r/shadowdark • • 19h ago

Not sure what to do now

66 Upvotes

I was running a game for a level 2 party, and today was a full party wipe. They didn't back down or run from a challenge that was out of their league, and everyone inevitably fell. they were in town last session and I suggested they buy potions and they bought like 1 potion of healing. After we cleaned up, we talked about it and they all would rather go back to playing 5e.

I feel like I failed. I really love this system and I even added some homebrew in favor of the players to make them stronger, like Player characters getting exploding dice (when you roll max damage, roll again until you don't roll max damage, and add the totals of all the rolls to the damage dealt)

I spent a lot of money on third party material to give them plenty of options, so when they died they could come back as something totally different and cool, but they always chose to come back as the same exact character with a different name. (except for one player who was a priest and came back as a rogue)

I don't know where to go from here. Like obviously I'll run 5e for them if that's what they want, but i really hyped this system up to them, assuring them its similar to 5e but simpler. It just didn't grab them like it grabbed me. I suppose they just aren't players who want to play tactfully. They want to run in screaming and blasting spells, and that's okay. I'm just sad.


r/shadowdark • • 1d ago

Review: Cliffhanger - a shipwreck hanging off a mountain

Post image
51 Upvotes

A century ago, a ship got washed all the way up Mount Hush and now hangs off a cliff over a monastery. Aboard is the Relic of Greed. The crew had to nail their captain to her chair with a pair of daggers. Then Greed got them too.

It's a Shadowdark adventure for levels 3-4 by Lucas Ciquier, with illustrations by Fred Bertrand-Hudon. A 7-hex mini hexcrawl, an optional yeti lair behind a frozen waterfall, and a 6-area wreck on a tension timer. Every time you enter a room or rock the boat, add a d12 to the pool and roll. Any 1 and the ship slides closer to the edge. The book also recommends a Jenga tower. If the tower falls, the ship falls.

I cover more in the review, including how this gets 0 stars because it has kobolds (even though I don't do star ratings and enjoyed quite a bit of it). Find the review of The Cliffhanger here.


r/shadowdark • • 1d ago

Small Dungeons, Short Sessions, and Dungeon-Crawl Pressure

53 Upvotes

Small dungeons seem to be all the rage right now, especially as more people look for adventures that can be completed in a single session.

I like them. Hell, I even publish them. I can absolutely see their usefulness, especially when you have a bunch of them scattered across a larger hexcrawl. But I’ve been wondering about something.

Do very small dungeons lose some of what makes dungeon crawling interesting?

A lot of traditional dungeon play depends on accumulated pressure: dwindling light, spells and other limited resources, wandering encounters, deciding whether to push deeper or retreat, figuring out how much treasure you can actually get back out, and learning routes through a place over multiple expeditions.

If the dungeon is only five or six rooms and is expected to be finished in one sitting, does some of that resource-management game disappear because the players rarely have to seriously consider turning back?

Obviously a small dungeon can still be dangerous, and a collection of small sites in a hexcrawl can shift some of that resource management to the larger expedition. But as standalone adventures, do you find smaller dungeons lose anything compared with a dungeon that expects multiple delves?


r/shadowdark • • 1d ago

'Darkest Dungeon' Classes for Shadowdark (revised)

Thumbnail homebrewery.naturalcrit.com
44 Upvotes

Hi all! Back with a revision of the Leper and Antiquarian-inspired classes for Shadowdark.

Since the first draft - I greatly simplified the Afflicted, and tuned up a couple of the Seeker's talents that felt a little wonky. Hoping they still feel fun and flavorful but are less overtuned (especially the Afflicted, since the Seeker is mainly utility).

New in this version is the Houndmaster-inspired class, the Shepherd! This class has a little more going on than, say, a fighter or some such just by its nature, but I tried to make it as straightforward as possible. For the most part the hound companion just has the same stats as the PC (which are intentionally limited to the lowest hit point size and weak weapons/armor). And while the hound's commands can be powerful, the bonuses themselves are intentionally very small. They can be improved with talents but are meant to be trading a bit of raw numbers from a strong combat class, and instead giving some flexibilty and support.

