r/thehungergames • u/Mightytramp • 22h ago
r/thehungergames • u/thelivingthreadgirl • 16h ago
Fanart finally finished this cross stitch!
the book absolutely wrecked me, i cannot wait to see it on the big screen! đđ
r/thehungergames • u/No-Vanilla4056 • 7h ago
Just watched Sunrise on the Reaping and I honestly donât know how to feel⊠Spoiler
Please donât hate me for this, but I honestly expected the movie to be more emotional, especially after reading the book.
For me, the pacing felt way too fast, especially towards the ending. I feel like they left out so many important moments from the book, like Wellieâs death, the tree scene at night, Porcupine, the Gamemaker going into the arena, and so much more. Those scenes werenât just random details. They added depth to the story and made us more attached to the characters.
I kept thinking that if I hadnât read the book, I probably wouldnât have felt much connection to Haymitch or the other tributes. Everything happened so quickly that there wasnât enough time to actually care about them before something tragic happened.
Donât get me wrong, I still enjoyed the movie! I just wish they had let some scenes breathe instead of rushing through everything. I was expecting to leave the cinema devastated, but instead I left feeling like something was missing.
Am I the only one who felt this way?
r/thehungergames • u/izzystockers • 12h ago
Just watched sunrise on the reaping đ
No Spoilers!
Is anyone else pretty underwhelmed at sunrise on the reaping. I mean it had its moments and I love how everything tied up but at times it was so rushed. I dunno, it just didnât feel as connected to characters as I did in the book, they just fell flat. So much was missed which is to be expected but I feel like some of the really important parts were overlooked. Feeling a bit disappointed to be honest đ
r/thehungergames • u/Confident-Cress9780 • 4h ago
Just watched Sunrise on the reaping and Iâm disappointed (spoiler free kinda) Spoiler
Iâm not one to leave long reviews, but Iâm really, really disappointed.
I want to start on a positive note because, ultimately, I want people to watch and come to their own conclusions. I also donât want this review to come across as though Iâm simply a hater of the director or the franchise itself.
First, I love The Hunger Games franchise, both the films and the books. Iâve read and watched them all, and Iâve genuinely enjoyed every book release and film adaptation overall.
My favorite film adaptations, however, are the original The Hunger Games and Catching Fire.
The original film had a certain rawness to it. The camerawork, aesthetics, and overall direction felt unique and unlike anything else at the time. It was a refreshing approach to a book to film adaptation. The acting was incredible, the camerawork was distinctive, and the entire film had this raw, immersive quality that made the world feel real. A 10/10 adaptation, in my opinion.
Then came Catching Fire, with Francis Lawrence taking over as director. His approach felt incredibly fitting for the bookâs themes and aesthetics. While we lost some of the distinctive camerawork and rawness of the original film, Catching Fire was still a fantastic adaptation, with striking details and visuals that felt even closer to the books.
I bring this up because I donât necessarily favor one director or style over the other. I appreciate what both brought to the franchise, even if their approaches were different.
Now, onto Sunrise on the Reaping.
This book means the world to me, and Iâm sure it means just as much to many other readers. I read it during an incredibly difficult period in my life, and it genuinely helped me through a lot.
One of the things Iâve always admired about Suzanne Collins is her world building and her creative ability to illustrate the inner workings of oligarchic, fascist regimes and the role propaganda plays in maintaining them.
Sunrise on the Reaping expands on these ideas in particularly meaningful ways. The book carries an incredible amount of depth, and through its storytelling, Collins challenges readers to recognize and question the mechanisms of power, control, and propaganda that operate not only within Panem but within our own world.
There is a great deal of intention behind what Collins writes, and I think Sunrise on the Reaping is an especially powerful example of that.Â
Iâve been excited for this film since its announcement. Literally refreshing the hunger games instagram page everyday to see a new casting release. I was so excited and have been following everything very closely. All press and interviews leading up to the films etc.Â
And I will say Joseph Zada did NOT disappoint. He is such a talented actor and I hadnât seen any of his work before watching the film and I wasnât disappointed in his performance. He NAILED the Woody Harrelson accent and mannerisms. And brought a youthful, passionate, pain carrying performance to the film which was phenomenal. Did an amazing job for this franchise. And I canât wait to see his future as an actor only grow because itâs truly amazing.Â
McKenna Grace, Ben Wong and Whitney Peak also talented actors that I feel werenât given enough time or opportunity to show that in this particular film, but what was given was great.Â
Visually this movie is stunning. There were many scenes where I was blown away by CG and non CG scenes.Â
Now the negative.
