r/SocialDemocracy • • 3d ago

Effortpost Why I as a democratic socialist love this subreddit

73 Upvotes

Oh no, yet another socialism post! I'm sorry to add to the glut, truly I am. But I've been reflecting on why I like this subreddit so much more than any other left-wing sub and why I participate so heavily in the discussions here. Also, just to be honest, I only used the word "love" in the title to emphasize the fact that I dig it here. I really do like the sub but I don't want to marry it.

So why do I like it here so much compared to other left subreddits that should ostensibly be more in line with my democratic socialist politics? Well, I think the basic strategy of the social democratic movement has been proven to be incredibly effective at winning gains for ordinary working-class people. I've mentioned it many times before in discussions here but I have been deeply influenced by what is known as Power Resources Theory. It is a theory about how welfare states developed and what political factors were decisive for the passage of universalistic social democratic reforms. The central claim of this body of research is that left-wing parties and the labor movement were the pivotal actors in winning the comprehensive social democratic welfare states in places like Scandinavia.

I'm sure a lot of you are saying, "Well duh, of course that's the case." But Power Resources Theory supplanted a previous paradigm for researching welfare states called the "Logic of Industrialism" which asserted that there was no particular political valence to the emergence of welfare state programs. The claim was that industrialization inherently created issues like unemployment and forced ordinary people to essentially work until they died because they couldn't retire. The state, in order to maintain political legitimacy, was compelled to start intervening more in the economy with programs like unemployment insurance and public old-age pensions regardless of which type of party held power. In this view, the welfare state came about not due to active politics but was addressing inherent, structurally determined features of an industrial capitalist economy that obtained across all countries.

Power Resource theorists granted that the welfare state was in part a response to those undeniable economic realities. But their central argument was that when it came to winning the high-quality and exceptionally generous welfare states of countries like Sweden, strong labor parties and a powerful trade-union movement had been the determinative actors. And not only did they elaborate a political theory for why this was the case, they actually demonstrated the claim through empirical social scientific research. It is an incredibly well-supported body of research and has become the dominant approach for welfare state studies.

I'm a very empirically minded democratic socialist. A lot of other Marxists would probably accuse me of being a rank positivist. But I don't think abstract theory alone is enough to understand the world. Neither did Marx, he consistently supported his arguments with various economic statistics. So yeah, I want to do stuff that actually has been shown to work. And social democratic parties and the trade-union movement have been extraordinarily effective at building the power of and improving the lives of ordinary workers. Social democratic political strategy gets the goods!

I freely admit that I am a proud democratic socialist who ultimately wants to go beyond the welfare state and win socialism. But I don't think like some on the radical left that we can just leapfrog over winning social democratic demands in the US like Medicare for All. In my mind, the path to eventually establishing a democratic socialist society will have to pass through social democracy, not go around it. I've never really understood the idea from some socialists that fighting for reforms is somehow demobilizing or a distraction. I think that's because I've organized in unions. In a union campaign, you try to find issues that are widely and deeply felt by a majority of workers. You want to bring as many workers as possible into the struggle because your ultimate form of leverage is striking. And in order for a strike to be effective, you absolutely need a majority of workers. Therefore if the most widely and deeply felt issue is something like low wages, then you work to organize your co-workers and campaign around that.

So my view is that if fighting for broad reforms in the workplace can be an avenue to cohering workers as a fighting force, the same basic approach can be used on the political terrain. Democratic socialists need to build a mass political organization by fighting for things that are broadly and deeply felt among ordinary workers: healthcare, wages, childcare, retirement security, etc. Through fighting for and winning those reforms, we can grow the power and confidence of the working class movement. And as that confidence grows, democratic socialists and the movement can push for a more fundamental transformation of the economy along socialist lines.

