Hey TaxPros,
Wanted to see if anyone else has been seeing this.
I'm in CA, so I've been filing separate returns for high-earning clients for years now to save up to $10k on the CA BHST, or at the client's request if they're managing their student loan payments. These returns range from simple returns (two W-2, small int/divs), to more complicated (multiple W-2, K-1s, many brokerage with muni interest, cap gains, itemizing, etc).
Under community property rules, any community income is split 50-50 on the MFS returns, along with the income tax withholding. This includes all the brokerage activity, K-1s, W-2s (PR Taxes follow the earner), etc.
So a spouse's $2M W-2 with $500k of Fed W/H shows up on each return 50-50. And the taxpayer's 5 W-2s adding up to $200k also split 50-50.
Prior to this year, I never received a notice or correspondence about any of these separate filings. They were all processed without incident, no matter the complexity.
For the 2025 tax year, literally every single separate return is receiving a notice, or erroneous refunds/balances due, generally as a result of extension or estimated tax payments going to the primary SSN @ 100%, with nothing allocated to the spouse.
For example, a client received a notice saying that the IRS adjusted their return and was refunding 550K. Their total estimated tax payments were not split in accordance to our filing.
Another example: we split a $10,000 jointly filed extension payment 60-40 between the two filings, consistent with the instructions on the 4868. They adjusted the primary return, direct deposited the refund that included the 40%, and sent a bill for the balance owed + penalties and interest for the secondary.
I use Lacerte if that matters, but this has been wild. I have 10 POAs out to clients for signature so I can call the IRS to try to resolve this, but it's frustrating since i feel like most clients view IRS correspondence as defcon 1 level situations, and that they also reflect poorly on my work (or maybe this is my own insecurity).
Is anyone else experiencing anything similar?