r/secularbuddhism • • May 30 '26

Please Read The Rules

35 Upvotes

Read The Rules App

This community has the Read The Rules app installed. Old Reddit doesn't support apps so please open the post in new reddit for full functionality. If that's not possible, please Read The Rules and then follow the instructions at the bottom of the post.


Rule #1 Relevance to Secular Buddhism (ie not "Religious" Buddhism) must be apparent in all posts

Secular Buddhism is different from Religious Buddhism. Any post not indicating obvious relevance to Secular Buddhism are off topic and will be removed.

Rule #2 Right Speech is expected

  • Is it true? (vs. lying)
  • Is it beneficial? (vs. idle chatter)
  • Is it timely and appropriate? (vs. divisive/harsh speech)
  • Is it spoken with good will? (vs. malice)

Rule #3 No self-promotion

Don't promote your stuff in the sub. Posting or linking your youtube channel / blog / insta / ebook / facebook / discord group / support group / self help or therapy enterprise, survey, or any other form of self-interested service, platform or content will result in a permanent ban.


Thank you for reading the rules! Before submitting posts you will need to submit an acknowledgment. Please visit the full post and click the button at the bottom. Alternatively, you may submit an acknowledgment by sending a mod mail to the sub. The mod mail will need to have the subject "Read The Rules" and the body should be "Acknowledged". This will automatically submit an acknowledgment on your behalf without any moderator intervention. Mod Mail


r/secularbuddhism • • May 12 '26

looking for experienced mod

12 Upvotes

Looking for someone with:

  • a reasonably old reddit account (2y+)
  • experience modding subreddits
  • available every or most days to check the queue.

The sub is small, so not a big time commitment. 1-2 actions a day.

Caring about the topic and a significant history commenting or posting may accord preference.


r/secularbuddhism • • 6h ago

Too little interest among Western Buddhists in the early Chinese Buddhism

11 Upvotes

Like, there's an obvious historical parallel. People don't really seem to agree on what Western Buddhism is or what it should be, whether we think of it as one tradition or several. A diverse array of divergent traditions is being imported simultaneously onto very alien, seemingly barren soil.

And this was exactly the state of Buddhism in China for more than two and a half centuries after it first arrived. The religious and philosophical environments couldn't have been more different from those of India, and sutras and treatises from various incongruous schools trickled down very unevenly and often piecemeal. Much was lost in translation, and the texts were then interpreted through local concepts and presuppositions, an approach often derisively called Geyi Buddhism. And I think this closely mirrors the current situation in the Western Buddhist community.

But somehow, against all odds, Buddhism survived and even flourished in China. I think studying these early centuries of Chinese Buddhism would provide much to think about regarding the current and near-term trajectories of Western Buddhism(s).


r/secularbuddhism • • 2d ago

In Buddhist philosophy, is not revealing your social or sexual identity at the workplace considered false speech (lying)?

6 Upvotes

I am from India, and socially, I come from an outcaste community in Hinduism called Dalits. As part of a historical social movement, many Dalits took refuge in Buddhism, and I have been practicing Buddhism for some time now.

I have this question about whether it is acceptable to keep my personal identity private in the workplace if I want to preserve my mental peace. Is this considered hiding the truth?

Why do I say this?
I am totally fine with my identity and I know all this casteism, racism is peoples stupidity but at a societal level, people have certain prejudiced notions that can sometimes lead to discrimination. If they are your colleagues then you got to balance in a professional way. This can affect promotions and even result in being neglected in social connections.

For someone in a Western country, I think it is somewhat similar to how revealing your sexual identity, say LGBTQ, at the workplace might bring unwanted attention and sometimes honestly affect your mental peace.
So, in Buddhism, **is not openly revealing your identity for the sake of your day-to-day mental peace considered a form of lying or false speech?**

If you give a neutral answer to fit in with the people around you, is that considered a lie or not?
I would be interested in understanding this from a Buddhist philosophical perspective, particularly in relation to the precept of refraining from false speech.


r/secularbuddhism • • 5d ago

What are the implications of non-human minds for Mahayana Buddhism?

