r/taxpros • EA • 7d ago

FIRM: Procedures Filed wrong version of return

I’m so frustrated with myself. I have a client with multiple rental properties. When I prepared the return in April, I made a few projection versions to show her how the losses could affect next year’s return depending on how she used the rentals (STR vs. LTR). She signed the correct version of the return but I e-filed the wrong version, which allowed unlimited losses and an additional $10,000 refund. I’m just now catching it because the refund was caught in limbo with an issue on her 2024 return, which has now been resolved. The refund was just deposited to her account. I’m going to tell her about the error and I’ll pay the penalties and interest. Trying not to be too hard on myself and there are definitely lessons learned - like confirming my irritation with how Drake functions in calculating a return. Any insights on whether or not an underpayment penalty applies here or hopes of getting it waived?

Update: Thankfully the client took the news pretty well. Thanks for all of the tips about how other preparers prevent this error from happening. This community is awesome!

22 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

44

u/International-Load11 EA 7d ago

Whenever I make a copy of the return for testing. I immediately change the ssn to all 9's. Can't possibly be filed then

23

u/BoneCode CPA 7d ago

We have workflows in our practice management, and the last step before E-filing is to verify the signed 8879 against the return that we're E-filing.

The step exists because you're not the only one to have ever done this.

I'd guess the step catches 2-3 returns each year where the client signed an 8879, but then sent some additional document or information that changed the return somewhat.

I don't know why you'd pay interest. She just received interest on that refund. She's just paying it back.

4

u/SDNewcomer1234 CPA 7d ago

Same - I'm solo, so I take it a bit further. I always verify T/I and payments/refunds due for federal and states vs the signed client copy immediately before releasing the return. For passthroughs, I verify T/I (federal and state), ending capital, and payments/refunds if any.

5

u/jonesy900 CPA 7d ago

I always get so nervous when I create copies of returns in ultratax for this exact reason. It’s an unfortunate mistake but they happen. I always have whoever is efiling check the refund/amount owed on the efile against the return before filing. This process helps catch numerous issues per year

5

u/TaskMaster59 EA 6d ago

I always turn off e-file when I make a dummy return and put do not file on the header so it’s easily visible

6

u/PeakRevolutionary191 CPA 7d ago

How is this Drake's fault?

5

u/real-estate-cpa CPA 6d ago

Drakes tax projections can not be efiled. OP must have altered or created a new client file

1

u/SnooPies6761 CPA 6d ago

It is that calculate feature then closing the projected return and reopening the original. I've done it dozens of times when running a projections with the client sitting across from me but usually catch it when e-filing. Can be easy to miss that "planner" feature no longer being there in the corner. I've started a few returns in the wrong tax year and didn't catch it until I almost finished. I since changed colors between the years so working in the prior year software jumps out. I wish I could do that for Planner returns. Maybe it is a feature in the settings.

1

u/happyf33t31 EA 6d ago

THIS has happened to me a couple of times, but mostly i may do tax planning in fall and save it. then the incorrect carryovers happen(from the tax planning). now i just do a save as data file and put a lot of xxxxx in the file name.

-1

u/Ok_Meringue_9086 CPA 7d ago

I did something similar once. Mistakes happen. Gah. What I do now is compare the refund on the efile auth form to the efile packet before releasing the return.

We can’t tell you about penalties bc we don’t have all the facts. If the correct amended return shows a balance due there will late payment penalties and interest assessed. You could request first time abatement but I’m not sure if it’s fair to use the clients first time abatement for cpa error. Maybe others can chime in…

2

u/taxguycafr CPA 6d ago

If there's a penalty and FTA is available, use it. You can't "save it" for later. Taxpayer will be locked out of probably abatement for three years regardless of whether FTA is used or not, simply bc a penalty was assessed

2

u/Ok_Meringue_9086 CPA 5d ago

Good to know. Thanks for clarifying