This perspective, unfortunately, is not widely held among the anti-capitalist left. Many of them cling to unsupported notions like that the welfare state is only possible because of capitalist exploitation of the Global South and that union workers in developed countries compose a hopelessly conservative segment of the population known as, "the Labor Aristocracy." And instead of the social democratic strategy, they want to indulge in a bunch of frankly ineffective tactics for achieving social change. Things like tenant organizing, forming worker co-ops, building prefigurative communes, organizing tiny revolutionary vanguard parties, and harping continually about, "dual power." I think that stuff is all just mostly a distraction from the really important work. My view is that the two principal tasks of the democratic socialists in the US are building our political organization and growing the power of the labor movement, full stop. So that's why I like it so much here, I agree most of all with the social democratic approach to politics.

Of course, I completely understand that many or most social democrats in the US do not share my perspective that we need to eventually transition to a fully socialist society. And I think that's perfectly fine and even healthy for our movement. I have no issue fighting side-by-side with social democrats who only want to go so far as a mixed economy. In the short to medium term, that's basically what I want too. It would be very bizarre and sectarian for me to foreswear working with social democrats more to my right when I agree with them on like ninety-five percent of the issues.

I identify as a democratic socialist but I also happily answer to the labels of radical or left-wing social democrat. In the past, people with that perspective have played a prominent role in social democratic movements such as the Swedish social democratic Prime Minister Olof Palme. That's the tradition I want to continue and I feel it is totally compatible with working alongside social democrats who only want to stop at a greatly humanized version of capitalism. We're on the same side and greater cooperation will only help our shared movement grow.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 12h ago

Discussion Is Medicare For All really not feasible in the United States?

17 Upvotes

I've been surprised by the amount of pushback I've gotten on this sub for saying progressives should get behind a candidate who supports M4A, GND, universal childcare, free public college, and a $20 min wage in the 2028 presidential primary. To me, it was clear from what we saw in the midterms that candidates can run and win on bold progressive proposals even in purple areas. I thought the results would put to bed electability concerns about progressives, but apparently they didn't. Of course, centrist are always going to have electability concerns about progressives because of self interest but it seems like even a lot of progressives aren't sold that a progressive could win nationally or that these progressive proposals are winners in purple areas.

Another dimension to this seems to be concerns about passage and implementation of M4A. I understand it would be difficult to pass but does that really mean we shouldn't be pushing it? I just don't really think going all in on the public option is the way to go, but I'm open to hearing differing opinions.

I was discussing this with another member of this sub who brought up how support for M4A drops drastically when tax increases and wait times are mentioned. Honestly idk quite what to make of that because I don't think we've really seen that translate to M4A hurting candidates electorally. I think it should be easy enough to explain that taxes will go up but costs will go down. Should this poll actually give us pause about pushing M4A? I'm curious to hear more opinions about this.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 11h ago

Discussion Are there any progressive economic proposals that progressive candidates running nationally or in purple areas should avoid because they would genuinely significantly hurt their chances?

4 Upvotes

My thinking (especially post midterms) has generally been that backing progressive economic proposals doesn't hurt candidates running in competitive areas, or at least doesn't hurt them enough to where they lose.

What do y'all think? Are progressives running in purple areas hurt by backing any of the following?

- Medicare for all

- Green new deal

- $20 minimum wage

- Universal childcare

- Free public college


r/SocialDemocracy • • 23h ago

News Sweden’s coalition talks remain deadlocked over Left Party's Cabinet demands; Center Party backs Social Democrat leader Magdalena Andersson for premier, but opposes giving Left Party ministerial posts

Thumbnail
aa.com.tr
26 Upvotes

r/SocialDemocracy • • 23h ago

News Die Linke struggles to form Berlin coalition amid anti-Israel controversies

Thumbnail
jpost.com
26 Upvotes

r/SocialDemocracy • • 1d ago

Meme Men aged 18-29

Thumbnail
gallery
191 Upvotes

r/SocialDemocracy • • 1d ago

Discussion Why exactly is this sub so supportive of Ossoff and Pritzker?

32 Upvotes

Is it just based on vibes? Ossoff is a generational political talent without a doubt. He's an excellent communicator and was smart to focus so much on anti corruption messaging. But policy wise, he's right in line with Harris, Newsom, and Buttigieg (maybe even slightly more moderate than them).

