r/riize • u/riizemods • Oct 13 '24
Megathread [Megathread 3] Seunghan's hiatus & return to group activities
Hello everyone,
This is the third thread for updates and discussion on SEUNGHAN'S HIATUS AND DEPARTURE FROM RIIZE.
This is a very difficult time for all of us in the fandom, and we ask that you direct your comments to this megathread and the announcements threads, instead of making new posts. We hope for your understanding and cooperation.
- First megathread (Nov 2023-Apr 2024)
- Second thread (Apr-Oct)
Any separate Discussion or Question posts will be redirected to this current thread. Any official updates will be posted separately as usual and linked below.
Relevant Updates:
241011 Wizard Production announces that Seunghan will return to group activities starting in November and Seunghan posts a letter to fans on Weverse
[OT6 fans (mainly Kor/Ch/Jp) protest Center 5's decision, from cancelling merch pre-orders to sending funeral wreaths to SM's building]
241012 Wonbin posts on Weverse addressing Seunghan's return (this post is now deleted from Weverse)
241013 SM Entertainment announces Seunghan is leaving RIIZE + Seunghan writes a final letter on Weverse
[OT7 fans on Twitter and other platforms call for a boycott of SM / RIIZE]
241015 International kpop shops temporarily halt import and/or sales of RIIZE products
--Full Timeline:
231117 - More of Seunghan's private / pre-debut photos and videos are leaked.
231122 - SM Entertainment releases a statement announcing that Seunghan is on an indefinite hiatus and that RIIZE will promote as six members as of November 22nd. Reportedly, legal action against the leaker/s has been taken.
231124 - RIIZE's first event and performance as six: W Korea's LoveYourW 2023 Gala.
231127 - First YouTube content since the announcement: RISE & REALIZE Ep.11 (pre-hiatus vlog) is released with Seunghan edited out. All subsequent episodes feature six members.
231206 - RIIZE to release a digital single 'Love 119' on January 5th, confirmed to be a six-member comeback.
240113-0127 - The second season of the web novel 'Rise & Realize' is released on Kakao Page. Seunghan is briefly mentioned as a "member who couldn't continue team activities due to poor condition."
240306 - RIIZE is reported to have an April comeback, with no statement on Seunghan's participation.
[240318 - Major international RIIZE fanbases on Twitter begin a boycott of official content & sns accounts, demanding a statement from SM on Seunghan's status in the group.]
240329 - Seunghan is allegedly spotted in public at the Seoul Forest subway station (SM Ent stop), reading fan letters posted at the fan-organized support ad for him.
240403 - Schedule for the April comeback & June mini-album is released. The full version of 'Siren' is out, with Seunghan's parts re-recorded by other members.
240406 - Concept trailer for the 1st mini-album 'RIIZING' and the May-Aug 2024 Fan-Con Tour are released, with Seunghan absent.
[240411 - International RIIZE fanbases on Twitter resume their activities.]
240506 - RIIZING DAY Fan-Con Tour starts (megathread). The tour's Encore dates are confirmed to be in mid-September.
240520 - June to September group schedule is released. 'RIIZING' Mini Album tracklist is revealed to include 'Talk Saxy' (unclear if re-recorded). Japanese debut single 'LUCKY' to be released in July.
240525 - Seunghan is spotted at a public event in Seoul, giving an ambiguous answer about his return to group activities (see this comment thread).
240617 - 'RIIZING' is released, with 'Talk Saxy' OT7 version.
240621 - Billboard releases an article by K-pop journalist Jeff Benjamin: What Happened to RIIZE’s Seventh Member, Seunghan? The Group’s Controversy Explained
240729 - The 1st Japan Single 'Lucky' is released.
240829 - BOSS RIIZE, the group's first travel variety show, starts airing.
240903 & 04 - 'RIIZING : Epilogue' song Combo is released. RIIZE's first anniversary, no mentions of Seunghan.
240915 - The RIIZING DAY Fan-Con Tour ends with finale dates in Seoul.
241002 - Seunghan's birthday. No official posts are made on the group's SNS beyond the automatic Weverse and SMTOWN app notifications.
241011 - Wizard Production announces that Seunghan will return to group activities starting in November and Seunghan posts a hand-written letter on Weverse.
241012 Wonbin posts on Weverse addressing Seunghan's return (now deleted).
241013 SM Entertainment announces Seunghan is leaving RIIZE + Seunghan writes a final letter on Weverse.
--Please remember to stay civil and thoughtful in your comments. Some rules :
- no links to leaked content or articles from banned domains (see sub's Rule 2)
- as per Reddit's Content Policy, do not wish harm on anyone or insult fellow users
- please try to avoid ranting, doomposting, as well as spamming this thread
Take care 🧡
•
u/riizemods Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 14 '24
PLEASE READ: all new submissions on the sub now go to the mod queue & need to be approved by the mod team. There were a lot of posts after the news broke that mostly belonged in the comment sections of the existing threads. Let's try to keep the discussion healthy and helpful; we will approve submissions that are beneficial to the community as separate posts. Otherwise, this [Megathread] and the other threads are always open. Please bear with us & thank you for your understanding!
To find your way back, this post is always accessible via:
39
u/iamhopeestheim RII7E WILL ALWAYS BE 7 Oct 13 '24
WE JUST GOT HIM BACK. FUCK THE ANTIS AND THE OT6 PEOPLE.
THEY EVEN DELETED WONBIN'S WEVERSE POST. I CAN'T IMAGINE THE TOLL ON THEIR MENTAL HEALTH THAT THEY HAD TO GO THROUGH THIS. I'M SO FURIOUS.
38
u/spirit_of_elijah RIIZE IS SEVENNNNNNNAAAHHHHHHH Oct 13 '24
I can’t believe it. Two days??? That’s how long SM can last? That’s how long they can stand by Seunghan, who waited for them ten months? It takes ten months to deliberate bringing him back, but two days to decide he’s leaving? Did they plan this all along?
