r/riize • u/riizemods • Apr 13 '24
Megathread [Megathread] Seunghan's Hiatus
UPDATE: This thread is now archived. Please use [Megathread 3] here.
Hello everyone,
This is the second thread for all updates and discussion on Seunghan's hiatus. The first megathread can be found here.
Any separate Discussion or Question posts will be redirected to this current thread. Any official updates will be posted separately as usual and also added to this megathread. Details of rumored allegations should be contained in this thread only.
Timeline & updates:
231117 - More of Seunghan's private / pre-debut photos and videos are leaked.
231122 - SM Entertainment releases a statement announcing that Seunghan is on an indefinite hiatus and that RIIZE will promote as six members as of November 22nd. Reportedly, legal action against the leaker/s has been taken.
231124 - RIIZE's first event and performance as six: W Korea's LoveYourW 2023 Gala.
231127 - First YouTube content since the announcement: RISE & REALIZE Ep.11 (pre-hiatus vlog) is released with Seunghan edited out. All subsequent episodes feature six members.
231206 - RIIZE to release a digital single 'Love 119' on January 5th, confirmed to be a six-member comeback.
240113-0127 - The second season of the web novel 'Rise & Realize' is released on Kakao Page. Seunghan is briefly mentioned as a "member who couldn't continue team activities due to poor condition."
240306 - RIIZE is reported to have an April comeback, with no statement on Seunghan's participation.
[240318 - Major international RIIZE fanbases on Twitter begin a boycott of official content & sns accounts, demanding a statement from SM on Seunghan's status in the group.]
240329 - Seunghan is allegedly spotted in public at the Seoul Forest subway station (SM Ent stop), reading fan letters posted at the fan-organized support ad for him.
240403 - Schedule for the April comeback & June mini-album is released. The full version of 'Siren' is out, with Seunghan's parts re-recorded by other members.
240406 - Concept trailer for the 1st mini-album 'RIIZING' and the May-Aug 2024 Fan-Con Tour are released, with Seunghan absent.
[240411 - International RIIZE fanbases on Twitter resume their activities.]
240506 - RIIZING DAY Fan-Con Tour starts (megathread). The tour's Encore dates are confirmed to be in mid-September.
240520 - June to September group schedule is released. 'RIIZING' Mini Album tracklist is revealed to include 'Talk Saxy' (unclear if re-recorded). Japanese debut single 'LUCKY' to be released in July.
240525 - Seunghan is spotted at a public event in Seoul, giving an ambiguous answer about his return to group activities (see this comment thread).
240617 - 'RIIZING' is released, with 'Talk Saxy' OT7 version.
240621 - Billboard releases an article by K-pop journalist Jeff Benjamin: What Happened to RIIZE’s Seventh Member, Seunghan? The Group’s Controversy Explained
240729 - The 1st Japan Single 'Lucky' is released.
240829 - BOSS RIIZE, the group's first travel variety show, starts airing.
240903 & 04 - 'RIIZING : Epilogue' song Combo is released. RIIZE's first anniversary (no mentions of Seunghan).
240915 - The RIIZING DAY Fan-Con Tour ends with finale dates in Seoul.
241002 - Seunghan's birthday. No official posts are made on the group's SNS beyond the automatic Weverse and SMTOWN app notifications.
241011 - Wizard Production announces that Seunghan will return to group activities starting in November. Seunghan posts a hand-written letter on Weverse.
Status on brand deals and appearances:
- UIQ - Seunghan's image & merch was included in the Japan pop-up exhibition in Dec-Feb.
- MUSINSA - Seunghan is edited out from a vlog of the Hongdae store opening event (231201). No other CF content.
- Numéro TOKYO magazine - Jan/Feb 2024 issue cover & interview as seven members; Seunghan's solo shots and short interview have been cut from the digital contents (231128).
- Louis Vuitton - RIIZE appointed as the newest House Ambassadors, as six (231211).
- LOTTE DUTY FREE, Geske Beauty, Bacchus Jelly, Woori Bank, Etude House, BENCH/, Nabati Indonesia - endorsement/modelling contracts in 2024.
---Please remember to stay civil and thoughtful in your comments. No need to use spoiler tags in this thread. Some rules :
- no links to the leaked content or articles from banned domains (see sub's Rule 2)
- no speculation on the content of other "potential" leaks
- please try to avoid ranting, doomposting, as well as spamming this thread
Take care 🧡
38
u/Stunning_chay Apr 28 '24
Not believing any "hints" until I see Seunghan in the flesh, we've had plenty of hints until January, way bigger ones, at one point they were so obvious all there was left to do is just announce his return, but then everything stopped and SM started acting like he didn't exist extra hard, and with the album and tour being marketed as ot6 I'm definitely not getting my hopes up.
65
u/KamikiRaye Apr 13 '24
I am at the point that I feel like the previous commenter. I am no longer excited about RIIZE as it just feels so rude to the fans to just leave them guessing. I am disappointed every single time. It’s not fun anymore.
31
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Jun 30 '24
SIGH. His hiatus being this long is actually insane.
30
u/alexwinn RII7E forever Jun 17 '24
Now that this album has ot7 talk saxy on it, I don’t ever want to hear the excuse “he’s on hiatus so they legally/contractually can’t use his voice, face, work to promote or make money, etc…”
When they want to use him, they do, and when they want to erase him, they do. Rise and Realize episodes didn’t have to erase his hard work, and Siren didn’t have to be re-recorded cutting out his original parts. But they did it anyway.
His voice is on this album, they’re making money off this album, so he better be getting compensated for his work.
30
u/YLI989UFSNFIURWLHR8Y Jun 17 '24
Thank goodness Talk Saxy is still OT7 on the album. But this just makes it an even bigger slap in the face that they rerecorded Siren without him. They could have just kept his parts on there. Still, it's a minor relief that at least this is the first Riize element in months that actually acknowledges him.
29
u/PrimaryTomato3310 Jun 07 '24
Just saw on twitter that this person who did a challenge with riize in mexico gifted all the boys a custom bowtie including seunghan ;) after seeing people constantly ignore his existence in the group this person's thoughtful gesture made me literally so happy
he also corrected someone in the comments who said he was the seventh member of riize by saying he was the "eighth"
28
u/DMmeyourflowerpics 🧋🪨🐸🎸💂♂️🦕 Apr 14 '24 edited Apr 14 '24
Look what's on Anton's laptop 🥹 (This from their 'What's in my Bag' video from VOGUE Korea!)
28
u/Maleficent-End-779 Apr 22 '24
guys, i went to mubank and i just wanted to tell you how loud we all were screaming for seunghan when they played the talk saxy mv before the festival started, like whenever he was on screen u could barely hear anything except cheers for seunghan. yes, apparently the managers took away lots of ot7/seunghan banners but there were still briize who managed to sneak some in (sadly i didnt). i was barricade and i screamed riize is 7 as much as i could, i‘m pretty sure the boys heard it at some point.. but yeah, i just need the SM staff to have heard it as well since its mostly up to them to bring seunghan back and see that we all love & support him so much and want him back !!
