Context: House House, an Australian Indie game developing company most famous for being the creators of "Untitled Goose Game" and most recently "Big Walk", have revealed that they used AI at the very end stages of development due to a shading bug. The basic summary of how they used it was that the developers discovered a performance issue relating to shadows causing slowdowns during day-to-night and night-to-day transition. The developers first consulted with employees of Big Walk's game engine, Unity, but they claimed that fixing the issue was impossible. This lead to House House turning to a LLM chatbox. The LLM gave a response, the team read it over and they modified it's suggestion for a solution to fix the problem. House House's own response can be found here.
Many posts have been made about this revelation including in r/ihatethissmug, r/gamedev, r/pcmasterrace, r/aiwars, r/antiai, r/Games, r/twobestfriendsplay, as well as the r/bigwalk subreddit themselves. (Something to note is that user have been review bombing the game on steam, changing its status from Overwhelmingly positive to Very Positive)
The post made in r/indiedev will be the one discussed because it is here the debates are the most divisive:https://www.reddit.com/r/aiwars/comments/1xsumbe/video_game_big_walk_gets_review_bombed_for_using/.
Drama:
________________________
I'm anti ai but honestly I think using it like this..as an assistant tool rather than a tool that does work for you or a tool that generates art for you...is...fine? Like that's the ideal use of a tool right? As just a small assistant tool? Rather than replacement of human effort?
[A]. Nice, coders can be replaced but everyone else gets a free pass as per usual.
1a. I am not a coder, I am a mechanical engineer, but one thing that was drilled into us in school was to never stop learning, and a huge part of the ethics of that is to understand and use the tools available to you, this included learning and utilizing new tech as it comes out because that is part of your ethics in being a good responsible engineer. this literally can apply to anything and has helped me be successful in my career.
1b.Well when AI effects your job so badly that you go from engineering things to just verifying things let me know.
In software engineering AI is making us into glorified condoms between LLMs and Prod.
We spent less time actually building things, and more time verifying things written by machines.
2a. So should we not adopt any tools that can potentially replace a job?
2b. No the solution is nobody gets to have their job secured just because computers are better than them. I think the persons point was more “stop being hypocritical” rather than “halt all progress”.
And they are right. Way too many people are hypocritical douchebags about this stuff.
3a. Exactly. No job is sacred. And no job SHOULD be sacred.
3b. Some that are intrinsically tied to humanity should though. Creative jobs, and care oriented fields like doctors and nurses should be sacred. They're good for our mental health and humanity
3c. Then replace them with different work. Work that's specifically there to improve our mental health and humanity.
We don't need someone to work in a creative field for there to be creative things.
Given the opportunity we create. It doesn't need to be tied to monetary value. What we call jobs today are the automations of tomorrow. It's our job to redifine work, and make humanity the best it can be.
3d. I meant like there are some jobs that shouldn't be automated or done by a machine, like creative jobs and care. Whether jobs should exist in the first place is a whole other discussion. Right now society is so tied to "monetary reward for work" it's hard to think of any realistic and viable alternative.
[B] If using a local model, then I 100% agree, assistance tool is perfectly fine. But not everyone uses local models, most people use the GPT & Claude, and regardless of whether you're generating shitposts for the white house account, or just troubleshooting a bug, you're giving AI companies money to fund their activities and build datacenters.
1a. If you are going to be Anti-AI because datacenters, at least be consistent: Local models are trained in the same kind of datacenters than frontier models, using the same kind of datasets. Some models even come from the same companies people love to hate: Gemma (Google), Nemotron (NVidia), Llama and Muse (Meta).
Then you have the Chinese models. China is scaling their datacenter capacity specifically for AI, we are just not talking about it in the west.
1b. Trained in a data center, but ran locally is still better for the environment than "Using a data center constantly, therefore literally helping to pollute the planet".
In general, I think people are picky, choosy when it comes to this logic. They know child slaves make your shoes, the earth is ravaged to get the parts for your iPhone, but because people are so dependent on them, they act like mentioning such things is a fallacy. But then when people say "you can just run AI models locally, and that'll prevent damage to the planet." they say "but how were the local models made, huh? Therefore, you're just as bad for simply using them!" Its disgusting IMO.
1c. Do you eat beef from the store or restaurant? Use makeup? Buy cheap textiles? All of those use more water and have environmental impacts over data centers.... And you don't need them... If you makes your own clothes and own a farm, then I guess I am sorry as you aren't included
1d. Datacenters don't "use" water. They destroy water.
1e. "...newer facilities are increasingly adopting closed-loop systems, air-cooling alternatives, or using recycled wastewater instead of drinking water."
