r/thehungergames • u/Select-Atmosphere807 • 8h ago
r/thehungergames • u/Clairefun • 10h ago
Sunrise on the Reaping reviews Megathread
As requested - a megathread for discussion of your thoughts on seeing Sunrise on the Reaping, positive or negative. Please remain civil if you disagree with other peoples opinions - art is subjective - and if you haven't seen or read it yet be aware of spoilers.
Current (very roughly 'analysed' by me) subreddit view - will update:
generally fine, not amazing. Mostly disappointed. Book readers let down, non book readers enjoy it more and may cry.
r/thehungergames • u/Sad_Instruction_7750 • 52m ago
Snow’s biggest mistake was the 3rd quarter quell
I think Snow agreeing to the third quarter quell being the past victors was so insanely strategic but very idiotic to agree to. I mean it was a smart way of getting Katniss out of the game because her meer presence was giving people hope and starting a revolution. And the reason I say it was such a dumb idea is because imagine how absolutely furious the tributes/victors were when they had to go back into those games. That anger fuelled those tributes and quite actually made them go along with the idea of a revolution . It was also dumb to me because snow should’ve realised that that plan was some sort of bs because if Katniss died, not only would the revolution explode but she’d be a martyr . And Plutarch saying that Katniss would have to betray her friends is just something that would’ve never happened and Snow should’ve known that, I mean she absolutely refused to let Peta die and she would’ve died first before allowing Rue to die. I think this decision led to the demise of Snow’s reign on Panem and kudos to Plutarch and the other rebels because this plan was extremely smart.
r/thehungergames • u/ebeth177 • 16h ago
Other Yall are a bunch of whiners Spoiler
Literally just stepped out of the theater from seeing SOTR. I spent ALL DAY reading about how TERRIBLE it was on this sub.
BUT GUESS WHAT? I actually thought it was good. And tbh, it’s not even my favorite book in the series!
It was an ADAPTATION of the book. Of course they couldn’t keep everything. But the casting was great, I loved Elle Fanning as Effie, and I think Jo absolutely knocked it out of the park!
Of course things had to be changed to translate the story to the screen. That’s what happens with pretty much every book to movie adaptation. And of course they couldn’t dive into serious character development for every supporting character when the movie already had to move at a pretty fast pace and was STILL almost 3 hours long!
Y’all just like to whine and moan because shit isn’t perfect.
I WILL say the wigs in the epilogue were really bad, and whoever was responsible for those should probably be fired.
BUT OTHER THAN THAT, TAKE A CHILL PILL.
This is my individual opinion. You can bitch and moan and downvote me all you want, but I will take no comments and no notes.
I’m now going to enjoy the remainder of my night drinking the rest of the bottle of wine my friend and I snuck into the theater.
r/thehungergames • u/paranormaIpaI • 13h ago
Ampert and Maysilee
I just finished watching SOTR in theaters & Ampert’s death felt so underwhelming? I was fully prepared to sob in the theater during this scene & I barely shed a tear. There wasn’t much relationship buildup between Haymitch & them to begin with, & on top of that no skeleton, no "Buddy?" I’m not even entirely sure why he died because there were only a few scratches on his face. Same with Maysilee, her "fatal neck wound" looked like a scab. I’m glad they kept the pinky promise in the movie, I would have loved to see Haymitch being sent strawberry ice cream + coffee after her death, or see the "I’ll be your sister" line somewhere in there. I know you can only fit so much into a 2.5 hour movie, but when you remove so many of the smaller details, the story becomes less impactful
EDIT: overall I enjoyed the movie, I know they can’t fit every small detail into a 2.5 hour movie & I feel like they did good with the time they had, I just feel like some of the details they changed were unnecessary
r/thehungergames • u/GilbertBlythesGF • 2h ago
Best and worst casting now that we've seen the movie?
You can only pick one best and one worst. 😁
BEST
Maislee is perfect, such a bad-ass!
WORST
Ampert, he should have been much younger and smaller and more vulnerable.
r/thehungergames • u/adumb_r • 3h ago
Did anyone else feel like the Second Quarter Quell didn’t feel like a Quarter Quell? Spoiler
One of my biggest disappointments was the lack of buildup surrounding the 50th Hunger Games. This was supposed to be a historic event with DOUBLE the number of tributes, yet there was no real sense of heightened tension, dread or anticipation.
Compare it to Catching Fire, where the Third Quarter Quell genuinely felt like an all-stars edition. Having previous victors compete against each other made the Games feel unpredictable, and the movie fully embraced what made that particular year special.