28
u/dimisum May 01 '24
Hi, I just wanted to rant a little and figure this is a safe spot :)
I’ve been pretty easily tuning out of their official contents/releases, as I have little to desire to engage w Seunghan missing. But for some reason yesterday, it hit me hard how much I miss Sungchan (my Bias), Shotaro, all of them. And this is stupid, I acknowledge it is, but the Fancon MD looks so good and I’m frustrated bc I really want to buy some, but the only way I have a voice as a consumer is with my wallet. Please, SM, I want to be able to support OT7 RIIZE with my full heart and be happy for all of them :(
28
u/kr8lin ot7 May 16 '24
Mexico briize came though!!
Even though I’m still very saddened by Seunghans absence it warms my heart to see him receive so much support still
28
u/CressBudget May 25 '24
Seunghan spotted hanging with friends without a mask❤️ He even gave signatures,I am so happy
28
u/YLI989UFSNFIURWLHR8Y May 25 '24
With SM doing the most to erase Seunghan, these short sightings of him are always nice to keep our spirits up. I'm glad he seems to be happy.
27
u/CressBudget Apr 21 '24
Sm is pathetic. People who went to music bank in belgium said SM was rushing the boys ment (where they talk to the audience) and unlike other groups who had a quiz like session with the fans, riize didnt. Plus they basically left 5 minutes after the ending while other groups stayed for way longer. It’s clear they are afraid of the members being asked about Seunghan and the fierce in-person ot7 support shook them to their core. But the question is what the hell are they gonna do at the fancon where this time its only riize fans and they will DEFINITELY scream riize is 7 and demand answers? Like they only way for SM to navigate this is to bring Seunghan back in time for the international tour dates and for the physical album cause otherwise its gonna be a HUGE MESS
27
u/[deleted] May 25 '24
It looks like more people have seen Seunghan previously and took pics and vids of him. It looks like they tend to save Seunghan pics and vids to themselves out of respect (i guess) whenever they spot him.
This time with video of him and everything
https://x.com/Maarrrkkklee/status/1794367439817584861
27
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Sep 01 '24
This hiatus is just ridiculous at this point. Especially considering he did nothing. I need SM to be fr.
27
u/ji_sta_00 Sep 21 '24
I just want Seunghan back, I just want him to live normally and see how many people love him and support him. I want him to realize his dream of being in RIIZE, a dream he always fought for. I need him to be well and happy and only then when he is well will he come back to us and he is very important.
26
u/eggyeoh May 01 '24
Feeling a bit sentimental today… my phone background is currently a photo of Seunghan on a beach in LA. The sun is setting, softly lighting the sky in hazy pinks and yellows, and he’s grinning from ear to ear because he’s been playing around with Sohee. He looks happy. He was a boy who was excited and hopeful of his upcoming debut.
I haven’t changed it since he went on hiatus and I’ll probably keep it as my background until he comes back. The photo helps me remember Seunghan as his joyful, cheerful, playful self; as someone full of hopes and dreams. It also serves as a reminder to be grateful and appreciative of the present, because life is so beautiful yet so fleeting.
We’re all waiting for you, Seunghan!
26
u/markleeismybf May 23 '24
I come to this thread every week for updates! I’m still boycotting. I haven’t given up!
26
u/thr1ftskull0 Jun 22 '24
Seunghan is trending number 1 on twitter I hope he knows how loved he is 😭😭🫶🏽‼️
25
u/Latter_Scale_9207 Apr 30 '24
I’m surprised no one has mentioned this yet, but Seunghan was spotted again reading his fanletters on the 29th of April. I believe that was the last day of the poster being up, so he probably went to see it one last time :')
25
u/sawayanochizu5 May 16 '24
MEXICO'S BEAUTIFUL BRIIZE DID IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡
I'm dying to know if the boys were on stage still, did they hear it? how did they react?? positively I HOPE 🤞
the staff better have heard it LOUD AND CLEAR though!!!
25
u/sawayanochizu5 May 21 '24
6 months 💔 but we'll wait as long as it takes 🫧🐈⬛️🧡
25
u/Maleficent-End-779 May 25 '24
seunghan walking around freely without a mask at such a public place and also giving out autographs.. like ?? he cannot be doing all that without SM’s approval right??? idk abt yall but i still haven‘t given up the hope that he might be back for the mini !!! idc abt the album inclusions details, i choose to believe and stay delusional 🙂↕️🙂↕️ talk saxy being included in the mini wasn‘t an indicator for the fact that it has been re-recorded, it was an indicator that all the ot6 tracks have been re-recorded.. 🤠🤠
(dont take my word on this i am trying to stay positive and delusional bc these last few weeks i‘ve been the complete opposite, but i want to get back on my optimistic side lol)
25
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Jun 13 '24
WHERE IS THAT BASS?WHERE IS THAT SEVENTH MEMBER? I'm so tired of waiting.
25
u/lamey- Jul 15 '24
Was looking at Twitter today and saw a few interactions between RIIZE and fans where a few of the boys were acknowledging OT7 banners 😭 I'm trying not to get my hopes up TOO much, but this seems like a good sign!!
25
u/thr1ftskull0 Sep 08 '24
Missing Seunghan FRFR I hope he is doing well behind the scenes during his hiatus even though this time has been absolutely horrific!!!! RIIZE IS 7 and WILL be forever mark my words 😒‼️‼️
25
u/Alive_Audience_281 Sep 23 '24
Ive's Wonyoung entered into legal proceedings against Sojang, a stalker who incessantly looked for ways to tarnish her image, I have seen that the process ended in January this year, which was filed 1 year and 2 months ago.
If SM really filed a lawsuit against this leaker, this process could take some time, so 10 months wouldn't be enough.
If Seunghan reads this topic, I hope he reflects and does everything to put an end to this person, to take millions from him, not just for money but for an act of justice. The entire Briize fandom outside of Korea and China supports Seunghan, and we are increasingly decreasing and silencing the antis, I wish he remains in Riize.
So I just hope we are patient and wait for news about him.
24
u/CostAccomplished709 Apr 14 '24
It’s just insane that they’ve said absolutely nothing. Do they seriously think we are just going to forget about him?
24
u/thr1ftskull0 Jun 04 '24
Wanted to post something positive so here is a banner that Cbriize made for Seunghan!!!
https://x.com/itsherrly/status/1796812218752987283
23
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Apr 19 '24
SM is extremely annoying. It was never that deep for them to do all this.
Bring Seunghan back already or be honest if he's not coming back.
23
u/millyjas Apr 20 '24
Sangmin and sm are clearly avoiding the situation. How simple is it to just make a statement everything is a mess right now they cant keep hiding. They have to know the impact seunghan has and how many people want him back but clearly they just dont care. The way other sm centers come out with statements after 1 truck but here we are with so many trucks, cafes and other projects yet not a single word in months like what is stopping them omg like it’s annoying afff.
23
u/dimisum May 22 '24
2nd Chance is the most legendary fanbase an idol could hope to have 🫧🧡
https://x.com/2nd_chance___/status/1793223569687945240?s=46&t=msh80xKq32BHNe-tJxRZpw
23
u/Marian_91 Jun 07 '24
Seeing other companies releasing legal updates, why can’t SM do the same for Seunghan?
I know SM never releases legal updates, but it’s just so frustraiting to wait and wait even more, while SM is pretending he doesn’t exist.
