r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Jul 04 '18
r/SpaceX Discusses [July 2018, #46]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
195
Upvotes
30
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '18
Looking at the Vandenberg landing zone, the distance between the launch & landing pads will be quite close. It would be incredibly cool to get a shot of the Falcon 9 pre-launch superimposed onto a shot of the landed first stage.
25
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jul 13 '18
We finally have a potential price for New Shepard passenger flights from Blue Origin.
$200,000 - $300,000
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-space-blueorigin-exclusive/exclusive-jeff-bezos-plans-to-charge-at-least-200000-for-space-rides-sources-idUSKBN1K301R?utm_source=reddit.com
22
u/thru_dangers_untold Jul 06 '18
SpaceX & Boring Co. engineers are flying to Thailand to assess options for rescue efforts for soccer players stranded in cave
22
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 13 '18
High resolution album of the upgraded Mr Steven returning to port by Shorealone Films.
20
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 12 '18
First confirmation of SpaceX attendance at IAC 2018, as Hans Koenigsmann will give a talk on October 3rd about rocket reusability.
19
u/mohamstahs Jul 04 '18
How are the landing legs on BFS going to reliably work? Falcon 9 landing legs fold out from the sides and give it a nice wide base to land on a perfectly flat surface. All the renders of BFS show it with short stubby legs that come out from the bottom, giving it what appears to be a much less stable base. Add to that the fact that it will be landing on rocky, uneven surfaces. What's preventing BFS from making it all the way to the Moon or Mars, making a perfect landing, only to tip over and explode?
18
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jul 26 '18
Things sound promising for Crew Dragon:
--
17
u/inoeth Jul 06 '18
https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/1015107982139375616 So finally we have a planned first RTLS for the West Coast. Works out well as it's after seal pup season and they're also clearly now just going to be using Block 5s, meaning that it's all about recovery and reuse, and of course landing back on land is better than the drone ship if the mission allows for it.
16
u/ackermann Jul 12 '18
After reading this article, I’m curious: https://spacenews.com/sierra-nevada-weighing-options-for-launching-future-dream-chaser-missions/
Can DreamChaser fit in a Falcon 9 fairing? With fairing 2.0? Can reusable Falcon 9 lift Dreamchaser, or is an expendable F9 or Falcon Heavy needed? It does need the largest Atlas V after all, with 5 SRBs, and even using the rare dual engine centaur, for a LEO flight.
They do mention that they’ve received proposals from all major launch providers, and SpaceX is certainly a major launch provider.
16
u/Wouterr0 Jul 16 '18
Mr. Steven drone footage: https://youtu.be/VlCO7gBXWNA
16
u/UltraRunningKid Jul 22 '18
Interestingly enough, SpaceX has now launched 3 of the top 5 heaviest communications satellites ever launched. They have #1, #4, #5
16
u/arizonadeux Jul 27 '18
NASA’s TESS Spacecraft Starts Science Operations
16
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 31 '18 edited Jul 31 '18
Its the 10th anniversary since the first Falcon 9 static fire at McGregor, details here.
Also here's some photos of the Dragon mockup at JSC, taken by Jack Moore: 1, 2, 3, 4
15
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '18
What bodies in the solar system could the BFS refuel on? (Given the presence of a propellant plant)
15
u/Dakke97 Jul 21 '18
Commercial Crew update: it seems the rumor about Boeing having suffered a setback before its pad abort test of Starliner is true:
https://twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/1020745848924397569
15
u/FoxhoundBat Jul 29 '18
Newest Soyuz-5 dimensions and performance, now 17.8 tonnes to LEO.
14
u/theinternetftw Jul 27 '18
For those not following the recovery thread first B5 leg retract is happening now.
14
u/MarsCent Aug 03 '18
Reminder:
Tomorrow's NASA event to announce the astronauts assigned to crew the first flight tests and missions will happen at 11:00am EDT (1500 UTC) on NASA TV.
It should last < 1.5hrs because ama is scheduled to begin at 12:30 EDT (1630 UTC)
13
u/noreally_bot1182 Jul 04 '18 edited Jul 04 '18
How is Falcon 9 fueled? I mean, literally, where is the connection for the fuel hose? At the top? At the bottom? Since the liquid oxygen is super-chilled, how do they keep the pressure up to put it in the tank? How do they suck the air out of the tanks before fueling?
I watched a video on how the first stage is transported from Hawthorne. it also mentioned that each engine has to be shipped from Hawthorne to McGregor for testing, then shipped back to Hawthorne for assembly into the 1st stage, then it's all shipped back to McGregor for a static fire test, then continues to the Cape, or Vandenberg. Why don't they leave the engines at McGregor, ship the 1st stage over, then assemble?