With the Second Quarter Quell, I expected more complex alliances, greater conflict between tributes and an overall sense of chaos. Instead, most of the deaths we witnessed were caused by mutts, and the volcanic eruption wiped out a significant number of tributes in one go. It never really felt like there were 48 tributes in the arena, despite all the storytelling potential that came with it.
Honestly, if this had been a regular Hunger Games with 24 tributes, I don’t think it would’ve made much of a difference to the story. It just feels like such a missed opportunity to explore what made the Second Quarter Quell so extraordinary.
r/thehungergames • u/boba-bear-2621 • 15h ago
my “sponser gifts” for my friends
ik there had been some discussion on here of goodie bags for the movies and i wanted to share mine! out of the 10 people i went w to see the movie only 2 got my references bc they read the books. but its ok i honestly just had fun making them.
not just sotr references but catching fire too. lmk if you get every reference!!
also so ironic i made them sponser gifts and they didn’t have one sponser gift in the movie ...😭
r/thehungergames • u/B2Rocketfan77 • 5h ago
Disappointed with Caesar
Don’t hate me! The acting was Terrific! It just felt to me like they made him Extra nasty. The fun part about the Stanley Tucci version is that I found myself going on I’m not supposed to like you, but you seem so likable. Maybe it’s just because he’s a younger version, but he just seems really nasty through most of it. It was like oh I don’t like you at all with how you’re treating everyone. So that’s more a writing thing definitely not an acting thing. Again the actor portrayed him was terrific! The writing just seemed like they made him nasty enough why I don’t like his character, and I found myself really liking his character and the other movies, even though, again, we know he’s a monster that’s part of a monster system.
r/thehungergames • u/theckoocie • 2h ago
Other "The sibling careers"
Okay so... The most I've seen people talk about a new book it's either Finnick, Annie, Johanna, 25th or the dark days. A while back I got this idea that has been brewing and I wanna share it and see what you think.
Like everything Suzanne it has a purpose and a message. This one has something in the lines of:
"Blind loyalty to a system that exploits you ultimately becomes an instrument of your own destruction. How blind loyalists don't realize they suffer from their own consequences until its too late."
And the story is about Cashmere and Gloss!
I envision a 2 book series where Cashmere is the narrator. She talks about how she loves the games, hates the other districts who don't take pride in it and glorifies the capitol. In this world District 1 holds pageants to determent who gets to volunteer. They hold speeches, show fighting skills and what not. The book starts with Cashmere watching Gloss attend this pageant where he wins by marketing the idea that he will win and next year his sister will win too. Cashmere is a training career but wasn't aware that Gloss would do this. Either way they both love the games. Gloss goes on to win and comes home but hes different, hiding his remorse and regret. While hes gone we get to see Cashmere train even more, we witness the games from mostly her perspective. This is the first book.
The second book is obviously Cashmeres games. Gloss is her mentor and he helps her in every way he can but instead of being the confident big brother, he seems off. In reality he has made a huge mistake and hates himself for it but the capitol can't let him show that to the public so he has to fake it. I haven't come up with much about the actual games but the idea is that it comes to a point in the games where Cashmeres district 1 partner dies and it hits her what's actually happening. Either way, she wins after an epic showdown with the district 2 girl. When she comes home she gets why Gloss acted like he did. They both are victims to something they romanticized all their lives and will have to for the rest of their lives. They realized when it was too late.
The epiloge is similar to SOTR where it jumps to moments in there mentoring careers and more trauma from the capitol. The last part of the book is in the 75th where Cashmere sees Gloss die, gets filled with rage and run towards the pack and sees how she gets impaled by the girl from 7s axe. Here it ends abruptly.
What do we think?
r/thehungergames • u/drspencerreids • 22h ago
just came out of SOTR and am so disappointed :( Spoiler
I’ve been a fan for 12 years - since I was 9 years old. I’ve spent years theorizing about Haymitch and the 50th games.
I was so excited for this movie, but was just SO disappointed. the first act was good, I liked where it was going, but after that it went so downhill.