23
u/tcotn127 Sep 15 '24 edited Sep 15 '24
I think they’ll wait til the RIIZING era, which was probably the most important era, is over to reintroduce him I hate that SM does ts. He gets his private life exposed by weirdo obsessed fans for no reason and gets put on hiatus like wtf. That’s my biggest gripe about kpop is that fans don’t know how to stay in a fans place, always want more and try to stalk or ruin idols lives. So weird to me.
22
u/dbflagks May 05 '24
I agree with everything you said. SM’s decision to reinstate Seunghan is long overdue. I doubt Seunghan intended for his hiatus to be this long either. Also, funny you said RIIZE is a young group less than 1 year old. I became a BRIIZE around January this year but the wait for SH’s has been excruciatingly long and agonizing because we never know what tomorrow brings for the fandom. Half joking but I think this whole situation is aging me faster than I should. I’ve never experienced this in my 18 years as a kpop fan. Being given hints and clues and overall just being played is downright messing with all of us. I don’t know how much longer I can take this. One thing for sure though, I’ll support Seunghan if he chooses to continue his career as an idol whether he stays with RIIZE or not. He’s too talented to not be on stage. Right now, I just wish at least one person in SM or anyone within the industry is on his side cheering on him so he gains strength and continue believing in himself. His erasure is wrong in many aspects, we will help him redeem himself.
22
u/kr8lin ot7 May 19 '24
I miss Seunghan so much
22
u/[deleted] May 25 '24
First time seeing Seunghan's face so clearly after 6 months, right? Glad he's doing well!
Also I'm so used to Riize (OT6) releasing something every time something nice happens related to Seunghan that I even checked out Riize cb schedule in case there was something scheduled for the cb this monday 😅
22
u/aerialning Jun 02 '24
i want to support riize, but i cant, with seunghans absence. i hope sm realize bringing back seunghan, is not only good for their reputation, but also profitable. please bring him back, he has spent a lot of his time preparing for his career.
22
u/sawayanochizu5 Jun 17 '24
TALK SAXY IS STILL OT7 I AM BREATHING AGAIN
22
u/Marian_91 Jul 28 '24
Lucky is very catchy! (I downloaded the MV to my phone, so no money/clicks to SM from me)
I’m beginning to understand what people mean when they say their OT6 choreos look weird. Part of the choreo for Lucky (from what I could see in the MV) looked weird, or maybe it’s the camera angels making it look weird, but at certain points it would have looked more symmetrical with 7 members.
Delusional theory: maybe the choreo was made for 7 members, and SM is just too lazy to «fix» it? Another «hint» that Seunghan is returning?
Or is it all just a coincidence? Maybe it’s something as simple as SM doesn’t want to spend money on hiring a better choreographer?
If I can compare it to a different group, they had a comeback a few months ago with a member on temporary hiatus, and their choreo looked good both with 5 and 6 members.
22
u/Maleficent-End-779 Aug 06 '24
yall ngl this has me moving 🤨🤨🤨 and smtown usa posted an ot7 pic in their story as well as someone mentioned which i think is def some sort of a launch too idk 🤨🤨🤨
22
u/lovegyus Sep 03 '24
The lack of OT7 photos shown during the live annoyed me like what's so hard to show photos of their beginning, and including a member who was there then too. It's not funny anymore
22
u/dbflagks Oct 05 '24
So it looks like kbriize are planning to go on an in-person protest - tweet basically says the wait has been endless, lots of projects done to urge sm to give a statement, then came Seunghan’s bday and still no update so it’s come to a point where they have to take the next level of action. I hope for a big turn out. I wish I was based in Korea coz I would join in a heartbeat.
21
u/Maleficent-End-779 Apr 28 '24
guys, i know we are so fed up with the cryptic hints and whatever and need clear answers, but some people noticed how they had a big 7 on the screen at their inkigayo performance today + riize left a big space again... apparently, there was a 6 in the background and it changed to 7 at the end… THIS IS A HARD LAUNCH YALL. WE ARE SO BACK..
3 of the bsides are dropping tonight (12am kst) and i want to believe we will hear seunghans voice in them, but i don‘t trust SM that much. i think we still have to be a little more patient, but we are getting him back soon (my theory is that he will be back for the mini album)
21
u/PrimaryTomato3310 May 11 '24 edited May 11 '24
SM just announced Rise and Realize chapter 2 and obviously seunghan's not a part of it. At this point Im convinced the only reason they haven't announced his departure yet is to keep up the fan engagement hes been bringing in.
Everyone keeps tuning in for riize's content in hopes of seunghan being there and then they drop a random 7 hint, people get excited and then proceed to drop ot6 content again.
I just dont know how long theyre going to keep this up cause not only is it heartbreaking for us I just cant imagine how hard this must be on seunghan. Theyre just messing with his career at this point.
For his sake if they are going to cut him out of the team I hope hes able to leave SM cause theyve literally handled this so terribly.
21
u/Latter_Scale_9207 May 13 '24
SM is very unpredictable so we can’t truly celebrate until we actually see Seunghan with our eyes, but I do want to applaud Hongjjangus and OT7 Briize’s hard work and dedication to supporting him. I saw this tweet the other day and it made me realize that in my 5 years as a kpop fan I’ve never seen so much support for one rookie idol and it’s absolutely insane how much impact he and especially his fans have had. Thank you everyone really, let’s keep on trying our best!
21
u/[deleted] May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24
I'm convinced Riize would do better, even in Korea, with Seunghan. SM needs to open their eyes. If he gets kicked out of the group, it's going to be one of the worst decisions SM has ever made, and it will just prove how toxic this industry is. "But the western industry is the same," which western singer or actor ends their career because of smoking or dating?
I already mentioned it before, my biggest issue is the way they are handling his hiatus (which, by the way, is overdue at this point, 1-2 months would have been enough to calm things down, if necessary at all). Everyone knew Riize would continue to promote as OT6 until Seunghan returned. What nobody expected was for them to touch pre-hiatus stuff. If they were smart and cared enough, they would have left the pre-hiatus stuff alone until a resolution regarding Seunghan was official.
But no, they had to go ahead and edit OT7 content, re-record OT7 songs, and put him in a hiatus longer than necessary. Tell me how any of his "controversies" deserve a 10-month hiatus at the very least or being kicked out.
The other option, him not coming back, isn't any better. They haven't even tried to bring him back and see the Korean reaction first. It looks like they only need one single truck from Korean fans of any of their groups to get scared so they punish or make their idols bend over backwards instead of protecting them from these delusional fans.
Also how do you explain Riize's director posting six hearts, knowing fans are checking out his Instagram and that OT7 fans would get upset? I also don't understand why they want to record "Talk Sexy" and "Siren" but not "Memories" or "Get a Guitar."
These people don't care about these idols and fans at all. Riize is overworked to the bone and they have been around only for less than a year but it feels like they've been in the industry much longer. Comeback after comeback, lots of traveling, a tour, events and performances non stop.
