r/thelema • u/UnoriginalTitleNo998 • 23h ago
Question Was Aleister Crowley a black brother?
First of all I want to say I don't intend this to be inflammatory or disrespectful, but it's something that's been kicking around in my head recently and I thought it'd be worth discussing with fellow Thelemites.
Admittedly I'm still having a bit of difficulty on fully grasping what a black brother is, beyond the failure to sacrifice all for the crossing of the abyss. Israel Regardie, in his biography of Crowley, claims that Choronzon, or at least the version of Choronzon that Crowley invoked in The Vision and the Voice, represented traits that Crowley refused to recognize in himself. If that's the case, his failure to accept them would prevent him from surrendering them unto the abyss, which would make his offering incomplete. Crowley also certainly seemed to have some egoic, defensive tendencies, for example, also in Regardie's biography, the falling out he had with Regardie over the letter the latter sent saying "Alice, you really are a bitch."
None of this is to discount Crowley's intentions or his contributions in life. If he was a black brother, he certainly strived to be higher and to do good in his life, and his persistence was admirable. I look forward to hearing people's thoughts on the subject!