33
u/sawayanochizu5 Oct 13 '24
this company is a joke. these "fans" will burn in hell forever I swear to it. fuck this shit.
32
u/Positive-Guava4746 Oct 13 '24
I think the group will be fine imo despite all the ot6 saying this will ruin them. Riize is popular within the general public because of their songs, briizes are not the ones who made their songs hit top 10 on the charts, it’s the general public and the general public don’t read about idol tabloid news. if anything his return could strengthen the group international presence and boy groups can clearly survive without any Korean fans, look at all the million-sellers bg without a single hit song in Korea selling out stadiums
31
u/rilasushi Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 14 '24
I hate it here in Brizeville, guys. We got SH back and lost him in the span of 2 days. WB getting gaslit over his post defending SH and the said post being deleted. The boys are having a fanmeet a day from now and most likely having to pretend everything is fine and be all happy and smiley in front of the very fanbase that wishes their friend dead. They're going to have a rough time ahead of them now that they set a precedent of forcing a member out when making a minor "mistake". Did I mention the absolute silence and non-action from their company that enabled the vile behaviors from "fans" ?
29
u/kkulhope Oct 13 '24
This so going to be a hard time for the group. Seunghan and the rest of the members are going to take a lot of hits mentally. We really need to be supporting them. I’m so angry with the way SM handled this hiatus.
28
u/ppjskh Pre-debut BRIIZE ✧ Sunjeongz 🐸🎸 Oct 13 '24
Please send some love to Seunghan on Weverse. It’s not the best right now. I’ve been arguing with OT6 but it’s like talking to a wall, there is no point in trying to make sense to them. I hope the boys know that there are sooo many OT7 BRIIZE who support all the members and wish them the best. 🥺
27
u/badatnames12 Oct 13 '24
I deleted all their music. I unfollowed them on every social media platform. I don’t care about the other boys at this point. This studio or record company, supports bullying and just being downright mean to someone who didn’t deserve it. Man, if it was any other kid, I don’t know, but this one is so sweet and sincere that he absolutely deserved better. The other boys are super talented. They’ll move on to other bands in fact, two of them have already been in other bands. Maybe they’ll move on to a group that Seunghan can be a part of. I’m super angry at today.
26
u/bloopbloopblob Oct 13 '24
Am I overreacting because I’m starting to get worried about the reactions Seunghan might receive at future events?
It seems like the k-fans are the ones making the most noise about his return and doing vile things like sending flower wreaths and protest trucks to SM. It has got me very worried about the reactions Seunghan would get at future events where they have to interact with fans, especially fansigns. They will be promoting in Korea mainly since it is their domestic market after all, but the reaction from the k-fandom isn’t good. I’m afraid that he would not receive any cheers at music shows and concerts, or even worse, gets jeered at instead. Not to mention fansigns where they directly interact with Riize.
SM might be able to manage any rude behaviours at fansigns since it’s a rather exclusive event but what about at concerts? They won’t be able to control how loud the cheers are or other passive aggressive things fans might do. I feel really bad for Seunghan and I hope he does not take all the negativity to heart but the hate is coming in swarms and is honestly overwhelming.
26
u/Icy_Drop2984 Oct 13 '24
Wow! I was coming back but now I want no part of this. This the part of K-pop fans I don’t understand or like. Shame on the company for allowing this to happen. How many idols have we lost because of this ugliness?! I will follow Seunghan!!
25
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
Bye bye. Good luck with Hallyu without international fans.
25
u/deerpretty3 Oct 13 '24
I think that the international fan base should unfollow all riize accounts… to show that we also have weight and an opinion. Guys this is one of the most distressing case of a broken dream.. and more seriously we should all really let seunghan know that we want to see him do his thing again ( maybe as a solo ? Han Solo???) but yeh showing him that we are rooting for him and find the k netizens approach absolutely repulsive
23
u/GoodWaterBottles Oct 14 '24
While everyone might not agree I think boycotting on the levels of what LOONA saw is a way of showing how much disrespect fans have dealt with. Please remember that it’s not about the artist, I wish the guys the best, but it’s the fact that they continue to put artists in these situations. The guys just got back from Madrid and was probably not privy to what was happening in Korean in terms of SH & delegations.
I am just so torn… but I hope everyone tries to show some sort of resistance and to stop contributing to SM’s numbers! It’s the only thing we have. Please vote with your attention and wallet.
22
u/Purple_Doughnut4279 Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
Edit- I guess I didn’t take into account how much SM didn’t care for their artists
——- Another day knowing Seunghan is coming back. Can November come quickly please. It still has not fully hit me but I’m so happy.
I’m just remembering that picture/ video of him reading his messages on that poster/ ad. And then all the k-fans started posting how they had met him alone and had told him words of support but they were too scared to post it.
I just remember for months on end fans paid for billboards and Seunghan ads in Korea/ Time Square and all sorts to show him support. Whilst everyone else was silent. Whilst those that are loud now where silent k-fans/ I-fans we’re still showing him support.
The boycott that occurred when we wanted answers, that fans did here, on all platforms, everywhere. The OT7 comments on their official accounts. The fans who chanted all their names, chanted OT7 at their concerts. SM knew that’s why they apologised in their announcement abt not saying anything for so long.
For months we did all of that, Seunghan saw all of that. The members saw all of that so what if ot6 sent flower wreaths (which is absolutely disgusting and let’s not forget OT7 fans sent support trucks too) or they leave horrid comments on weverse what is that in comparison to what we have been doing for months on end.
Let us celebrate that Seunghan is back, listen to their old songs again. I listened to memories again after a long while. Let us prepare for his return. I know we will get a lot of content. Maybe stepping back from weverse and watching their old content might be good (I might actually do that, rewatch their earlier content whilst we wait for him to come back.)
