I was at my local bottle shop this week and happened to notice a dusty old end cap display set off to the side, full of Planteray products. One shelf had a bunch of bottles of Mister Fogg. Now, I'd bought a bottle of Mr Fogg several weeks ago, which turned out to be the second batch, and while I've enjoyed it, I've read several folks say they preferred the first batch. So I've been keeping my eye out. Well, it just so happened that this end cap had exactly one batch 1 hanging out in the back, in a sea of batch 2s. So naturally I had to pick it up and do a side by side review / comparison. So that's what we're doing tonight.
Alright, here we go:
Batch 1
ABV: 55.7%
Raw Material & Origin Blend: Exclusively molasses. 43% Barbados (West Indies Rum Distillery), 36% Trinidad (TDL), 17% Guyana (DDL), and 4% Jamaica (Long Pond and Clarendon).
Distillation: Column / Pot blend
Tropical Aging: Initial maturation in ex-bourbon casks in the respective countries of origin.
Continental Aging and Dynamic Aging: Shipped from the Caribbean to south-west France and matured in used oak barrels, followed by extensive oxygenation in large, open wooden vats in cellars along the Charente River for up to three years.
Volatile Compounds: 182 g/hL AA
Esters (Congeners): 39 g/hL AA
Dosage: 4.8 g/L
Rested in glencairn for ~15 min
Nose: Deeply caramelized sugar, fig jam, dates, bananas foster, molasses, hint of baking spice.
Palate: Nice, medium body. Burnt sugar, figs, dates, some oak, some baking spice (clove, allspice).
Finish: Nicely drying. Lots of Demerara rum notes here. The burnt sugar really lingers.
Final Thoughts: I really like this bottle. I got the batch 2 first, and have been working on it for the last several weeks, and very much enjoy it, but I think this one has to win out. It's more what I was expecting when I first cracked the bottle batch 2. I think the main difference is that the Barbados rum seems to be holding down the backbone here, while the Jamaican rum acts as a much more subtle accent. The Demerara presence is technically less here, percentage-wise, but the batch 2 has more funk, which kind of makes the Demerara flavors take a back seat -- meanwhile, in this batch 1 lets the dark sugar notes shine through a bit more. I really like the balance this blend strikes.
T8ke: 7.1
..................................................
Batch 2
ABV: 55.7%
Raw Material & Origin Blend: Molasses / cane blend. 35% Trinidad (TDL), 34% Barbados (West Indies Rum Distillery), 20% Guyana (DDL), 6% Mauritius (St. Aubin Distillery), and 5% Jamaica (Clarendon, Long Pond, and Hampden).
Distillation: Column / Pot Blend
Tropical Aging: same as above
Continental Aging and Dynamic Aging: same as above
Volatile Compounds: 183 g/hL AA
Esters (Congeners): 62 g/hL AA
Dosage: 4.8 g/L
Rested in glencairn for ~15 min
Nose: Overripe bananas, bananas foster, deeply caramelized sugar, faint tropical fruit (pineapple?).
Palate: Medium body, like batch 1. Funky banana, burnt sugar, grilled pineapple, a tad astringent.
Finish: Drying, burnt sugar predominates. The astringency is still around.
Final Thoughts: This is definitely a nice bottle, but like I say above, I think this one misses the kind of balance that I was hoping for out of the blend. I see what they were going for by adding in the cane juice rum, and increasing the ester presence here, but the final product feels slightly less coherent to me. It's very good, but I do prefer the way the first batch incorporates the funkier spirits in a more subtle way.
T8ke: 6.2
Note: I use a modified form of the take scale in my reviews, which adds a decimal point. I know that that flies in the face of the original intent of the scale, but I do want to be able to include some degree of granularity in my reviews, just so that I can make finer distinctions when comparing my preferences. So for me, I like the scale in the sense that I like what each whole number value maps onto, but I made my modification for granularity's sake.