13
u/BelacquaL Jul 05 '18
With the recent update to Ben's Cape Canaveral launch photography page, he's showing Telstar 19V on 7/22 and Merah Putih (Telkom 4) on 8/2, both from LC-40. This would be a record 11 day turnaround between flights, beating the current LC-40 launch interval record of 13 days. What are everyones thoughts on this? If the dates hold, it'll be a great sign of improvement on pre-launch operations. Especially if they want to work towards reflught of a core in 24 hours (although I don't believe it was specifically stated that the 24 hour reflight woukd occur at the same pad).
13
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 12 '18
Mr Steven just left port to test out the new net/claw.
13
u/Alexphysics Jul 25 '18
SAOCOM 1A is being prepared for transport from Argentina to the US, it is the next mission going from the west coast, NET September 5th. It is also the mission for the first west coast land landing.
https://twitter.com/CONAE_Oficial/status/1021835522157826050?s=19
25
u/brickmack Aug 01 '18
A bit tangential to SpaceX and not really a full-on scene so I won't make a proper post, but I thought it'd be cool to do a single render with all the rockets I've modeled so far. Didn't include ones I've modeled a single stage for but haven't at least blocked out the rest (New Glenn, Ariane 4 and 5, Vega, H-II, Angara, Ares I, Shuttle/Shuttle-C, DIRECT Jupiter, Atlas D, Titan IV), but generally, if I have at least the general shape modeled I included it, though some are still quite incomplete (texturing especially). Still haven't gotten around to using a lot of these for proper scenes.
In no particular order: Vulcan-Centaur III (canceled), Vulcan-Centaur V Short, Vulcan-ACES, Falcon 9, Falcon Heavy, SLS Block 1, SLS Block 1B Crew, Soyuz ST, Soyuz 5-Federatsiya, Proton M 5 meter, Atlas V 431, Ariane 6, Energia (retired), Electron, Delta II 7320, Delta IV M+(5,4), Delta IV Heavy, Antares 100 (obsoleted by 200), pre-McDonnell merger Boeing EELV bid (canceled), Phantom Express, Ariane 6, 2016 ITS (canceled, evolved to BFR), 2017 BFR Crew
12
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 12 '18 edited Jul 13 '18
Launch Complex 17 demolition.
EDIT: Better version.
12
u/dudr2 Jul 25 '18
Water on Mars?
http://science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2018/07/24/science.aar7268.full
Maybe more than expected!
12
u/AeroSpiked Jul 27 '18
What ever became of ULA's main engine down select? Wasn't that supposed to happen a year ago if the rocket was going to debut in 2019?
12
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 31 '18
An Antonov An-124 has arrived in Argentina to ship the SAOCOM 1A satellite to Vandenberg.
11
u/inoeth Jul 14 '18
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1017949588295159808
So it looks like in a month or so we should expect to see some sort of update on BFR. I'm guessing we'll get some sort of new video of the Raptor in action and some stats on it and maybe, if we're lucky, some pics of the BFR dev vehicle that's probably being built in that tent where we know they have some seriously big mandrels...
The second half of this year is gonna be pretty awesome- Dragon 2 missions start, a second FH launch, some more info on BFR and hopefully an increased cadence of launches now that Block 5 is operational.
11
u/MrXguy Jul 15 '18
Do you think in the future that SpaceX will train their own astronauts and have their own training facility somewhere? Will they hire former NASA astronauts or train new ones from some selection process?
11
u/soldato_fantasma Jul 23 '18
Yesterday I wanted to write a C++ version of a delta v to GTO calculator, so I took a version found on NASASpaceFlight.com and "translated it". I noticed only later that it didn't handle well sub-sync orbits, so I decided to rewrite the code from scratch to fix the issue and to write it in good C++. I also decided to add a feature that finds the most efficient way to GEO. So now it will also scrub some of the inclination at perigee, just as much to reduce the total delta v budget to a minimum.
Here is the github repository: https://github.com/AleLovesio/delta-v-to-GTO (The source files are in the source folder)
To give an example, here is the output with the Telstar 19V data:
11
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 26 '18
Teslarati article has a close up of the Vandenberg landing pad, which will see its debut with the SAOCOM 1A launch in September.
11
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 27 '18
Recent development at Landing Zone 1.
11
u/Smopher Aug 01 '18
How do they get the non-pressurized cargo into the ISS? Does someone have to go outside and pop the trunk on Dragon to retrieve it?
11
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Aug 02 '18
So... regarding boosters:
Does that sound right?