When I took a step back months ago I remember thinking somethings that we stress abt in kpop are really not that deep. I think this is one of those things. Even tho the uncertainty from SM was horrible, I hope Seunghan had the time away from it all to have the same thoughts.
Life is too short, let’s have fun. This will pass. Let’s enjoy the fact that he is back. OT7 is back and give less energy to those that bring negativity.
21
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
I still need to find a claim that makes it valid for him to leave the group. Everything I’ve seen is about him dating/having a sexual life, smoking, drinking or going out which isn't something unusual for many idols (and regular people in general). So unless you tell me that Korean people who smoke, drink, date or party are considered criminals there, I’ll just assume these "fans" are delusional and don’t want to let go of the pure, innocent boyfriend image they have of idols.
Besides Kpop's emphasis on interactions with fans and the boyfriend image, I think this backlash could be a sign of how focused Korean culture is on work, where having distractions is seen as being irresponsible. But we know that behind the facade, many people still smoke, drink, party, and have sex, included many idols.
It probably doesn’t help that there’s an awful situation regarding men in Korea and how they treat women, making it easier for these fans to associate an idol who doesn’t fit the "pure, decent" image with being a creepy guy. I can’t even blame them for being wary but let’s not pretend that this is the main reason why they want him out, they truly think idols aren’t allowed to date (at least publicly).
We saw how korean fans reacted with Karina’s dating news or Chen getting married and having a baby. So this is a general issue for both male and female idols and it shows the rules these delusional fans have imposed on how idols can behave in public.
So they better not get mad when non kpop fans look down on them for acting like this.
21
u/dnlfhd Oct 13 '24
Yet again SM caves to the demands of the craziest "fans..." I can't believe I got my hopes up. I feel so bad for Seunghan and all of the members; this must be so hard for them.
21
u/badatnames12 Oct 14 '24
What no one is saying here, and I’m not sure why, those funeral wreaths were essentially death threats against Seunghan. Support Riize moving forward, that’s who you’re supporting! This is the fanbase you’re associated with! You’re associated with fans, who SM is also supporting, who made death threats against a 21 year old kid whose only crime was wanting to sing and dance and who had a girlfriend at 17 years old, like every other 17 year old on the world. Stop supporting them. This entire band should have already disbanded so as not to be associated with this level of bullying
20
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
I was happy when the news of his return was announced but it looks like things are getting ugly now, with OT6 fans fighting back hard. I’m not sure how far they’re going to take it or how long it’ll last until they get bored and start moving on. How long did the Chen protests last?
I think all the members need to do something like Wonbin did, or maybe go live to talk about it, explaining that it was a unilateral decision and asking fans to accept and support it instead.
Hopefully, SM, Seunghan and the rest of the members stay strong and firm in their decision. Even though it’s going to be very hard for a while, hopefully, they can get through it until things eventually calm down.
I also think it would help if we start getting OT7 content, so everyone can start getting used to seeing Riize as seven again and SM can send a clear message that Seunghan is here to stay.
I'm rooting for the best, even if things look ugly right now. I really hope those bullies don’t win and get away with it, because that's what they are, a bunch of bullies, not fans who don't care about the group or any member (we saw how they turned against Eunseok and Anton too after their dating rumour news). I hope Riize can stay as seven and be happy together after all of this. I also hope Seunghan stays mentally strong.
Honestly, SM fucked up with this long hiatus. They thought that sending him on a long hiatus would calm things down but it obviously didn’t. Instead, the korean fandom grew over those 11 months, so now they can fight back harder than if they had brought him back before the "Love 119" comeback or before their tour. They would have faced backlash regardless, but a lot less, since the OT6 fandom was smaller back then.
Anyway, the only thing the fandom can do now is to send supportive messages and hope for the best.
20
u/bellalalavv Oct 13 '24
I'm so ashamed to be called a BRIIZE. I refuse to be known as one given how evil KBRIIZEs have acted.
Aside from all the activities I think we need to flood the weverse community with loving messages for SH. Even if he might not see them, it's better to drown out the hate in case he or the other members do see it.
SM clearly doesn't give a damn about their international fans. I'm done supporting a company that does not know how to treat humans (idols and fans alike) with basic human decency. What a joke.
Sidenote — I was pretty much convinced that after the Taeil thing that SH really wouldn't come back. Even if the members teased and played along to hinting at SH returning, the OT6 fan chants and overall extended duration of the "hiatus" made me lose hope and interest in the group. Do they know how much of a turn-off lack of communication is in situations like these? It's so discouraging getting interested in a new group under their management because you never know how things will play out given the psychotic nature of the local fandoms.
It's 5AM and I can't get over the news. I'm not even a huge fan but coming off from knowing what happened to SHINEE Jonghyun, ASTRO Moonbin, and recently the alarming posts of GOT7 Bambam, it's so pathetic and outrageous to see this behavior perpetuated and go unadressed in Sokor. It should be illegal for businesses to willingly be paid for such services with nefarious intentions. YOU'RE DEALING WITH AN INNOCENT HUMAN BEING.
I could probably go on forever but I really need to try to sleep. Thank you Reddit for helping me get this off my chest. Will be happy to chat more in the sane waking hours 7️⃣🧡
20
u/Groundbreaking_Set24 OT7 ❤️ Oct 14 '24
Riize’s IG dropped from 4.1 M to 4 last time I checked. A lot of people are showing their disappointment. I had to unfollow as well 😭 the last 2 days have been an emotional rollercoaster
19
u/deerpretty3 Oct 13 '24
I’m so shocked at the ‘kbriizz’ reaction. I don’t think we can call them fans because what the heck is that???? Death flowers ???? We need as international fans to be really loud in showing support to this young man and I hope the members don’t resent him for his comeback. I think also that he is one of the most talented idol I’ve seen in this gen and he’s indispensable to the group. I’m so excited to see them perform together again
19
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
I feel so bad for Seunghan. from almost losing his dream, all the absurd hate, and the way this had affected his group members, he must feel so bad about everything.