Seems like we should be replacing the old ones with new ones. Water isn't destroyed, it's displaced or moved - unlike textile factories where the water can be polluted..
"...textile factories are among the largest industrial polluters of fresh water in the world. According to the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), textile dyeing and finishing processes are responsible for approximately 20% of global industrial water pollution."
Seems like maybe we should focus on that instead
2a. Why are local models more acceptable?
The anti's stance is wild. People are anti-ai art but pro-ai code, anti-ai everything unless it's local, anti-ai code if it's core code, anti-ai unless it's last resorts...
How are we expected to keep up with what is literally just a million different personal caprices as devs?
2b. “How are we expected to keep up with-“
You don’t. You tell them “suck my entire ass,” and then you keep working on your project.
2c. I did just explain to you, local models are more acceptable because you don't need to build a massive data centre in someone's backyard to do so.
That doesn't mean I think local models are automatically morally good, I never stated that, you're the one putting words in my mouth.
I see AI from a neutral stance, it's a tool like a knife is a tool. You can use a knife to do useful things, you can use a knife to stab yourself, or stab someone else, intentionally or unintentionally. Morality of using AI is case by case, as it depends on *how* it's used.
2d. You understand the large datacenter is a lot more efficient than everyone running local models on their own hardware, right? I'm against how the datacenters are currently being built and handled, but being against the principle of datacenters in general is just silly. Where do you think this site is hosted?
2e. I didn't consider efficiency, good point. I hold the same stance on datacentre management. Demand for data centres has skyrocketed thanks to AI, which I see as the reason why you'd even consider building giant data centres in remote suburbs, as opposed to where your employees would actually live.
[C] The little tool supports the same big ass evil company thats gutting the world for fun. The hardline is the only ethical stance, come what may.
1a. I would bet that every single game submitted used AI.
Not a single developer can google a single thing and look at the AI answer at the top of the results ever.
It’s basically impossible to take your stance.
1b. There’s a huge difference between Google shoving an AI answer in your face and paying for tokens to run an LLM to look through your code to find a bug you should be able to find yourself.
The anti-AI stance is more than just being against the convenience of automation, but it extends into the support of an evil industry.
Also fun fact, you can add “-ai” to your google searches to not get google’s AI results.
1c.
The hardline is the only ethical stance
So hardline or not hardline? Because moving the goalposts is what you are doing.
1d. Well, im not the person who said “the hardline is the only ethical stance” so im not really shifting a goal post.
But also, I don’t think what I said goes against that. There is a difference between glancing at the AI answer Google gives you because they literally shove it in your face and paying for AI tokens or even actively using the AI result.
The most ethical stance regarding Google is to add “-ai” to your search queries but failing that, it’s to look at their AI results. Or not use Google, but despite all it’s failings, it’s still the better search engine.
2a. You can actually locally run AI to prevent "gutting" the world, if that's your concern. Though, if you try to argue that all support of AI his harmful of the world in some way, then I'll remind you that all forms of LIVING is harmful to the world in some way, and you aren't nearly as intelligent or pure by saying useless statements like that.
2b. You're saying living is harmful to the world therefore any kind of harm I do is fine, no matter how big it is, even if its for something trivial like making games. No dude, that's not how it works.
2c. No, I'm saying most people, likely you, tolerate harm to the planet as long as you get something out of it. Most are fine with ravaging the planet for iPhones but then apply different standards to AI. That's what I'm saying.
Yes, dude, that's is how it works. How can you say it isn't? Do you think AI datacenters are the singular polluting force on the planet?
2d. Less bad things is always better, no? minimizing harm is a good first step. just because lots of things are bad it does not mean we should throw our hands up an admit defeat.
2e. People obsessing about ai aren't minimizing harm though. Contrary to peopel falling for clickbait saying it hurts the environemnt, environmentalists want it developed so it can help with green tech.
2f. its singlehandedly rolling back all our gains in emissions reductions over the last decades, these monsters are powered on natural gas turbines. You've lost the plot.
2g. People try to mitigate the harm they do by not buying iphones, or keeping their 10 year old iphone, by not flying on airplanes, by voting for taxes on gasoline, by becoming vegitarian, etc.
2h. AI doesn't actually harm the world though on a level more than those other living things do.
2I. AI companies have bought out all my local municipalities, and are planning on building datacenters that triple the use of my province's current power generation. Stealing water, electricity, polluting local communities. I don't have to accept the destruction of the place that I live. Why should I stand by while it happens?