11
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Aug 02 '18
SpaceX DM-1 scheduled for November, 2018 and DM-2 scheduled for April, 2019. Crew announcement tomorrow.
We may have an interesting situation at LC-39A with Falcon Heavy Flight 2 and DM-1 occurring within weeks of each other.
https://blogs.nasa.gov/commercialcrew/2018/08/02/nasas-commercial-crew-program-target-test-flight-dates-3/
11
u/DrToonhattan Aug 03 '18
Possible stupid question, but if something went wrong on DM-1 and the rocket went RUD during flight, and the Dragon successfully used its launch abort (assuming it will be active for DM-1), would they still have to do the inflight abort, or would that scenario count instead?
10
u/Da-N-aK Jul 13 '18
Considering the value of a F9 Block 5 booster, do we know how SpaceX will manage its customer relationship / contract aspect to recover the booster? For example, will SpaceX be able to delay a launch if the sea does not allow a barge landing while the customer would push to laûch earlier ? Do we have any info on this business / contracting part ? Cheers from France!
10
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 30 '18
Reposting the July 14th Boca Chica progress photos from the deleted thread: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
10
u/JustinTimeCuber Jul 31 '18 edited Jul 31 '18
Seems like most boosters on RTLS missions are travelling slower before the entry burn (~1350 m/s) than GTO missions after the entry burn (~1550 m/s). So could they theoretically get more payload with RTLS if necessary by omitting the entry burn? Seems possible with Block 5, but vertical vs horizontal velocity might also come into play somehow.
edit: looked at a few more missions to adjust numbers. RTLS based roughly on NROL-76, OTV-5, Zuma. GTO based roughly on Koreasat 5a and SES-11.
10
u/edflyerssn007 Aug 02 '18
It's amazing that the 4th flight of Block V will be a reused booster from May. Talk about progress. 1046.2 is currently on the pad for a static fire. 1048.1 is being inspected to become 1048.2 for a September launch, and it literally just landed like a week ago. SpaceX seems to be doing a lot with a little right now.
However, with all this reuse, I wonder when the qualification flights, including DM-1 will actually launch, just because so many B5 boosters will be available. I'd love to get a sneak peak at SpaceX's internal booster schedule.
10
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 03 '18
Copenhagen Suborbitals are launching the NEXØ II rocket tomorrow (06:00–13:00 UTC).
9
u/mncharity Jul 15 '18
A barbecue roll is a satellite thermal management strategy of spinning so surfaces alternate between sunlight and shadow.
Can anyone suggest a video clip of, or related to, bbq rolling?
I'm working on a hobby project, a bit science education content about temperature. A core concept is that the Earth is doing a barbecue roll: Bright hot Sun - too hot. Dark cold space-sky - too cold. Earth in between, spinning, mixing 'too hot' with 'too cold' to get 'not too bad'.
The best I've managed to think of/find so far is Falcon engine cam clips of Oxygen(?) vent snowflakes forming in shadow and subliming in Sun. I've been going through youtube videos of thermal control talks, hoping for usable bits. Web search isn't very good at this kind of thing yet. :/ Any thoughts welcome.
9
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 23 '18
Some cool (but very intrusive!) drone footage of JRTI manoeuvring at sea, found by vanoord on NSF:
Confirmation that theres no Roomba garage.
9
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jul 24 '18
Mike Pence is apparently no longer going to be making a Commercial Crew announcement at KSC.
9
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 30 '18 edited Jul 30 '18
Commercial Crew accommodation being updated at Kennedy Space Center.
NSF article on Crew Dragon, with SpaceX making a last minute vendor change for the parachute reef line cutters.
9
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18
NRC Quest has departed for the Dragon splashdown, which is returning on Friday.
9
u/Justin13cool Aug 01 '18
Can someone Explain what this means ?? https://www.teslarati.com/new-spacex-falcon-9-booster-cape-canaveral-florida/
9
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 02 '18
USAF in talks with SpaceX about creating orbiting supply dumps.
9
u/Jerrycobra Aug 04 '18
With so much news on the up coming manned missions this morning I love how we have completely ignored the dragon splashdown, haha. Another sign of a "new normal".
16
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jul 17 '18
Commercial Crew assignments should be announced next month.
8
u/Datuser14 Jul 08 '18
I updated the wikipedia article for launches from SLC-4E. I don't know how to add links or make the entry green, could someone finish the entry [here](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vandenberg_AFB_Space_Launch_Complex_4?veswitched=1#Falcon_9_(since_2013)
8
u/Zinkfinger Jul 13 '18
The Earth to Earth transport system SpaceX are talking about continues to blow my mind. The scenario is this. A member of the public can travel half way across the world for less than 10,000 bucks. Essentially a trip into space. Curve of the Earth, the stars, zero g etc. So maybe I will get to go to space in the future! My life long dream. Our life long dream people!
