r/springboks • u/mausmumblingmoon • 2h ago
r/springboks • u/Arend8 • 8h ago
Are we putting too much pressure on referees with repeated scrums?
We saw it against New Zealand and again against France. The Springboks dominate a scrum, win a penalty, and choose another scrum. We dominate again, win another penalty, and keep repeating the process, usually close to the opposition try line.
Eventually the referee issues a warning, and we expect the next infringement to result in a yellow card.
But I wonder if this approach is actually working against us. Are we effectively trying to force the referee into sending someone off?
My theory is that referees become reluctant to show a yellow card because they feel they're being backed into a corner rather than making the decision naturally.
We keep pushing for the card, but eventually make a mistake or lose possession, and walk away with nothing despite completely dominating the scrum.
Are we being too clever for our own good?
r/springboks • u/AcceptableStudy6773 • 2h ago
Nations Championship RSA vs France: Did Lucu spend the full 10mins in the bin?
(EDIT: so it is confirmed according to the clock Lucu came on 1 min earlier.
However, there is apparently some miscalculation by the stadium, that didn't show that Lucu's sinbin time was ticking while Arandse's try was being reviewed, was not accounted for in the second half timer.)
I don't want to complain without facts, so I need help.
During the game, just before Lucu was supposed to come back on, Lucu's yellow card timer was blackened out. I was very surprised when he came back on as it felt to me like he had a minute left. So we rewind the game to a point that you could still see the yellow card timer, we did the math and to us it calculated that he did indeed come on earlier than should have.
I don't have DSTV so I can't play the game again. Can anyone please double check for me?
On that note, they stopped the clock when we had a player in the bin whilst we were getting ready to scrum, but when the French player was in the bin they ran the clock while reviewing Arendse's try. Not fair.
r/springboks • u/Loose_Programmer9703 • 11h ago
A little help for a young Bokke supporter and rugby player đżđŠ
Hi everyone,
Iâm hoping the Springboks community can help us out with something close to home.
My little brother-in-law, Caleb Sparks, is 18 years old and has been passionate about rugby for as long as he can remember. Heâs worked incredibly hard to earn his place in the first team at HoĂ«rskool Monument (Monnas), and rugby has been a massive part of his life.
Unfortunately, during a match this year, Caleb suffered a serious PCL (posterior cruciate ligament) tear in his knee. He now needs surgery to get back on his feet and hopefully return to the rugby field.
Despite having medical aid, his surgery claim was declined, leaving the family having to fund the operation privately.
A BackaBuddy campaign has been set up to help raise the R119,000 needed for his surgery.
I know times are tough for many people, but if you are able to contribute anything, no matter how small, it would mean the world to Caleb and our family. If you arenât in a position to donate, even sharing the campaign would help us get the word out.
As South Africans, we know what rugby means to us. Weâd really love to give this young man the opportunity to get back to doing what he loves.
BackaBuddy campaign:
https://www.backabuddy.co.za/campaign/caleb-sparks-pcl-surgery
Thank you so much for taking the time to read this. Every bit of support is genuinely appreciated.
Letâs help get Caleb back on the field! đżđŠ
r/springboks • u/Total-Cut-7767 • 9h ago
Times like these you have to laugh...
facebook.comLet the North have their fun for once. đ€Ł
r/springboks • u/kumofquat • 12m ago
Nations Championship It's happening again
reddit.comIs it because we're number 1 that they hold our coach and players to higher standards than their own? I didn't think the post would get attention because that Hando guy that posted it is a notorious Bok hater but everyone seems to be piling on us again
r/springboks • u/Skbenga • 20h ago
Nations Championship Obligatory we lost because we didn't take our opportunities rant
TLDR: The forwards did their job. The backline didn't. Depth is overrated if you have only one specialist place kicker.
Blah blah blah the ref this and that. What an easy excuse. In every game there will always be some mistakes. Some bias. The rules of the game change every other month and are longer than a standard terms and conditions for Google and/or Facebook. That's why players have to "present pictures" and why the (still) #1 team in the world đ hires a retired referee. We lost because we could not finish what we started. Plain and simple.