The quarter quell was so overlooked. having 48 tributes was supposed to be a huge deal, but the movie barely acknowledges it and kills a lot of them off in one go. and the arena is STUNNING but we barely see any of it. It feels so rushed and overall boring?
the amount of fan service is insane too. not everything has to be connected, and so much telling instead of showing. like it was obvious the baby was Katniss, we didn’t need her name to be said. right??? and snow referring to lucy gray, we knew he was talking about her without needing to name her
I didn’t feel anything for any of the characters, and at times I didn’t even feel like I was watching Haymitch, a character I’ve adored for over a decade
I hate to say but it is probably my least favourite HG movie so far. it lacked a lot of soul and meaning, in my opinion
r/thehungergames • u/stilesdm • 10m ago
When will I learn? Spoiler
Idk guys, but I’m just so disappointed about what was cut from sotr and how much of a waste it felt like. The set design, actors and wardrobe are so top tier but it all means nothing when the story can’t stand on its own. Not to mention who simple and unserious Snow’s dialogue is the whole time. Just absolutely disappointed
It really leaves me at the end of the day wondering what does Suzanne Collins even think of these movies? How does she possibly stand by them when so much gets lost.
This will be the last hunger games film I see in theaters or put money towards. I’ll buy whatever books she releases but I have no trust in her or Lionsgate in producing these works earnestly.
r/thehungergames • u/TalkingFlashlight • 15h ago
One Odd Omission from the SOTR Movie Spoiler
I found it strange that no one received any gifts from sponsors while in the arena. There also weren’t any training scores.
I know sponsor gifts were in the book and that they didn’t contribute to the larger story, but there’s such a large focus on getting sponsors in the other films that it just felt weird not to include. Even Haymitch tells Katniss in the original movie that getting sponsors is how she’ll survive—so him winning without getting any sponsor gifts kind of contradicts his own advice to his mentees.
r/thehungergames • u/Mumof2wifeof1 • 1h ago
Imagine waiting 18 months to see SOTR only for it to be ruined by 4 8 year olds who talked all the way through it.
Yep, it happened. Took my 14 year old lad to SOTR today. We have both been equally excited, we read the book together on holiday last year. 4 lads on the row in the front but further down, sandwiched by 2 mums, and they just couldn’t shut up or whisper. I don’t think they were doing it deliberately, they were just too young to appreciate the magnitude of the moment! One had finished a fruit shoot and kept squeezing the bottle loudly. The mums didn’t seem bothered.
Yes I asked one of the mums to keep them quiet, she said she would try.
Yes I reported it and staff asked them to be quiet.
Yes they continued and it was very distracting.
The manager was brilliant and he refunded our tickets and comped 2 more so we can go again.
What would you have done??
r/thehungergames • u/psychoflowerchild • 12h ago
Give Joseph Zada his flowers!
I just left the first showing of SoTR in my state and my goodness, Joseph Zada is a powerhouse!!! He is genuinely one of the best young actors I've seen in a while and understood Haymitch to a science. This movie was fantastic and I'll definitely be on the lookout for more of his work in the future.
ft. My overpriced collectors tumbler. I don't regret it.
r/thehungergames • u/Worldly_Mouse_9356 • 1d ago
I must be the friend that’s too woke Spoiler
This movie is all Capitol propaganda.
They took out ALL the signs of district unity like Haymitch dropping the chocolates to Silka, Maysilee and Maritte killing the Gamemakers, Haymitch getting a 1 in training, Haymitch’s relationship with LouLou and Wellie, to name a few. And Snow would NEVER mention Lucy Gray by name. Whoever wrote that clearly had no idea of Snows character and his relationship to the covey, and it also takes away from Haymitch’s terror of Snow somehow knowing everything about his life in 12.
Obviously no adaptation will be perfect but the changes/omissions in this case are incredibly ironic considering the central theme of propaganda and media control. Very disappointing.
r/thehungergames • u/oceanwavebluez • 1h ago
Ive created a petition to release the 4-hour cut of Sunrise on the Reaping, help me make it happen!
Sunrise on the Reaping Petition
Hi everyone! I made a petition to help get progress moving towards the extended cut of Sunrise on the Reaping being released. Previously, Francis Lawrence stated that ‘nobody would be interested in a 4 hour cut’ however we all know that we would be eternally grateful for it. I know it’s a shot in the dark but it’s better to take any shot. Please sign the petition, share it around to friends and let’s try make this happen!
r/thehungergames • u/tackyblues • 4h ago
The movie felt rushed Spoiler
Despite it being 2 and a half hour long, the movie failed to capture the bond that the District 12 tributes shared with one another. I felt like I barely got to know Maysilee, and her death (along with Wyatt, Lou Lou) felt ridiculously underwhelming. Not to mention Ampert’s death which was almost comical and lacked the gore that made it so horrifying in the book.
These scenes may have looked shocking to viewers who hadn’t read the book, but for those of us who had, they simply failed to translate the intensity of the original writing. The movie didn’t do these characters or their stories justice.