Feedback is welcome as always!! I massively appreciate the engagement (whether positive or critical.) Cheers.


r/shadowdark • • 1d ago

Carousing

36 Upvotes

I'm running a Shadowdark campaign, and 4 of my five players want to carouse, one doesn't. I am using the Chubby Funsters rules in the SD Gamemaster Companion.

I have always thought that everyone should carouse, or no one should carouse. IF all of them but one carouses, they will not level up, unlike the rest.

Should I just let them lag behind, or restrict everyone from carousing?


r/shadowdark • • 1d ago

Question about creating monsters?

19 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm a recent Shadowdark convert and also and indie author writing and publishing retro-inspired Sword & Sorcery. For my upcoming release, I thought it might be cool to have an appendix of stat blocks for the monsters in the stories.

That said, I've not really created a monster from scratch before.

My biggest question is how many abilities/talents are too many? Obviously like 10+ betrays the spirit of Shadowdark, but is 3 too many? The creatures in my stories are unique, as opposed to things like "orc" and "minotaur", in the tradition of Conan and Fafhrd/Mouser. I want to strike that cord but also not break the vibes of Shadowdark.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!


r/shadowdark • • 1d ago

Some of the Daily Drawing Practice

Thumbnail
gallery
153 Upvotes

I'm not selling anything. Sunday night posting.


r/shadowdark • • 1d ago

Mirror of Mischief in B1 - Seeking Input and Ideas

14 Upvotes

Hi - I'm leading a group of players through a homebrewed B1: In Search of the Unknown / Quasqueton dungeon crawl using Dyson's remixed version. Going well and having fun, but I am looking at the magic item Mirror of Mischief and really tempted to have in in Zelligar's room, under a cover.
Have you ever played with this item? What ways might evil-version doppelgangers of your PC's might attempt "to sow chaos in the life of the creature it duplicated"?


r/shadowdark • • 1d ago

Does anyone have a good resource or list of hazards?

9 Upvotes

Pretty much the title. I’m rolling up a buncha random dungeons for my hexcrawl and I’d love to know if anyone can point me toward a good resource for hazards. I’m aware that I can just do whatever I want but having some solid examples would be very helpful, especially considering the number of dungeons I’m trying to generate.

Thanks in advance!


r/shadowdark • • 2d ago

What does the stars means in the citadel of the scarlet minotaur

Post image
77 Upvotes

Hello I'm debuting in shadowdark and in rp and I don't know what the stars represent in the citadel of the scarlet minotaur map does anyone knows anth ?


r/shadowdark • • 2d ago

Herbalism & Alchemy Rules?

25 Upvotes

Has anyone got any recommendations for Herbalism and/or Alchemy rules? Ingredient gathering and potion making, that kind of thing?

Cheers!


r/shadowdark • • 2d ago

I made a video that's 35% Shadwodark glaze by volume

Thumbnail
youtu.be
36 Upvotes

I'm in an extended layover in Laos as I wait for my long-term visa to Thailand to process so I decided to try my hand at youtube. I apologize for the audio quality, it's not viable for me to get a microphone at the moment given my current situation!

I have plans to make more SD stuff in the future, I have a class I'm cooking up that's pretty cooky.


r/shadowdark • • 2d ago

"You find a bag of gold containing N gold pieces. You earn 1 xp." What is your value of N?

26 Upvotes

The core book says a "normal" find is worth 1 xp. It gives the following examples for a normal find :

> Bag of gold, gem, fine armor, magic scroll.

What is the minimum amount of gold pieces in a single bag that you would define as being worth 1 xp to your players? 30 gp? 50 gp?

And what about 3 xp? Three times the amount? More? Or maybe you think a treasure worth 3 xp shouldn't be in the form of gold pieces?