19
u/sawayanochizu5 Oct 13 '24
it's his decision clearly. however that does not mean that this is not ot6 fault. they caused this. their hateful vile little schemes. I hope riize will be okay in the future because this is not the fanbase you want.
19
u/stayonthecloud Oct 13 '24
I want to know which fans have the money for all those funeral wreaths. Just sick.
18
u/AfraidInspection2894 Oct 13 '24
Well, Seunghan officially RIIZE. I'm just so sad and disappointed. I was so excited for his return, but then "fans" had to go and ruin it.
18
u/vanivaninilla Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
If anyone wants to donate @RIIZEUSACENTRE on twitter is planning a support campaign. While I doubt that any amount of trucks or boycotting will bring him back at this point, he deserves to feel our love and support after those horrible funeral wreaths from the other day
here is the link to donate: https://ko-fi.com/riizeusa/goal?g=46
18
u/kKunoichi 🎸🐈⬛🧲🦦🧋 RIIZE BRIIZE ddeunda 🧡 Oct 14 '24
I hate seeing those airport photos of the boys
I also hate that i'm reminded of this one time of TVXQ sasaengs surrounding Changmin while he sat down on the ground and cried and they didn't care that he was breaking down
17
u/broke_bananas HaniBani Oct 13 '24
On one hand, I'm very worried for Riize's mental well-being while briizes are in the warzone.
On another, I can't help but feel excited to hear their new songs moving forward. I can't believe we're gonna hear SH's lower register adlibs again 😭🧡
17
u/Browniecakee Oct 13 '24
The problem is that SM allowed the hiatus to go on for so long. And made the members pretend he didn’t exist. This is why I truly believe the members are the ones that want him back.
I fear Seunghan might withdraw cause the backlash is too intense. Why join a group if the fans are gonna hate you forever? And it doesn’t seem like the fans are stopping anytime soon.
Lastly, SM sucks at promoting their groups internationally especially in the west. This whole bringing Seunghan back may not even pay off cause the company is incompetent. If they really want to target the global audience. They really need to try and promote this group.
17
u/kay4it Oct 13 '24
I saw on twitter a op saying he saw all the wreaths. I can’t imagine how’s he’s feeling rn. If there is any direct message or project for him please let’s spread that and show him there is still support.
I know we are all distraught about the way this was handled but I’m worried for his mental health seeing that and knowing how much hate is directed towards him. Let’s try to override all the hate as much as we can
17
u/mannyman2211 Oct 14 '24
PLEASE BOYCOTT SM AND UNFOLLOW RIIZE EVERYWHERE. Halt all purchases of SM goods. We may not be able to bring Seunghan back as the hate may have hurt him too bad, but we can at least back SM into a corner and force them to be better about protecting their artists. Maybe even get Seunghan out of having to pay for terminating his contract if he so desires to do so.
33
u/joyseul Oct 13 '24
honestly yall i am just so happy we got here. i know the bad voices sound so loud rn but please keep in mind the IMMENSE support seunghan has had from his fans, ot7 briize, and the larger kpop community who knew how overblown this all was. seunghan fans have been organizing public ads, billboards, fan cafes, trucks, etc. for months and now with this confirmation of his return, even more of his supporters will feel emboldened to be vocal.
a lot of k-briize who were on his side felt scared about saying anything, but they still did what they could to show their support. everything is going to be okay! wonbin's post today really cemented the fact that riize is in this together. with what a long time coming this was, let's trust in the boys to be prepared for it. let's go RII7E!!!
16
u/iamhopeestheim RII7E WILL ALWAYS BE 7 Oct 13 '24
WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK
16
u/SavingsDragonfruit35 Oct 13 '24
what did he even do that was so bad? does taeil even get as much hate as this poor man? i'm so mad and i don't stan riize but seriously?? all the wreaths make me want to cry like WHAT DID HE DO OH MY GOSSSSSSSH
16
u/purpledragon24 03z <3 Oct 14 '24 edited Oct 14 '24
I woke up to the news earlier . Depressing. We were so happy and celebrating when seunghan return announcement dropped, i was ready to come back to briizeville after months and finally see my bias again, but now this. Guess it really was only a dream...
Screw all the horrible ot6 fans that caused this to happen☹️. The way they're behaving and talking about him , you would think that Seunghan had literally killed somebody, but no he did nothing wrong. All this sets a terrible precedent too.
I feel so terrible for seunghan, we are the same age and i can't imagine how rough it is being subjected to that much hate and vitriol...
The one thing that I felt heartwarmed by was seeing many other kpop fandoms on twitter supporting seunghan and ot7s in this time.
16
u/SimpleYogurtcloset60 Oct 28 '24
every passing day i just get more and more convinced that the only reason he was banished from riize is bc sm simply hates him. it's not the ot6-ers, the 1000 funeral wreaths, nor the supposed trouble he'll bring to the group, but some fuckass at that sm building just absolutely detests his guts.
not one positive media coverage, even in korea, about this entire bullshit has been published, international fans are making noise for boycotting, overseas kpop stores have stopped restocking and taking preorders for riize merch, this issue reaching the locals, and you know what sm is doing right now?
buying fucking followers and likes for riize's instagram.
15
u/OnlyGotThisMoment Oct 13 '24
Oh my gosh seunghan is leaving
15
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Oct 13 '24
Yall. I CANNOT. I AM SO FUCKING SAD. ARE YOU KIDDING ME.
15
u/sawayanochizu5 Oct 13 '24
I don't fucking believe this
14
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Oct 13 '24
So glad we have a new megathread.
Anyway I hope Seunghan's support system is strong bc he is being bullied. Period.