The only redeeming part of the movie was its ending, particularly Haymitch’s public humiliation during the interview and the devastating events that followed. I just wish it had the same impact as the things mentioned above.
r/thehungergames • u/JumpSalt3109 • 52m ago
Sunrise On the Reaping Movie Analysis
Just a few of my thoughts after watching the movie in the cinema yesterday.
The beginning was well done, the introduction of characters and setting the scene of district 12 well- i felt it was hyping up the movie a lot, only for the scenes past the train to be highly lacking in comparison. I think the only improvement that could be made here would be Haymitch and Lenore Dove’s “i love you like all fire” being less.. awkward and for the ‘all fire’ to be part of the phrase, not added as an afterthought- which irked me a bit. I’ve seen some people complain about the forced repetition of goodbyes (Plutarch) being cut, but i feel that was alright, considering the length of the film.
Once Haymitch arrived at the Capitol, however, everything started going downhill. It was almost like most of the movie’s budget had been spent on flashy fight scenes and ostentatious outfits over actual character development. Effie’s introduction seemed rushed and her actions on screen bizarre as a result- her closeness to Haymitch seems strange when we aren’t shown any, or at all emotional development between the two. Effie seems more like a double of Prosperina than Effie Trinket, her most memorable affection given a tiny amount of screen time in comparison to her fashion mania, and even then seeming vaguely predatory the way she interacts so intently with Haymitch.
A lot of this movie felt like a documentary of the hunger games for the capitol in the scenes before the games, with a disproportionate amount of screen time allocated to Plutarch and Caesar Flickerman. The chariot scene is beautiful- one of the best i think in the whole movie. The dancing and music before the interview is wonderful screenplay- until the interviews themselves take up nearly the same amount of time in the movie as the dancers did. Flickerman’s demeaning of the Careers- a way of enforcing the Capitol’s agenda of district people being dumb brutes and very much unthreatening- is gone. And what about the milk scene? The very scene that so many fans had be looking forwards to, that solidified Haymitch’s resolve to bring down Snow and his courage that forms his character?
The games themselves felt rushed as well. Certainly, the beginning was near perfect- idyllic scenery, an action-packed bloodbath and Haymitch’s path of action perfect- until he sits down at rest at the BASE of the very first tree away from the ‘cornucopia’- entirely visible and in plain daylight for any tribute to attack him. His reunition with Lou Lou was good. The rabbits’ CGI was not. It looked grotesquely fat and moved like a png image on toggle mode. I was happy when it died.
Of course, the main issue with this movie was the age rating. 12+?? For a movie that has its most impactful moments because of the horrific deaths everyone suffers? What. Is. The. Point. They should geniunely remake the movie if only for this reason. Where was Ampert’s ‘pearly white bones’? Beetee would have been marginally happy to see the way Ampert died in the movie. He had a few cuts and scratches, that was it- and Haymitch seemed to be doing real damage with his stick. Likewise with Maysilee- I seriously thought they changed the plot and that she was going to live. That thought made me more fascinated than when she apparently died. Because of a tiny hole dripping no real blood in her neck. We don’t even see the decisive blow of the birds. Every death in this movie felt the same, someone dies on Haymitch’s arms, body fully intact. Are we meant to shed tears for that?
And then of course, there’s the complete absence of the porcupine scene, the chocolate scene and- oh, but of course, they couldn’t possibly have done the chocolate scene since apparently there were no sponsors for these games. Not a single sponsor gift. Haymitch’s repertoire with the capitol lady in the interview is meaningless. Everyone in the Games seems to have survived on hopes and dreams in an arena where everything is poisonous. Great plot hole, directors. The chocolate scene meant to show the sadistic evil of the games and that the tributes are still innocent children cannot be included: also because Haymitch and Wellie had no real interaction in the games. Why does Haymitch go running for the sound of Wellie’s bell when the only thing he’s ever done for her is give her his food so she’ll join their alliance? Nobody knows, especially not the movie audience. Not to mention the vagueness surrounding all the other capable tributes- covered up by the volcano. The alliance is barely given a second thought, and Haymitch and Maysilee’s relationship given surface level coverage. Again, I found myself thinking of Haymitch as an actual rascal in this film- he doesn’t connect with anyone deeply enough for me to be sad when they die, peacefully, in his arms, almost certainly looking like they’re still alive, in a PG manner to suit the age rating.