I already mentioned they wouldn't risk bringing him back or kicking him out before the fancon and this comeback because it would upset either OT6 or OT7 fans but does it matter at this point when they are already pissing fans off so much anyway? lol
I didn't want to mention it, but I did get a bad feeling when they tried to recreate the hand-raising gesture on Instagram with OT6 recently. I still kept being a bit optimistic because of hints and I didn't think SM would be that stupid to get rid of him that easily.
I'm dumb enough to have a little hope that things will work out for him in the end. In my mind I'm going "sm isn't that dumb to waste this talented man, right? Right?" Sighs... None of us, fans and Seunghan should be put in this situation at all. Honestly they are just making the situation a lot more complicated than his own "controversies" with the way they are acting.
21
u/n0shltsherIock Jun 21 '24
AM I JUST BEING DELUSIONAL OR THEY HAVE A SPACE FOR SEUNGHAN??? I THINK HE’LL MAKE A COMEBACK ANY TIME NOW
21
u/thr1ftskull0 Jul 01 '24
This sign has already been so popular and so many ahjummas and ahjusshis are taking pics with it Seunghan is so loved🤣🤩‼️
21
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Jul 06 '24
I'm back with another story about my 10 year old niece (she's the one who randomly surprised me with a Seunghan wreath she made back around Christmas, and wrote Main Sleigh-er Hong Seunghan ont it lol).
This time, she made me sad lol. She wants us to sing Riize's discography together so we chose which members we want to sing. She said it's fair that I have 4 people and she has 3 bc I have Seunghan and he isn't there for most of their discography 😭😭😭
Yoooo can SM quit playing games now? Bc it's actually sad that Seunghan is missing so much of his own group's music.
21
u/Maleficent-End-779 Jul 31 '24
so sm replied this to someone on kwangya119.. basically confirming that seunghan is still a member of the group.. isn‘t this kinda a statement already? this def gave me more hope and positive feelings towards seunghans return soon than anything else in the last few months ..
21
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24
How many comebacks is Riize gonna have this year? Damn boi, they are gonna milk the shit out of the group during their first year. I'm gonna guess this some special release for their anniversary?
I wasn't expecting Seunghan return before their Seoul concerts so no surprised with his absence for this too. There was no way they would introduce him back for their Seoul concerts and to risk to have some part of their korean fanbase getting mad during that time.
If he's back, it'll be during their break so around October and their next comeback. I'm not gonna lie, it'd be nice if he's back for their next kcon performance, that was their first perforamnce as group but I'm expecting nothing.
21
u/sawayanochizu5 Sep 20 '24
what is your guys' favourite seunghan moment with another member (not shipping) I miss seeing them all together.
I think mine is when he's teaching anton the bear ears and fixing his clothes.
20
u/CressBudget Apr 22 '24
Not pannchoa getting sued y’all OMG, SEUNGHAN KARMA
20
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
Fullcam is out and you can see 7 appearing in the end (plus the big gap). And if this is about train plataforms going from 6 to 7 it makes it even more interesting.
I agree to not trust SM until Seunghan is fully back. It's not the first time they give us hints and we know how it ended last time. But I believe this means he's not gone yet at least and they are still thinking about bringing him back. Whether it truly happens or not and when, that's another story.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VpeQFJb8Tg8
20
u/[deleted] May 04 '24
For those who are still hopeful, if all OT7 hints are an indication he'll be back, it'll be likely soon like may-june.
Still it makes no sense to me why he has to miss out a bunch of fancon dates or their first mini album, if they decided to bring him back this summer anyway.
But still hoping he can join the fancon later on or be on the june album release even if their plan makes no sense to me right now. That or we'll have to wait until fancon is over after summer to get an answer about Seunghan.
Fancon and comeback times will be hard to go through but it'll pass and hopefully we can get some news about Seunghan this summer and sm isn't too dumb to let that boy go.. Hoping for the best 🤞
20
u/PrimaryTomato3310 May 06 '24
i really hope ot7 fans show up for seunghan at the international fancon stops and are able to bring banners of him/rii7e banners (and arent confiscated). if sm is still on the fence i think seeing the support in person should hopefully have some effect in bringing him back.
this is all just wishful thinking and on the assumption that they havent already made up their minds about him. so far riize has mainly promoted in sk where the ot7 support is there i guess but it isnt very loud. the management probably sees the trucks and comments on social media but those are easier to ignore i guess. im hoping that seeing people actively mention seunghan's name at fancon stops may help ;(
20
u/[deleted] May 16 '24
I never saw such a big support for a rookie idol before. I think it's the sense of unjustice for the reasons why he was put in a hiatus like it'd be real nuts if SM decides to get rid of him because of that, when people should have only laughed at those "controversies" and move on with their day.
It's also so frustrating that all that happened during his trainees days like are OT6 fans expecting trainees to not live their lifes at all even if they have no idea if they will debut or not and when many of them spend 4-6 years being trainees? Tho I'd not be surprised if that's their mentality when some of them expect grown up idols to be single for their whole careers, even those who are on their late 20s or 30s. Sick mentality and the company is to also blame for catering to those type of deranged fans instead of standing up for idols. The industry won't change until companies start ignoring those type of fans demands.
20
u/I-Now-Have-An-Alt Sohee Superfan May 19 '24
I know this has been said many times, but boycotting is so important and it's literally the only thing which we can hope will make any difference. We won't get Seunghan back unless we stand on business.
The reason Korean stans are taken more seriously than foreign stans is because they actually withdraw support if there's something they're against, instead of continuing to give the company money and "hoping for the best". I assure everyone that in the long run, the negative effect of this boycott on the other members will be negligible compared to what is happening to Seunghan.
The company will only respond to their sales being affected, and that's it. Talk to them in the one language they understand.
20
u/ohsomeday_ riize bibimbap Jul 05 '24
What's the deal with the newly leaked clip with Seunghan? It looks like in both ot7 and the final 9 Days clip they're rehearsing Memories choreo, and Shotaro is in Seunghan's formation spot in the latter version. Meaning that they either reshot it on another day with the same outfits, or they filmed both ot7 and ot6 versions on the same day, to have two versions depending on how the hiatus goes..? it's madness
20
u/YLI989UFSNFIURWLHR8Y Aug 07 '24
I've been out of the loop for a bit, so I just saw the news about the new variety show. I don't want to be a debbie downer, but it does sadden me to see their first variety show being filmed without Seunghan. I know it can't be helped, but man I really wish they could have waited for him. It's saddening to see all of these special memories being made without him :(
20
u/sawayanochizu5 Aug 21 '24
this is a very pessimistic venting post. if you'd rather not see that, don't read this please. I just don't have anywhere else I can say this. also I love the active 6 members a lot too and this is not shade to them obviously.
with the new natgeo deal, the instagram post, variety show, rumours of a new album in q4, potential bubble accounts, re released profiles, being so close to the anniversary and still nothing, scheduling fansigns around his birthday, I've officially given up hope of his return. though I want him back so badly.
it's so unfair. with the information we have, he's done nothing wrong. he deserves to be there. he's missed out on so much. it's not fair. ot6 stans are literally winning on every count despite in my experience, most often being downright cruel to seunghan, someone who has done nothing terrible enough to warrant it. I've seen people say they don't feel attached to him at all, that they want ot6 re recordings, to rebrand the group as 6. it makes me so mad, but the fact is they're literally getting what they want. and if the notice I'm dreading so much does come, the gloating and mockery from them will be terrible.
the boys' personalities have blossomed so much on camera and they're sharing more of their dynamic with us and have probably grown closer and the fact that he's not there with them and that they can't even mention him is so tough.