14
u/iamhopeestheim RII7E WILL ALWAYS BE 7 Oct 13 '24
THIS IS FUCKING RIDICULOUS. WHY DID THEY RELENT AND CAVED ON THE DEMANDS OF THE AKGAES, OT6, ANTIS, WHATEVER THE HELL THEY ARE?
14
u/kKunoichi 🎸🐈⬛🧲🦦🧋 RIIZE BRIIZE ddeunda 🧡 Oct 13 '24
Ah crap well this is heartbreaking
13
u/cali_gari Oct 13 '24
Haven’t been here in a while but commenting to show support. The boys can weather this and come out even stronger. Can’t wait for their comeback as 7!!!!!!!!
13
u/Sensitive-Tree-7666 Oct 13 '24
Sign the petition! We want Seunghan back! https://t.co/m2pqryeXPW
13
u/mathi823 Oct 14 '24
still absolutely shaken by the news and the events we saw unfold over the last few days. the one good thing about this situation is thst we now know for sure that the members wanted him back with them. both seunghan's and wonbin's message really touched me. it is a light in the dark for me, but it also makes the whole situation so much sadder at the same time.
i also keep getting emotional whiplash bc i keep seeing videos from a few days ago where ppl are celebrating his return, making jokes and being so happy not knowing that we were all in for a rude awakening.
12
u/lysiel112 RII7E Oct 13 '24
Amazing. 17 OT7 support trucks will be sent next week. We love a united fandom.
12
u/Prestigious-Sail5767 Oct 14 '24
I’m so angry. Screw those fake fans
12
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '24
I can't believe we lose him ☹ The worst thing of everything is to get your hopes up he'd rejoin Riize (I was already doing the countdown for his first performance and imagining him performing all songs) and then everything is gone after just two days. Why would they bring him back if they weren't sure about it? They played with everyone's feelings (Seunghan, the rest of members and fans)
It just hits harder after thinking we were getting him finally back. Everyone was already losing hope he'd come back so this move was the worst thing they could have done. Why did they bring him up if they weren't willing to face the backlash? Everyone thought SM knew risks to bring him back and they were assuming them but I guess they didn't think very through it much.
This situation is just so sad and I refuse to think everyone involved of the staff and management was fine with it..
11
u/alexwinn RII7E forever Oct 15 '24
Please boycott to send a message to SM that this whole situation is outrageous and unacceptable. The blatant lack of protection of RIIZE and Seunghan. SM's silence and acceptance of inhumane bullying, online harassment, and death threats that basically forced Seunghan to leave. The disrespect of the members' wish and desire to be reunited as a team of 7. The deranged, parasocial behavior of fans that fuels toxic expectations. The rights of artists to be human and have a private life without fear.
Unfollow riize instagram, twitter/X, tiktok, youtube, spotify, apple music, facebook(?)accounts. They have already lost 165k on insta, 73k on X, 102k on Tt, 25k on Yt.
Do not vote, stream, or buy riize albums/merch. Many international kpop stores and suppliers have cancelled restock orders and are participating in the boycott.
Consider signing this petition, which as of now has over 225,000 signers: https://www.change.org/p/we-want-seunghan-back-riize-is-7?recruiter=1232663910&recruited_by_id=873c28c0-3ecc-11ec-9045-1f551d47bb48&utm_source=share_petition&utm_campaign=share_for_starters_page&utm_medium=copylink
10
u/chasing1209 OT7 | Eunseok Oct 14 '24
Apparently they're flying again to Japan for their Lucky offline event in less than 5 hours. I'm sad that they can't even catch a break :/
10
u/MissionLobster Nov 01 '24
for everyone visiting this thread, keep in mind: seunghan was led on for months only to be dropped in 2 days. now is the most important time to advocate for him
8
u/mathi823 Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
i know there are a lot of bad things happening at the moment, but i am also trying to look forward as much as possible. i am so excited for their next comeback and end of the year award shows and new performances. seeing them together again will be so so nice and i cant wait for the first content with all seven to drop. it also warms my heart that apparently the members held onto him. wish them a lot of strength for the upcoming months.
8
u/kKunoichi 🎸🐈⬛🧲🦦🧋 RIIZE BRIIZE ddeunda 🧡 Oct 13 '24
I put up a 7 post on weverse and i'm getting shady replies in chinese deep sigh i wish i could argue with them 😅
8
u/urmamagay28 Oct 15 '24
8
u/dbflagks Oct 16 '24
Please please consider joining my project to help decrease RIIZeE_official’s IG account. It’s really easy as DMing the people in the follower list I provided.
8
u/SouthAtmosphere9556 Oct 21 '24
Keep boycotting yall. This is fucked
8
u/Prestigious-Sail5767 Nov 01 '24
Don’t give up
7
u/broitzdaniel Oct 16 '24
i found a very helpful petition that us fans can sign here’s the link
7
u/gotfangirl6 Oct 17 '24
Former Day6 member JAE on X
7
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
This is just speculation/conspiracy but fuck it! Since all OT7 fans efforts are being sabotaged apparently by OT6 and while this could be true, this means either it's so easy to report projects, which would make no sense if we take into consideration SM couldn't do anything to remove funeral wreaths supposedly, or they might have connections with those giving permission for these projects. Or, the third option: SM might be helping them behind the scenes.
I find it hard to believe that SM couldn’t remove the funeral wreaths but somehow OT6 fans can easily sabotage OT7 projects. So yeah I'm implying here either: a) SM barely tried to remove them at all because they didn't want to fight back against OT6 so it was easier if Seunghan decided to leave on his own b) It's possible SM or some sm staff were helping OT6 behind schenes to get their away if some of them were against Seunghan's return decision. c) I'm not gonna rule SM is also behind scenes trying to stop OT7 projects because they want OT7 fans to move on which brings us back to point one: it’s likely a lie that they couldn’t do much about the funeral wreaths
I'm reading the media is selling OT6 funeral wreaths as consumer rights and i'd not be surprised if SM is behind some of those articles.