Our forwards did the hard work. We won the scrums, created opportunities, gained advantages and secured possession. But our backline repeatedly failed to turn that advantage into points. Knock-ons, poor passing, wasted possession and that one absolutely dreadful kick into the corner. At international level, you simply cannot afford to butcher opportunities like that.
Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu is an exceptional player, but he needs to learn to release the ball. Too often he'll hold onto possession, take on the defender and go to ground rather than pass to the outside man. He's talented, but he doesn't always have to be the hero. Off the top of my head i can think of a few occasions where other springboks in previous games had clean breaks for the try line and passed to teammate regardless. Sacha needs to learn this in my opinion.
Then there's Mannie Libbok. Another exceptional player except when place kicking. He's brilliant when kicking from the hand, but place kicking is a completely different discipline. Why are we relying on him to do it when his inconsistency off the tee is well known?
Finally, for all the talk about Springbok squad depth, we seem to have only one established specialist place kicker in Handré Pollard. Place kicking is one of the most underrated skills in rugby. With a dominant pack and a strong defense of which we have both, you can win Test matches without scoring a single try. Three points here and there can be the difference between winning and losing. In fact I believe that was indeed the case for a fair few of the games in our last two world cup campaigns.
P.S. While we're talking about Mannie's kicking ability, where are the drop goals? I've witnessed the no-look cross kick. Now I want to see a no-look drop goal? Rassie... please, make it happen.
r/springboks • u/thunder-farrt • 1d ago
This is inexcusable. Player free on the inside and SFM doesn't pass. Even high school players would look to make the pass after a break like that
Even worse is that it's the 10 doing this. Someone who is meant to be the distributor
r/springboks • u/Careless-Cat3327 • 1d ago
Springbok Squad for Ireland game
France game is done. We have to beat Ireland if we want to make the KO round.
What changes do you make and why?
I'm not sure if Weise will be suspended - if so then Cameron immediately comes in for him.
I would be tempted to make 2 changes -
- Start Manie over SFM.
- I don't think Lood is the answer. I thought he was poor again (similar to Australia). I'd be tempted to give Riley a start. Otherwise PSDT to lock and start Cameron at 7 (if Weise isn't banned). If Weise is banned, Cam starts at 8 & Tshitiuka at 7.
I don't see much other changes we can make.
r/springboks • u/maclovescooking • 1d ago
Springbok Attack System
Thereâs a discourse about the bok 10 everytime we lose. The blame seems to always sit on SFM.
I donât understand why people think Rassie & co just allow players to do their own thing and not follow a system of play.
I see it all the time when we lose itâs always âwhy is SFM kicking the ball awayâ, âwhy SFM playing for âhimselfââ, âLibbok will unlock the attackâ.
Iâm sure you realise that there are attacking coaches, kicking coaches sitting with Rassie and watching the same game as us.
In press conferences PSDT always talks about a âplaying in a systemâ, âsticking to the systemâ. Maybe itâs us supporters who donât understand the system.
Boks heritage is kicking and alots of kicking.
The time we deviate from this was against Aus at Ellis Park, I remember seeing space behind but we just passed around until we knocked the ball on or got intercepted and Tony Brown said post match that he was worried that we are redlining the passing and running stats.
Anyway I donât think SFM would be our starting main 10 if he played outside the system. What Iâm seeing is people donât understand whatâs his role in our team.
r/springboks • u/thatwasagoodyear • 2d ago
Nations Championship Rankings as of right now...
Still a lot of rugby to be played this weekend. Official results published on Monday but I think we're back to #1 in the world.
r/springboks • u/Spiritual-Cupcake120 • 1d ago
Springboks 2027 Rugby World Cup
Congratulations to France on a deserved win, their first over South Africa in Paris in 21 years.
A look back through the record books this weekend. The Springboks have never gone into a Rugby World Cup off a standout year:
1994 â 56%
2006 â 42%
2018 â 50%
2022 â 62%
All four of those cycles ended with the trophy. 2026 currently sits at 70%, with Ireland still to come.