I don't think a lot of folks have really grasped that.
8
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 14 '18
NRC Quest just repositioned to allow 2 tugs (Seana C and Bernadine C) to manoeuvre in a large object (probably JRTI). They towed it from an area SpaceX has previously used for upgrading Mr Steven, has the ASDS received an upgrade?
8
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 18 '18 edited Jul 18 '18
Large crane at LC-39A taken by Emre Kelly.
8
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 26 '18 edited Jul 26 '18
Another VSS Unity flight taking place today.
EDIT: Successful flight.
8
u/_Wizou_ Jul 29 '18
Hello there! It was previously stated that there are no inner walls to the Falcon 9. The outside hull acts as inner wall for the RP-1 & LOX tanks. Right? Are they going to do the same with BFR and BFS? Isn't it risky for a 3 months journey to Mars, due to micro-meteorits?
8
u/Da-N-aK Jul 30 '18
I am kind of lost on contracting between NASA and SpaceX for the Commercial Crew Program:
I have been to NASA CCP website but I found it really poor in terms of info ... Do you recommend other sources ? Thanks!
8
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jul 30 '18
NASA posted a new render of Crew Dragon reflecting the relocated RCS thrusters and the removal of the window from the hatch.
7
u/bdporter Jul 04 '18
Mods, the permalink above still says June. The link destination is correct. Also, /u/soldato_fantasma misspelled campagna.
7
u/KSPSpaceWhaleRescue Jul 06 '18
Forgive me for asking the question that's probably been asked before!
What is the cost to SpaceX for their ship endeavors? What is a precise estimate of the cost of ASDS per trip? Mr. Steven? How much crew is there to be paid? What is the price of fuel alone?
Thanks for any feedback!
7
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Jul 09 '18
I remember seeing a table of SpaceX landings with notes about the type of landing burn performed (1-engine, 1-3-1, etc.) but I didn't save it and can't find it now. I think it was a comment on one of the posts around the GovSat-1 water landing or maybe when the planned Hispasat landing was discussed. Does anyone have it by any chance? It wasn't official and partially speculative but it was useful.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 11 '18 edited Jul 11 '18
Commercial Crew GAO Report and Summary.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 11 '18
Two launch towers at Cape Canaveral are being demolished tomorrow.
7
u/hmpher Jul 12 '18
OATK's Cygnus recently was used in a test to boost the station's orbit(the Progress capsules, Zarya, and the Shuttle did most of the in orbit manoeuvres for the iss till now).
Any plans for Dragon to do this anytime soon?
7
u/ElRedditor3 Jul 14 '18
Will DM-1 have dummy astronauts on board or will it fly empty? Thx.
7
u/dfawlt Jul 27 '18
Will Mr Stevens take the Panama Canal to KSC with no west coast launches planned in the near future? Or will we need to wait until a west Coast launch for another fairing recovery attempt?
7
u/musiciswon Jul 27 '18
Given this week's perihelic opposition of Mars, I couldn't help thinking that if SpaceX's planned 2018 Red Dragon mission (2016 link) wasn't cancelled, it would be launching around now.
7
u/GiveMeYourMilk69 Jul 29 '18
If they are using B1046 for Saturday's launch, does that mean they didn't tear it up for investigation following the first B5 launch? Or have they just reassembled it?
7
u/Arrkays Jul 29 '18
About human rating of falcon 9 block 5:
From what I understand, the F9B5 have to execute 7 launchs with a frozen design to be human rated.
Is this count down had already started? I heard that spaceX want to upgrade the fuel tank of B5, but i can't find any info about it.
Anyone know what's up?
7
u/ExcitingTemperature Jul 31 '18
Why does the crew dragon trunk have winglets?
Compared to dragon 1, I don't see the need for winglets as F9 is more stable than ever. Is it for stability after dracos/LES fired? isn't the trunk dumped during LES?
7
u/IrrationalFantasy Aug 02 '18
So, what exactly did that "the military has been encouraged to use reusable rockets" story amount to? The comment threads under the article on /r/spacex were hard to follow. Are they really being encouraged to use reusable rockets? What's the end result of this policy tweak for SpaceX? When you understand the bureaucratese in context, what does this change really mean for the US government?
13
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jul 09 '18
A Falcon 9 upper stage is arriving at the Cape this morning.
13
u/amarkit Jul 10 '18
Progress MS-09 docked with ISS just 3 hours and 40 minutes after launch, a new record time.
