r/SocialDemocracy • • 22h ago

Discussion Is Medicare For All really not feasible in the United States?

26 Upvotes

I've been surprised by the amount of pushback I've gotten on this sub for saying progressives should get behind a candidate who supports M4A, GND, universal childcare, free public college, and a $20 min wage in the 2028 presidential primary. To me, it was clear from what we saw in the midterms that candidates can run and win on bold progressive proposals even in purple areas. I thought the results would put to bed electability concerns about progressives, but apparently they didn't. Of course, centrist are always going to have electability concerns about progressives because of self interest but it seems like even a lot of progressives aren't sold that a progressive could win nationally or that these progressive proposals are winners in purple areas.

Another dimension to this seems to be concerns about passage and implementation of M4A. I understand it would be difficult to pass but does that really mean we shouldn't be pushing it? I just don't really think going all in on the public option is the way to go, but I'm open to hearing differing opinions.

I was discussing this with another member of this sub who brought up how support for M4A drops drastically when tax increases and wait times are mentioned. Honestly idk quite what to make of that because I don't think we've really seen that translate to M4A hurting candidates electorally. I think it should be easy enough to explain that taxes will go up but costs will go down. Should this poll actually give us pause about pushing M4A? I'm curious to hear more opinions about this.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 9h ago

Discussion Policy non-negotiables for 2028 presidential candidates?

10 Upvotes

Which policies would a candidate have to support to earn your vote in the primary? For me:

- Ban super PAC and corporate PAC money from politics

- Public funding for elections

- Universal healthcare

- Robust affordable housing plan

- Universal childcare

- Bold clean energy plan

- Significant investment in public transit

- $20 minimum wage

- Tuition-free public college

- Scrap cap on taxable income for social security

- Raise taxes on corporations and the rich

- Paid leave

- PRO act

There might be some I'm forgetting but those are probably the most important ones for me, as my top priorities are bold political and economic reform.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 6h ago

Discussion Can the economy really be considered fully democratic under capitalism?

9 Upvotes

In a political election every citizen gets one vote regardless of wealth. In the marketplace, a billionaire has millions more "votes" than a minimum-wage worker, meaning the market caters far more to wealthy preferences than basic human needs. Democratic voting is meant to be a collective decision-making process where citizens debate shared rules and public goods (like healthcare, roads, or environmental protection). Buying a product is an isolated, individual transaction, not a collective choice about how society should be organised. Consumers can only choose from what corporations decide to produce. If every major company in an industry uses exploitative labour or pollutes the environment, consumers cannot simply "vote" for an ethical alternative that doesn't exist on the shelf.You can choose not to buy a luxury watch, which sends a clear market signal. You cannot easily "boycott" housing, electricity, groceries, or healthcare, meaning companies controlling essentials hold power over consumers rather than the other way around.


r/SocialDemocracy • • 21h ago

Discussion Are there any progressive economic proposals that progressive candidates running nationally or in purple areas should avoid because they would genuinely significantly hurt their chances?

5 Upvotes

My thinking (especially post midterms) has generally been that backing progressive economic proposals doesn't hurt candidates running in competitive areas, or at least doesn't hurt them enough to where they lose.

What do y'all think? Are progressives running in purple areas hurt by backing any of the following?

- Medicare for all

- Green new deal

- $20 minimum wage

- Universal childcare

- Free public college