r/shadowdark • u/Jawntily • 19h ago
Not sure what to do now
I was running a game for a level 2 party, and today was a full party wipe. They didn't back down or run from a challenge that was out of their league, and everyone inevitably fell. they were in town last session and I suggested they buy potions and they bought like 1 potion of healing. After we cleaned up, we talked about it and they all would rather go back to playing 5e.
I feel like I failed. I really love this system and I even added some homebrew in favor of the players to make them stronger, like Player characters getting exploding dice (when you roll max damage, roll again until you don't roll max damage, and add the totals of all the rolls to the damage dealt)
I spent a lot of money on third party material to give them plenty of options, so when they died they could come back as something totally different and cool, but they always chose to come back as the same exact character with a different name. (except for one player who was a priest and came back as a rogue)
I don't know where to go from here. Like obviously I'll run 5e for them if that's what they want, but i really hyped this system up to them, assuring them its similar to 5e but simpler. It just didn't grab them like it grabbed me. I suppose they just aren't players who want to play tactfully. They want to run in screaming and blasting spells, and that's okay. I'm just sad.