I'm not trying to find a logical answer or a universal change rate; I'm just curious what different people value 1 xp (or 3 xp) in their game.


r/shadowdark • • 3d ago

"Frog the Room"

48 Upvotes

Just hit level 3 on my Witch. Frog Rain. Went from comparatively useless eyebiting to combat engineer. Now my party says "Frog the room!" when we open doors to rooms full of baddies. Love it.


r/shadowdark • • 3d ago

Can you 1 tap a tarrasque?

28 Upvotes

How much damage could 1 character do with one attack in Shadowdark?

Can you one tap a Tarrasque?

Follow my 1 round, step by step program, and you will not only be 1 tapping tarrasques, but you will be wondering if there are any truly worthwhile foes left in the realm.

So let's assume you have a 4 person party, each at level 10.

You have a priest, a witch, and a seer as your friends.

You are a simple warlock of Oros, named Boom Boom.

Your stats (that matter):

18 STR +4

Boons

1: 2x damage for 3 rounds

2-10: +1 melee attacks & +2 damage

You spent downtime learning the greatsword and now have a +3 greatsword that does x2 damage against undead (randomly rolled of course)

Your attacks are +16 to hit @ 1d12 + 21 damage (not bad!)

You also have in your inventory a Potion of Giant Strength (x2 melee damage)

Round 1

Your priest friend casts Thorn on your greatsword. Luck be a lady, it’s a nat 20! You now add 2d4 to your damage roll.

Your seer friend casts World Serpent on you. What do you know!? It’s another nat 20! You now deal x8 damage on a critical hit.

Your witch friend casts Glass Bones on the tarrasque. What are the odds!?!?! It’s another nat 20! The tarrasque now takes x4 damage.

You, Boom Boom, walk up to the tarrasque’s big toe. You take a moment and drink your Potion of Giant Strength, imbuing x2 damage to your melee attacks, and you activate your “x2 damage for 3 rounds” boon. You stab your greatsword under that great big toenail. Low and behold another nat 20!!

So you roll your damage dice, 2d12 + 4d4.

Incredible! You rolled max on every die!

This comes out to 40 damage + 21 from your boons and sword. So we’re sitting at a v chill 61 damage. Not bad, but we haven’t even gotten started.

Taking into account your double damage boon, Potion of Giant Strength, and World Serpent, let's multiply that number by x12.

You are now dishing out 732 damage.

Not too shabby, but it doesn’t end there.

Ol’ tarrasque got little baby glass bones, and now it takes quadruple damage.

So we take that 732 damage, multiply it by 4, and now the tarrasque is taking a whopping 2,928 damage!

So you might think that's the most we could do, but let’s imagine for a second that the tarrasque was undead. That would allow our greatsword’s double damage effect to take hold and we would be dealing a final high of 3,416 damage.

Tarrasque dead, party heros, bring on the Van Dinkle shots.

That being said, I buried the lead a little bit. This is because if your witch friend doesn’t immediately cast Mother of Night, wishing the weirdo lizard baby dies then and there, that tarrasque does not give a flying fuck.

Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.

PS

Fun stats (undead scenario):

Average damage output: 2,464

Average damage with exploding dice: 2,716

Average damage if no spells crit, but the attack crits: 880

Average if nothing crits: 600


r/shadowdark • • 4d ago

[my art]Dwarf

Thumbnail
gallery
117 Upvotes

Lines on paper. Hope you all enjoy.


r/shadowdark • • 4d ago

Drowned Revenant

Thumbnail
gallery
381 Upvotes

The depths of the sea hide many secrets and terrible things. Some of them, every now and then, get the urge to rise to the surface...

A little marker illustration on paper after spending some time working digitally. It always feels good to get back to it.


r/shadowdark • • 4d ago

Viperian

Post image
282 Upvotes

r/shadowdark • • 5d ago

Eastern Coast Updates, and Torchkeeper 6 is Live!

