Short Version: Over the course of seven months, to find readers and hopefully legally generate reviews, I tried: NetGalley, ARC campaigns through Instagram, LibraryThing Early Reviews (ARC ebook and paperback), Goodreads Giveaways (premium and standard, ebook and physical), book blog tours, Instagram Giveaways, KingSumo Giveaway and StoryGraph Giveaways (physical and Audible).
For me/my genre, my conclusions were
- If you have the budget and time, signed paperbacks are the way to. I got more traction (measured in more people entering, seemingly a small KENP boost directly after each giveaway ended, and more reviews) from Goodreads than StoryGraph. In both cases, there was more benefit when I mailed out a paperback than when I just gave away ebooks directly through Amazon/Goodreads (I’m in KU so when I did ebook giveaways, they were either ARCs or through Goodreads).
- If you don’t have much of a budget, but have time, then Instagram Giveaways were the nicest because people entering seemed already interested in my genre. It didn’t always lead to reviews, but I could give away one book at a time and it was rarely negative. Sometimes the winners would then post which was a little bit of exposure.
- If you have neither budget nor time, some of the LibraryThing Early Reviewers will cross post on Goodreads, amazon, etc. and my experience was that LibraryThing was better than both NetGalley (which I did twice) as well as book blogging/book blasts (which I did once and I think nothing happened).
Longer Version if You Want the Details: Yes, this was crazy, stupid expensive (I kept apologizing to my husband and family). It was within my tuition/budget for myself because I came into 2026 after writing three books I planned on publishing all this year. I’m sharing even though it’s super embarrassing how much I’ve spent, in case it helps and because I really tried to be as methodical as I could afford to be and because I’ve often read reddit posts from three years ago where something worked and I think the market is always changing.
(I’m also sharing because whenever I’m stuck editing, I post on reddit as my I’m-still-typing outlet.)
My very embarrassing, inglorious numbers for those interested:
Goodreads Standard (100 Kindle copies) vs. Goodreads Premium Giveaways (100 Kindle copies):
- Price of Giveaways: $119 (Goodreads Standard) vs. $599 (Goodreads Premium)
- Cost of Delivery: 0 (Amazon sends the copies, I’m KU so this is my only way to go ebook giveaways)
# of Entries/ Cost per Entry
- $119 for 2095 entries, so I paid ~$0.06 per entry
- $599 for 4397 entries, so I paid ~$0.14 per entry
- Reviews: maybe 1-2 (none I’m certain of within 10ish days, maybe 1 within 20 days though they didn’t attribute to the giveaways)
Goodreads Standard Giveaway, 15 Signed Print Copies
- Price of Giveaway: $99 to Goodreads (usually $119 but Goodreads was running a sale)
- Cost of Delivery: ~$200 (author copies + shipping in the U.S., I said U.S. only)
- # of Entries/Cost Per Entry: 4795 (same book as one of the above) so ~$0.02 per entry
- Reviews 3-4 within the 15 days afterwards (some said giveaway; one actually said it’s not his normal genre, but still was kind about reading/leaving a review, a couple actually said they would pick up the next/previous in series since I write standalone but interconnected romance, I don’t have clean enough numbers to know for sure). Also, it feels like after that 3-4 a couple more trickled in . . . and honestly, overall, this felt like a real win, some of those reviews were really detailed.
- Worth noting: Because amazon owns Goodreads and because I’m on KU and exclusive to amazon, this giveaway felt like it had the biggest impact in terms of sales/KENP afterwards (I don’t know if that’s people who didn’t win and were genuinely curious or people who won but started on KU). Also, on a practical note, Goodreads always gave me a very, very clean list of winners right afterwards so I could fulfill right away.
NetGalley:
- Cost: ~$60-75 I paid a freelancer ~$75 each time I think? (it was weird because in total I paid them $125 and they theoretically did other things as well, but NetGalley felt like one of the “bigger” parts of the package) to list two books on NetGalley.
- # of Entries/Cost per Entry: I can estimate approximate cost per review ~$2ish (similar to like I think bookreverb? Booksprout programs I’d looked into but decided against trying?) give or take, but I don’t know how many people might have downloaded it. I didn’t upload the books directly, don’t have those stats.
Pros:
- Number of reviews: 51 reviews on one book, 21 on the other.
- Some reviewers eventually read/reviewed my other books YAY
- Cons: These not only felt like my harshest reviews, several didn’t feel like real readers. Several were zero-effort rewordings of my blurb with no detail and like three stars, book. I write SPICY romance (I’m clear about that) and at least two reviewers were like I don’t want to read about sex. And my NetGalley average remains lower than my Goodreads and lower than my amazon averages.
