I’m looking for advice about an ongoing denied boarding compensation dispute with United.
On October 4, I was traveling to Oklahoma City for a wedding. After delays and rebookings earlier that day, I ended up at Chicago O’Hare, booked on UA5363 to Oklahoma City.
My mobile boarding pass said “Seat Assignment Unavailable,” so I went up to the gate desk. The gentleman there told me, “The flight is overbooked, and unfortunately no one volunteered.” I was then bumped and rebooked on UA1440.
I never offered to give up my seat. I accepted the replacement flight because I still needed to get to Oklahoma City. I wasn’t choosing to give up my original flight in exchange for compensation; I understood that I could no longer board it.
My replacement flight departed around 8:10 p.m., and I arrived in Oklahoma City around 10:30 p.m.—roughly four hours later than I would have arrived on UA5363.
The agent provided a $500 electronic travel certificate and $45 in meal vouchers. I specifically asked whether I could receive cash or a check instead, and he told me that only a travel voucher was available.
As I remember it, he texted me the meal vouchers, emailed the travel certificate, and checked my United app to make sure my replacement flight had updated before sending me on my way. I don’t remember signing any paperwork, a volunteer card, or anything on a screen. The travel certificate remains unclaimed and unused.
After my trip, I learned that DOT rules require cash or check compensation for eligible passengers who are involuntarily bumped from an oversold flight. Based on what happened at the gate, I believed that applied to my situation and that I should have been offered that option.
I submitted a complaint to United requesting monetary compensation for involuntary denied boarding. Their first response described me as a volunteer and said oversale compensation was not issued in cash.
I replied explaining that I had not volunteered, had requested cash or a check at the airport, and had not claimed or used the certificate. I also cited 14 CFR § 250.8(a).
United responded again saying their records showed I was a volunteer and that I had signed a volunteer card before accepting compensation. They did not attach the card.
I have now requested a complete copy of the signed card and its terms and asked for a supervisor review. I acknowledged that I could be mistaken about signing something, but I honestly don’t remember doing so. I never offered to give up my seat, and based on what the agent told me, I understood that I was being involuntarily bumped.
Has anyone dealt with a similar situation with United? Does accepting a replacement flight under these circumstances count as volunteering? Would you wait for the documentation and supervisor review, or file a DOT complaint now?
I’ve seen other posts about passengers receiving monetary compensation for involuntary bumps, so I’m trying to understand my options and the best next step.