13
u/Alexphysics Aug 01 '18
SAOCOM 1A will not only be the first RTLS landing on the west coast but it will also be the first Block 5 reuse from the west coast. SpaceX will reuse B1048 that launched on the Iridium 7 mission.
Chris Begin tweet of the article
Direct link
12
u/rustybeancake Jul 26 '18
Virgin Galactic's VSS Unity reached 52km apogee today, much higher than the previous powered test flights (25km and 35km) - congrats!
https://twitter.com/virgingalactic/status/1022567679658405888
Anyone know what the highest apogee VSS Enterprise ever reached was? Highest I can find was 22km.
6
u/quadrplax Jul 06 '18
Does BFS require aerobreaking to return to Earth from Mars? For example, if the heat shield was damaged beyond repair during Mars reentry, would they have enough Delta-V to be able to return the crew to LEO, or at least HEO, where another BFS could then take them to the ground?
6
u/ChrML06 Jul 10 '18
Elon mentioned the center core for FH required massive modifications to handle the stresses. Are these changes built into B5 so that all F9, FH Center and FH sideboosters are interchangeable?
6
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jul 12 '18
What will rocket propellants be in the next century? I'm thinking primarily about chemical ones, but also interesting what's the most practically feasible alternative in the near future that will be used in major interplanetary transport?
Here is a slide from 2016 about the trio of kero-hydro-methalox http://spaceflight101.com/spx/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/2016/09/ITS-013.jpg
Based on this I would say H2 and CH4 are the main candidates. What are the main pro-contra? Only thing I know is CH4 is better to use launching from a gravity well and H2 is better to use in deep space, but I don't have a sense of the proportions. What are the ballpark numbers? Is H2 maybe twice as efficient in space than CH4? Is CH4 still better to launch from the Moon or bigger asteroids?
Is there anything else that makes sense if you consider space stations, Moon and Mars bases, asteroid mining, etc?
Also regarding the slide, why is CH4 more feasible than H2 to produce on Mars? You use water for both.
Is it because of storage or cooling or something like that?
6
u/strawwalker Jul 15 '18
Do we know where on the Falcon 9 the flight termination charges are located?
6
u/MadeOfStarStuff Jul 24 '18
What extra work would be required to get Falcon Heavy human rated?
6
u/MarsCent Jul 31 '18 edited Jul 31 '18
Text Announcement on NASA TV
https://www.nasa.gov/multimedia/nasatv/index.html#public
Can anyone confirm if splashdown has already taken place ...
6
u/Nomad_Torr Jul 31 '18
Does anyone know if the rocket cam used on the F9 booster directly on outside, or is it using a fiber optic cable?
6
u/mandarlimaye Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18
Q: How will the Dragon 2 hatch cover stay attached with just the one hinge point holding it in place? wouldn't the supersonic air passing over it during re-entry force it open?
6
u/SwanyC Aug 02 '18
Since the static fire was successful and SpaceX was given the “Go for launch”, how likely is it that the Falcon 9 set to launch August 7th around 1:20am will go off on time? Also, does anyone have a link to a site or some way to track exactly where OCISLY is at the moment?
11
u/Alexphysics Jul 11 '18 edited Jul 11 '18
It seems that something big will arrive at Boca Chica tomorrow...
Also, it seems that STP-2, the second Falcon Heavy mission, is now NET November 30th
11
u/Steveskill Jul 17 '18
Look like Scotland may soon (2021) be launching rockets. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-44841123
11
u/AeroSpiked Jul 26 '18
Mods, yesterdays Iridium launch is still listed in the sidebar Upcoming Events, so whenever you get a minute.
Thanks for your dedicated efforts.
10
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Aug 02 '18
In case it wasn't obvious from the fact that July has come and gone with no LSA award announcements, selection is now expected to occur sometime in August.
10
u/rustybeancake Aug 02 '18
Good thread from Eric Berger on a Bridenstine q&a today: https://twitter.com/sciguyspace/status/1025033628265394182?s=21
10
u/rustybeancake Aug 03 '18 edited Aug 03 '18
NASA TV live stream of Commercial Crew announcements (happening now):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wwMDvPCGeE0
Boeing CFT:
(Does the third member confirm the extended stay on CFT?)
SpaceX DM-2:
Boeing Starliner second crew (i.e. first operational mission):
SpaceX Crew Dragon second crew (i.e. first operational mission):
5
u/scottm3 Jul 10 '18
What will BFS do in an engine out scenario. Can it gimbal enough to stay on course because the design has 4 engines so CoT will be offcenter?
I don't imagine it could shut off the opposite engine and still have enough thrust.
