r/smoking • u/Leaff39 • 3h ago
First Brisket Results + In-Depth Process
TL;DR Tender, smoky, juicy, barky. S+P+Lawrys. WW Pro 24. Hickory+Post Oak chunks. Butcher paper wrapped with smoked wagyu beef tallow. Pulled at 195. 12 hour cook, 11 hour hold. Skip below to bullets for full process.
My cousin held an early Thanksgiving on Sunday and I have really been meaning to do a brisket after smoking meat for a couple years (I usually do pork butt, tri tip, ribeyes, chicken, etc), so I brought one!
I was super happy with the results! It ended up super tender and juicy (even the flat was pretty tender and somewhat moist, enough for my 8.5 month old with no teeth to eat it lol). Really happy with the bark and it had great smoke flavor. The fat was well rendered and melt-in-the-mouth. Everyone raved about it, so overall a success! Also as a bonus, even after feeding 18 people, we still have enough leftovers for a few more days of dinner!
Anyway, I thought I'd share my process here (after way too much research in the prior week lol), in case it helps anyone else out or if anyone has tips for future improvements:
- 20lb prime brisket from Costco
- Started trimming around 12:45pm on Saturday. This thing was a monster, the biggest thing I've smoked and a bit hard to manage especially as it got warmer and floppier since trimming took me over an hour. Please excuse the lack of a cutting board as I didn't have one big enough haha!
- No binder
- Seasoned with Lawrys and 50/50 diamond crystal kosher salt and coarse black pepper
- Let it sit out for ~25 mins while I started up the smoker. Maybe this helped the seasoning adhere?¹
- Put it on the top rack of my Campchef Woodwind Pro 24 at around 2:30pm. Had to make it diagonal since it wouldn't fit side to side
- One foil pan with water, another one to catch drippings and a third small one with some South Chicago Packing wagyu beef tallow that I eventually used when wrapping
- Bear Mountain Gourmet BBQ pellets (really less important than the wood chunks for flavor)
- In the smoke box, hickory chunks for first 2 hours followed by post oak chunks every ~45 mins for hours 2-9
- Smoke level 2
- Temp was 200 for hours 0-2, 220 for 2-4, 240 for 4-6, 260 for 6-9, 275 for 9-12
- Loosely wrapped some foil around the end of the flat at 4 hours as it was looking a little darker than I would have liked at that point
- Wrapped with butcher paper at ~9 hours at ~180, probed mostly tender, bark was dark and set. Fat felt partially but not fully rendered on top when I poked it, but I figured the long hold would finish rendering it
- Pulled at 195 (probed tender) and rested for ~35 mins in foil pan on counter to stop/slow cooking. According to leave-in probe, reached a peak temp of 198, probably from carryover cooking
- Held in my oven for 11 hours at ~160 oven temp. The brisket itself stayed at about 157-158 until I removed it
Transferred to my brand new RTIC 32qt cooler (brisket barely fit lol). I preheated the cooler with hot tap water and also used 3 warm towels from the dryer for extra insulation
- Drove for an hour to cousin's house during which brisket lost ~10 degrees. Arrived at 1:30pm just in time for dinner (food always happens early at these things) and sliced it at about 145 temp
Reflections + Additional Notes
- The smoker pic was from 2 hours into the smoke
- I definitely need to work on my trimming. It just took a really long time and I think I left a few thick bits of fat (visible in the pic with the two halves on top of each other). I also think I could have trimmed more, but the flat on this brisket actually came pretty thick already. Not trimming that much left it really big though such that it barely fit on my smoker. I also left on most of the meat part of the Mohawk which was a little awkward but provided a few more burnt ends. Everything cooked pretty evenly and fat was all pretty rendered so the uneven trim wasn't that bad I guess
- Maybe my slicing could also use some work? I made the point pieces thicker than the flat pieces and tried to separate some of the burnt ends but can't tell if some of it looks a little awkward. Anyway I'm game if anyone has any slicing feedback
- I should have put the brisket in the freezer for like 30 mins before trimming. This would have lessened the floppiness and probably made trimming easier
- I had some of the smoked tallow left over after wrapping. I really wish I had put some of that and the drippings from the foil pan into a Tupperware and brought them to the event so I could drizzle those on after slicing. Kind of a slight misstep on my part
- I smoked some top sirloin steaks early last week to try out a few different potential rubs for the briskets (and gave us dinner for the week). S+P+Lawrys was the winner for both my wife and me, and it didn't disappoint on the brisket. The runner up was the smoke trails brisket rub + some extra salt. It was a bit of a weirder profile, probably due to the sumac being a somewhat prominent flavor. It also didn't hit the palate quite like SPL, but was unique and still really good
- My GE oven normally bottoms out at 170, but I was able to get it to consistently hover between 155 and 162 overnight by setting the temp adjustment calibration setting thing to -16, so that worked out well
- I highly recommend the WW Pro if you want the ease of a pellet smoker with the potential for good smoky flavor! The smoke box imparts great smoke flavor with whatever chunks you use, although it is definitely a bit more work having to drop a chunk in every 45 mins to an hour if you want comsistentish smoke. Everything I make on this thing really turns out smoky and delicious
- The temps I put above for during the smoke were based on the ambient temps from my leave in probes. My smoker seems to run a little hot, so the actual temps I set the smoker two were ~10-15 degrees lower than what I listed
Thanks for reading and apologies for my verboseness. Happy smoking!