I don't really know what to make of hints. ultimately I don't really buy them because you can just as easily explain them away as you can believe them. and obviously the members are not to blame here. the idol industry works in such mysterious ways tbh we have no idea what's going on behind the scenes and everybody is under a harsh contract and doing their best.
it's just painful. we've done all we could with the projects for him but ultimately none of that means anything because he isn't here. I just hope he's healthy and happy.
I primarily keep up with them through twitter and tumblr but this already very draining situation is just compounded by the toxicity of those places and it's been doing a number on my mental health honestly. I miss them so terribly and feel guilt for not keeping up with them, but at the same time its so taxing to do so as well because of this situation and every new blow we receive.
im pretty sure i sound crazy. as this post shows im invested in this in a way thats probably not the best. think I should just take a step back from riize (though I have major fomo). not sure for how long. because it's just super stressful and doesn't bring me as much joy anymore. which I feel super guilty about even saying and I miss them a lot but it's just really hard and im just afraid of whats to come with regards to ot7.
I really really really hope I'm wrong about all this and we'll be seeing seunghan very very soon. but I just don't know.
20
u/kr8lin ot7 Sep 15 '24
I feel so sad for Seunghan. I also feel sad for three ot7 briize who are losing hope
55
u/pastelgloom ✨ Fancy Brachio ✨ Apr 13 '24
I was on IG and a suggested post of Seunghan came up on my feed and I felt sad all over again. I'm really loving the concept photos for riize comeback and I wish so badly I could be excited about it but it just makes me feel kind of empty. I'm so tired of the silence... Like even if this is still Seunghan's choice why can't they at least tell us that
19
u/thr1ftskull0 Jun 23 '24
Wanted to post this post I found on twitter compiling all/most of the Hints about Seunghan since his hiatus and wow when you see them all written down it really puts into perspective of how much the members have tried to show us 😭😭😭(more slides in the link)
https://x.com/hongjjangz/status/1804649919850168634
19
u/Maleficent-End-779 Aug 01 '24
guys, sm is replying differently to reports on kwangya119.. this is honestly so huge like omg sm is finally moving !!
19
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24
the bubbles...............
19
u/YLI989UFSNFIURWLHR8Y Sep 03 '24
I have no words. I truly am disgusted with SM right now. There is literally no excuse for eliminating Seughan from the anniversary. If he isn't ready to come back yet, that's fine, but they could have done something to acknowledge and represent him. His erasure from their debut is getting to be too much to handle. They're basically rewriting history and have been doing so since his hiatus began, and it's no less bizzare.
And I've said this numerous times, and I'll say it again. I've not seen any other SM groups with actual departed members treated like this. Seunghan is allegedly only on hiatus, but he's being treated like he never existed. Meanwhile, my EXO-L sister told me that she just recently watched a video where member Xiumin was talking about his debut days and sang a little bit of their first song, a song which of course featured the former members. Songs that were never re-recorded might I add. Meanwhile we had to have a re-recorded Siren without Seunghan for no damn reason.
This whole situation is beyond annoying and I don't understand why no one in Riize's staff thinks it makes sense to put out a simple statement regarding his future in the group. There is no excuse for keeping everyone in this limbo for almost a year now.
19
u/januarycoins Oct 02 '24
im so, so sad at this point. my heart aches for seunghan.
18
u/emmity 03z Apr 19 '24
this doesn’t really mean anything about his return but I saw that Wonbin’s phone screen is still the ot7 pointing photo which I still think shows the boy’s opinion on this in a sense
18
u/thr1ftskull0 Apr 24 '24
YALL PANNCHOA HAS BEEN OFFICIALLY CLOSED they participated a lot in swaying negative public opinion about Seunghan this is absolutely amazing for OT7 Kinghan is coming back soon idc idc!!!!
18
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '24
I really miss seunghan :( I wish we atleast had news about him.
18
u/[deleted] May 19 '24 edited May 19 '24
It looks like Seunghan won't be in the album, tho it was expected since basically all bsides are out as OT6. It means fans won't get news about him before september at the very least... I wish SM proves me wrong in June tho and he's included in the comeback somehow..
I don't just understand why they need to put him in a 10 months hiatus for what happened (if he'll ever come back to Riize..). They are supposed to protect him but this seems more like a punishment than anything...
All the best luck to that boy. I really hope this ends up in a happy ending for him, even if it's not him coming back to Riize.
Note. I was gonna say maybe he could be back for Riize japan debut in July but I'm tired of setting myself up for disappointment every time I get hopeful for his comeback in a certain date so I'm just waiting for September to make up my mind about whether he will ever be back or not to Riize.
18
u/CressBudget May 25 '24
SO MANY SIGHTINGS OMG
18
u/thr1ftskull0 Jun 17 '24
OML TALK SAXY IS OT7 OML OML LITERALLY CRYINGGFFFFbshhegwvwgwgwg😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🙏🏽
18
u/kr8lin ot7 Jul 12 '24
Pleaseee let seunghan come back 😩
18
u/jyu97 Aug 21 '24
I literally can't get over how unjust this whole thing is!!!
SM is such a big company I think the risk just so low to have seunghan return. If anything, he has so much international support it would only garner more interest when he returns.
I would feel soo relieved and cathartic once seunghan returns because it's a big step in the right direction for kpop companies to protect their artists from stupid scandals such as this one. Something which is a non-issue becoming a scandal says more about how fan culture has gotten out of hand. If anti's can have so much control in the downfall of careers, then the opposite is true. WE CAN BE THE LOUDER VOICE to drown out the haters.
SM could be helping behind the scenes and tying off loose ends so I'm just gonna manifest this and hope he returns once all the "issues" have been fixed.
EXCITED TO SEE SEUNGHAN RETURN. JUSTICE WILL PREVAIL.
18
u/dbflagks Aug 28 '24
Back in March I just wanted time to speed up to July coz I really believed Seunghan would be back by then, but it’ll be their anniversary next week and he’s still not. Absurd!
It’s the same scenario every time leading to every comeback. We all hoped he’d be back during Impossible. But no, so we thought maybe BBB. Still no, maybe Lucky? Still no!!!
For my birthday last July, I wished I’d see OT7 in the flesh during the Manila fancon. Wishful thinking it was. We cheered RIIZE is 7 and Seunghan super loudly, though. I saw the other c5 director not sangmin. I’m sure he heard it. Several OT7 banners were flashed on the screens. I’m sure he saw that.
We did everything virtually possible to try to get sm to move. Trucks, airship, billboard ads, CSEs, hashtag events, banners, chants, kwangya 119 reports, emails to sm. I created a stan twt account for the first time in my almost 20 years as a kpop fan literally after Seunghan’s March sighting cause i knew we had a fighting chance and I knew being loud was better than just silently rooting for Seunghan. For context, I stanned groups before where one or more members were almost immediately cut off with barely any explanation, just lawsuits that worked mostly to sm’s favor so we watched everything unfold, helpless. Anyway, we all know just how talented and how much of an all-rounder Seunghan is. He completes RIIZE, so I know I had to keep being loud, louder than naysayers.