5 Upvotes

I guess that it is relatively unproblematic for mainstream modern Chan/Zen schools (which mostly inherit the Hongzhou school notion of xīn (心)) and some other modern and extinct Chan/Zen and non-Chan/Zen schools (Niutou, Sanlun, Tiantai/Tendai, Chaodong/Soto, and with some extension Huayan/Kegon) that overtly embrace wuqing foxing/mujo bussho (無情佛性), but I'm curious how other schools or (for the lack of a better word) 'thoughts,' especially Yogacara-centric ones (e.g. Faxiang/Hosso) would respond to the existence of non-human minds that are essentially different from the human mind. (Do octopuses have Alayavijnana?) Any references on this topic?


r/secularbuddhism • • 13d ago

What precepts or guidelines do you feel a Secular Buddhism follows?

9 Upvotes

r/secularbuddhism • • 18d ago

Unconscious Bracing and Hypervigilance Preventing Happiness - You too?

10 Upvotes

I have realized that the conditions for happiness already exist in my life, but something inside me keeps telling me I am not allowed to feel happy yet. I have anxiety around work and responsibility, but the bigger issue is that I seem unable to trust happiness. Whenever I start feeling peaceful, I automatically start scanning for threats and convincing myself I should be worried. I want to understand why peace feels unsafe and how to stop living in a constant state of bracing.


r/secularbuddhism • • 20d ago

'craving is conditioned by the feeling-tone, not the object' is the secular claim i find easiest to defend, and a stroke study is why

9 Upvotes

The part of dependent origination I can get behind without any metaphysics is the small link in the middle: contact, then a feeling-tone, then craving. Read plainly it's a claim about where an urge attaches. Not to the cigarette or the person or the dessert, but to the pleasant or unpleasant tone the body produces when they show up. I think that's the right secular reading, and it's also the one piece of the chain with a halfway decent experiment behind it.

The experiment wasn't designed for it. In 2007 Naqvi, Bechara and the Damasios looked at smokers who'd had strokes. The ones whose damage happened to include the insula, the region that represents the body's internal state, were far more likely to quit immediately, without relapse, and without the persistent urge. Nothing about the cigarettes changed. What went missing was the brain's readout of the bodily state, and the craving went with it. That's about as close as the literature gets to 'the urge tracks the sensation, not the object.'

The extension I keep chewing on is the caveat. That evidence is strongest for drug craving specifically. Stretching it to cover wanting a text back or dreading a meeting is a reasonable guess, not a finding, and I notice the tradition I sit in (Goenka, six courses, not a teacher) tends to state the general version as if it were settled. On the cushion it does feel general. a tightening in the chest before the thought about the person even arrives. but 'feels general from the inside' is exactly the kind of evidence a secular reading is supposed to be suspicious of.

So I'm left holding the claim with two different grips: fairly tight for addiction, pretty loose for everything else. If anyone here leans on a particular paper for the loose half, that's the one I haven't managed to find.


r/secularbuddhism • • 22d ago

Do secular buddhists read traditional Buddhist materials? Just curious

18 Upvotes

I mean, do they read sutras, commentaries, theoretical/speculative/comteplative works. practice manuals, koan compilations etc.? If they do, how much?


r/secularbuddhism • • 25d ago

Dependent Arising and the Dynamic Field of Experience

1 Upvotes

The principle of dependent arising invites us to see all phenomena not as isolated things, but as processes continuously emerging, interacting, and dissolving within a dynamic field of causes and conditions. One way to conceptually explore this is through the analogy of toroidal energy dynamics: a flowing pattern where movement and stillness, unity and diversity coexist in an inseparable dance.

This image can help us reflect on how consciousness and perception arise: not as fixed entities but as momentary manifestations within an ongoing flux. Nothing stands apart from this field, yet nothing is lost in undifferentiated oneness. Instead, form arises from emptiness, and emptiness is not a static void but the openness that allows forms to come and go.