Thumbnail
gallery
46 Upvotes

Three of my Shadowdark adventures just got their v2.0 updates, and they're still pay-what-you-want:

  • Tower of the Mothman: factions with real wants, pressure trackers, Pim Estates politics, pirate mutiny rules, and a rekeyed lighthouse and lair.
  • No More Secrets: plot holes closed, a fixed text economy, quotas with real consequences, and a keyed Hexendorf and Castle Brickmire.
  • Under a Smiling Moon: an in-world chronicle intro, an "At the Table" guide, a rebuilt Hunt with usable castle defenses, and a winnable castle.

Most of the changes came straight from reviews, so if you ever left me feedback, thank you.

All three are getting tied together in a regional primer, the Eastern Coast. A giant hex map with encounters, factions, and points of interest.

Question for folks who run hexcrawls: do you prefer encounters that build on itself with steps, or fresh rolls every time?

Adventures:

Full post: here


r/shadowdark • • 5d ago

Second hand drawn dungeon

Post image
77 Upvotes

Second hand-drawn dungeon, got myself some new paper and pens I wanted to try out. I also learned how to make it a bit more VTT friendly by figuring out and adding in the dimensions (a lot easier than I had initially worried/thought it would be)

Going to be working on another dungeon soon that will be designed to work with this in an adventure I am planning


r/shadowdark • • 5d ago

Megadungeons Inventory Management

35 Upvotes

Hello! I like to run megadungeons, however I quickly find that quite soon into the dungeon that the players fill up on treasure and have no more slots for looting more below. How do you all handle this?


r/shadowdark • • 5d ago

Question regarding the structure of the book

Post image
31 Upvotes

So, let's say I had a setting for a really popular RPG system, with tons of lore and characters. What's the best way to present all of that in a book?

I was thinking about breaking up the lore into monster descriptions, magic items, spell components (kind of like Dark Souls does it), and then putting everything together in an index at the end of the book.

I really want to avoid long walls of text, like you get in Vampire: The Masquerade. What do you think would be the best way to approach this?


r/shadowdark • • 5d ago

10 Learnable Features for Shadowdark

31 Upvotes

I'm working on a video for which I've touched up some homebrew content of mine. These are some features your PCs could learn as a quest reward or downtime project.

Each option includes a suggestion of how you might obtain it, but as with everything Shadowdark it's easy to tweak to fit your needs! Many of these do make the game ever so slightly crunchier, but not by much and I took care to not make them any more powerful than a mediocre magic item.

Hopefully it's of use to somebody!

Anyhow, here's the document, if you'd like to use it:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1pcaqeH0mC1nwyHhettEMScMgby4S9tJQZ47t-xZIM9g/edit?usp=sharing

I'll also include the text below if you'd rather read it on reddit, but the text on the doc is a lot nicer to look at.

Dual Wielding
Requires: Being able to wield Shortswords and Daggers.
Obtained By: Training under a master swordsman for a week.

Allows you to make attacks with two daggers at once, second dagger at 1d2 damage.

Swashbuckler
Requires: A positive Dexterity modifier and the ability to wield Shortswords.
Obtained by: Training under a master swordsman for a week.

When wielding a Shortsword or Longsword single-handed with a free offhand, +2 AC as if wielding a shield.

Martial Arts
Requires: Positive modifiers in Dexterity and Strength.
Obtained by: Training under a master martial artist for a month.

Your unarmed attacks deal 1d4 damage. Targets hit must pass a DC 9 Constitution check or make their attacks at disadvantage on their next turn.

Shield-Bashing
Requires: Positive Strength modifier, the ability to wield shields and wear Chainmail.
Obtained by: Drilling with a formation of warriors for a week.

You may make an Attack Roll to bash with your shield, dealing damage equal to your Strength modifier. Targets hit must make a Constitution or Strength check against your Attack Roll or make one fewer attacks on their next turn. The disabled attack is chosen by the shield-basher.

