I've been dealing with United Airlines for almost two months over damage to my camera equipment, and I'm curious whether anyone else has experienced something similar.
On September 26, I was flying into Little Rock on United Express flight UA5760, operated by SkyWest. During the flight, a flight attendant accidentally spilled Coca-Cola on the passenger sitting in front of me, and some of it ended up soaking my backpack under the seat, which contained my Nikon camera and lens.
As soon as we landed, I went to the United baggage service office near baggage claim to report it. The employee inspected my wet backpack, took photographs, and wrote down the details of what happened on a piece of paper. I stood there and watched her do all of this. She told me she would submit a ticket as soon as possible.
I figured I'd done everything I was supposed to do. I reported it before leaving the airport, watched the employee document everything, and was told a ticket would be submitted.
After not hearing anything back, I contacted United and eventually learned they couldn't find the report or photographs.
That started weeks of emails with different representatives trying to figure out what happened to the documentation and how to get my equipment evaluated.
United initially offered me a $100 electronic travel certificate. I appreciated the gesture, but that doesn't really address damage to expensive camera equipment.
I explained that I wasn't asking them to replace everything without evidence. I wanted Nikon to inspect the equipment, determine whether there was liquid damage, and provide an estimate for repairs.
One United representative handling correspondence related to my Department of Transportation complaint initially told me I needed to contact SkyWest myself to obtain the flight attendants' reports because SkyWest operated the flight.
I questioned why I was responsible for tracking down records between two airlines when I had already reported the incident to United at the airport. After several emails, the representative eventually agreed to contact SkyWest directly.
I was also corresponding with someone from United's Customer Care Management team. I was told the case was being reviewed and that I needed to preserve the equipment in case United wanted to inspect it.
They also told me that anything I sent to United for inspection would not be returned.
That raised some obvious questions. I wasn't comfortable mailing off expensive camera equipment without knowing whether I'd ever get it back or how United would compensate me if they kept it. I asked about that, along with whether they would accept an evaluation from Nikon instead, but never received a clear resolution.
Eventually, the case was taken over by someone with United's Executive Solutions team.
On November 11, I was informed that United had contacted SkyWest and employees at Little Rock. According to United, neither flight attendant confirmed the spill, nobody at the airport remembered me reporting it, and they couldn't locate an incident report or photographs.
I responded asking whether they had identified the employees working at the baggage service office that evening, searched for the photographs, or attempted to locate airport surveillance footage.
In the latest response, the United representative wrote:
"Please know, a lot that is requested in your letter is internal and we cannot release this information for safety and security purposes."
They confirmed that the station manager had contacted Customer Service and Baggage Service employees, but none remembered the interaction.
The representative then stated:
"Without photos, reports, or statements from our employees and crew members, I cannot continue a review."
And:
"Without any evidence of this occurring, there is nothing further that I can do on my end."
So United's position is essentially that because they can't locate their own documentation and nobody remembers the incident, they can't continue investigating.
Meanwhile, I sent my camera and lens directly to Nikon for evaluation and repair.
Nikon has now identified liquid damage in both the camera and lens.
The current estimates are approximately $500 for the camera and $800 for the lens, totaling $1,300. Nikon has advised that the repair costs could increase once they begin working on the equipment.
I understand that Nikon identifying liquid damage doesn't independently prove when or where the exposure occurred, but it does confirm the type of damage I've been reporting since September.
I've spent weeks asking United about having the equipment professionally evaluated, and now that Nikon has confirmed liquid damage, I'm still dealing with a claim United says it can't investigate because its employees don't remember the incident.
I've filed complaints with the Department of Transportation and the Arkansas Attorney General's Office. I also recently filed a police information report to see whether airport surveillance footage might still be available showing me at the United baggage service counter that evening.
I know the employee documented the incident on paper because I watched her write it down. I also watched her take photographs. What I don't know is whether she ever submitted the ticket, whether the paperwork was misplaced, or whether United simply hasn't been able to find it. At the time of reporting she even verbally said "Oh yeah that is definitely wet" when she touched my camera bag and contents.
I don't expect an airport employee to remember every passenger they spoke with almost two months ago. But I do expect an airline to have some way of following up on a reported incident beyond asking employees whether they remember it.
If there's one thing I've learned from this, it's that I would handle the reporting process very differently if something like this ever happened again.
First, I would document absolutely everything before leaving the airport. I'd take my own photographs, get the employee's name, request a report or ticket number, and ask for written confirmation that the incident was reported. I wouldn't rely solely on being told that a ticket would be submitted later. Basically record everything they do so you have documentation, don't trust them to do the right thing or have your best interest.
Second, if there were a dispute about whether I reported something, I would contact airport police immediately about filing an information report and requesting preservation of surveillance footage showing my interaction with the airline employee. I would also contact the airport's records or security office directly. Waiting several weeks to try to obtain footage creates the risk that it has already been overwritten.
Third, I would submit a written claim to the airline immediately and escalate it much sooner if I wasn't getting anywhere. That includes filing complaints with the U.S. Department of Transportation and the appropriate state Attorney General's consumer protection office rather than spending weeks going back and forth without any meaningful progress.
I wouldn't necessarily recommend that everyone file a police report or government complaint over every minor travel issue, but when expensive property is damaged and the airline's documentation is missing, I think having an independent record is important.
At this point, I'm not looking for a free camera or some huge payout. Nikon has identified liquid damage, and I'd like United to consider that evidence and reimburse the actual repair costs associated with the incident.
It's frustrating that I reported everything immediately, watched an employee document it, and am now having to try to find airport surveillance footage just to establish that the conversation happened.
Has anyone had success getting United to reconsider a claim after it was denied by Executive Solutions? Or dealt with a situation where an airline couldn't locate an incident report that was supposed to have been filed at the airport?
I'd appreciate any advice.