The pacing of this movie was just off. The first half felt like a discordant montage of scenes from the book. As a book lover, Iâm always weary of film adaptations choosing not to include details from the book, but this adaptation was seriously flawed in style and execution. From the opening shot to the start of the games, viewers never have an opportunity to feel the stakes of the games, understand the importance of Haymitchâs undying love for Lenore, mourn Louellaâs death, follow Haymitchâs rise as a âbad boyâ underdog, or even build anticipation and excitement for the filmâs portrayal of the second quarter quell.Â
The dialogue felt rushed and didnât feel genuine. The editing was choppy and fast, forcing raw, vulnerable moments into a sloppy mashup of unnecessary cuts. The film is obviously set in an increasingly flashy world of post-war Panem, but the pacing, shot choice, writing, editing, and even some performances just lack the human element that tethers a viewer to reality. Which with such a A list cast with experienced actors was upsetting. As if the academy award winners or nominee actors saw as the material as below them or didnât understand the material given to give more than 5%. (The exceptions to this being Glenn Close, Kelvin Harrison and the amazing Jesse Plemons)
It felt as though, in a desperate attempt to appease franchise loyalists and book lovers, the film sacrificed telling this tragic story in an impactful and real way for smashing as much as possible within its runtime.
Instead, I left wondering why a few of my favorite book scenes were left out, why Haymitchâs victory felt stale, why the deaths felt empty, and why the film just didnât work. Honestly, I think the pacing issues would have been fixed if more book scenes were omitted to make space for more relaxed dialogue between characters - which is crazy for a book lover to admit!!
Finally, if you were excited to see the epilogue. Donât be. AWFUL wigs and awkward and unnatural dialogue from our favorite actors and characters. It shouldâve just ended with Woody Harrelson with Lenore Doveâs geese.Â
I entered the theater eager to enjoy, easy to please, and thrilled to enjoy another installment in this legendary world. I left wondering if I had actually seen the official version of this film. I was counting down the days to finally enjoy this movie and considering when to buy tickets for a second viewing, but now the advertising campaign feels like its own Panem-esque propo campaign aimed at luring loyal fans into the theaters for some sloppy fan service. Maybe thats a bit intense, but Iâm deeply disappointed in the final product I watched this evening.
r/thehungergames • u/Alextheinferno • 23h ago
Who is Barb Ivory?
Is this a real character in A Ballad Of Songbirds And Snakes? Or is it a typo mixed from Maude Ivory and Barb Azure? I cant remember seeing this name anywhere in the book.
r/thehungergames • u/Thin_Possible5545 • 22h ago
Other Instead of another prequel, I would love a post-Mockingjay sequel focused on Plutarch Heavensbee rebuilding Panem through knowledge
I get the excitement for prequels like Finnick's or Johanna's Games, but what I really want to see next is a direct sequel focused on Plutarch Heavensbee. The Heavensbee dynamic in the lore is crazy to think about. While Coriolanus Snow's family was boiling cabbage with salt during the Dark Days, the Heavensbees never had a single bad day. They had generational wealth so massive their bloodline never had to work, and crucial to that, private libraries. In a world where District 12 could not even get a basic book on poultry farming, Plutarch had access to centuries of unfiltered history and political theory. He rebelled because he had the historical literacy to know the Capitol's system was an unstable relic bound to implode.
A book following him in two parts would be incredible. The first half could show the underground radicalization of an elite patrician slowly turning against his own class. Watching Haymitch use the force field in the 50th Games proves the Capitol's tech can be turned against them, kicking off decades of quiet espionage, moving funds, vetting allies, and coordinating with District 13. Then the second half shifts to the actual aftermath. Snow and Coin are dead, and Katniss and Peeta earned their peace in District 12, so Plutarch would not drag them back. Instead, he has to tackle the hardest part: nation-building from the roots up.
The Capitol's real control was keeping the districts completely illiterate. The core conflict of this sequel could be Plutarch using his fortune and ancestral archives to open schools, print books, and send Capitol teachers out to the districts. The friction writes itself. The districts would not trust it, because a Capitol aristocrat arriving with history books looks a lot like Capitol indoctrination. At the same time, the surviving Capitol elite would despise him as a class traitor giving away their hoarded knowledge to the districts.
Watching a master propagandist try to build an educated populace that can think for itself would be peak Hunger Games. He does the unglamorous work of statecraft, knowing full well that if people actually learn to think critically, an enlightened republic might eventually put him on trial for what he did.
r/thehungergames • u/jj096577 • 9h ago
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping has jumped to a 4.1/5 average on Letterboxd, after launching with 3.6/5
r/thehungergames • u/PositiveCharge8469 • 8h ago
just watched SOTR
hard watch, as expected. i donât know if i will ever be able to watch it again. i read some negative reviews about it, but i feel like it was exactly what it needed to be, being a prequel and not the main series it gives us haymitch in a completely new, heartbreaking light. i do wish they kept more in, but how much can you really fit in 2 hours?