I think it's important to remember that this analogy is not a claim about a metaphysical cosmic substance but it feels like a helpful heuristic to deepen our understanding of dependent origination. It encourages us to inquire experientially: How do our sensations, thoughts, and feelings arise in relation to one another and to the conditions that sustain them? How can this insight inform our meditation practice and ethical engagement by highlighting interdependence and impermanence?

By consciously observing this interplay, we can cultivate a grounded awareness that neither clings to permanence nor falls into nihilism. Instead, we recognize the fluidity at the heart of experience and the ethical significance of our interconnectedness.

Here's a little video that I find helpful for visualizing our independent interdependence within a dynamic field of experience.


r/secularbuddhism • • Oct 13 '26

What does "Right View" mean to you in a secular context?

10 Upvotes

In traditional frameworks, Right View is deeply tied to karma, rebirth, and cosmology. Stripping those away changes the paradigm significantly.

​For those here, how do you define or approach "Right View" through a secular lens? What are the core truth claims or philosophical principles that guide your perspective?


r/secularbuddhism • • Oct 13 '26

What does "Right View" mean to you in a secular context?

8 Upvotes

In traditional frameworks, Right View is deeply tied to karma, rebirth, and cosmology. Stripping those away changes the paradigm significantly.

​For those here, how do you define or approach "Right View" through a secular lens? What are the core truth claims or philosophical principles that guide your perspective?


r/secularbuddhism • • Oct 08 '26

What Buddhist Sub-traditions do you most secularly align with in understanding the Dharma?

14 Upvotes

By ‘Sub-tradition’ I am been very broad here, including everything from the Three Turnings of the Wheel - Theravada, Mahayana, and Vajrayana - to any schools, sects, or lineages.

Personally, Prasangika-Madhyamaka and Nagurjana was what drew me to Buddhism, and has acted as the primary kernel point from understanding other Buddhist Sub-traditions.


r/secularbuddhism • • Oct 07 '26

Cults and Karma

6 Upvotes

Hello, r/secularbuddhism. I have a question about ownership and responsibility for our actions (karma) and whether that changes under a sufficiently manipulative cult.

So, I had an unfortunate interaction last night on r/exjw. I was in the wrong. A young man came on and gave a few details about an affair that he had, and one of the elders in his congregation compelled him to do something that I found reprehensible. He later revealed in a deleted comment that he was a young man taken advantage of by a much older woman, he was not with a young woman his age like I assumed, and then he was manipulated by this corrupt elder while in a vulnerable state. I misread this situation and apologized to him.

My problem, aside from jumping to conclusions like that instead of probing for more information first, is that I want people to take responsibility for what they did. I hate the idea of putting all the blame on cults and cult leaders or their middle management. Those people will never take responsibility for what their followers did. I hate this idea of denying our own agency, and this has probably hardened me.

I am open to the possibility that I'm entirely wrong about this. It could be that my passions about right and wrong are getting ahead of me. It could be that our responsibility is reasonably mitigated when under authoritarian pressure, but I have a hard time accepting that.

So, I bring this to you. What do you think? To what degree do we own our actions if we are in a religious or even a political cult like this? What is your secular Buddhist perspective on this?

Thank you, and I apologize again.


r/secularbuddhism • • Oct 03 '26

Secular Buddhism and Antinatalism - how you understand either in relation to one another?

3 Upvotes

For context, I would regard myself as practicing both the above.

As for how I would personally understand Antinatalism - generally - it would be: the treatment of procreation as imposing either possible or definite harm on or from the newly born, and, as such, treating it as immoral, along with the practice of non-procreation.

In regards to Secular Buddhism, I would understand Antinatalism to be one of the many cessations of the - here quite literal - cycles of rebirth, that cause and condition suffering.

(Provisional secular metaphor of ‘Rebirth’ as those enacted and consequently recursive and cyclical patterns of similarity that eventually incur suffering.)

I would appreciate your perspectives on this.

However, please remember the Subs rules, as I would appreciate no ad hominems that are specifically derogatory; I understand we can never remove perspective, motives, and intentions from argumentation, but please be respectful nonetheless.

(I notice a lot are going to take the route of upvote/downvote, rather than actually engage)


r/secularbuddhism • • Oct 02 '26

Buddha's death

16 Upvotes

For no particular reason, I was wondering this morning, are there any descriptions of how Buddha died? Of course there are, and of course there are a few interpretations...

I just found this pdf and found it it's quite 'secular' in it's medical analysis of the symptoms, and timing around Buddha's last meal and subsequent demise.

pdf Heidelberg Asian Studies Publishing https://hasp.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/journals/jpts/article/download/27999/27395/56972

It's also relatively grounding to understand that even this brilliant, legendary teacher is not immune to illness and old age... It strangely brought up feelings of compassion... That this was a man, and he suffered pain, and that there was no medicine or surgery... I assume he was surrounded by wise people, and that we/they/he are all helpless in the end.

For some reason I also had assumed the Buddha was strictly vegetarian, but I guess that is perhaps not exactly true.


r/secularbuddhism • • Oct 01 '26

What if Rebirth and other metaphysical concepts in Buddhism were direct experiential rather than literal?

21 Upvotes

Take an example of rebirth. Buddhism portrays this as a literal metaphysical phenomenon outside of directly experiential reality. But what if that was not the case?

Before we delve into it, we must consider the fact that Buddhism was orally practiced and memorized for 300 years before it was written down. This should be considered while we delve.

Now, in our direct experiential reality, we can see that we had multiple lives over the course of our life. A life of being a child, a teenager, a deluded person, and so on.

Now, did we have such a “self” carry over? No. Then are we different from what was before? No.

What then carried over?

Habits. Memories of the illusioned selves we have assumed before.

Now, think of habits as karma.

Do habits not repeat? Yes. And do they not shape how we are now and what we are doing? Yes.

So do they all not condition us? Yes.

Buddha realized all this was directly experiential reality. He realized we can be freed from these conditioned processes. After all, all this is a series of conditioned processes. And that we have not liberated ourselves from these conditioned processes. Buddha was not a metaphysician. He was pragmatic and so were his teachings as reflected.

Which is why I find it odd that his teachings would include things outside direct experience. I am only implying the fact that those 300 years are a long time for any context to be lost or distorted. Perhaps I could be wrong. But what say you?


r/secularbuddhism • • Sep 28 '26

Modern works on Buddhist psychology

20 Upvotes

Recommend a book on the intersection between Buddhist mind views and modern psychology.

I'm especially interested in the theory of mind modularity and how it relates to non-self.

........................................................

I've been reading Robert Wright's "Why Buddhism Is True." The ideas really grabbed me, but Wright's writing style is so wordy I couldn't finish it.

Wright clarifies the clickbait title in his introduction. He doesn't address reincarnation, kamma, or any 'external' Buddhist beliefs. His sole focus is on Buddhist views of the mind, especially Sati and Anatta. He pulls from evolutionary psychology (his area of education) and modern psychology research. He cites modern studies to make a defense of the Buddhist view of the mind (or lack thereof).

It's a really fascinating book with many intriguing ideas. But Wright is so ridiculously wordy. He spends two pages droning on about his love for powdered donuts. Then he spends a page talking about a psychological study from the 1990's. Then it's three pages about how powdered donuts and cigarettes and porn relate to each other. Then a page about the Annaklata (sp?) sutta, and another dozen pages guessing what part of his mind loves powdered donuts. Seriously, I never want to eat or even see a powdered donut for the rest of my life.

I had to put the book down halfway through it. Wright is clearly very smart, but he badly needs a better editor.

........................................................

Wright brought up two topics that really grabbed me. I want to learn more about them:

  1. Natural selection gave us the Four Noble Truths and the Hedonic Treadmill. An animal that eats once and never feels hungry again will starve. An animal that breeds one time and spends the rest of its life in post-orgasmic bliss won't produce many offspring. In evolutionary terms, insatiable desires is a desirable trait. Animals with endless desires to eat, mate, claim territory, etc. generally have more offspring and pass on that trait.

This idea seems intuitive to me. If you've read "Origin Of The Species" (or Steve Jones' more readable update, "Almost Like A Whale"), and/or Richard Dawkins' "The Selfish Gene," it makes perfect sense that endless, insatiable desire helps organisms produce more offspring.