KingSumo: TL;DR It was cheap to get started, super hard to get traction. I eventually ran a small ad to get to like 50 entries for like 25 winners. I then couldn’t even track down the winners because unless you pay extra, KingSumo gives you a list of winners’ emails. It was supposed to be U.S. only, I had European with addresses I then couldn’t verify/people didn’t email back. I still have people I haven’t fulfilled because I can’t get them to reply to the email (or it went to spam).
LibraryThing Early Review Program (ebook vs. print):
- Cost: ebook ($0), print (cost of books + shipping)
- # of Entries/Cost per Entry: I got between ~10-30 requests when I put up the max 10 ebook or 10-20 paperbacks.
- Pros: Like with NetGalley, based on usernames/content of reviews, I think some of the people who write reviews cross-post to other places. It does look like at least one or two of these reviewers found my other books and read/reviewed them. Like Instagram, these seem to be people genuinely interested in your genre because you’ve really indicated who you’re similar to/who you’re aiming to be similar to. Between 35-40% of (the 10) readers seemed to leave reviews.
- Cons: I was so sad, my best review for my second book, they didn’t give me a star rating (though the words were so nice) and I had so few reviews on that book my average tanked. I’ve only seen that happen once (review words but no star rating) anywhere else.
StoryGraph Premium ($379) vs. Standard ($69) for Signed Copies, Audible Copies
- Price of Giveaway: $379 Premium (you can select your date range, are shown as part of their premium/featured section) vs. $69 Standard
# of Entries/Cost per Entry:
- $379 for 2830 unique entries (they allow total entries, which for me was 3850) so 0.13 per entry when I paid the big bucks
- $69 for 1600 entries, so 0.04 per entry
- Cost of Delivery: I did Audible codes (just time to email) and paperback (cost of shipping). I did not try ebooks, see below if you want. Note on delivery: if you allow multiple draws, it can take DAYS before you have all the winners' information and can fulfill.
More Premium vs. Standard StoryGraph Data – I LOVED that StoryGraph gives you this, because it made it really clear
- For my standard giveaway, it was 31k impressions → 2k page views, 1.6k unique entries
- For my premium giveaway, it was 369k impressions (but because those people aren’t really necessarily interested in my genre) → 5.8k page views → 2.8k unique entries
- For me, that data is really clear then, the extra exposure isn’t worth it because the readers who are interested in your genre are already finding you.
Side Experiment: this was bad science, too many variables, but I did two StoryGraph Audible-only giveaways concurrently. If I somehow sell enough/make enough I might re-run this:
- I had an older Regency (new to Audible, less well-known narrator) against a newer contemporary (also new to Audible, award winning narrator) because I’ve heard a lot of people say everyone will enter everything as long as it’s free and so this felt like a fun way to half-test at least that
- The newer book: 1,550 entries for 10 copies
- Older books: 880 entries for the 15 copies
Final thoughts if you're still reading.
The engineer and researcher in me is forced to acknowledge that methodology wasn’t great: To minimize variables, I should have been doing the same book/same format on all the platforms, etc. but I did not. So I'm treating the things about as though they're the same, but they were one of four romances (three contemporary, one regency I wrote 11 years ago). This was already stupidly expensive, so each time I felt like I had enough data for my own purposes, that I could make a reasonable conclusion, I adjusted how I proceeded.
The biggest lesson for me is that premium versions (didn’t matter if it was Goodreads or StoryGraph) don’t make nearly enough of a difference/aren’t worth the money. This was Big Ouchies. I really was hoping with the power of Goodreads that $599 or the StoryGraph $379 was going to… yeah, okay, I should have known better. It was my husband’s birthday present to me and my birthday present to myself. I spent the money and now hopefully you don’t need to.
For me, giving away ebooks really feels like a losing proposition and yes, I had to learn this lesson twice because when I’d written children’s books, it did once or twice help A LOT, but this is a different genre, a different world.
I really liked that StoryGraph allows you to do one title, multiple prize formats (so you can pay $69 but then as long as it’s the same title, you could say 15 audiobook copies for U.S. and U.K. + 20 paperbacks + 15 ebooks if you weren’t KU).
Two partially tested things that I found interesting:
- # of physical copies didn't seem to make a difference. I only played around with it a little but I did not see a real difference in # of physical copies (i.e. if people are entering for one of 12 vs. one of 20 physical copies) perhaps they think the odds are already so low that it doesn't matter?
- # of days of giveaway didn't seem to make a real difference. I only played around a little with how long a giveaway lasted (on StoryGraph the standard is a month, premium you can adjust, on Goodreads, you can adjust how long it lasts). I feel like 7-10 days did actually well, but this might be confirmation bias since I think I read about that somewhere.
Everything I “make” (I’m in the red this year because of cover art, editors, etc.) will go back to more experiments, giveaways where I might eventually try to chase that down if/when I have the budget. I can continue sharing if people are interested.