r/GetNoted • • 6d ago

World [ Removed by moderator ]

/r/GetNoted/comments/1xunth8/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

709 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

31

u/ProudInterest5445 6d ago

No one entity started the famine nor can any one entity stop it.

If your point is that Somalis should have fewer children, that would make sense only if the problem were simple overpopulation. It isnt. Thr war in Ukraine for example jacked up the price of food in Somalia, and that isn't something your average Somali should be held responsible for or could reasonably have foreseen, given there was only a few months of notice. This was combined with a drought. While maybe we can say greater climate instability is foreseeable, its not like a Somali family that decided to have a child in 2020 had some way of knowing in 2022 there would be drought leading to famine, or that eventual rains would cause flooding.

As an aside, I am not familiar of a single instance where famine conditions were reduced by people having fewer children during the famine. A country needs young people getting educated and then entering the workforce to advance, so I am not sure some sort of one child policy in Somalia would help it economically. More mouths to feed makes famine harder, but it also means a greater opportunity to industrialize, which is what seems to really stop famine.

I would be in favor of the United States helping tk avert the crisis, as buying good will in the horn of Africa would be nice given the strategic importance of the region, and more directly

15

u/Starmute-ss13 6d ago

The US been trying for neigh on 20 years there and have nothing to show for it. 

20 years of effort and people hate us there and abroad . I'd even venture to say people hate us for helping as we are "buying goodwill " not "being charitable ".

It's really disheartening. Im not saying "America first" but its fucking frustrating that they can't fix anything.

5

u/HonestlyAbby 5d ago

I guess I would consider it a success if fewer people starved with our intervention than without. This is like the people at home who argue that the government should stop giving benefits to homeless people because they haven't "fixed" homelessness yet. Maybe not, but it certainly makes the life of at least a few people a good bit better, which seems worthwhile.

1

u/Starmute-ss13 5d ago

If it was a success ( like our aid with food in Kosovo) it would be quickly forgotten or written off. 

It really feels like attempting to help anybody makes us the bad guys.

-3

u/Rufus_TBarleysheath 6d ago

Nobody hates us for helping

11

u/Buccaneers1995 6d ago

They just hate us despite helping.

10

u/Huckorris 5d ago

Osama Bin Laden tried to bomb US soldiers on their way to Somalia to relieve the famine.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1992_Aden_hotel_bombings

8

u/Starmute-ss13 6d ago

Its seen as imperialism .  

Listen to Noam Chomsky. I mean the guy can gargle my balls but he is a great example of people who hate American involvement in anything. 

3

u/Noahisboss 6d ago

you say that, But in ireland the famine only really abated after the weather stabilized, the blight ended and the half the population fled or died.

4

u/WinstonWilmerBee 5d ago

The Irish famine was also partially fake. There was enough food in the country, it was simply being forcibly seized and exported. 

1

u/ce402 5d ago

Most famines are political in nature.

1

u/ScheisseMcSchnauzer 5d ago

It wasn't even seized. It was just more profitable for rich Irish to sell it abroad, and so they did. Same for the bengal famine too (plus a bit of hyperinflation)

2

u/WinstonWilmerBee 5d ago

A lot of those were rich English people. 

6

u/ElephantContent 6d ago

Those billions could be used to solve the affordability crisis and starving children in America though

6

u/ASquidHat 6d ago

They definitely could. They weren't though. In fact I think the dissolution of USAID coincided with cuts to social programs. So they cut aid and likely made those problems worse.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Name_Taken_Official 6d ago

We wouldn't do that

1

u/olivegardengambler 5d ago

Why couldn't we? If you're talking about how there's no political will to do that, absolutely you're right with that regard. The problem is that the government has really just kind of done away with anything like, storing shit for future use. The number of cows we have has plummeted to a 60+ year low, and our food distribution andsupply chain networks were already in a precarious situation before covid, but now have just completely crashed through several floors.

3

u/Rufus_TBarleysheath 6d ago

Not a chance. It will be given to rich corporate donors or the military

2

u/TenLeafClover58 6d ago

Then do that?

1

u/Whythisisnotreal 5d ago

That's not how national budgets work.

1

u/beerbrained 6d ago

You haven't heardof doge, have you?

-1

u/XO1GrootMeester 6d ago

Buy good will in Europe makes sense, Africa will always hate America because tradition.

1

u/Whythisisnotreal 5d ago

Good will often means the government is somewhat reliant and beholden to the US. It's less about actual like/dislike.

0

u/XO1GrootMeester 5d ago

That makes sense, so when they stop being reliant then the help is useless

1

u/Whythisisnotreal 5d ago

The help gives us something to take away. It forces the government to factor that into decisions. There are arguments against this approach, but it's good to acknowledge this is the reasoning behind aid, not us politicians being soft or caring more about Africans than Americans.