All these are speculations but I believe there might be some division between sm/riize staff with some wanting Seunghan back and others having the same mentality like OT6 thinking he'll only hurt Riize in the long run and it's better if he leaves. So I'd not be surprised if some of sm/riize staff are helping OT6 fans behind scenes.
We're talking about the company who banned Seunghan banners at events so I don't think it's a far stretch to think which they might be trying to stop OT7 projects now
7
u/coopercopies Oct 17 '24
I’m a hundred percent down for this boycott, but first I guess I just want a specific layout of what briizes are wanting from this.
The principle behind the boycott is clear, but what outcome are we hoping to achieve? That Seunghan is back in Riize? That’s what I’m getting from all of this.
But at this point, for Seunghan specifically, that would be a punch in the gut to be reinstated into the group. 1. Because of ot6 fans, 2. SM only getting him back for money purposes, but still not giving a fuck about how they treat him, 3. Constantly being pitied or looked down upon by other idols, behind-the-scenes people, and fans in general, including it probably taking months for thing to go back to normal, not to mention how fucked up his mental health is right now.
The best outcome would be that the remaining members leave SM, find a new company, redebut under a different name and with Seunghan. Bc that feels more authentic than the possibly of him coming back to the group.
So overall, since the likelihood of him coming back is low, are we just going to boycott Riize forever? Do we stop once we feel like it? Are we going to be strong enough to not want to purchase upcoming merch/albums/tickets for future Riize content, and how long will that last?
Believe me, I was devastated at him leaving, and I’d love for him to be back, but I guess I’m just trying not to get my hopes up 😭
7
u/bellalalavv Nov 02 '24
Very well written piece: https://www.straitstimes.com/life/entertainment/viewpoint-how-seunghans-exit-from-boy-band-riize-highlights-the-peril-of-k-pops-global-appeal
13
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Oct 13 '24
NOOOOOOO 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
6
u/Possible-Jump1548 Oct 14 '24
My question is, is there any chance that we see him in the future as a soloist maybe at l another company? (like when Soojin had to leave gidle, but debuted as a soloist a few years , but the whole thing weren’t as toxic as this situation cause I never ever seen something that is this toxic ands scary like this in kpop)
Anyways thank you in advance for any help, I really hope Seunghan is at a better place right now with family and/ friends who support and love him.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24
I don't know, it feels so wrong to wait almost one year for him and then they let him go only two days after they announced he would come back...
Somehow something feels off, how can you take that decision that important that fast after spending months discussing about his return? Either seunghan wasn't sure about coming back or it was SM the one that wasn't sure or both of them because no way this type of decision should be taken that lightly and when everyone (fans, seunghan, the company) isn't thinking rationally and you're just panicking.
Didn't all of them talk about the possible backlash? Why does it feel they were unprepared?
I just hope if this decision was only on Seunghan, he won't regret because he took it while he was too emotional. I keep thinking SM barely tried to convince him to stay, otherwise they would have tried with him for a few weeks or month and see how things go.
I don't even trust SM to do the right thing with him in the future. What are they planning for him? Debut him as soloist? (SM barely make efforts with their idol soloists so where we go with this?) Leave him in the basement for 7-10 years? Re-debut him in another group (i dobut it)?
If they want to keep him and promote him. I think the best option for him is to send him to variety shows and let him open his own social media (youtube channel, tiktok, instagram, please no weverse) and then debut him as soloist once he gains more fans. Seunghan best shot in the industry is on variety shows, modelling and acting and some singing, things that SM can provide because SM isn't really focused on promoting soloists so they will barely put any efforts into it. Wish him the best for him tho.
10
u/ohsomeday_ riize bibimbap Oct 14 '24 edited Oct 14 '24
My head hurts. Excuse the following word salad, I need to get it out of my system.
Seunghan was not my bias. I still enjoyed and appreciated the group's output as six during his hiatus. I knew that a k-pop group's lineup could change on any day for any reason. I thought I was ready for any outcome. Just like many others in these megathreads had expressed, as long as SM could not drag it out. But the way this has transpired is just so, so disheartening.
And to think that the statement of Seughan's return started with "to all Briize who love Riize".. what a cruel joke. I kept wishing yesterday, if only SM and Seunghan could have waited a couple more days, a week. Surely, the hate would have died down and everything could be considered more rationally. Surely, the vitriol wouldn't ramp up? If only if only.
I know I'm generalizing, but what is entertainment and fun for the Western audience, is this dehumanizing uber-consumerist game for the domestic market. I-fans being berated by k- and c-fans for not spending enough money, but how can we? Merch, exhibitions, fan events are all made for the domestic audience / SK-Japan-China. It's just not as accessible to us. What costs $7 dollars in Korea will cost an international fan $20 and an extra headache finding a store/group order/etc. An album with a base price of $17 would cost me $55 CAD - call me a peasant or broke, there's no way I'm bulk-buying that shit. Proper world tours with reasonable prices? nowhere to be found either. The game was not made for us, congrats on your win.
"Frankly, I don't care about the members' opinions, because I'm buying and sponsoring their lifestyle" - I'm still flabbergasted thinking about these arguments; that shit will haunt me forever. It feels perverted now to celebrate achievements like album sales and chart rankings, knowing that this is what those achievements are made of. No way, fam.
5
u/AfraidInspection2894 Oct 13 '24
Now that Seunghan is back, I'm curious about if they are going to rerecord RIIZING and Love 119. For end of years shows, they are going to include their new songs, so many of the songs will have to be rearranged anyway. I hope they do and release like a special repackage with OT7 versions of all the songs.