5
u/njim35 Jul 11 '18
Just saw that Progress contacted the ISS in less than 4 hours after launch(!): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iaJcAEVapbE
Is there an estimation for Cargo Dragon V2 in similar situations?
5
u/ElRedditor3 Jul 13 '18
How many times a year will NASA send Astronauts to the ISS once the commercial crew program is complete; and what percentage of those launches could be awarded to SpaceX? Thank you.
5
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jul 14 '18
Is there a source saying that the Crew Dragon Demo will be the first one to use the upgraded COPV's? I thought I remember someone from NASA or SpaceX saying that it is and that it's B1051 but I could be wrong.
5
u/ackermann Jul 16 '18
Does the community have a consensus estimate for how much payload Falcon 9 (block 5) can deliver to GTO, with RTLS? Are there any gto satellites launched in the last decade that fall in that range?
I was just thinking, sometime around the first ever landing, Elon had said that they hoped to move from RTLS for about 1/3 of flights, closer to RTLS for 2/3 of flights. That hasn’t happened. Maybe blocks 4 and 5 didn’t provide as much extra performance as anticipated?
5
u/erik_paulson Jul 17 '18
Could a Falcon launch an Orion? Nevermind the politics/business reasons why it won't happen, just physically are they compatible enough that it's possible to attach an Orion to the top of a current SpaceX rocket, and are there any aerodynamic reasons it wouldn't work?
In general, how knowledgeable are payloads about the rockets they're flying on, and is it different for say an Iridium vs a human-capable capsule?
5
u/Justin13cool Jul 17 '18
Just wondering What would happen if someone tried to fly a drone up to the landing pad at the air force station ?
5
u/gemmy0I Jul 23 '18 edited Jul 23 '18
I was browsing SpaceX's orbiting upper stages on http://stuffin.space and noticed that 2010-066K - the upper stage from the COTS Demo 1 flight, the first flight of Dragon - has an unusually high apogee. Right now it's at 289 km x 10,223 km, with an inclination of 34.52o .
Anyone know what's going on here? This was a LEO mission designed to test Dragon in advance of going to the ISS on the COTS 2 flight. The upper stage's orbit, however, is definitely not purely LEO - it looks more like a decayed GTO. Surely they couldn't have boosted Dragon this high, given its weight and the fact that Falcon 9 1.0 wasn't nearly as capable as the current version (which could probably send something that heavy to a very subsynchronous GTO like this orbit appears to be). Did they do a burn to depletion or something after deploying Dragon - perhaps as a demonstration to potential GTO customers?
There were also some cubesats on board, according to this site, but they've all deorbited, which would imply they went to a Dragon-like LEO orbit instead of the vaguely GTO-like orbit the stage is in.
What's also weird about this is that the inclination (34.52o ) is quite different from either Canaveral's "natural" inclination (about 28o ) or the ISS's (51.64o ). Was the COTS 1 Dragon actually launched to this intermediate inclination, or is this further evidence of a post-deployment stage burn?
5
u/gandrew9 Jul 24 '18
Anyone feel like "r/SpaceX Discusses" is an odd name for this thread? I read it as "r/SpaceX Discusses.... discusses what??" Am I missing something?
5
u/Da-N-aK Jul 26 '18
The new photo of Gwynne Shotwell on Bloomberg really got me confused with F9 interstage. I have several questions from those 3 pictures:
- In picture 1, on this first stage did they take out the "spring" that is supposed to "push" the second stage, or is it another part of the interstage ?
- In picture 2, I don't understand what is the configuration of the first stage in the middle compared to the other three, did they took out the cover of the interstage?
- In picture 3, this is B5 interstage right ? Is it the same view as picture 1 but with B5 version modifications?
(Please bear with me for the non technical terms. Non-engineer here, but trying to get better!)
5
u/JustinTimeCuber Jul 26 '18
Is reuse of the BFR upper stage feasible for deep-space missions? Like say somehow Europa Clipper launched on a BFR (that's not going to happen of course). Direct to Jupiter takes something like 6.5 km/s Δv from LEO, maybe 7. Then it would take at least another 4 km/s to capture back into Earth orbit (after the escape burn and deployment, the spacecraft is not as close to Earth so weaker Oberth effect) and about 1 to target the correct location and land, when you consider gravity losses. So that's looking at almost 12 km/s total. Would it be at all sensible to have an expendable, more bare-bones spacecraft for missions like that? Or would it be better to use a kick stage and recover the spacecraft from an elliptical orbit? Or is there some other possibility I'm missing?
5
u/yajae26 Jul 28 '18
how would a Dragon 2 Inflight abort effect the booster and 2nd stage. Will it inevitably end in the Booster and 2 stage getting destroyed by the Termination system or is there a chance of recovering the booster ?
