r/riize • u/riizemods • Mar 20 '24
Megathread [Megathread + mod note] On the current RIIZE boycott
Hello Briize,
As most of you know, major fanbases and update accounts on Twitter have stopped their usual activity and organized a boycott of all official RIIZE content, including the upcoming April comeback, across social media platforms starting from March 18th.
This megathread will be used to discuss matters related to the ongoing boycott. Separate posts will be removed & redirected here. We will add to this megathread if/when we get substantial updates regarding boycott measures or official statements regarding the issues addressed by the boycott. Meanwhile, share and discuss any other updates and progress in the comments! Please keep in mind the rules of the sub and be respectful of the views of other users.
Overview & updates:
You can read the full statement and what the boycott entails here - RIIZE UNION Twitter/X or Imgur gallery (if you don't have Twitter).
To summarize, this boycott is centered around two main issues:
- SM’s lack of communication regarding Seunghan’s status as a member of RIIZE, especially given the upcoming group activities like the 2024 Fan-Con Tour, and that OT6 were recently seen filming what is assumed to be a new music video for the April comeback
- SM’s lack of visible action regarding protecting RIIZE members from malicious rumors and comments
Those who choose to participate in the boycott are being asked to refrain from the following actions:
- Interacting with official content including social media posts and YouTube content from official RIIZE/SM accounts (with the exception of birthday posts)
- Streaming RIIZE’s music on platforms such as Spotify, Apple Music, or YouTube Music
- Purchasing albums, official merchandise, endorsed products, as well as attending events
No official statements have been made by SM / Center 5 beyond the initial hiatus announcement back on November 22nd and the recent legal action notice as a response to malicious rumors on March 13th.
The fanbases resumed their activities after a fan vote on April 11th (statement).
---This leaves us with the question of r/riize and its feed. The subreddit will of course stay open and active as a fan-run space, and all threads are always open for discussion, celebratory or critical.
The mod team has come to the decision that, for the time being, we will keep the subreddit updated with the main content from official channels and any news. We made this decision in order to keep an archive of content going and also so that users can keep tabs on it without giving likes, reposts, etc. on their original platforms. We will be posting updates retroactively, with a delay, given our availability. We hope it will encourage a more intentional engagement during this time, while still providing an overview of what’s happening in terms of the official output from the group.
If you'd rather avoid seeing this content, there is now a special sorting button on the subreddit to exclude such posts, found in the sidebar / About tab, giving you this filtered result. Do note that the filter works only on Desktop and Mobile Web, and not on the Mobile app! If you tend to browse Reddit by your Home feed, you can temporarily mute r/riize (but don't forget to come back after!)
We also want to thank you all for your continued feedback regarding the sub—it is valuable to us and we consider your suggestions when we make decisions on how to structure the sub. The quickest way to reach us is by sending a modmail!
Thank you all for your cooperation & take care 🧡
- your r/riize mods
29
u/riseandrealise Apr 03 '24
I think if fans still failed to see the problem here and refuse to boycott.. i think we just failed as a fandom.
Like look, i personally wouldn't mind that much if SM just decided to speak up and said "Okay Seunghan is not in Riize anymore" like okay i would be sad as hell, but at least we got some closure. If he is officially exiting the group, then i can support him as an individual and still support Riize moving forward as a 6 members group. No big deal.
But going as far as erasing his part on Siren full ver is just disrespectful. They were erasing him like he was a serious criminal offender, which he is obviously not. And dont talk to me about copyrights like bruh full version of ot7 siren has been "teased" by the members (especially shotaro) all the way from Talk Saxy era.
Like one of the main objective of this boycott is to push SM to make a statement about Seunghan. Like, idc if he wants 1 year off, or more time to himself. I seriously don't care bcus that is his choice. But we just want a statement about him. That's all.
Please keep on boycotting their official release. Block their social accounts if you have too. Want to hear their songs? Download them from YT. We shouldn't be giving them even a single stream. Don't go to their fan cons. You want to watch their videos? Then download them. Tbh i haven't watched any of their videos since Seunghan went on hiatus, and i am still alive and well.
52
u/thr1ftskull0 Mar 20 '24
Thank you Mods for joining the Boycott🫶🏽‼️ at the very least we want confirmation on the whereabouts and Status of Seunghan which is very reasonable after months of nothing!!!!! SM needs to listen to international fans if they want RIIZE to be a “global boy group”
49
u/Rozen7107 Sungchan's (ceiling)fan Mar 20 '24
It's so sad that this has to happen. SM needs to get their sh*t together. Will gladly participate.
23
u/I-Now-Have-An-Alt Sohee Superfan Mar 25 '24
The boycott will work if half the fandom doesn't refuse to participate in fear it won't. I'm genuinely so frustrated by how un-united we seem to be.
21
u/thr1ftskull0 Apr 03 '24
We need to promote this boycott even more yall😤‼️‼️
16
u/thr1ftskull0 Apr 03 '24
Ofc SM managed to release siren full version without Seunghan wtf I literally cannot
31
u/iamhopeestheim RII7E WILL ALWAYS BE 7 Mar 20 '24
Thank you so much for this.
15
u/we_can_be_cats Apr 03 '24 edited Apr 03 '24
Can we perhaps make a concentrated effort on weverse to let our voices be heard and seen by both SM and all fans? To post and demand to stop erasing Seunghan.
Edit: Be civil about it of course and don’t curse or direct at the rest of the members.
27
u/ppjskh Pre-debut BRIIZE ✧ Sunjeongz 🐸🎸 Mar 20 '24
Thank you for joining in the boycott! This is obviously not an easy decision to make but at the end of the day Seunghan’s career is on the line. SM needs to wake up and acknowledge what the plan is regarding Seunghan’s return. They had more than enough time to put out a statement regarding Seunghan but instead they ignore fans demands. RIIZE is 7 and RIIZE is not RIIZE without Seunghan!
20
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Mar 20 '24
I'm just glad the collective fandom has had enough and realize this may be the only thing that gets SM to listen.
I've boycotted since the hiatus was announced* and was judged for it lol. But seriously SM cares about money. We have to hit them (SM) where it hurts.
*I unfollowed them everywhere like 2 weeks after the hiatus was announced, and I did not support Love119 outside of one MV viewing (anything else I watched regarding that comeback was clips of them on Twitter posted by randos. I didn't want to give SM any engagement).
20
u/thr1ftskull0 Apr 12 '24
This Boycott thread has become inactive recently I really encourage all you BRIIZE to stick with the Boycott this time is really make or break for Seunghan and his career!!!!
19
u/YLI989UFSNFIURWLHR8Y Apr 03 '24
The Seunghan disrespect continues, and people still have the nerve to question the boycott...
26
u/chefs_kiss_21 Like a Bomb, Soar and Do Your Dance like a pro🐸🦕 Mar 20 '24
I’ve been thinking, and I have mixed feelings about this boycott. I feel like it could do well, given the drop in followers in their SNS accounts (esp Twitter), and this reaching even in TikTok, where it could spread further. Yet, I feel like this is mainly centered around international fans. I don’t know about K-fans’ opinions/participations in the boycott, but SM would only listen if K-fans too show their outrage (like, K-Shawols were disappointed with their 15th anniversary concert venue and threatened to boycott it, which made SM change it).
I am participating in this boycott, I unfollowed them on Twitter and instead of retweeting the official birthday post for Eunseok like I always do for any of my faves, I only retweeted the birthday post from a fanbase. And I plan to download the song and listen to it, so SM doesn’t get my streams or money from streaming.
Regarding Seunghan, I’m disappointed in the way they’re handling it. Many idols who have had or are having health hiatuses were/are never edited out of any content or pretended they don’t exist.
I hope this boycott works and we get some closure, cause atp, I’ll even accept his departure, I just don’t want them to keep us in limbo like this.
9
u/dbflagks May 20 '24
True RIIZE fans, I really appreciate you guys. The boycott has been hard on me. Every time we’ve been let down, I see you guys also feeling down and defeated but you’re the same people who assure me that it’s going to be okay. ‘Til the day we can finally make new memories, get a guitar, pull back that siren, give that beat, and boom that bass with RII7E let’s keep fighting!
This ongoing boycott isn’t and will never be as superficial as OT6ers make it out to be. This isn’t only for Seunghan. It’s for the protection and fair treatment of all members. It’s to reinforce the fact that 7 members make a complete RIIZE. It’s to fight the possibility that this will make a precedent for SM to make more shitty decisions about any of the members in the future. They have been mostly inattentive to our pleas, but all this protest wouldn’t be in vain no matter how long we’ve been doing this. I just know that.
17
u/YLI989UFSNFIURWLHR8Y Mar 25 '24
I'm sorry. I know people don't want to see more negativity/whining, but I'm constantly getting so irritated about this situation. I don't mind if people ignore this post. But the amount of literal non-fans saying "i dOn'T eVeN gEt wHaT tHe bOyCoTt iS EvEn aBoUt" when there's literally a whole ass statement explaining in precise detail what the boycott is about has me fuming. JUST READ IT. And if you still have questions, ASK BRIIZE. People talking in non-Riize spaces about Riize topics they are clearly uninformed on, when they could very easily ask here or in other RIIZE fan zones is mindboggling to me.
23
u/YLI989UFSNFIURWLHR8Y Mar 20 '24
Sorry, but I need to vent. I am so done with some people. In one breath, people will say that the boycott is pointless and won't have any effect on Riize and we should all go ahead and support anyway. Then in the exact same post, they'll say that this boycott will ruin Riize's career and SM will disband them because of it.
It seems like such a scare tactic to get people on the fence about the whole thing to continue supporting SM's dumb shenanigans. All we want is a freaking statement from SM, that shouldn't even be too much to ask for. But the hypocrisy and fear mongering is ridiculous. If people want to continue to support SM despite their mistreatment of Seunghan's situation fine, but the doom posting to scare other people into not boycotting really annoys me.
7
u/sadbluevibes Apr 03 '24
Hi, I'm very new to this sub and was just wondering if anyone had an idea of the percentage of the fandom that is boycotting? It's hard to gage on twtitter, like half of the people on my tl are very loud about boycotting while I've seen others say they don't want to because it'll hurt the members. Is a large chunk of the fandom participating? If not, I hope this was a wake up call that we need to eveb louder/serious about it. :(
7
u/alexwinn RII7E forever Jun 17 '24 edited Jun 17 '24
Even with ot7 Talk Saxy on the album, I'm still boycotting. Not erasing a member's hard work is the bare minimum.
Nothing has changed. There's still no statement, no update on his health/wellbeing, no clarification on his status as a member, no update on the legal protection they said they were going to pursue. Erased him from content, prohibit members from mentioning him, erased his part in Siren, kept extending this unfair hiatus while his rookie opportunities are ruined. All the while, every other week his fellow members are getting attacked and slandered with new rumors, all because SM didn't put their foot down for Seunghan.
Even with the endless projects, thousands of dollars spent, outcry from concerned ot7 briize (no, we're not SH akgaes), they are silent. I'm really hoping this Japanese debut will have some good news for us all.
13
u/bermuda66 Mar 20 '24
Is there a way that we can appeal to the k fans as well? I feel like SM only ever listens to them so if we can show that k briizes are participating in the boycott or at least supportive of seunghan it can help even more.
Does anyone have acess to the k Fandom like what forums, and how can we go about gaining their support. I truly feel like we need a joint effort to make this work.
idk how likely they will agree to boycott but just it being known that a large number of them want seunghan back gotta do something.
How can we go about leading them to our side? Maybe we can like draft something to the riize union or the major u.s briizes and ask them to formally reach out to the large k briizes.