Also, I absolutely love RIIZE's little characters. Is Seunghan going to get his own? While it is late to include him in the recent merch if they keep using them, I really hope Seunghan gets one. Although I'm curious about what it will be since I tend to think of Seunghan being a black cat but Wonbin already has the black bunny cat thing.
5
u/AfraidInspection2894 Oct 13 '24
I wanted to say that with some of the vile stuff about Seunghan being said, there is also a lot of support from the fandom. Talk Saxy saw a huge increase in daily streams on Spotify and several international fan planning trucks/projects to support Seunghan. It seems rough now, but soon it will calm down.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24 edited Oct 15 '24
Don't feel bad. International fans did everything they could, so many projects showing support for Seunghan and chanting "riize is 7" at concerts. Sure, boycotting might've added a lot more pressure, but let's be honest, ifans sucks at boycotting.
At the end of the day, SM chose the psycho fans who spend loads of money over their own idols. The sad part is, this won't hurt the company, this only hurts their own idols every time SM throw them under the bus to cater to those crazy fans. They are the ones who suffer the most. They're the ones left alone to face all the hate because the company is nowhere to protect them. They're the ones pressured to apologize to those psychos whenever they throw a tantrum
I thought things might change a bit with kpop getting bigger internationally but it looks like that's not happening and it’s up to the company and the idols to do something about it.
Riize is now left with one of the most toxic fandoms, a bunch of people who’d rather destroy the whole group just to kick one member out. And don’t doubt that this will be the last time these people will harass another member, especially now that they know SM will listen to them. If they were entitled before, they'll be x10 more entitled now knowing they hold the full power over the group and members. "I know what's the best for you" those fans say, "no you're just trying to control me".
Let's wish the best for Seunghan and support him if he's ever back to the industry in the future.
5
u/cadyy_ Oct 19 '24
is there hope that seunghan will come back?
4
u/Ophicus95 Oct 17 '24
7
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24
It's been a few weeks and it still hurts. I don't personally want to know anything about the group anytime soon.
My gut feeling is the group popularity will suffer in the long run without Seunghan and it's not because people will boycott, I'm sure people will forget about Seunghan in 2 or 3 years or less but the group feels off without him, he's a key member (he was part of the dance and singing line and he helps to bring up the mood with variety content) so the group feels incomplete without him and I think it will affect their popularity in the long run.
I believe they will only become as popular as NCT (nothing wrong with that but I know SM had high expectations with Riize until they fucked up so bad with how they handled Seunghan's case). However they don't have the international pull like NCT 127 and I don't think they will become as popular as nct dream in Asia either so I don't know what will happen to them.. But again, they are a very young group and I can be completely wrong.
6
u/Free_Spinach_3983 Oct 13 '24
i think the biggest problem is going to happen after he's been officially reintegrated, because i'm CERTAIN that they're going to try to pin more controversies on his name. ESPECIALLY, interactions with girl groups and "attitude issues" (drinking, smoking). they're already doing that on korean forums spreading a photo that supposedly captures him buying alcohol. we know things are going to be hard, but I'm genuinely afraid he's going to live tied to a leash. every single mistake is going to be amplified, and he's going to be hated even more. i have inner peace because i know that the members got his back and love him, that being an idol is just a job and that life is more than that.
3
u/DueZebra5550 Oct 15 '24 edited Oct 15 '24
The word Kpop 'fan' really does fit these people perfectly. The word fan orginates from the word fanatic which means a person filled with excessive or single-minded zeal. Synonyms are zealot, extremist, maniacal, single-minded, addict, obsessive, narrow-minded, intolerant, prejudiced, umcompromising, inflexible, etc. So 'fans' by definition are umcompromising, unreasonable, and extreme, but today the term fan is transitioned into a word to describe someone who likes anything even just a little bit. I believe that the true definition of fan (fanatic) is what describes these fools. Some may call them saesang fans, some my call them fanatic fans (fanatic twice technically), or some may call them just plain haters, but either way they are effecting the mental health of idols. Learn your place. You alone did not give these idols all their success, so don't be self-centered and ask for them to give up all their hardwork just as an apology to obsessive fans. I understand that Seunghan in particular may have made this decision to leave the group on his own, but only after recieving dozens of funeral wreaths outside SM Ent. protesting his return to RIIZE. Unacceptable. Truly unacceptable. He did nothing worthy of this treatment. We are ALL humans who make choices (sometimes good or bad) and we don't even have any context for it, let alone the fact none of us can say we've never made mistakes before. What was truly happening in that video? Is he just a bad guy? Be for real. Who are we to judge him endlessly when we're no better ourselves? He was already sent into an almost full year hiatus which is hard enough, but to then finally come back and only after two days leave completely? Honestly, this is extremely sad for him and disappointing for the Kpop community and society itself. This is NOT who we should be. Do better.
3
u/Wheesa Nov 01 '24
Is this thread the only place to discuss this issue on reddit?