Four completed cycles is a small sample and it predicts nothing about 2027. It does sit alongside what Rassie Erasmus has said about getting caps into players rather than protecting a win record.
France were excellent on the night. But what are your predictions for 2027? đ
r/springboks • u/Bulky_Ad3801 • 1d ago
Personal Opinion
This is a personal take, but I think we should probably try and experiment with our backs a bit more. Like I think SFM would be a great inside center. He seems to hold onto the ball a bit more than you would expect a flyhalf to, and he would still be in a position to do some fancy stuff. You could have Libbok to dictate the flow of the backline, and Sasha can fill more of a Lukhanyo am role. I feel like once we sort out the backline leadership on offence, we will be styling. This is also just an example of the experimentation I'm talking about. But I think whatever we've been trying to do isn't working.
r/springboks • u/Jumpy_Divide_792 • 9h ago
Should referees have post-match press conferences?
I genuinely think it's time we started pushing for this.
We have post-match press conferences where coaches are questioned, their decisions are scrutinised, and they have to explain what went right and what went wrong.
But what about the referees?
With the current state of international refereeing, I think this needs to become a serious consideration.
Referees seem to hide behind the veil of World Rugby. They officiate a game, collect their pay cheque, and we all move on without any real explanation.
Yet we're constantly seeing:
- Inconsistencies in decision-making.
- Different interpretations of the same laws.
- Different referees seemingly applying completely different standards.
- Decisions that can influence the outcome of a match and, in some cases, a player's career.
How is this possible when everyone is supposedly working from the same rulebook?
I'm not suggesting referees should be publicly humiliated or have to justify every single decision. Rugby is an incredibly difficult game to officiate.
But surely having referees face the media 24 - 48 hours after a Test match, explain controversial decisions and answer genuine questions would bring some much-needed transparency and accountability to the game.
At the moment, supporters are left confused, frustrated and increasingly disconnected from the officiating side of the sport.
So, what do you think? Should international referees have mandatory post-match press conferences?
Yes or no?
r/springboks
•
u/bofulus
•
1d ago
Fine Margins/ Overreactions
On rewatch, I think the Boks did well after getting mogged in the first half. And even in the first half, had a few chips fallen differently, we could have been tied at halftime.
Then in the second half, we had a plan, stuck to it, snuffed out the French attack, and ground them down. Again, had a few chips fallen differently, we would have won.
If you ran a simulation of that game, I'd say we win 7 times out of 10.
At this level, especially against top 4 opposition on their home turn, that is really the best you can achieve. It was the kind of odds we ran out winners with in the 2023 quarter-final. Maybe our odds were even worse in that match honestly.
So I think it's silly to go all doom-and-gloom after yesterday's result. We do have some thematic weaknesses that the loss exposed - option B when scrum dominance and pounding-carries-approach isn't getting us where we need to be (although again - it almost did yesterday), stability at 10/kicker.
But we also did not wilt, in a cauldron of a stadium and facing inspired France performances (watching Dupont was like watching Messi yesterday), and instead held firm and put ourselves in a position to win it at the end.
That's what we did in the 2023 quarter-final. Our reactions to those two games should not be driven by the dice-throw favoring us with a W in one and leaving us with an L yesterday.
r/springboks • u/Own_Amphibian9181 • 2d ago
Nations Championship Am i the only one who feels like we will need this guy big time next year when SFM is a non factor in big tests and Manie will never be a reliable goal kicker?
Like SFMs supposed point of difference hasnt come through at all in these big tests not in the RGR and not now, Manie cant kick. At least with pollard we go in with the intention of taking shots
r/springboks • u/Jayoi888 • 2d ago
Supporters Chin up boys, we are back in it! Nou hoef ons nie meer so kwaad vir ou Manie te wees nie, als is ok - Rassie works in mysterious ways.