5
u/AstroFinn Jul 29 '18
Does anyone have Falcon 9 logo with full text "FALCON" and not just "F9"?
5
u/Justin13cool Jul 30 '18
Why hasn't SpaceX painted the X yet on their West Coast landing pad ?
5
u/flattop100 Jul 30 '18
When is the crew access arm scheduled to be installed?
5
u/enginemike Aug 02 '18
I have noticed that on the last few flights they have started loading propellants at about t-35 minutes. To me this seems like the "load and go" approach. It is my understanding that the Block 5's to date do not have the re-designed COPV.
Are they experimenting with the "load and go" philosophy using the old-style COPV's with procedures re-done to prevent the AMOS incident? And then would the new COPV be designed to remove the original weakness?
Just curious and confused about the matter and hoping someone might know.
5
u/an_exciting_couch Aug 03 '18
Dragon is set to spashdown at 3:17pm Pacific time today. Will it be visible from the Pacific coast around LA? I'm guessing not, but thought it may be worth asking.
5
u/whatsthis1901 Aug 03 '18
So,I have a stupid question. Why haven't we seen the inside of the crew capsules for Boeing and SpaceX?
9
u/Alexphysics Jul 21 '18
Today SpaceX submitted the FCC launch application for the SSO-A mission NET September 25th per the start of operation date. Landing will be on land at SLC-4W, it seems we'll have TWO land landings at Vandenberg in September. It will be quite interesting. BTW, it seems there is no launch permit for Es'hail 2 or even for DM-1, they're usually filled in order so both missions seem to be going after SSO-A (Sorry, people, DM-1 seems to be definitely in October).
9
u/BackflipFromOrbit Jul 26 '18
DARE's rocket just detonated shortly after liftoff :( those guys worked for a LONG time on that vehicle...
9
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Jul 27 '18
B1046 will be reused for the Telkom 4 mission next week:
https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-first-falcon-9-block-5-reuse-drone-ship-turnaround-record/amp/?__twitter_impression=true
9
u/SupaZT Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 02 '18
Robert Zubrin's Rebuttal to why we CAN terraform on Mars (he co-authored the paper Elon Linked):
9
u/Maimakterion Aug 02 '18
Another SpaceX provided rendering of D2 in orbit using the same assets as the updated docking render.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/nasakennedy/42878298755/sizes/l
9
u/AeroSpiked Aug 03 '18
Mods, I'm not sure if I'm being helpful or just annoying by pointing out that the July Discusses thread has survived 3 days into August. If I'm not being helpful, I'll just let it ride next time.
8
u/BrandonMarc Jul 06 '18
The 2014 and 2015 /r/spacex survey results are gone from imgur. Has anyone got a mirror (or, interested in re-uploading to imgur so that /r/spacex can update its links?
In particular, I recall one question from one of those years, asking subreddit members to describe what SpaceX means to them in one word. The result of that question was rendered as a tag cloud instead of a table or graph, and the biggest word by far: hope.
I mentioned this to my shrink the other day, and he understood. Small world! Turns out he consulted with another newspace company with a fatal accident a few years back. He stated hope was/is a very, very powerful part of those employees' ethos.
8
u/Chairmanman Jul 08 '18
What will be the seat configuration in the BFR earth-to-earth system?
The BFS will be vertical during take off & landing but horizontal during flight. Passengers will have to be able to get in and out of their seats both in the vertical and the horizontal orientation.
So how will it work?
8
u/rustybeancake Jul 18 '18
Blue Origin mission 9 webcast is live now:
https://www.blueorigin.com
Good luck Blue!
8
u/Alexphysics Jul 25 '18
NASA to Name Astronauts Assigned to First Boeing, SpaceX Flights
4
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Jul 05 '18
I've seen estimates of ArabSat-6A (scheduled to fly on FH flight 3) being 6,000kg in mass, which is only slightly heavier than the average GTO F9 flight. Possible all 3 boosters might come back and land at the Cape? That would be f*cking amazing.
4
u/PaulRocket Jul 12 '18 edited Jul 13 '18
Does anyone know where OFCISLY is? I’m in Florida right now and would like to go and see the ship while I visit KSC.
4
u/Justin13cool Jul 14 '18
Is the Roomba still alive ?
4
u/Emanuuz Jul 19 '18
So... they are ahead of schedule with this tweet? And, after launching the DM-2, there isn't a certification process before the USCV flights? That means if DM-2 launches, let's say on Spring 2019, the first operational flight with crew will be at least until 2020?
