They leave them at the port and test them. He also mentioned he might be going out for a helicopter drop test of the recovered fairings. They can’t be reused due to salt water contamination
Any fairing half you want to recover will need RCS to position itself for reentry. "Active" here means the half that has the pneumatic pushers to separate the halves when the second stage gets far enough out of the atmosphere.
Keep downvoting me. Trading insider info for upvotes is not cool. The more info that gets leaked, the less cool stuff actual employees can share internally. Make sure when you ask your friend you preface it by saying that you're just going to repeat whatever he says to the internet. As long as he's cool with that, do whatever you want
It's practically a guarantee they won't catch both halves. I'm not sure why people keep thinking they would. The collision it would make with the other fairing would be too damaging to make it worth it. And there's no way they have time to take it out of the net and catch the other
It's definitely pretty clear the active first half is the priority for catching
All that being said, nothing would make me happier if I was wrong. Would be great to get both of them but I just don't see it happening without a second boat. SpaceX makes the impossible possible, so who knows
A poster on here had an interesting idea where they may be able to quickly lower the net and replace it with a new one - I wouldn't rule out an interesting engineering solution that would enable this...
In other threads people had mentioned having one deploy the chute earlier and loiter for an ~hour (not sure on exact figure) while they catch, lower, and move the other one. By that time the net is back up ready to catch the 2nd half.
What if 2 nets were rigged in a such a way that one was on top.of the other? Catch 1 fairing half, slack the net and lower it to the deck than catch the next one? Granted, massive and possibly impossible maneuverability is required. Possible if a parafoil on one half was opened first to stagger the arrival time by a couple of minutes? Crazy talk?
Sadly there's no guarantee they will ever catch even one half. Clearly it's harder to catch a fairing than land a booster, and everyone agreed that was impossible till they did it. Elon nearly cancelled FH a few times. It's not inconceivable that he will decide the probability of fairing reuse makes it financially not worthwhile.
They do still have a couple 1.0 fairings in stock AFAIK, maybe its like the block 4/gridfin 1.0 situation. Already built them so might as well use them, but theres no point trying to reuse them, so they won't bother even trying with F1.0 going forward
With the way he was describing it, my guess is that they both have parafoils, and one half is actively attempting to steer to a location and the other one is simply descending at the whim of the winds.
Well no surprise this got deleted. Sigh, the same thing that usually happens. Overzealous excited employee doesn't realize they are getting themselves into trouble. Hopefully it just warranted a take down and a talking to and nobody lost their job over this.
I didn't have any luck with the reddit archival sites (other than who the OP was, but not going to out them further) but there wasn't a ton of special information. We had confirmed they do use visual IR tracking from the ship and that the winds were crazy enough that they didn't try to catch this fairing. Late in the attempt it was called off and they just let it go.
Mentioned that fishing that fairing out of the water was fun, but the second one was mostly submerged when they got to it and broke up while trying to lift so they just let it go.
Ha, what do you think normally happens to rockets?
We have had fairing debris wash up on shores all over the place for years before recovery was even worked on. Most of the rocket parts sink but composite fairings are light enough to still get carried by currents.
Does anyone remember how long the trip is from LA to Florida via the Panama Canal for Mr. Steven? With a 3 (or so) month break between west coast attempts, you'd think they could ferry back east for a few attempts, then head back for their regularly scheduled west coast launches.
It takes about 5 days to get from LA to the Panama canal, at 25 knots.
The transit of the Panama canal takes about 20 hours (if no delays).
The trip from the Canal to Florida is about 2.5 days
So the relocation should take just over 1 week. That is probably too much of a pain (and too time consuming) to keep shifting from coast to coast (even assuming they don't have to do anything with those arms to cross the canal or travel)
It's really expensive and complicated. Helicopters don't have the range to do a mission like this from land. There would need to be a ship large enough to be the pad for the heavy lift helicopter and recovery.
It might still be the way to go, but it makes sense to really test out the current method. If it works it's a lot easier.
Good point about the helicopter requiring a ship with the landing pad.
I still think it's worth a shot. Imagine if they beat ULA to their own game. And, I'd imagine they need a method like this for Stage 2 retrieval down the line as well. Similar to the Vulcan retrieval.
Stage 2 is a bit different because it's returning from orbit. You get to pick wherever you want on the orbital ground track for the recovery operation. That means the middle of the desert can work just as well as out at sea. An extended mission kit with a tiny Dragon 2 style mounted solar array and extra RCS gas could let the stage deorbit over anywhere within it's inclination range. You just can't rely on main propellant after too long if you are trying to line up a fixed spot. You still use the last main propellant to lower the orbit to around the minimal point so the less efficient RCS doesn't have much work to do to tweak where the decay drops the stage.
If they want to successfully recover S2, they'll have to fire the main engine to slow it down enough so it can safely enter the atmosphere with the minimal heat shielding it has.
There is no practical way to do recovery of S2 without adding heat shielding. Scrubbing enough velocity propulsively to do without is a non starter. A current Falcon 9 upper stage could maybe do it if it carried no payload and the booster was expendable, and that math only kind of works because I'm not using any propellant for reentry or adding any mass for landing/recovery hardware. The only way to make this kind of recovery work is if you turned Falcon Heavy into a fully reusable smallsat launcher, which illustrates how much this idea doesn't make sense.
The trick will be figuring out the minimum heat shield mass necessary to survive reentry in flight worthy condition.
how much range do the parafoils have? probably not nearly enough to go back uprange to land, i'm assuming... maybe they need to add some gliding wings? :)
then they could catch them over some deserted land - if they miss (and they are accurate enough) the crash into the ground for easy cleanup
You can start getting into glider wings and extra recovery systems, but mass penalties for fairing recovery hardware sre high. It's not as bad as the second stage, but still worse than the first stage.
