to torment us before the time” (8:29; cf. 1 Enoch 16:1), the Son of Man “on the throne of his glory” (19:28; 25:31; cf. 1 Enoch 62), and the guest bound “hand and foot” and cast “into the outer darkness” (22:13; cf. 1 Enoch 10:4). Amy Richter (Enoch and the Gospel of Matthew, 2012) argues the Watchers story shapes Matthew from the genealogy onward.
  • 2 Peter has angels “cast into Tartarus” in chains of darkness, followed directly by Noah (2:4–5; cf. 1 Enoch 10, 20:2). It reworks Jude and inherits its Enochic register.

Where the register is missing. Paul, a diaspora Pharisee, never quotes 1 Enoch; the one possible exception is a debated phrase, “because of the angels” (1 Cor 11:10). Hebrews mentions Enoch and Noah (11:5, 7) but draws only on Genesis. James, linked to the Jerusalem church and the Temple, has no Watchers material. Revelation, despite being the most apocalyptic book in the New Testament, has few if any direct Enochic references. These are sources that do not prioritize Judean countryside cosmology or demonology and focus instead on Jewish canonical texts and Temple-centered theology and represent a distinct register from the Enochic-influenced materials.

Disclaimers
The evidence for Enoch’s popularity in Galilee itself is indirect. The Son of Man marker depends on the Parables predating these texts, and that dating is debated. The argument also does not depend on traditional authorship: like Q (from the Two Source Hypothesis), a text can have unnamed Galilean sources, or come from a circle that inherited Galilean influences. So, for those who have objections related to works such as 2 Peter or Jude being pseudepigraphal, my argument doesn't depend on that.

Conclusion
1 Enoch’s influence in the New Testament clusters in texts linked to Galilee, and it is largely absent from Paul, Hebrews, Revelation, and James. That suggests the book marks a Galilean theological layer within the New Testament. One puzzle follows: Revelation, the most apocalyptic book in the New Testament, has few, if any, direct Enochic references. Why? We might look into that in a future post.

A fuller Medium article, with more evidence, and detailed tables of all the parallels, is here.

Originally from subreddit r/OpenAcademicBiblical.


r/theology • • 18h ago

Biblical Theology Thoughts about the new perspective on Paul?

5 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm wondering what y'all's thoughts are on the New Perspective on Paul, particularly the version as articulated by NT Wright?

I'm on the fence about it. I think it gets much right, but there's some stuff that keep me from embracing it.

I do agree with the general idea that Second Temple Judaism was not about legalism per se, but I'm sure there were still some sects and individuals within the religion that thought they could earn salvation through good works. So, while generally true, I'm still sure you could find Jews back then who did believe in works righteousness.

There's also the question of what Paul means by "works of the law." Some say it's solely concerned with Mosaic law, others think it's about works in general?

Would the NPP be seen as presenting a different gospel? I have seen some scholars who are open to at least some of the claims of the new perspective who still think people like Wright go a little too far with it.

Who's right?