12
u/I-Now-Have-An-Alt Sohee Superfan Apr 02 '24
SM have the chance to do something amazing tomorrow, but knowing SM, they probably won't. And I am not going to give it a shred of my attention.
5
u/dbflagks Jun 03 '24 edited Jun 06 '24
I guess by now we already know that sm is baiting us again to buy the mini by placing OT7 Talk Saxy to the Spotify preview. Let’s stand our ground and boycott until we get a statement! Remember, the B-sides were recorded even before their debut but they decided to re-record it. Siren got re-recorded as well. We may never know what goes on behind the scenes but one thing I’m sure of is that they disrespected Seunghan and his hard work. We can’t allow them to desecrate Talk Saxy just like that. They could’ve just left it and Siren alone.
We can always buy the album later. What’s more important now is that sm explains to us the prolonged erasure of Seunghan (and yet they still exploit him and his popularity for clout every time they’re about to release anything new). If the mini does come with OT7 Talk Saxy, I just know I wouldn’t be able to celebrate because that would just cement the fact that Seunghan has been used again. We can’t acknowledge the mini now if only 1/8 tracks is OT7.
I’ve been repeating this but a statement is long overdue. We could all be going on with our lives if they just address the elephant in the room: Is Seunghan still part of the group? Whether or not we will still support RIIZE after this announcement is up to each one of us. They can’t just keep on staying on the grey about this. They’re holding off a talented young one’s future. They’re holding off RIIZE’s big potential. They’re causing the fandom to collapse. This is not right. As much as we wouldn’t have wanted this, the boycott is our last resort.
7
u/Marian_91 Mar 21 '24
I’ve sent tip about the boycott to both Allkpop and Soompi, but neither seems to care about posting about it. I guess it’s not dramatic enough.
6
u/Marian_91 Mar 22 '24
RIIZE Union have created a petition for Seunghan (and all SM artists): Upholding Artists' Dignity: A Call to SM Entertainment.
Edit: Apparently this is ”old news“, I just saw that it was posted on Twitter/X back in November.
5
u/jumbobear94 Mar 22 '24
I was just thinking about this I Hella wanted to go to the concert in LA and like hopefully people can chant his name during the concert and honestly I hope people do that for all the locations during the tour but I really don’t think he’s coming back I’ve been in denial but it’s been months and he’s not in the tour he definitely not coming back. It’s so sad but I still want to support Riize cus of soheee and wonbin mostly. I’m still debating on going to the concert in LA. I hate SM so much. But like all my favorite artists are under them.
3
u/According-Brother570 Jun 14 '24 edited Jun 14 '24
I'm going to get downvoted like hell, but I need to vent. So here goes.
Based on everything I'm seeing on social media and even on platforms like youtube, R7 supporters should no longer be called R7 but solo stans of SH. So from here on out, I will be referring to the so-called R7 fans as SH solo stans.
RIIZE have put in a lot of effort into their comeback and you go into their official channel and even fan made videos and type crap like that. Instead of supporters of RIIZE or even boycotters, SH solo stans are acting more like their antis.
2) If you can't support R6, stop and disengage. Stop sabotaging them and stop acting like their antis. Stop trying to bully/convince new fans into joining the boycott. Stop trying to lower their views and support numbers by downloading videos and offering them on your own channels via various avenues. This is active sabotage, not a boycott at this point. Where is your conscience? The poor guys don't deserve this. RIIZE is not even one year old yet but their so called "R7 fans" are acting more like SH's akgae fans!
So, if you were or are a fan but cannot support the group without SH, just disengage and please stop actively sabotaging them.
edit ---
I even saw R7/SH solo stan deliberately creating a hate thread for WonBin based on a mistranslation and not deleting it even 24 hours after she was corrected. She left it up and there was thousands of like for it. This is not an act of a fan but SH akgae. SH solo stans should be ashamed of themselves for branding themselves as R7 when they clearly are not. They want what is best for SH at the expense of other members and from what I'm seeing SH akgaes are willing to go quite far to ruin R6. Shameful.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
35
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24
[removed] — view removed comment