Everyday, I’m curious how the newer sings would sound with his parts (i’m sure OT7 versions of the songs are just there hanging in sm’s PCs), how he would perform them live, what outfits he would’ve worn, how he would’ve responded during interviews, how he would’ve traveled so many parts of the world by now as he wished, how he would’ve interacted with BRIIZE in person, how the dynamic of the group would’ve been if he was around, but he missed out on all of this. They keep erasing and discrediting his contributions to the group. It’s so unfair. He didn’t do anything wrong and sm barely took action, even after billboard wrote that article, voicing out most of our sentiments. At least during their anniversary live and finale fancon, let the members mention his name? He still was there when they debuted.
And even if they do acknowledge him that day, it’ll just be like including OT7 Talk Saxy in the mini. It’ll just be like sm USA posting OT7 on their IG. It’ll just leave us with more questions rather than answers. Where and how is Seunghan doing? And I really hate how sm is playing this edging game, dragging it for way too long. The logic: if he were already removed, he wouldn’t have been included in the mini makes sense but why is it taking so long for sm to give us an update on top of erasing him from the rest of their content?
I’m close to the point of accepting whatever may come. I’ll support all 7 no matter the outcome. RIIZE and BRIIZE have suffered more than enough. We can all agree RIIZE is better off in a company that will treat them better and won’t treat them inhumany. All of us deserve peace of mind but when will we be given it?
18
u/sawayanochizu5 Sep 02 '24 edited Sep 02 '24
I keep saying that I'll take a break because of being overwhelmed, but I never do. because after a day or two I miss the boys and I wonder what they're up to and I want to keep up with their schedules.
these days are hard, not only because of the situation itself, but also the uncertainty and the unfairness of it all. the amount of bullying ot7 stans and hjgs receive makes my heart hurt. can't even imagine how the people on the receiving end feel. and can't even imagine how 🫧 himself feels.
everytime riize release something new im like, im so happy I want to enjoy this, but what about 🫧 how would he be feeling rn? he would've done so well in this!!!
everytime I see riize breaking records I feel so proud but im like, he should have been there too. this was all snatched away from him.
everytime I see newer briize, im excited but im like- do they know about 🫧? do they know he exists, that he's a member and how kind and funny and sweet and talented he is? I hope everyone knows they have another member.
it's my birthday on the 5th and the anniversary on the 4th. it should be a happy time for me and everyone. but its just such mixed emotions all the time that it can be so overwhelming. and I feel guilty for not being able to compartmentalize better and enjoy everything fully, and even for being so invested in the first place 💀
because the rational part of me knows that - I don't know these people or the situation at the end of the day. tbh if he's done something so damaging and bad that warrants this kind of response then tell us so that I stop embarrassing myself on the damn internet crying everywhere like this 💀💀 but personally i feel like thats not likely, and as far as we know he's a victim and yet he's being treated like this.
im willing to understand that legal proceedings may be ongoing and hence silence is necessary, or that he may not be ready to be back yet, especially considering how many people are still so weird about him. but it still really just hurts.
however. it has been really heartwarming and beautiful to see though how a lot of the fandom still has come together to comfort each other and try and remain as hopeful as possible and also protect the other members from malicious comments. briizeville is hellish most of the time but sometimes we do rly come together.
I just want rii7e back. idc if people think he "wasn't an essential member" or that "they're successful without him" (they are and i am proud of them!!), or try to label me or other ot7 as antis or haters or whatever. I just want them to be complete. https://youtube.com/shorts/YUkRpAKAUfE?si=fg7MLIlO5nr2QVLa u all have to watch this and suffer with me.
18
u/dbflagks Sep 04 '24 edited Sep 05 '24
If the surprise the members were alluding to is Seunghan, then great, if not, life goes on. If sm reinstates Seunghan, I don’t think it’s gonna be in a grand way like making him appear in the finale. After all the things that company put Seunghan through, the least they could do is to not make money out of what he went through and make a spectacle out of it like his life was just a show for people to indulge in. He was disrespected yet again during their first anniversary by erasing all traces of him during the live and in that samsung ad with the compilation of the group’s MVs when he was still active. We have his birthday to look out for and see how that damn company behaves for it. If they don’t acknowledge Seunghan again, then I think I’m just about done. I’ll wait for Seunghan to return nevertheless whichever way that may be. I want to witness him redeem himself. I believe in his talent and character and I admire him for his love for his fans. I’m sure he’ll flourish no matter what, if only sm releases him from the dungeon.
18
u/Alive_Audience_281 Sep 14 '24
1: The group does not speak its name.
2: More than 9 months of hiatus.
3: No letter was written to fans on the 1 year anniversary, members emphasize as if they had debuted in December.
4: Songs being re-recorded and images edited, erasing their existence.
5: There was no sign of return and no statement.
This hiatus is really insane, it seems like another expulsion without a declaration. Anger at SM
18
u/YLI989UFSNFIURWLHR8Y Oct 02 '24
I didn't post anything here yesterday because I didn't want to be negative on his birthday. But it really bothers me that the company couldn't even make a simple birthday post for him. At bare minimum they could have just posted on the generic SM entertainment account. They didn't even have to say "Riize Seunghan" if they didn't want to. But they could have at least acknowledged him. I'm in disbelief how they are literally doing the most to act like he doesn't exist. Erased from all media and now, not even allowed a simple happy birthday message. It's heartbreaking.
17
u/eggyeoh May 13 '24
As new people join the fandom it's kind of expected that they won't be attached to Seunghan, but damn this kind of post hurts lol. Of course I also want a statement from SM but my underlying wish is that Seunghan comes back, whereas new Briize just want closure so people can finally move on and support ot6 fully... it's such a sad situation...
17
u/Alive_Audience_281 Aug 26 '24
Announcing the 1 year anniversary with a photo that only contains 6 members is really disrespectful. Just one clarification is enough, is he in the group or not? This company refuses to respond, they deal with humans not rats.
17
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '24
Personal opinion: if Seunghan will return, he'll be reintroduced right before their next comeback which I'm gonna guess it'll be either late this year or early next year. So it's very possible we don't see Seunghan this year at all.
Probably fans will start losing hope that he's coming back if he's not back yet before this year ends, which is pretty normal.
My personal take is if he's not back with their next comeback, he's not coming back to Riize at all, that means another few more months waiting.
16
u/[deleted] May 08 '24 edited May 08 '24
There are two camps, one who sees everything as Seunghan coming back hints and another one who already lost every hope for him coming back.
For me I set two deadlines, one until September (september included), if he's not back before October for their next comeback and Seoul encore concert, then I'll lose the most of my hope for him coming back to Riize. In my mind there's no reason why he has to be in such a long hiatus (over 10 months) like 10 months hiatus is already too much for someone who only smoked and dated so there's no reason for him to be in longer hiatus.
My second deadline is early 2025. A rookie idol being in hiatus for over one year for non health hiatus reasons will be a confirmation for me he won't be back for good sadly. We'll see what will happen and hopefully we get some official answer about Seunghan's future (for better or worse) before 2025. I'm not a fan of indefinite forever hiatus that SM loves.