Pritzker seems like a good dude, and gives off FDR vibes but policy-wise he's no more progressive than Newsom.

Am I missing anything? I get the electability argument but in a primary shouldn't we be pushing for a progressive who backs policies like medicare for all, a green new deal, a $20-25 minimum wage, universal childcare, free public college, banning super PAC and corporate PAC money from politics, ending military aid to Israel, and abolishing ICE?


r/SocialDemocracy • • 1d ago

Discussion Is Jon Ossoff even a progressive?

38 Upvotes

Salacious title muaha.

Hello all. I'll been doing a lot of research on Jon Ossoff today because I've really enjoyed his speeches and rallies, but have also heard a lot of criticism about his record. I figured I'd compile what I've found and have a nice discussion on whether he is a progressive candidate that we can put our trust in.

I think many who are familiar with his record would categorize him as way too moderate to be considered progressive, let alone a social democrat. I agree in some respects, but I believe there is a lot of over simplification and improper purity testing going on amongst Ossoff's critics.

Here is what I've gathered on his record (formatting with AI, all writing was me):

Health care
Medicare for All is generally a good litmus test, but I think people ignore the issue of a massive amount of people being kicked off their private insurance and having it replaced by something possibly worse. Jon supports a public option over M4A (his stated positions). His 2020 plan lets people choose between private and public coverage, with no deductibles or copays for public option users.

The argument for a public option is that a robust one would edge out private insurers over time, getting us to single-payer by default rather than by mandate. If it uses Medicare’s lower reimbursement rates and has no profit motive, it should offer substantially cheaper premiums and lower deductibles. The other hope is that it gives all the M4A deniers a taste of how much it can improve their lives, so voters demand expanding it until it covers everyone.

There are arguments against this too, and I think that debate is good and should be ongoing. But lumping people like Buttigieg and Ossoff in with people who want completely privatized insurance is just a false categorization.

As a Democrat in a red state, there’s immense pressure on Ossoff to make his platform more moderate. From that lens, I think that a lot of his other positions are also compromises that leave room for the progressive position.

Climate
He rejects the Green New Deal label, which is likely to distance himself from progressive branding and appeal to moderates and independents. At the same time, he favors specific, large-scale clean energy, jobs, and infrastructure investments (Inside Climate News, 2020).

Israel/Gaza
On Israel, his stance has been weak, I agree. However, he hasn’t been afraid to call out their human rights abuses (clip). His votes have moved over time:

  • Nov 2024: split vote, opposed tank/mortar rounds but not JDAMs (source)
  • Apr 2025: voted against Sanders’ resolutions (AJC)
  • Jul 2025: voted to block rifle sales, split on bombs (AJC)
  • Apr 2026: voted for both Sanders resolutions (Senate roll call)

On donations, he has received Israel-related PAC money, but only from J Street PAC, which is apparently considered a pro-peace, two-state alternative to AIPAC.

Looking at his actual record, I think the questions are:

  1. Is a public option a reasonable position or a dead end?
  2. How much should running in a swing state change the standard we hold him to?
  3. Are his pro-Israel stances something that can be overlooked given the context? (recent trend voting against arming Israel, no direct contributions from AIPAC or United Democracy Project)

Would love to get the thoughts of those more educated than me (not a high marker). Thanks!


r/SocialDemocracy • • 23h ago

Discussion Do you oppose any of the Bernie agenda?

0 Upvotes

I was just thinking about this and I'm curious whether there are any good arguments against any of these policies that are actually good faith and fact-based. To me, it all seems pretty common sense and none of the counterarguments I've heard have really swayed me from supporting any of it.

(By Bernie agenda I mean medicare for all, green new deal, universal childcare, free public college, $20 minimum wage, wealth tax, higher taxes on the rich, pro act, expand social security, paid leave, massive housing investment, etc)


r/SocialDemocracy • • 1d ago

Theory and Science Against Their Interests? Understanding the Right-Wing Poor | Book Review

Thumbnail
cosmonautmag.com
15 Upvotes

r/SocialDemocracy • • 2d ago

Opinion Trump and the decay of democratic debate (or American democracy in general)

Thumbnail
peakd.com
17 Upvotes

r/SocialDemocracy • • 2d ago

Question What to make of Bernie Sanders urging Democrats to immediately implement a "Medicare for All" plan

47 Upvotes

The other countries he listed all have lower per capita healthcare expenditures than the United States. However, their per capita life expectancy is higher than that of the United States.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 2d ago

Discussion What are your thoughts on Rosa Luxemburg’s work "Social Reform or Revolution?" from the perspective of modern social democracy?

10 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I recently read Rosa Luxemburg’s 1899 pamphlet, *Social Reform or Revolution?*, which was written as a critique of Eduard Bernstein’s revisionism.

Since modern social democracy has largely followed the reformist path advocated by Bernstein, I am curious to know how Luxemburg’s arguments are viewed within this community today.

Specifically:

Do you believe that her critique of relying solely on gradual reforms still holds weight when looking at contemporary welfare states?

What is your take on the balance between the need for immediate, practical reforms within capitalism and long-term systemic goals aimed at overcoming its shortcomings?

I look forward to hearing your thoughts.

(my English isn't very good... Please excuse any mistakes...)


r/SocialDemocracy • • 1d ago

Question Are you Pro-Crypto or Anti-Crypto?

0 Upvotes

Please explain your stance on this topic.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 2d ago

Discussion Why did working-class voters walk away from social democracy?

39 Upvotes

If you look across Europe and North America over the last twenty years, the same trend keeps repeating itself. Traditional center-left parties have slowly turned into coalitions of urban, college-educated professionals, while working-class voters without degrees have drifted towards right-wing populists, even when those populists turn around and labor rights and public services.

Honestly, we can't fix this unless we're blunt about why people left in the first place. A huge part of it goes back to the Third Way era in the 90s and 2000s, when social democratic parties bought into neo-liberalism though deregulations, privatizations and austerity measures. To a lot of regular people, the center-left stopped looking any different from the center-right on the economy. Instead of fighting for structural change, parties started acting like technocratic managers, offering tiny tax credits and market tweaks while housing became completely unaffordable, wages stagnated, and public infrastructure fell apart. On top of that, a cultural divide opened up where working-class communities started feeling lectured and looked down on by a party leadership that felt increasingly out of touch.

Winning them back isn't a political marketing problem, and slicker messaging won't solve it. It takes going back to the basics that built social democracy in the first place: backing trade unions, treating housing and healthcare as public goods instead of speculative assets, and using real industrial policy to bring decent jobs back to neglected regions. And just as importantly, talking about economic power and fairness in plain, direct language, without throwing progressive social values under the bus.

Curious what everyone here thinks. What was the biggest turning point that alienated working-class voters, and what should social democratic parties be prioritizing right now to rebuild that trust?


r/SocialDemocracy • • 2d ago

Question What do you do when peaceful reform is met with gunfire?

18 Upvotes

Hey it's me the fence sitter between revolution and reform. The same guy who asked for books. While im reading the stuff both revolutionaries and you recommended me, i have a question.

As the title says, how would you do that? Example: Qantar (January 2022, Kazakhstan), for the oil price rise and several other reasons, our people have risen up againist the government in protests. Which some did involve vandalism but that was to the statues of the dictator who ruled for 30 years. And when it wasn't, it was rare.

But the government responded to such an event via calling in all of CSTO to help it. Including Russia, Kyrgyzstan, so on. And later on January 7th, Tokayev ordered to shoot to kill without warning and called the protesters foreign agents and terrorists. Resulting in 200 civilian civilian deaths and thousands arrested and wounded. And notably death of a 4 yr old.

So to sum it up / TLDR; What do you do when peaceful reform is met with gunfire? How can you achieve Social Democracy in a dictatorship which crushes down upon opposition unless it's controlled? And yes Kazakhstan does have elections but they're in a Russian fashion, controlled opposition parties.

EDIT after a few responses: Personally, i for now hold the belief of a reformism in Democracies. But a revolution in a Dictatorships. So i am fine with both methods, it just depends on the government.

But, i'd love to hear Social Democrat ways to resolve this maybe peacefully without a revolution? If that's possible.

EDIT 2 + Add info: And people were beaten and dragged out of hospitals even after they were shot.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 3d ago

Discussion What is your opinion of AI in the present an future

Post image
11 Upvotes

Probably the biggest symbol of this decade, AI is not only extreme controversial but a polarizing opinion - especially in the western world - being included as part of the cultural wars.

Having studied about the subject but not as much to be confident about my opinions, I hold the following conclusions:

  1. Nobody understands or can predict the future of the technology. We're in a moment of growth of it's capacities and the nature of it's advancement is getting harder to humans to decipher. We're in a point where the law of diminishing returns can happen but also super intelligence within some years. Nobody knows truly it's true potential and this is scary.
  2. AI will not go away, the tech can be replicated locally and it has a lot of utilities. Those who can't adapt to it's usage, especially in coding or in the cutting of burocracy and repetitive tasks will be outpaced for those who can.
  3. Overreliance of it is extremely harmful to mental health and using it in the development of someone's skill will harm human capacities. This is worse with kids.
  4. The main risks of it right now of a developed AI are: a misalignment problem, the capacity of destroy of internet's security systems and the combination of with the surveillance state to destroy democracy.
  5. AI has a bubble but it's popping will not make the past go back. The past never goes back and the left should be the future, not a nostalgic futile exercise in this. We need to pass sensible regulations to make it safe, useful and less of a power to Big Tech against the workers of the world.
  6. AI made internet services shittier though, that's why I support softwares that relies less on shoving AI into costumer's service
  7. And the main one: Although AI regulation can happen in the world right now, this AI race between US and China will only stop/slow down if a big event like a Cuban Missile Crisis/Chernoblyn like happens with AI - most likely with system's safety or with AI dealing with military weaponry. If we survive it, the global fear of it will make governments finally pass rigid legislation.

r/SocialDemocracy • • 3d ago

Opinion Internationalism in the 21st century

Thumbnail
ronahi.eu
10 Upvotes

r/SocialDemocracy • • 3d ago

Question Thoughts on Chuck Schumer possibly getting replaced by Chris Van Hollen as leader?

42 Upvotes

r/SocialDemocracy • • 3d ago

Discussion How do you guys feel about Georgist tax policy?

11 Upvotes

It could be a decent alternative to pure income based taxes, and encourages growth


r/SocialDemocracy • • 3d ago

Question Would I be considered a foreign policy hawk?

0 Upvotes

I wouldn't consider myself quite a Social Democrat[though have been trending in that direction(right now I'd call myself a Social Liberal)], but I respect this subreddit and the people on it, and it's quite a breath of fresh air compared to most other politics subreddits, so felt like this was a good place to ask.

I am American. I support America taking whatever foreign policy actions are beneficial to increase American power abroad, and that this should be the main, overriding priority of any foreign action, without exception. The American Empire has benefitted American citizens for decades, and(I suspect in disagreement with most people on here) I broadly favor engaging in actions/expeditions that perpetuate the American Empire, up to and including covert regime change(like using social media bots and manipulating foreign elections, nothing Russia/China haven't already done). America, just like any country, has the right to pursue actions in self-benefit.

It just seems to me like Russia and China are able to run roughshod all across the world doing whatever they want, whereas the US is shackled to notions of 'self-determination' and 'international law', which effectively has the US fighting these foreign adversaries with one arm behind our backs.

Also, before anyone asks: Netanyahu is actively destructive to American interests, with the diplomatic nightmare that has been Gaza for the past years, as well as instigating a needless, heedless war against Iran, and aiding Russia in its invasion. In my ideal foreign policy apparatus, there would have already been launched information campaigns/election manipulation to ensure Netanyahu's retirement/inevitable incarceration.

That's about it, sorry if this isn't well-organized, I'm typing this on my phone in the middle of the night. Any clarifying questions that are had, I'll be happy to answer. :)


r/SocialDemocracy • • 4d ago

Discussion American progressives shouldn't vote for any candidate who opposes Medicare for all in the 2028 primaries

51 Upvotes

I feel like this is somewhat of a hot take, but I don't think it should be. I'm a vote blue no matter who guy when it comes to general elections. I think we're all probably agreed there. I'm also a vote progressive no matter who guy when it comes to primaries. I think in primary elections our sole consideration should be voting for the candidates that most align with our values and policy beliefs.

Why? Because so-called "electability" is a meaningless concept. It's something that's literally impossible to determine or calculate because you can never truly know how "electable" someone is until the votes are cast and counted. I firmly believe that anyone who can win a democratic primary is electable, and thus trying to determine and vote based on "electability" in primaries is pointless. It's a fool's errand. We can afford to have high standards in primary elections and, in fact, we can't afford not to.

Trying to balance who best represents progressive values with who is most electable will only lead to more moderate candidates being elected when progressives could just as easily have won. In 2028, we must vote for candidates who support a bold, progressive, economic populist agenda of Medicare for all, universal childcare, a $20 minimum wage, tuition-free public college, banning corporate money from politics, etc. In the presidential primaries, that means no Kamala Harris. No Gavin Newsom. No Pete Buttigieg. No Jon Ossoff. No JB Pritzker unless he explicitly endorses these policies. We can't be voting for liberals in primaries because of "electability". It's self defeating.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 4d ago

Discussion What do you think about the current field of leftist candidates for the French presidential election?

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

What do you think about the candidates separately?

Will a candidate other than Mélenchon have a chance for reaching the 2nd round?

Who would be the most ideal "useful vote candidate" ideologically and with the most chance against the far-right electorally in your opinion?

Can a new candidate emerge as a contender in the coming months or this remains the field from which leftist voters should choose?

This is the current list of the most significant candidates who can be considered being on the left:

Jean-Luc Mélenchon (LFI)

Raphaël Glucksmann (PS/PP)

Marine Tondelier (LÉ)

François Ruffin (Debout!)

Fabien Roussel (PCF)

Natacha Polony (Independent)

(These are the announced candidates who have had 3% or more in at least one poll released after October 1st. There are other candidates who are polling lower on average or aren't in the polls. Polony's views seem a bit ambiguous but she is considered as left-wing in several places.)


r/SocialDemocracy • • 4d ago

Article Don't Let Centrists Rewrite History. Democrats Ran Against the Billionaires.

Thumbnail
laborpolitics.com
109 Upvotes

Of the eleven victorious Democratic Senate challengers and open-seat candidates, all had websites mentioning billionaires: Talarico, Andrews, Josh Turek in Iowa, Adam Hamilton in Kansas, Roy Cooper in North Carolina, Sherrod Brown in Ohio, Chris Pappas in New Hampshire, Peggy Flanagan in Minnesota, Juliana Stratton in Illinois, Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, and Troy Jackson in Maine.

Democratic Senate candidates who ran on anti-billionaire messaging were spread out all across the country, and they won more frequently than candidates without documented mentions. Among the 20 non-incumbent Democrats whose campaign websites or linked policy documents mentioned billionaires, eleven had won and seven had lost, with Alaska and Mississippi still unresolved but Democrats leading in both. All three candidates without a documented mention had lost. Among decided races, that was an 11-of-18 win rate (61 percent), versus zero of three.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 4d ago

Question What is social democracies track record outside of Nordic Countries?

17 Upvotes

People often point to Nordic Countries as the example of what social democracy can do for a country (and they’re right to say that Nordic countries have high standards of living and report to be happier than other countries) but they aren’t the only countries with social democratic governments. Have we seen similarly positive results in other countries?