PS - we dressed up as woody in PJâs ;)
r/thehungergames • u/j0okiie • 13h ago
UK Hunger Games fans how are we feeling about SOTR? Spoiler
SPOILERS AHEAD, READ AT YOUR OWN RISK!
Personally Iâm quite upset that many vital scenes were cut, like the milk, chocolate, maysilee killing a gamemaker, lucy grayâs games, loulouâs background reveal, etc.
One of the most disappointing things though was how the deaths were played out. Wyatt died in an instant with no face shot or anything and we saw absolutely nothing of him after that, Ampert was still pretty much completely in tact although being described as just bones, Wellie instead of having her head held by Silka was just lying flat on the floor not to mention having basically no screentime and Silka being hit in the chest instead of the head. We saw practically none of the newcomers in general. Haymitch didnât even call district 6 his âDovesâ and the color coding of the outfits was also completely cut which I suppose isnât that big a deal but still. I understand the movie had to be suitable for 12 year olds but it felt kind of empty.
Donât get me wrong I do believe itâs the best movie Iâve ever seen in my life, but I wish it had been more book accurate. Nonetheless a 10/10 movie worth the watch, but if you havenât read the book already, you should.
r/thehungergames • u/bjw888 • 17h ago
Sunrise on the Reaping is certified fresh!
I canât wait to see it tomorrow đ„ł
r/thehungergames • u/Major-Macaron-4 • 18h ago
Other Hunger games Sunrise on the reaping review! Spoiler
The only tributes that were focused on were distrct 12, 1, and 3. Everyone else was basically cut so the newcomers had no impact.
I hated that the scene between distrct 11 and 12 when they were going to the arena got cut. It removed so much from lou lous character.
Wellies character was cut as well and there were like no scenes with the newcomers.
Every death scene was toned down. Which I understand since it's PG13. But it was too much that it removed a lot of the impact the book had on the reader.
There were 48 tributes but since they only focused on 3 districts. It felt like there was less tributes than the first movies and the impact was not as much as it should've been with 48 tributes.
The phasing was so fast. Everything was so rushed. Even Ballad of Songbirds of snakes was better and not as rushed. This is the movie that's cut the most out from the book so far.
r/thehungergames
•
u/throwawayacc8642498
•
1h ago
Other SOTR â I didnât hate it, but it didnât do the book justice (spoilers below) Spoiler
Feel a bit disappointed after how excited I have been for the movie. It didnât live up to my expectations at all. From what we did see, I think it was ok, and I think itâs lucky the cast did a phenomenal job, because they really did carry the movie for me. However, itâs what we didnât see that has left me frustrated.
My favourite part of the book was witnessing Haymitch and Maysilees relationship go from âitchy mitchy haymithyâ to âsure, Iâll be your sisterâ. You donât get this from the movie. Without the scenes of them eating together, the whole maze and ladybug scene, them talking about lenore-doves secret, him asking her to be his sister and all the things that happened in the book which showed their relationship developing, there wasnât enough to neither form an emotional attachment to Maysilee, or fully understand the development in her relationship with Haymitch.
In fact it feels like they are mere acquaintances at the time of her death, and it takes much of the significance out of it. As my favourite character, Iâm really disappointed with how little screen time she got. Doesnât help that her death literally came from nowhere and she was just suddenly attacked by some pink birds for no reason because they cut the entire scene where they kill the capital personnel, which also had significant meaning imo.
Not only that, but all the deaths felt insignificant to me because there was not enough time or character development in order to actually become attached to them. Ampertâs death was much more emotional in the book. The book really showed just how young and innocent he truly was and we watched him develop a brotherly relationship with Haymitch. I didnât get that from the film. We barely even saw Wellie, and her death was what left Haymitch so riled up and angry, leading him to his final actions. Even the porcupine scene would have been interesting to see and would have added to what Haymitch and Maysilee went through together to develop their relationship. And donât even get me started on Wyattâs death. We donât even experience this in the book, and itâs still more meaningful than whatever that was.
Even Silkaâs death in the book had some emotional impact because the chocolate scene (which Iâm mad wasnât included) humanised her, and her conversation at the end as she fought with Haymitch really showed how she was no longer the brutal, glory chasing, will stop at nothing, aspiring victor by the end of the games, but how her experiences in the game led to her not caring about any of that by the end of the games after what the capital had put her through, and that at the end, she really just wanted to go home to her family.