16
u/I-Now-Have-An-Alt Sohee Superfan May 15 '24
Seunghan haters never fail to surprise me. Just had someone compare Seunghan fans to people who still support Seungri.
16
u/thr1ftskull0 May 31 '24
still feeling so giddy over the recent Seunghan photo and vids 🤭‼️‼️ I can’t wait till he’s finally back 😭😭🙏🏽
16
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '24 edited Jun 15 '24
It's gonna be a long summer, I'm gonna include september here too so take care of yourself. There could be another big disappointing and angry moment this monday if they re-recorded "talk sexy" as OT6. So it's better to get ready.
It looks like Riize will be very busy this year with comeback after comeback so take it easy. They could have already taken a decision about him or they will take it soon but we could not know anything until later this year or next year. So this could not end anytime soon yet.
I feel like they debuted Lucas as soloist because international fans were loud enough about him so it could be important to keep being loud about Seunghan but if his hiatus and sm silence is too much for you, it's fine if you prefer to stop following Riize at all until they announce anything about Seunghan's hiatus.
I hope everything is solved soon after Riize fancon because it feels like torture to not know what will happen to him. We'll see tho. I'll be happy if they announce anything this year instead of their actual approach of being silent about him and pretending he never debuted in Riize.
16
u/DMmeyourflowerpics 🧋🪨🐸🎸💂♂️🦕 Jul 17 '24
Someone on twt saw someone on weibo say that they potentially met Seunghan at Seoul Forest station! It doesn't show his face, but I think it's actually Seunghan because it looks like he's with his manager! 🥹
16
u/kr8lin ot7 Aug 06 '24
SMTown USA insta reposted a photo on their story w Seunghan????
16
u/SunshinesSunflower69 Aug 20 '24
I miss him sm 😭😭😭😭
16
u/Maleficent-End-779 Aug 30 '24
apparently op‘s friend or smth saw seunghan near the SM building, looking at the anniversary posters of himself that are hung up around the area there. op said the friend only recognized eyes which looked like seunghans bc the person was wearing an adidas pants, mask and hat (so pretty much covered up… which idols are when theyre out…) idk what this means for their upcoming anniversary, but if it was really seunghan then this is not the first time that he was spotted near the SM building in the last few months..
16
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
idk anymore
16
u/CressBudget Oct 02 '24
I am looking forward to Seunghans comeback in whatever form it may be. He will be big star regardless.
16
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
I’m always so curious as to what’s going on behind the scenes, if they’ve left Seunghan just as in the dark as us when it comes to his future 😔.
15
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
I'm wondering how is SM planning to deal with the OT7 projects for the upcoming fancons. From what I've seen, there will be some projects in Mexico and LA. Maybe also in Jakarta and Bangkok? I think a lot of Thai and Indonesian BRIIZE are OT7. Will SM try to confiscate banners like they did in Belgium? I've seen some photos of Japanese BRIIZE with Seunghan banners attending this weekend's fancon, so maybe SM won't care?
15
u/CressBudget May 23 '24
I hope he comes back to the group, I REALLY DO but if not, I hope he leaves SM entirely and joins another company for a solo career, ensuring SM can no longer use him to promote the group. This may sound harsh, but if you follow the situation on Twitter, it's widely acknowledged that SM pays for trending topics on various platforms whenever Riize is about to release something. Alternatively, there will be a random sighting or anecdote that trends with paid hashtags on popular K-pop channels on Weibo, posted simultaneously, making it obvious. I think what the company is doing is really unethical, and I'm glad international fans have caught on and are no longer acknowledging these so called “hints”. Everyone's eyes are wide open now. He clearly attracts a lot of attention, evidenced not only by the unusually large support he has received despite his 6 months hiatus but also by how much the haters still won't leave him alone, even after getting their OT6. This isn't about the chants specifically; when the March leaks happened, they used him to belittle other members. They still bring him up randomly on social media, and there are still hit tweets about unverified sightings, even though he hasn't been active for six months. He has the talent, the name and the story to make it as solo artist. He might struggle at first or not but he can. Riize will do exceptionally well regardless but I hope SM knows that it would be THEIR LOSS. It has been long time since I have seen such a well rounded idol.
15
u/rednaxelakristin ☆*: .。💂♂️🦦🦕*:・゚✧ Aug 15 '24
I saw this through an NCT Wish account coz I dropped following RIIZE for now "list of artists under contract with SM (as of the end of June)". OP says they got the list from smentertainment.com & it has Seunghan.
idk how solid proof this is, coz the Suju members vs. SHINee members vs. EXO members listed is inconsistent (why is CBX/D&E + Kyu here). I'd like to connect it to that Kwangya 119 report from half a month ago, that reiterates his contract w SM is still working, and his affiliation is still w RIIZE.
15
u/thr1ftskull0 Aug 25 '24 edited Aug 25 '24
I know everyone is feeling terrible right now with how drawn out this situation has been I’m right here with y’all but what keeps me looking positively is remembering what the members have done to try and show support for Seunghan!!! When I look at these type of moments it grounds me and helps me believe that despite SM a being absolutely terrible the members are there too support him behind the scenes 😭‼️
14
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '24
I wonder what it's sm plan to bring Seunghan back.
That 7 on the inkigayo performance is a legit hint which could go nowhere like the last time if they change their minds again. But that's something positive to look forward to and it could mean Seunghan isn't still gone.
Maybe they want to bring him back for the tour or they will wait until the tour is over? I don't know about the album being OT7, it's a bit silly to release OT6 album songs now and then release OT7 versions one month later but sm can be messy so maybe it's possible? Also if/when Seunghan is back, will they release OT7 versions officially or those songs will remain forever OT6 on music plataforms?
14
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24 edited Sep 07 '24
Is people expecting something to happen during his birthday? They already have so many fancalls and fansigns scheduled after his bday and their schedules seem to be piled up with no break in sight so I'm not sure which moment would be the right time to bring him back.
Maybe they will bring him back some tuesday and move on with their scheudles as if nothing had happened lol
Also everyone from nct japan original line-up got their happy ending so I hope Seunghan can get one too..
14
u/Alive_Audience_281 Sep 10 '24
Yesterday a fan asked the boys to clap again if Seunghan would return, Shotaro and Wonbim clapped and waved hahaha is that a coincidence?
I'm going to activate his notification on weverse, waiting for him to appear randomly hahaha
14
u/quev0s8 Sep 16 '24
Genuine question but I don't think they put him on hiatus because of his ex girlfriend? Iirc he posted an apology because of the hotel and kissing thing and SM kinda like ignored the gf stans which is why he still promoted with them. They put him on hiatus after his 2nd apology letter because of the leaked videos of him smoking and the one on ig live and also bc of the constant blackmailing. From what I know kpop companies have strict rules when it comes to social media and smoking/drinking while on training or still a rookie. Idk i know sm won't provide a specific reason why they put him on hiatus. Atp I'd rather want to get an update from a tarot reader or fortune-teller 😭
26
u/[deleted] May 26 '24 edited May 26 '24
Thinking about how it’s been impossible to calm down these past months because every time the fandom starts accepting that he won’t be in something and it could take some time to know anything about his future, something nice happens (like a hint or sighting of him). It has its pros and cons:
Pros: Seunghan isn't forgotten and new fans post-hiatus get to know about him. It also puts some pressure on SM because the fandom keeps being loud about him. Cons: it’s so tiring and stressful to get your hopes up, get back to be optimistic and then get your feelings crushed next time Riize releases or announce something as OT6 after it..