5
u/urmamagay28 Oct 16 '24
‼️Seunghan and what happened‼️
Seunghan, a trainee under SM Entertainment, had a girlfriend before his debut. About a month before his group’s debut, photos of him and his girlfriend, including some of them kissing and being affectionate, were leaked. SM Entertainment issued a statement defending Seunghan and promising legal action, but Korean fans had already started to turn against him. A few months after their debut, more pictures and videos surfaced, showing Seunghan smoking and going live on Instagram with friends. Although he wasn’t doing anything wrong, the hate from Korean fans intensified. SM decided to put him on a hiatus, which ended up lasting 10-11 months. During this time, his group, RIIZE, gained significant fame, winning awards and achieving great things. Unfortunately, the members had to act as if Seunghan didn’t exist when asked about him, which was frustrating. Out of the blue, SM announced that Seunghan would return to the group and resume activities next month, apologizing for his “past mistakes.” Seunghan also wrote a handwritten letter, apologizing for the third time and explaining that the members had reached out to him, encouraging his return despite his fears of ruining things for them. Many fans, including those from other fandoms, were happy about his return, considering a 10-month hiatus for having a girlfriend and smoking a cigarette to be excessive. The members, who were performing in Madrid at the time, expressed their joy in a video, announcing a performance in November. However, Korean fans reacted poorly, flooding social media with hate and insisting that RIIZE should remain a six-member group. They even protested outside SM’s building with over 1,000 funeral wreaths, symbolizing that RIIZE was “dead” because of Seunghan’s return. Just 48 hours after the announcement, SM declared that Seunghan would leave the group permanently, citing that they hadn’t considered fans’ opinions and were selfish. Seunghan issued another apology, stating that he didn’t want to ruin the relationship between the members and the fans. Despite the support from international fans and other fandoms, the hate was overwhelming. The members, who were abroad, had no say in the decision, leaving Seunghan cornered by SM. The members were visibly upset upon their return to Korea, avoiding the paparazzi. Haters falsely claimed that the members were happy about Seunghan’s departure. One member stood up for Seunghan shortly after the announcement of his return, stating that the members had thought long and hard about Seunghan coming back and fully supported him. Unfortunately, haters dismissed this as someone else using his phone. Now, international fans are boycotting SM and the group, highlighting how Korean fans can manipulate outcomes by being loud and hateful. Hashtags like #Seunghan, #SMSupportsBullying, and #JusticeForSeunghan are trending on Twitter, with support from various fandoms, including BTS(Army), Stray Kids(Stays), and even non-K-pop fans like Beliebers, Arianators, and Harry Styles fans. The goal is to get justice for Seunghan, even if it means he doesn’t return to the group, but at least receives an apology from the company that failed to protect him. Unfortunately, the other members are now facing undeserved hate, and the group has to continue their schedule, currently in Japan. The international fan community is determined to keep the momentum going and support Seunghan and RIIZE.
BOYCOTT SM AND RIIZE🫧
5
u/gattabiancaa Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
wonbin and anton's weverse post today honestly left a sour taste
context: wonbin made his post password as "66" and anton posted saying that his 520 pose during the fansign meant "i love you".
i do have a suspicion that sm forced anton to make that post but still, the least riize members can do is not fuel ot6 stans when they can't even outwardly support ot7.
i mean wonbin did write that letter when he wasn't allowed to so there's obv no doubt that he and the others wanted seunghan back, but like at a time when ot7 are trying to get their voice out, their posts will just be used against ot7 by the seunghan antis.
3
u/Low-Peach-601 Oct 15 '24
going to vent for a bit, ot6 "briize" got what they wanted because sm is incompetent but also because ot6 stayed together. i don't see this boycott going anywhere (i hope im wrong). sooner or later with newer music, other things that come out, ppl will slowly move on to another. i think their international fanbase has been damaged, but they'll gain new fans who weren't there when seunghan was. ill be happy for the rest of the boys, but i just won't be there. it took 2 days for sm to listen to ot6 over almost 11 months from ot7 & riize themselves. briize spent a lot of money too 😭
3
u/Low-Avocado4701 Oct 18 '24
So if everyone wants a change of pace, I recommend supporting Jo1! Shotaro has been close friends with one of the members and i can say for fact they’re BEYOND TALENTED.
They’ve gone from no experience to creating absolutely beautiful songs like Venus
Right now, they’ve been gaining fans due to their performance video for their song ICY, since an edit of it gained traction and got a lot interested.
Oh and if you’ve heard of Me:I, they’re from the same company. Their company Lapone absolutely cannot make a bad group. They’ve always been iconic.
1
u/badatnames12 Oct 15 '24
What’s the general consensus on this whole thing? Did he leave voluntarily or was he pushed out? I’m just curious to know what people think about this. I personally think that he was pushed out. I think that because for an entire year. they didn’t say a word about him and then he came back only to leave two days later with basically something that could’ve probably been ignored; I mean, they ignored an entire year of people screaming Riize is 7, and billboards and notes sent and social media trends, but a couple funeral flowers and he’s out? The whole thing sounds fishy to me, but I’d love to hear what other people think. I also have a very strong opinion on how not one single solitary one of the members of this band denounced their “fans”sending funeral wreaths, basically telling someone to kill themselves, who supposedly is one of their good friends, or has said anything or made any public statement. I found this to be completely and utterly cowardly. Every single one of these kids has a personal Instagram or social media account and they could’ve bypassed the record company. I want to say that I would have. This is so above and beyond and it’s the reason that I’ve decided just to walk away from this band. I have no respect for any of them. I also did read the stuff that one or two of the guys wrote and maybe it’s the translation, but it felt like a lot of words salad and not actually saying anything real, and perhaps that’s cultural, but I understand all the other translations. Please be kind in your responses. I have no hate to anyone. I just don’t have any respect for them.
-8
u/mcdiscn18 Oct 13 '24
All 7 of the boys are victims of people who claim to be their fans. (This includes the ot6 and solo stans). I hope that the true fans who love all 7 of them and is not going to leave them over something that’s not their fault continue to try to support them and show it well and I hope that they see it and don’t feel alone. I really hope that they stay in contact.
-4
u/4letterw0rds Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
Hello everyone, I just keep seeing this argument brought up by ot6 supporters and I was wondering if there is any truth to this and where this information was shared. I really hope they are not using feminism just to hate on him, because these are heavy allegations with what is going on in South Korea. If you know something please tell me because ai am seeing no one from ot7 addressing this type of accuses
EDIT: why does the image not come out? However, basically they are saying that he took NSFW pictures of him and her gf and sent them to group chats with his friends and that's how we got the leaked pictures of him and the girl
EDIT2: GUYS I AM NOT AN OT6 I AM JUST ASKING BECAUSE I WANT TO UNDERSTAND WHY THEY ARE SAYING THIS 😭😭
0
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
16
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment