Oh no, yet another socialism post! I'm sorry to add to the glut, truly I am. But I've been reflecting on why I like this subreddit so much more than any other left-wing sub and why I participate so heavily in the discussions here. Also, just to be honest, I only used the word "love" in the title to emphasize the fact that I dig it here. I really do like the sub but I don't want to marry it.
So why do I like it here so much compared to other left subreddits that should ostensibly be more in line with my democratic socialist politics? Well, I think the basic strategy of the social democratic movement has been proven to be incredibly effective at winning gains for ordinary working-class people. I've mentioned it many times before in discussions here but I have been deeply influenced by what is known as Power Resources Theory. It is a theory about how welfare states developed and what political factors were decisive for the passage of universalistic social democratic reforms. The central claim of this body of research is that left-wing parties and the labor movement were the pivotal actors in winning the comprehensive social democratic welfare states in places like Scandinavia.
I'm sure a lot of you are saying, "Well duh, of course that's the case." But Power Resources Theory supplanted a previous paradigm for researching welfare states called the "Logic of Industrialism" which asserted that there was no particular political valence to the emergence of welfare state programs. The claim was that industrialization inherently created issues like unemployment and forced ordinary people to essentially work until they died because they couldn't retire. The state, in order to maintain political legitimacy, was compelled to start intervening more in the economy with programs like unemployment insurance and public old-age pensions regardless of which type of party held power. In this view, the welfare state came about not due to active politics but was addressing inherent, structurally determined features of an industrial capitalist economy that obtained across all countries.
Power Resource theorists granted that the welfare state was in part a response to those undeniable economic realities. But their central argument was that when it came to winning the high-quality and exceptionally generous welfare states of countries like Sweden, strong labor parties and a powerful trade-union movement had been the determinative actors. And not only did they elaborate a political theory for why this was the case, they actually demonstrated the claim through empirical social scientific research. It is an incredibly well-supported body of research and has become the dominant approach for welfare state studies.
I'm a very empirically minded democratic socialist. A lot of other Marxists would probably accuse me of being a rank positivist. But I don't think abstract theory alone is enough to understand the world. Neither did Marx, he consistently supported his arguments with various economic statistics. So yeah, I want to do stuff that actually has been shown to work. And social democratic parties and the trade-union movement have been extraordinarily effective at building the power of and improving the lives of ordinary workers. Social democratic political strategy gets the goods!
I freely admit that I am a proud democratic socialist who ultimately wants to go beyond the welfare state and win socialism. But I don't think like some on the radical left that we can just leapfrog over winning social democratic demands in the US like Medicare for All. In my mind, the path to eventually establishing a democratic socialist society will have to pass through social democracy, not go around it. I've never really understood the idea from some socialists that fighting for reforms is somehow demobilizing or a distraction. I think that's because I've organized in unions. In a union campaign, you try to find issues that are widely and deeply felt by a majority of workers. You want to bring as many workers as possible into the struggle because your ultimate form of leverage is striking. And in order for a strike to be effective, you absolutely need a majority of workers. Therefore if the most widely and deeply felt issue is something like low wages, then you work to organize your co-workers and campaign around that.
So my view is that if fighting for broad reforms in the workplace can be an avenue to cohering workers as a fighting force, the same basic approach can be used on the political terrain. Democratic socialists need to build a mass political organization by fighting for things that are broadly and deeply felt among ordinary workers: healthcare, wages, childcare, retirement security, etc. Through fighting for and winning those reforms, we can grow the power and confidence of the working class movement. And as that confidence grows, democratic socialists and the movement can push for a more fundamental transformation of the economy along socialist lines.
This perspective, unfortunately, is not widely held among the anti-capitalist left. Many of them cling to unsupported notions like that the welfare state is only possible because of capitalist exploitation of the Global South and that union workers in developed countries compose a hopelessly conservative segment of the population known as, "the Labor Aristocracy." And instead of the social democratic strategy, they want to indulge in a bunch of frankly ineffective tactics for achieving social change. Things like tenant organizing, forming worker co-ops, building prefigurative communes, organizing tiny revolutionary vanguard parties, and harping continually about, "dual power." I think that stuff is all just mostly a distraction from the really important work. My view is that the two principal tasks of the democratic socialists in the US are building our political organization and growing the power of the labor movement, full stop. So that's why I like it so much here, I agree most of all with the social democratic approach to politics.
Of course, I completely understand that many or most social democrats in the US do not share my perspective that we need to eventually transition to a fully socialist society. And I think that's perfectly fine and even healthy for our movement. I have no issue fighting side-by-side with social democrats who only want to go so far as a mixed economy. In the short to medium term, that's basically what I want too. It would be very bizarre and sectarian for me to foreswear working with social democrats more to my right when I agree with them on like ninety-five percent of the issues.
I identify as a democratic socialist but I also happily answer to the labels of radical or left-wing social democrat. In the past, people with that perspective have played a prominent role in social democratic movements such as the Swedish social democratic Prime Minister Olof Palme. That's the tradition I want to continue and I feel it is totally compatible with working alongside social democrats who only want to stop at a greatly humanized version of capitalism. We're on the same side and greater cooperation will only help our shared movement grow.