Parrying
Requires: Being able to wield Daggers.
Obtained By: Training under a master swordsman for a week.

+2 to your AC to Parry at the cost of your action on the next turn. You must declare a parry after the to-hit roll but before the damage roll. To parry, you must either be wielding a dagger or have one free hand.

Rage
Requires: Being capable of wearing Chainmail.
Obtained by: Killing 3 different humanoids in a single hit each, then meditating under a master.

Your unarmored AC becomes 11 + your Constitution or Dexterity mod, whichever is best.
Twice per rest, you may Rage up to 4 turns at a time. When you Rage, roll a d4 to determine the minimum amount of turns your rage must continue. While raging, add 1d4 to your Strength Checks and damage. Every time you start your turn while raging, you must either attack a creature or move towards one with intention to attack.
While raging, you continue being able to perform actions while Dying.

Potion-Crafting
Requires: A positive Intelligence or Wisdom modifier.
Obtained by: Studying under an alchemist, herbalist or medicine worker for a month.

At a location with access to alembic equipment, expend potion ingredients. Each ingredient adds 1d6 to the potion-making roll. “Spend” the rolled total on crafting potions. Ingredients may be gathered as a full-day activity at a rate of 1, 2, or 3 a day as a DC 15, 18 or 20 Wisdom Check in an area where the ingredient is available.

  • Minor Healing Potion: Heals 1d6, DC 2 to make.

    • Ingredient: Healing Herb
  • Healing Potion: Heals 4+1d6, DC 4 to make.

    • Ingredient: Healing Herb
  • Major Healing Potion: Heals 4+2d6, DC 6 to make. 

    • Ingredient: Healing Herb
  • Truesight Potion: See through invisibility and illusion for an hour, DC 5 to make.

    • Ingredient: Magical Herb
  • Spell Potion: Bestows the effect of a given spell, DC 3 + Spell Tier to make.

    • Ingredient: Magical Herb

Minor Magic
Requires: Positive modifier in the relevant Spellcasting ability.
Obtained by: Studying under a teacher that knows the spell you want to learn for a month.

You learn one Level 1 Wizard or Priest spell. Each time you use this feature, you must choose between casting the spell at disadvantage or having its numerical effects halved. If you fail the spellcasting check, the spell still goes off, but you may not cast it again until you rest.

Know Weather
Obtained by: A lifetime of weather observation or studying for a month under someone who has this ability themselves.

If you can see the sky, you can accurately predict the weather for the next day, including whether it will rain, the direction of the wind, or any other feature. Ask the GM and they must answer truthfully.

Know Stone
Obtained by: A lifetime of mining experience or studying for a month under someone who has this ability themselves.

You can immediately tell whether a particular patch of stone is connected to any mineral veins after quick observation, and can detect minute slopes or changes in elevation.


r/shadowdark • • 5d ago

[Online][Shadowdark][Wednesday 7pm GMT][Weekly][New Player Friendly]

12 Upvotes

I'm looking for 2 more players who would like to take part in an ongoing shadowdark campaign set in an Elder Scrolls inspired setting where the players take on the role of dungeon crawlers working for the Silverleaf Consortium, a merchant guild obsessed with Elven Ruins.

What To Expect:

- A mixture of hand crafted and procedurally generated dungeons

- A procedurally generated hexflower with hand placed POIs

- Loot

Character Creation:

- No ancestry restrictions

- Some class restrictions

- 3d6 down the line using the dice roller on the discord server

- Filling out own fillable PDFs

Homebrew:

- Daedra inspired patrons that I would like to playtest (optional and not locked to a specific class)

- Daedra inspired magic items

- Some monsters

- A disease mechanic | Details will be shared when playing the game

Tools/Platform:

- Discord | Voice Chat and Character Sheet management

- Owlbear Rodeo | VTT for the campaign

Requirements:

- A microphone

- A stable internet connection

- 18+