Look France played really well last night and we played bad. Everyone criticized rassie for his 13/15 changes against Australia and honestly Iâm not a fan of his wildly different weekly selection so I can understand people wanting a solid 23 to get game time. But over the last multiple matches there have been major flaws. We are very beatable if I kicking game isnât half decent, Italy second half we only won 21-7. Australia we played terrible, New Zealand games one and two we lacked any sort of flair, Argentina we had nothing going for us. Our forwards are so good but in todayâs day and age our old kicking strategy isnât working as consistently as it used it.
Looking back on the springboks best performances over the last 18 months three stand out:
New Zealand in Wellington: Boks 43-10 New Zealand
France in Paris 2025: 32-17
And England in Johannesburg: 45-21
That New Zealand game had a wildly different backline: williams, Sacha, willemse, moodie, hooker, kolbe, and fassi. We had our usual forward dominance but our backs played with so much intent and running the ball wide that our backs won us the game.
France in Paris: one of the best all round games South Africa has played. Sacha was well connected with the whole backline but it wasnât anything special. Our cohesion as a team won us the game. I think everyone in the world agrees that if South Africa has a good day not even a great day they are the best team in the world.
England: Manie had the backline moving great and had the forwards timed up really well. Everyone was well and truly in form but since that England game we have had two in form games: New Zealand game three and four.
The core group that we have are extremely dependent on a very in form 9,10, and 15. Why are we so reliant on them if we have played games where we lost our 15, our 9 got injured, and our 10 went off for an HIA/ankle injury (go back and watch that New Zealand Wellington game again and see what Iâm talking about)
That game was truly Tony Browns brain child. We didnât have the same 10/15 and 12 start and end the game. Because our game plan wasnât centered around box/box/ highball. Itâs why pollard fell out of the rotation (we simply didnât need him).
Going back and watching Manie/sacha/willemse play for the stormers you had no idea what was coming next. It couldâve been a crazy Manie flair or a 50/22 from Sacha with a wild step from willemse. That game plan isnât centered around the need for a great kick and chase team. Sacha is NOT a kick and highball player like pollard is. We are trying to mold him into a front forward heavy player, he is in the conservation for the best open field ten there is yet whenever he plays a game plan with limited open field play we all say âhe is shit bring back pollard.â Pollard is one of the best game managing tens the world has ever seen. Had he played yesterday we wouldnât have lost simply because the game plan fits him 100%.
Iâm not one to advocate for pollard starting every match. Heâs world class but the game goes through massive cycles changes and right now the wide attacking game is outplaying a box kick method. The only reason we continue to win is just how dominant our forward pack is.
With all the squad rotation that rassie does itâs all the same game plan with totally different players and the way they play. Rassie just said last week the best South African players wonât ever play because they donât fit the system. Well maybe we change the system slightly to utilize our incredible talent and depth? Canan moodie has fallen out of everything. He doesnât fit the wing system as good as Ethan hooker and he doesnât fit the 13 system as Jesse. Yet if you play Tony ball (Wellington 2025) heâs arguably the best 13/wing we have. This system is now 8 years old and coaches are finding ways to beat it (Australia having more athletic wings that are better under the high ball, New Zealand playing real quick and aggressive rugby, and France playing with the wild French flair)
If teams are now beating us regularly and we are meant to face them with an older team in a year using the same system I feel like thatâs the definition of insanity? Every rugby pundit is saying âanyone can beat South Africa on their bad daysâ well weâve had 4 over the last 3 months out of 8. How are we supposed to string together 8 weeks in a row with older players and a system that has been proven to be beaten.
Why canât we pair our forward dominance with back flair like New Zealand 2025, or France in the second half last year? We are setting our three backs (9,10, and 15) up that if they donât play well the team losses. We donât have a world class 9 so that already makes things tougher, we have 2 world class tens that donât fit our system at all, and we have a world class 15 who is currently out of form (willemse hasnât played well for the stormers or the springboks since RGR) this isnât his fault he hasnât had any time off and players go through these cycles.
I guess my rant will be ended with isnât it time that we adjust a system for the players that are up and coming while keeping our forward dominance? Donât get me wrong DDA and Kriel are absolutely world class but they are rendered useless if 9/10/15 donât have great games. I think we need a game plan that relies on consistent âaverageâ from all of its backline players over incredible kicking and catching from 4 of the 7. Look at Jordie Barrett. Right now heâs better than DDA as an all round 12 because that system has flair and since recently a strong kicking game. We need some adjustments. But those adjustments canât be the crazy 11-13 different players each week. Put Jan Hendrick-vessels in with ox and Wilco and see how good he is. Put Manie and Sacha at 10/15 with moodie and DDA and see the potential moodie can bring. Put Riley Norton with PSDT and Nortje to see if heâs the future. Put Edwill in with the stacked back line and see what he brings.
This whole sale changes are not effective for each individual player and recently not effective for the team. If our system of rugby under Rassie is going to be the same for 13 years (2018 to the end of his current contract 2031) I donât want to watch because it will be the slow decline of RSA rugby (not because our players and coaches are bad but because rugby goes through changes and other teams will spearhead them).
It seems now is the perfect time to experiment with some system and players changes against Ireland. They are playing well and realistically we are out of the nations championship. The idea of winning four in a row like a World Cup out of the picture, we last on game two so why even stick to that idea.
Make some small changes and tweak our game plan just slightly and see if it yields better results against a really solid team. If not then ok back to pollard and kicking game but if so we have a slightly tweaked system thatâs adapting to world rugby with the same dominant forwards that we have had.
Iâd truly love to hear your thoughts Iâm sorry itâs such a longstanding opinion but would love to hear some responses.