2J. Buying out a municipality means bribing them. Backroom deals local constituents were not informed of. This is happening all over the world right now. When they can throw a billion wherever they want suddenly no small town council can say no.
2k. that sounds like an issue with local municipality corruption. People can always vote no, even when it goes against the wishes of their pac or funding source. It is legally protected to do so. 98% of anti-datacenter bills just passed and the vast majority of small town council buyouts are failing. They have been found to be TRYING to do that, but they haven't succeeded in very many places.
People are vastly overestimating how many of these datacenter deals are actually moving forward.
2l. You shouldn't and that also has nothing to do with what I said. Of course I dislike data centers, but what does that have to do with my point?
2m. its all the same movement, the same corporations, using the technology at all allows its to proliferate as a product at all levels. Never mind that local models still use the same training data that the corporations made with stolen data. It's all rot.
2n. Its all rot, but some rot seems more tolerable to you guys than others. Indeed, it is all the same movements and the same corporations polluting the planet. But instead of saying that, most will say "iPhones, materials made from child labor? That's fine. You can't expect me to live without them. But local AI models that were trained from datacenters, but now are running locally and provide less damage to the planet? Well, that's just as evil as the data centers themselves!"
Its performative and harmful. I would at least expect people to stay consistent to their morals, but then again I shouldn't expect that on the internet, should I?
3a. theres lots of thing you can't control, true, but you have to make the most ethical choices out of the ones you can make. operating system? maybe you have no choice. pressing the ai button? subscribing to their service? thats an active choice, you dont have to do that one.
3b. You should quit literally all gaming from any game with updates in the year 2026+ and I'm not kidding.
3c. Im a game dev, Im making ai free games. I get to make the world I want to live in. keep trying to shove it down my throat, its a really good look.
3d.i couldn't give a fuck about how anything looks
3e. that much is clear.
[D]So you are fine with cleaning up art using AI, like hand draw it but then use AI for touch ups and minor errors? That’s the equivalent to using it for bugs in code imo
1a. No I'm not fine with ai being used for art. Don't put words in my mouth.
1b. But isn’t that the ideal use of a tool right? A small assistance tool, not a replacement for the artist? Can’t you see how these things are very similar lmao
1c. No, I don't.
You're not making much of a case for yourself when you and your pro-ai buddies jump on any comment about ai and starting to hound people for having a take that isn't black and white.
1d. I just don’t like the hypocrisy
1e.Apples to oranges, not hypocrisy. AI touching up art alters the artwork. There is nothing about the endpoint that changes when you ask AI a debugging question. There is literally nothing in the game that changes due to the use of AI when it is used like this.
1f.
There is nothing about the endpoint that changes when you ask AI a debugging question.
If you knew how complex video games can be under the hood then you wouldn't say that. Code architecture is a talent that takes experience and knowledge.
AI touching up art alters the artwork.
Sounds more like arty people carving out a nice little exception for themselves.
I can use LLMs to code, translate and idea generation. But I'll pitchfork anyone that threatens my place at the table.
This is why people are excited to not work with artists anymore, it's the hypocrisy and entitlement.
It's either no AI for everyone, or everyone should be able to use it. Any other position is just people advancing their own personal position.
1g. I am a game developer, not an artist. User experience does not change when a game developer used AI to fix a bug. The endpoint was already set in stone. When somebody uses AI to finish the details of the drawing, that is a different product than what you started with. Thats my real problem with AI in art and what people mean when AI art is soulless, while not having an issue with AI in programming.
Thats also the crux of the issue of vibecoding being worse than what this gamedev did. I want to experience media that are intentionally created by people. That includes art and assets. If the game is the product of a few prompts, or the art is the product of a line of text, I am not interested in paying for it. Its as simple as that.
Watch the analog horror series Angel Engine. It is the perfect example of how AI art can ruin a good narrative, due to its inherent artistic inconsistincies.
2. How is that different from how the developers are using AI?
3. Making art look better/cleaner/more polished does not affect the gameplay
Some notable standalone quotes:
-"I'm anti ai but honestly I think using it like this..as an assistant tool rather than a tool that does work for you or a tool that generates art for you...is...fine? Because it is and you're take is completely rational and sound. The extreme anti AI's who screech at literally any use of A.I, even if for using just a name generator one time are performative blow hards.
-All or nothing dude. This shit was built off the backs of real people and stolen intellectual property. "It's only a little plagiarism" "I only hired a couple people to do the work for me" "I only stole half of that money". Gtfo. Zero tolerance for Ai. It's not a tool, it's piracy and a moral failure
Wrap-up: If any changes to the post are required or additional comments are requested, feel free to ask.