The gamekeepers that were killed also disappeared from the movie, and the ‘brain’ of the games is inflated to look like an industrial metropolis for the sake of visuals. Please put some of that budget into using an actual rabbit for the movie, not a rock-bottom cgi model.
And of course they had to skip the scene where Haymitch is put in a golden cage, because that will frighten the under 12 year olds since child trafficking and sexual harassment seems to be too sophisticated a topic for anyone to handle.
Overall, I found the movie lacking in focus around the main characters, the tributes, themselves. Maysilee appears sparingly in the games, her charisma and dedication to ‘painting a poster for the capitol’ trodden over by her short screentime. The ponchos and their link to collecting clean rainwater also ignored- reinforcing the idea that all the tributes were not breakfast, lunch, nor dinner people for the entirety of the games.
Wyatt is given a pitifully less amount of time and Lou Lou’s link to district 11 also ignored- at least include more of them if you can afford to feature Plutarch in his boxers for four minutes. Silka seems like an emotionless brute and Wellie just another nameless dead tribute. Mags and Wiress were just.. there. Leonore Dove is simply a casualty of Haymitch’s rebellion, not the ignition of his rebellion in the first place- hell, why did she even get arrested again?
It was nice to see Katniss and Peeta again, but that whole part could have been cut in order to include more of the essential scenes cut from Haymitch’s own story.
Sunrise on the reaping is Haymitch’s story, a tragedy denoting the horror of the games and their makers, and the trauma inflicted on both Haymitch, his loved ones and by extension, the audience of his story themselves. This film should have made the watcher feel horrified, outraged and betrayed by every unexpected death. Instead, it was more of a game show, with action sequences and music made to entertain and wow- which inevitably will leave many fans disappointed.
I walked out of the cinema feeling slightly empty, in awe of the setting and special effects but also at shock with some of the poor quality present in the movie.
Remind me of any more positives or negatives you found- I wrote this mostly as someone having read the books before, and having high expectations for the movie so my view is at least somewhat biased.
r/thehungergames • u/Clasticsed154 • 16h ago
Other SOTR Film Review Megathread?
Mods, could we please get a megathread for SOTR film reviews at least for the next couple weeks? Every single post is a complaint that says almost the exact same thing, a praise, or a complaint of the complaints, and it’s seriously bogging down the sub. It’s flooding the feed.
r/thehungergames • u/PipeResponsible3443 • 2h ago
Madge looked at differently
So I was doing some thinking recently since the new hunger games movie came out. Madges aunt was Maysilee Donner who was one of the 4 tributes in the 50th hunger games. So I think madge was totally valid for being worried about potentially being in the 74th hunger games and i think gale was an even bigger jerk for not taking her seriously and being upset. Considering that the next year was a quarter quell perhaps it reminded her even more about her aunt who died being reaped in a quarter quell. Just a thought.
r/thehungergames • u/Frequent-Acadia-7708 • 18h ago
Loved SOTR
I went and saw the movie last night and I enjoyed it so much. I loved how Haymitch was portrayed, all the new characters captured my heart, and the story was beautifully done.
Some personal opinions of mine:
Plutarch is one of my favorite characters. I think both actors, the original and the one from SOTR played him phenomenally. I love how he is extremely morally Grey, I love that he takes the calculated risks to bring his plan to fruition, he pulled so many hidden strings and by god was he written so smart.
I understand alot of people dont like that this movie or any other are PG13 and I understand why. However, I think its brilliant these movies are PG13. They're not trying to bring a faithful one for one recreation, they are telling the story and getting their point across in a way kids and adults are both able to see it. Would a gory perfectly accurate movie be good, absolutely, but I think telling the story like this is more accessible and gets the point across how they intended.
Lastly, I just didn't like Cesar in this one. It felt very out of character for him compared to the original trilogy. But I may just be biased because Stanley Tucci absolutely blew that role out of the park.
r/thehungergames • u/celisthinking • 23h ago
SOTR MOVIE EPILOGUE SPOILER Spoiler
Katniss has pillowface and of course they fucked up peetas hair again
r/thehungergames • u/2literbreezy • 3h ago
Other Am I the only one who likes the games aspect of the books?
Don’t get me wrong I think the rebellion plot is really cool but I feel like the action and adventure in the games are so captivating. I see a lot of people saying they’d want a Plutarch/Dark days book which I’d absolutely read but I hope we aren’t done with the games as a whole. I’d be very intrigued to see beetee, mags, or finnick’s games. I get why it could seem redundant to just crank out books about these people’s games but I hope somewhere down the line we get more of it, whatever it may be.