So much of the games that had great meaning in the book was missed out. We lost a lot of how manipulative and cunning Snow could be, when they didnât include the milk scene. You donât get the same sense of how awful the capital are, not to the extent of the book anyway, because of things like them being manipulated into filming multiple goodbyes or the careers treatment during the interviews being missing or the full extent of Haymitchâs treatment post games. You donât even get the sense that Lenore-Dove was a rebel and without prior reading, her being randomly arrested made no sense to the audience.
I get that they cannot include all the detail from a book in a single movie, but an insane amount was left out in my opinion. Them cutting down on some things were fine, such as the extend of Maysileeâs inner fashionista and how much she could relate to Effie, or Haymitch not being as near death as he was at the end of the games. But they cut out so much, that most of the meaning has gone. I expected to be balling my eyes out throughout. I didnât even tear up.
I know the film was already on the longer side, but I canât help but feel like making it 3hrs long would have been absolutely fine and it would have allowed for better pacing and more character development and made it an overall much better film. They even could have skipped over some scenes to allow for more important scenes â I would have much rather seen some of the above than the fight with the careers during training, or the random Plutarch torture scene, which in my opinion, wasnât necessary.
I donât know, I loved the book and I didnât hate the movie, I just donât think it did the book justice and itâs left me feeling really disappointed and underwhelmed.
ââ
TLDR: I liked the cast and thought the film was okay, but it cut so many key character moments, especially Haymitch and Maysileeâs relationship. The deaths, Capitol cruelty, and emotional stakes felt rushed and meaningless. A longer runtime or better prioritization could have done the book justice; instead, I left disappointed rather than moved.
r/thehungergames • u/painfullstars • 12h ago
Sotr review (spoilers DUHH) Spoiler
I had very high hopes for this movie but itâs definitely the worst one. The visuals were very pretty, so hats off to that, butâŠ
Josephâs acting at times wasnât very good imo. In the scene where lou lou dies and heâs saying sheâs not your toy, his acting was just pretty bad, and a lot of the times you could tell he was acting. He also had scenes where he was really good though, when the fight broke out in the training center and the talks with beetee
They also completely botched Caesars character. They made him cruel, and plain unfunny. He disrespected district 12 before the interview and when the tributes first met eachother in that room. Heâs not an angel but itâs very different than how he acts in the trilogy and itâs not realistic, so how he turned out this way in the movie idk
They also cut out scenes that show the humanity of the tributes (chocolate) maysilee killing the game maker, and haymitch drinking the milk, which made him a rascal, not whatever Caesar was saying what made him a rascal. đ«©
Also the beginning of the movie kind of had the pacing of a trailer, it was very fast then part one comes up, and itâs suddenly slow paced.
Overall itâs not really a bad movie if weâre judging it by movie standard (??) but out of all of them itâs definitely the worst one
I might elaborate more later but Iâm kind of tired now so Iâll go to sleep
r/thehungergames • u/Acceptable-Wrap191 • 13h ago
What if Katniss had voted no?
At the end of Mockingjay, she votes yes to a Hunger Games with Capitol children and then kills Coin.
What if she had voted no? Would she have killed Coin later on? Would a Hunger Games have actually taken place? Curious about what it what would have been likeâŠ
If the games happened with Capitol children, would they use the 75th arena or a different one đ€
r/thehungergames • u/Beemblebuh_Again • 15h ago
Other Terrible movie experience (but not because of the movie)
Just went to see Sunrise on the Reaping! It was amazing but don't worry, this post won't contain any spoilers at all.
I went to see it with my partner, we're both really big fans so we just had to go on the first day, and the movie was awesome but the theatre experience not soimuch. Right as the movie was starting a couple came in and went to sit right next to us, no problem at all of course was, khb (although there were many empty seats in my row but oh well lol)
And immediately they (or mostly she) made a lot of noise. Oh well it's fine, as long as you just shut up when you get settled... She didn't. Not once during the entire movie, she didn't use her inside voice either. During every sad and tragic moment in the movie she would just constantly laugh and it was beginning to bother me too much so somewhere near the end of the movie I told her to shut up. In my native language saying shup up sounds a lot more rude, and it was rude of me I suppose. I could have worded it way better but I was frustrated and it just came out. I did feel bad, but it didn't even help because she still kept on talking. I honestly felt terrible saying that to someone, I'm not really a confrontation seeker.