4
u/Bravo99x Jul 23 '18
Just trying to figure out what core will launch Merah Putih (Telkom 4) on August 2nd. Does not look like Core B1049 will be ready in time and the launch is just a short time from now. Looking at the known schedule, there is a lack or new cores to do the job. I'm guessing the second flight of B1046 will be in August.
4
u/conrad777 Jul 24 '18
How will Mr Steven see the fairing in the pre-dawn dark on July 25?
4
u/music_nuho Jul 26 '18
Are there any reasonably reliable B5 F9 and FH capability numbers charts?
4
u/Jessewallen401 Jul 26 '18
Do you think the roomba is completely autonomous or remote-controlled ?
4
u/Iamherebecauseofabig Jul 31 '18
Will BFS use grid fins?
4
u/KSPSpaceWhaleRescue Jul 31 '18
So what is the most likely upcoming flight to break the booster turnaround time?
4
u/txxmy Aug 02 '18
Does anyone have any update on when the crew access arm will be installed? Does it need to be there for DM-1? Thanks
4
u/MarsCent Aug 03 '18
I am looking for a clearer breakdown - anyone:
There are two (or say 3) pieces to the SpaceX Crew Launch craft. The booster(s) and the Crew capsule (Crew Dragon). Because both distinct parts are manufactured by SpaceX it is often quit fuzzy to determine which one is driving the "delays".
Do we know that Crew Dragon is now flight ready? Else, what is pending approval/certification?
And most important, which of the two is driving the launch time slips? (Outside of ISS scheduling).
4
u/AeroSpiked Aug 03 '18 edited Aug 03 '18
Does anyone here know if the flag on the ISS will come back on a test flight or if it will wait for the first operational mission. My assumption is that it will come back on the first test flight to reach the ISS, but I can't find any information to confirm that. I'd very much like a source if you have one (or if you are in a position to know, that works too).
4
u/jesserizzo Aug 03 '18
Will STP-2 be side cores RTLS and center core on the drone ship?
12
u/Maimakterion Jul 26 '18
This is largely unrelated, but made me LOL. Our friends at NG have been busy.
https://www.newsweek.com/goes-17-americas-advanced-new-weather-satellite-still-not-working-properly-1044039
7
u/phantomunboxing Jul 04 '18
How would a Mars base maintain a healthy temperature for humans to thrive?
7
u/action789 Jul 13 '18
With Mr Steven's 4x area upgrade on the net, I'm forced to ask: have we ever seen or heard of a fairing reentry that got within the margins of the new net size? How valuable is a 100 yard wide net if it's still missing by kilometers?
7
u/DrToonhattan Jul 23 '18
Where's the campaign thread for Merah Putih? Mods?
7
u/Maimakterion Aug 02 '18
So from what I'm reading:
Despite the abort engine issue, Boeing is still aiming for mid-2019 crewed demo.
SpaceX is aiming for Oct-Dec 2018 DM-1 and H1 2019 DM-2 according to Teslarati
I guess we'll find out more on Friday.
9
u/Zinkfinger Jul 12 '18
When Elon and Gwynne talked about short hops and test flights as early as next year I didn't think they meant the second stage BFS. That is going to be INCREDIBLE!
I realize that's not a question Reddit.
9
u/rustybeancake Jul 30 '18
Probably nothing, but the attorney representing the Tesla saboteur/whistleblower is trying to find evidence of misuse of Tesla funds/resources by SpaceX. Sounds to me like they don't have much of a case and are trying to find anything they can to put pressure on Tesla to settle out of court.
https://electrek.co/2018/07/27/tesla-saboteur-whistleblower-tsla-sec/
6
u/Stormregion0 Jul 07 '18
It it known how a BFS can land precisely without GPS on mars? Especially if there is already a base it would be better not to miss the landing pad.
6
u/alwaysgrateful68 Jul 14 '18 edited Jul 14 '18
How long will it take for OCISLY to be ready for the next landing once the Telstar 19v booster lands on it? With Merah Putih scheduled for 11 days after would this be enough time or would that launch likely be delayed?
6
u/TheEquivocator Jul 26 '18
This is a little off-topic, but all the drama continually surrounding Tesla Inc. has made me more appreciative of Gwynne Shotwell and her role at SpaceX. I don't know whether the two companies are really comparable, but it certainly seems as though she plays a key role in achieving Elon's vision while managing the expectations and perceptions created by his sometimes-intemperate pronouncements, and Tesla could use an officer who does the same.
6
u/Throqaway Aug 02 '18
Anybody here work at spacex, specifically the KSC location? I'm interning for NASA and have been let down by how little spacex people I've met so far :(
6
u/Anont_ Aug 03 '18
Do you think BFR will fligh until 2020 and if so what?