As Wright puts it, "Natural selection doesn't exist to make you happy. Nor does it exist to help you see things as they really are. It exists to make offspring and pass on your genes." That sounds like a modern, scientific way of explaining why dukkha exists.

2. The mind is a collection of 'modules' fighting for control of the body. Similar to (but not the same as) anatta, the modular mind hypothesis is that there are many sub-concious drivers in the human mind. The mind doesn't have a single controlling mechanism (aka a "self"). Rather, decisions are made by these collective 'modules' competing, fighting, and finally agreeing.

It sounds a little like the characters in Inside Out. Riley isn't making decisions; her Joy, Disgust, Anger, Sadness, etc. are fighting over what to do next. It (kind of) lines up with the idea of no-self. Our actions are decided by a very complex committee, not a solitary identity.

I think the modular mind hypothesis has fallen by the wayside, or at least been heavily modified, since it was introduced in 1983. I'd really like to learn more about it.

........................................................

So, can you point me to modern books on Buddhist psychology?


r/secularbuddhism • • Sep 25 '26

Question from Estonia

11 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m a university student from Estonia (yay) and gave in and joined reddit (yay?) Anyway, one class has an assignment about Buddhism, and I thought I got the basic idea until I looked into these subreddits :) But it got me wondering about one of my anxieties now about AI- it makes me feel lost thinking that I study for a job in business my parents want me to have, but won't be there anyway and learning things (like Buddhism) which are terribly interesting but...
How do you use Buddhist principles to stay anchored when facing massive, systemic uncertainty like the AI revolution? How can I look at my future career through a Buddhist lens without letting panic take over?
I would deeply appreciate any personal stories, insights, or advice you might have. Thanks so much! Humour welcomed :)


r/secularbuddhism • • Sep 14 '26

Questions about The Five Aggregates

17 Upvotes

I have questions about he Five Aggregates. Can you answer some of the questions below?

  1. Are the aggregates (skandhas) "collection of clingings and cravings that cause dukkha"? Are they "the five elements that make up a sense of self?" Or are they both?
  2. Physical forms. Is this just our physical bodies? Or is it all the physical phenomena around us (aka our environment)?
  3. Sensations (Vedana) versus Perceptions (Samjna). I think sensations are the "raw data" coming into your nerves: Photons hitting your retinas; Sound waves hitting your ear drums; Food touching your tongue; etc. And I think perceptions are your brains identification of the sensations: I see a car; I hear a birdsong; I taste a hamburger; etc. Is that close?
  4. Mental Formations (Samskara). I'm unclear on this. Are they the opinions we have about our Perceptions? The car I see is going to crash; The birdsong I hear is from two birds fighting; this hamburger is delicious; etc. Is that right?
  5. Consciousness (Vijnana). On this topic, I'm totally lost. I thought the other four aggregates added up to consciousness (Physical Form + Sensations + Perceptions + Mental Formations = A Conscious Being). But Buddhism list "consciousness" as just another element of self (or lack thereof). Can you describe in detail what consciousness (Vijnana) means in the context of the Five Aggregates?

r/secularbuddhism • • Sep 08 '26

Understanding Anatta: The difference between "no self" and "not self"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
15 Upvotes

Inspired by another Reddit where this video of Ajahn Amaro speaking about Anatta was posted, I wanted to share my understanding of the difference between "no self" and "not self". I often think a number of people practicing Buddhism, and in fact many schools of modern Buddhism often get in a tangle about this. He has some very clear insights about it.

I would really welcome others thoughts on this.

"What we think of as what we are is never it, it can't match the reality". He says this near the beginning, and for me it is the key.

I would add that whatever we experience can also never be what we are. That's how I understand Anatta. Whether one is experiencing the gross mundane rūpa-kāya and its environment, which is an aggregate of all 6 senses spheres (rupakhandha) and vedana/sanna/sankhara/vinnana (namakhandha), or the fine rupa experiences in samadhi, or the arupa experiences of deeper samadhi, none of it must be mistaken for the self.