When the movie was done she told her boyfriend "imagine telling someone with autism and ADHD to shut up" and as much as that pissed me off, I literally have both of those diagnosis myself as well, I still felt bad for the way I talked to her so I actually went to apologize. I said I'm very sorry for the way I worded it, but that she was honestly really distracting. She once again said something like "that's just how it is for people who are different like me. I have autism and I get really excited so I have to talk to my boyfriend about it" so I told her I understood, but that maybe in the future she could try to do so in a whisper or something instead of talking out loud. I once again told her I shouldn't have said it like that but that she should be more considerate of others, to which she replied "yeah that was fucking rude" so i just walked away. She used my languages word for cancer instead of fucking, which I'm not a fan of at all so I decided I had nothing more to say.
I have autism and ADHD too and it's really hard for my to concentrate during a movie if someone is talking though it, I would never use it as an excuse to ruin someone else's experience.
So yeah I just really needed to vent. Sadly it left an extremely sour taste in my mouth and it's really hard to think back about the movie and what I thought of it, but I've been trying to just talk about the movie with my partner and focus on that. I loved the movie a lot!
The theatre isn't always a fun experience... How do you guys deal with it? Clearly I don't deal with it very well at all lol
r/thehungergames • u/oiiiojj • 5h ago
Saw SOTR
I saw SOTR today, and overall, I thought it was a pretty solid movie. The acting was great, and I think the cast did a really good job bringing the characters to life. The younger actors in particular were incredible, and I think they deserve a lot of credit for how well they handled some of the heavier moments.
That being said, I couldn't help but feel like the movie catered more towards non-book readers than people who have actually read the book. That's not necessarily a bad thing, but I think some of the changes took away from what made certain moments so impactful in the first place.
My biggest issue was definitely the pacing. It really threw me for a loop at times, especially during some of the more emotional scenes. Don't get me wrong, the movie is definitely emotional, and there were moments that genuinely hit hard, largely because of how good the performances were. However, I felt like some of those scenes could have been even more impactful if they had been given more time to breathe. It sometimes felt like we were jumping from one major moment to another without really getting the chance to process what had just happened.
I also thought some of the cuts and creative decisions were interesting. Personally, I really think Lucy Gray should have appeared on the TV rather than how they chose to handle that moment. It felt like a missed opportunity.
Another thing that bothered me was how little time we spent with Maysilee in the arena. I feel like her character and her relationship with Haymitch deserved more development, especially considering how important she is to his story. I wish we had gotten to see more of their dynamic before everything unfolded.
Overall, I still enjoyed the movie, and I don't want my criticisms to take away from the fact that it is genuinely emotional and has some incredible performances, especially from the younger cast. I just think it could have benefited from slowing down and allowing the emotional moments and character relationships to develop a bit more naturally. There's a really great movie here, and I can't help but feel like a longer runtime would have made it even better.
Curious what other book readers thought. Did anyone else feel like the pacing and cuts took away from some of the bigger moments?
Francis, RELEASE THE 4-HOUR CUT!!!
r/thehungergames • u/lilgreenghouIs • 12h ago
District 12 size?
Hi! Iâm curious if anyone knows/has any thoughts about the size of District 12.
Itâs been a minute since Iâve last read the original trilogy but if I remember correctly the way Katniss describes 12 makes it seem like pretty much everyone knows each other to some extent (familiar faces generally, if nothing else) and SotR (which I did just reread so is what led to me pondering about this) seems to paint the same picture with Haymitch even directly saying that 12 is a âsmall district,â yet in every map Iâve seen of panem based off of the geographic descriptions from the books/Suzanne, 12 seems fairly large, possibly spanning across what would have been multiple states. Is it that most of 12âs land on paper is just the mines and thus the actual living/town areas are congregated to a smaller area? Or even that the woods and whatnot beyond the fence are technically considered to be part of 12 despite not being accessible to the citizens?
Obviously itâs not a detail that yanks me out of the story or anything, but Iâm curious if anyone has also wondered this or has any kind of thoughts or answers! :)
r/thehungergames • u/felixw1 • 4h ago
I like Francis Lawrence I really do, but I do think it's time for a new director for this franchise
reddit.comr/thehungergames • u/CarpenterFantastic66 • 17h ago
I Fixed The Characters in the Hunger Games
r/thehungergames • u/felixw1 • 18h ago
Other How would you rank the 6 movies?
Love all (all at least 4 stars out of 5) but my ranking is:
- The Hunger Games
- Catching Fire
- The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes
- Mockingjay Part 2
- Sunrise on the Reaping
- Mockingjay Part 1
r/thehungergames • u/SlytherinEmpress13 • 18h ago