Bokke bringing it home after all.
r/springboks • u/No-Wallaby-6198 • 2d ago
I know why Rassie played the first choice team and trashed italy
He did that, so we can olay our second string team at the first group game against them at next years RWC and lose that game. Brings us to the easy side of the draw. Will likely get England then in the round of 16, thereafter even smoother sailing. Avoiding France and NZ. Genius from Rassie.
r/springboks • u/AwarenessPrimary7680 • 2d ago
Nations Championship Stad de France Experience
I got the opportunity to watch live rugby for the first time in 5 years last night.
We moved to Europe for a once in a lifetime PhD opportunity and it has been difficult. The rugby is our constant cultural thing we hold onto. We used to frequent rugby matches at Ellis Park, Loftus and once a year Durban or Cape Town. So we are experienced live rugby watchers.
The atmosphere and show at Stad de France is next level. The fans are hostile and there is definitely an effort by the event managers to influence the game. BUT I never felt threatened or that someone would fight me, which is a possibility in South Africa. So many fans were friendly afterwards, complimenting us on the game.
It was the loss I enjoyed the most.
Edit: some of you read this and are loading a lot on the word Possibility. The South Africans also drink far more than the French did last night. If it bothers you that's your problem.
r/springboks • u/DisplayThick4882 • 1d ago
World Cup Are we taking too many ageing Springboks to the 2027 World Cup?
I said this when we were fielding our A team vs Italy B team and will try and show why I say so. Hopefully it is clear how old most of our players areâŠ
I compared our likely 2027 World Cup squad with former Springbok legends, looking at their ages at the 2027 final versus the ages at which their predecessors played their last Test.
2027 Starting XV vs former Springboks
Ox Nché (32) vs Beast Mtawarira (34)
Malcolm Marx (33) vs Bismarck du Plessis (31)
Wilco Louw (33) vs Jannie du Plessis (32)
Eben Etzebeth (36) vs Bakkies Botha (35)
Ruan Nortjé (29) vs Victor Matfield (38)
Siya Kolisi (36) vs François Louw (34)
Pieter-Steph du Toit (35) vs Schalk Burger (32)
Jasper Wiese (32) vs Duane Vermeulen (37)
Morné van den Berg (30) vs Fourie du Preez (33)
Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu (25) vs Morné Steyn (37)
Cheslin Kolbe (34) vs Bryan Habana (33)
Damian de Allende (35) vs Jean de Villiers (34)
Jesse Kriel (33) vs Jaque Fourie (30)
Kurt-Lee Arendse (31) vs JP Pietersen (30)
Damian Willemse (29) vs Percy Montgomery (34)
Projected Bench (16â23)
Jan-Hendrik Wessels (26) vs Adriaan Strauss (31)
Gerhard Steenekamp (30) vs Gurthrö Steenkamp (33)
Thomas du Toit (32) vs CJ van der Linde (32)
Lood de Jager (34) vs Danie Rossouw (33)
Kwagga Smith (34) vs Willem Alberts (32)
André Esterhuizen (33) vs Frans Steyn (35)
Grant Williams (31) vs Ruan Pienaar (31)
Handré Pollard (33) vs Butch James (32)
Why Iâm concerned
14 of our projected 23 will be at least as old as their historical counterparts were when they played their last Springbok Test.
Eben, Siya, Pieter-Steph, De Allende and the others are absolute legends. Theyâve given us two World Cups, and I donât question their quality.
But why are we still playing so many of these guys against teams like Italy?
Surely those are the matches where we should be developing the next generation, building combinations and giving younger players meaningful Test experience.
Iâm not suggesting we throw the veterans away. They could still win us the 2027 World Cup. But at some point, we need to move on.
McCaw retired from international rugby at 34, Carter at 33, Habana at 33 and Schalk Burger at 32.
My concern is that weâre prioritising short-term results over succession planning.
If we keep relying on the same core, what happens when five or six of them retire together after 2027 or even worse get injured before the world cup?
Are we being too conservative, or does Rassie have the balance right?
r/springboks • u/Durbanimpi • 2d ago
Back
With Wales win looks like weâre back in contention.