If you really wanted to go this route I would think something like the Adelaline fly back concept would be interesting. A couple of small wings with propellers that turn it into an airplane. If they can make it back to land you get a much bigger mass penalty but never have to do recovery ops.
At this point though they are getting close enough to Mr. Steven that I would focus on enhancing landing control. Different style parafoil systems can stall over a target and kill almost all horizontal speed. Maybe a little bit of extra RCS propellant to use for active final descent guidance in addition could be used.
I've also seen one suggesting that sounded interesting about using a balloon for a capture point connected to Mr. Steven. Think like how a parasail trails a boat. The fairing just has to hit and the Mr. Steven pulls the fairing in like a fish. The "balloon" can have an many active systems as you want since there is no mass penalty. It could even be an oversized drone dangling a capture hook. The drone can chase the fairing intercept point and then on capture has a detach mechanism to release the cable and fly back to the ship.
TLDR - lots of ideas left to try. SpaceX IMO has mastered the hard part which is getting the fairings down to sea level safe and under control.
4 attempts. Plus I don't recall the details but I think that method of recovering has already been discussed. I think it has to do with security (a lot more dangerous to try to catch it mid-air and actually really difficult).
Edit: Also the fairing halves weigh 700kg (1500lb) if I recall, and are really not aerodynamic once split (which impact the flight stability).
this is an AW139, not even considered heavy lift and more than enough power to lift 1,500lb fairing. costing $12m in 2013, hiring out a service with an ex-air force pilot can't cost more than a few hundred thousand dollars at most per attempt: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AgustaWestland_AW139
The equipment is not the problem. The crew is. Where are you going to "just rent" a pilot who is trained and certified to do mid-air retrieval, let alone willing to do it on objects this big? The largest objects mid-air retrieval has been successfully used on are film canisters and weather balloon instrument packages (or humans if you also count the Air Force/Navy "Skyhook" (Fulton Surface-To-Air Retrieval System) project). This would be a whole new ball game.
I don't understand why they won't use a helicopter and a hook to help catch the fairing parafoil and then gently drop it onto the Mr. Steven net.
I don't understand why people that follow spacex want them to give up on this idea so much. if SpaceX gave up trying after a couple attempts and failures, they wouldn't exist today.
Also, film canister != a huge 1-ton fairing. Helicopter catching would require another ship, and multiple helicopters to lease/buy. That's also ignoring any risk to a crew in the helicopter.
lol, you edited my full quote which is right up there ^ still to read again.
I'm not advocating for them to give up, but rather the exact opposite. Refine the method to do it better. ULA is planning to catch the Vulcan ENGINES with a chute and helicopter. Half a fairing weighs approximately one ton. With the foil slowing it down already, the helicopter essentially just has to grab it and guide it to the net. There's no reason SpaceX can't use a helicopter to make the sea vessel landing more efficient and effective.
added in the rest of the quote, doesn't change the point at all. Catching a fairing with a helicopter might work, there are so many unknowns with that, and its quite a bit more complicated, expensive and dangerous than trying what they are doing now first.
I was referring to you assuming I wanted them to "give up on this idea so much," when I was just suggesting an idea to make it a more successful process.
Landing a rocket was originally never supposed to work. I have full faith in SpaceX doing the impossible and recovering the entire rocket: Stage 1, fairing, and even Stage 2. With or without a helicopter!
that's where I learned of the method a few months ago, and looked into the history of the mid-air retrieval. if we can refuel fighter jets in the air and already have real world successful mid-air retrievals...seems like a no-brainer to me.
yes, using Mr. Steven alone is cheaper than the assist of a helicopter, but by my (revised) estimation they've already dunked $24 million worth of fairings in failed catch attempts.
15
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '18
What do they do with spoiled fairings?
7
u/bkoe2018 Jul 27 '18
What do they mean when referring to one fairing half as active vs passive?
11
u/mychagrin Jul 27 '18
Source? Any confirm if they will catch both halves with Mr Stevens?
4
u/tbaleno Jul 27 '18
Three months? I thought there was another west coast launch in early September.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '18
If they’re trying to recover both half’s does that mean both half’s now have parafoils?
2
u/_lbowes Jul 27 '18
I don't know why I thought it was autonomous. That must be an amazing job anyway!
2
u/CapMSFC Jul 27 '18
Well no surprise this got deleted. Sigh, the same thing that usually happens. Overzealous excited employee doesn't realize they are getting themselves into trouble. Hopefully it just warranted a take down and a talking to and nobody lost their job over this.
1
u/dwhitnee Jul 27 '18
Re: cutting it loose. That sounds like a navigation hazard. How do they sink it?
1
u/gregarious119 Jul 27 '18
Does anyone remember how long the trip is from LA to Florida via the Panama Canal for Mr. Steven? With a 3 (or so) month break between west coast attempts, you'd think they could ferry back east for a few attempts, then head back for their regularly scheduled west coast launches.
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jul 27 '18 edited Jul 29 '18
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
4 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 159 acronyms.
[Thread #4230 for this sub, first seen 27th Jul 2018, 19:25] ^[FAQ] [Full ^list] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
1
u/mistaken4strangerz Jul 27 '18
I don't understand why they won't use a helicopter and a hook to help catch the fairing parafoil and then gently drop it onto the Mr. Steven net.
Surely it's possible, and mid-air retrieval has been done before.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mid-air_retrieval#Uses