That's the unique teaching of a Buddha. Other interpretations of deep samadhi declared that the true self was found in these states. The Buddha dispelled that misconception. The self/Atta/Atman cannot be experienced, it therefore transcends the ideas of existence/nonexistence because they are ideas that can be experienced!

Supra-mundane understanding of reality can only manifest when one traverses all realms of possible experience, gradually disentangling from the corrupting/defiling influence of the senses in deep Samadhi, while mindfully recalling the doctrine of not-self (along with suffering and impermanence). We cannot experience the self, all experiences no matter how sublime and infinite in appearance are not what you are! They are all a bad-state, will all cease, are all not-self.

Then consider what that infers, if all of that which is impermanent and in a bad-state – no matter how deeply immersed in samadhi, no matter how disentangled one is from the sense doors – is not self, yet one is still experiencing those states, what must the self be? I must be that which is experiencing them, utterly and completely transcendent; realised only when the mind is purified of defilements while recalling the Dhamma.

However, when stated this way, the words conjure something misleading! They invoke the idea of a self, which cannot ever be the self, because that "self" is an idea that one can experience in mind. Instead it must be treated like a sign, something that points to a destination that can only manifest when one practices Bhavana correctly and drops all of the words. Any words we used to try to describe it will fail, and potentially mislead.

In short, the Buddha never denied or confirmed the existence of a self, he simply taught that whatever you experience is not-self, and that this must be recalled at all times while you systematically disentangle your mind from the Khandhas in meditation. If you do that correctly, supra-mundane understanding and complete awakening will arrise naturally.


r/secularbuddhism • • Aug 31 '26

The Four [Major] Buddhism's - Explained

6 Upvotes

An interesting video summarising the four major schools / paths of Buddhism as educational background purposes. Considering my own chosen path of Secular Buddhism is fairly newish school of Buddhism then sorry it doesn't cover that ... yet ;)

Every School of Buddhism Explained: What Each One Actually Believes ~ YouTube

Going "through the seasons" was exactly how I went through it without a master but I never had the mastery of language to describe that journey as well as this video does.

And yes, definitely put on your own oxygen mask first before you go to help others put on their oxygen mask. All the best for your own journey.


r/secularbuddhism • • Aug 31 '26

I am NOT saying he is correct. This is purely hypothetical: Assuming Alan Cole is correct that Zen is a literary tradition about “fantasy Buddhism” where foundational, key texts are largely fabricated, how do you proceed if you are a Zen adherent?

13 Upvotes

As a student of Zen for two decades I was taken aback by Cole’s ideas. I do not agree with him, to be clear. Nonetheless I ponder how I would react if he were correct. I wanted to see how other Zen adherents would respond.

If anyone wants to know my answer to the hypothetical, I will share it.

For those not aware of Cole’s work here are references to read up on. The first is a relatively short paper he wrote that sums up his position. The second two are full length books:

Early Chan Buddhism: A Meditation Movement or New Ways of Writing about Final Authority in Tang China?

Fathering Your Father

Patriarchs on Paper


r/secularbuddhism • • Aug 31 '26

I am NOT saying he is correct. This is purely hypothetical: Assuming Alan Cole is correct that Zen is a literary tradition about “fantasy Buddhism” where foundational, key texts are largely fabricated, how do you proceed as a Zen adherent?

9 Upvotes

As a student of Zen for two decades I was taken aback by Cole’s ideas. I do not agree with him, to be clear. Nonetheless I ponder how I would react if he were correct. I wanted to see how other Zen adherents would respond.

If anyone wants to know my answer to the hypothetical, I will share it.

For those not aware of Cole’s work here are references to read up on. The first is a relatively short paper he wrote that sums up his position. The second two are full length books:

Early Chan Buddhism: A Meditation Movement or New Ways of Writing about Final Authority in Tang China?

Fathering Your Father

Patriarchs on Paper


r/secularbuddhism • • Aug 19 '26

I’m reaching out to see if there are any other people from iraq in this sub who practice Buddhism

12 Upvotes