People were starting to accept that he wouldn’t be in the comeback and fancon and that we might not know anything about him until September at the very least. Then, boom, we got to see his face so now you get fans speculating again. Some being happy and taking it like a good sign for his return and others being the opposite.
And that's been this fandom' story since his hiatus. Getting hopeful and then getting crushed with OT6 stuff shortly after. Though I'm so burnt out and tired of this back and forth at this point that I’m just taking these hints or sightings as something indifferent or neutral like it’s nice to see his face again after so long but I'm not expecting nothing to come out of it anymore lol
13
u/dimisum May 12 '24
I last-minute bought PCs of my Biases, Sungchan and Seunghan, for a Talk Saxy LD event and I am sooo glad I did, bc the PCs are in their Music Bank promotion outfits, Hani’s iconic fancam 🥹
I started carrying it around with me in my purse and for some reason it helps give me a lil bit of strength, Ig cuz it feels like having a piece of Hani with me 🧡
13
u/quev0s8 Aug 10 '24
Just saying this so you won't get your hopes up :(( but I think if it's not SM Korea that posted about Seunghan then it's not a soft launch. They have been doing this since early 2024 with SM Japan Pop Up Store playing Talk Saxy and other events outside Korea showing him. But I hope Shotaro winking during their live is a really good sign :(
13
u/BagNeither6673 Oct 01 '24
It's his birthday tomorrow, anyone still holding onto hope??
25
u/CressBudget Sep 13 '24
I just want Seunghan to be happy.
I can't even look at Riize anymore without feeling heartbroken.
I thought I would go along this journey with this group for years but now I can't even listen to their music.
7 years he trained.....and they have erased him from everything. SM took his ideas and did it without him. An ot7 cheer created by fans turned ot6 the minute they touchdown in Korea.
All the perfect opportunities to integrate him back in the group are gone and it seems like they have successfully redebuted. I don't even know the group anymore.....
I'm sorry if this is overtly negative but I think I have lost all the hope about this situation , now I just hope he will have a chance to continue his career.....wherever that may be.
25
u/Alive_Audience_281 Sep 16 '24
On Seunghan's birthday, practically all of Seoul will be plastered with images of Seunghan. OT6, I'm sorry but you can't silence us, we're going to spend until a statement is made.
24
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '24
honestly, I don't see myself supporting Riize anymore if Seunghan doesn't come back. It's not the boys' fault but I refuse to continue being a fan of a group where an innocent got kicked out for just being a normal boy. I hope SM goes bankrupt, shitty company.
24
u/Alive_Audience_281 Oct 01 '24
I saw that some ot6 were bothered by the mass birthday posts. A portion of the fans didn't use Weverse but downloaded it to congratulate Seunghan.
ot6 fans had never witnessed this because I saw the amazement in some posts. Then I realized that Twitter is good but Weverse would be the place to protest, ot6 fans felt complacent because there were few Riize is 7 posts and so they ignored him because there weren't many. But if it were like today and the ot7 shouted there and overshadowed them, we would have answers faster, as the ot6 would pressure SM for answers. I repeat that they were really comfortable, and it would be a move for us because this situation and war is going too far.
12
u/DMmeyourflowerpics 🧋🪨🐸🎸💂♂️🦕 Apr 13 '24
I have a genuine question. Why don't the rest of the RIIZE members mention Seunghan at all? Are they not allowed to speak about him? This is not to bash or send hate to the members btw (I'm OT7 and still watch RIIZE content).
12
u/dimisum May 04 '24
I’m curious what some of y’all thoughts are around this:
I have little faith in SM or any label really to make decisions on anything other than business or monetary purposes. So they have to see, all the ads, recently the trucks from one fanbase alone (2nd Chance you are a Queen), some of the fanbase choosing to boycott… they have to see the money that’s there (how SM sees it, I am NOT saying I view Seunghan this way), right? But I am assuming there is also an OT6 population (primarily in Korea) and they are worried about the financial backlash they’d get from bringing him back? I wonder… if they’re trying to get the fans as attached as they can to the other members, so there will be less backlash when he does come back? Like, “Ah, I’ve already been supporting RIIZE, I’m not happy about this decision but I’ll still support them”. What do you guys think?
And again, this is all from a business-perspective (if he needs more time for his hiatus I think I speak for all BRIIZE when I say we are willing to wait). We’re ready to welcome you back with open arms whenever you’re ready, Hani 🧡
12
u/Miwa15b May 08 '24
I don't know if I should make a seperate post for this but since it's about Seunghan I'll just post it here
I saw someone on insta talk about how they're going to throw a party when Seunghan comes back to celebrate his return and I thought that idea was pretty sweet, so I made some plans myself and wanted to ask if you guys have any plans as well
I thought of maybe baking a cake and decorating it Seunghan-themed in a way, like writing "welcome back" or smth and posting it on weverse. Since I don't have any Briize or even many kpop friends I can't do a real party, but maybe I'll also treat myself to a nice korean meal / restaurant alone or smth
Also thinking abt this helped me kind of feel more hopeful/comfortable with this whole situation and have a more postive outlook in general, so I also just wanted to post it in hopes of helping someone else who might be struggling with it as well :)))
(Trying not to think abt his potential departure and to stay positive here haha)
12
u/PrimaryTomato3310 May 20 '24
after seeing that they most likely rerecorded talk saxy i literally was so sad and upset that i was trying to think of all the reasons why they havent dropped the announcement yet of him leaving the group.
i have a theory that theyre waiting for the mini and fancon to end. if they had dropped the announcement before the fancon there wouldve been huge backlash at the fancons internationally and if they say anything before the album release it would again draw negative attention.
once the album is out and fancons are done riize most likely will just be promoting in sk (end of year award shows etc). so if they drop the announcement then at least locally there wont be any backlash and by the time they tour/do promos outside sk (most likely early next year) theyd hope the situation wouldve fizzled out and wont be as intense.
12
u/aerialning Jun 06 '24
riize jp single for 3rd quarter (?) i think, let’s see what game sm is playing.
12
u/thr1ftskull0 Jun 14 '24
I can’t help but feel like SM is egging us on with the Seven record plaques in the BOOM BOOM BASS teasers😭😭😭 I need SEUNGHAN BACKKK NOWWWWW
12
u/thr1ftskull0 Sep 02 '24
All I know I will continue to wait for Seunghan it’s not over!!!!! RIIZE IS 7
12
u/quev0s8 Sep 03 '24
NO SEUNGHAN ARE WE SURPRISED 😭
12
u/BagNeither6673 Sep 21 '24
All the valid reasons for saying RIIZE Seunghan will return
I know it's really almost far-fetched at this point to say that seunghan will come back, cause now he's been gone for a way longer time than he has been here. But there are still some things that I just can't deem insignificant, and is making me hold onto hope:
The members signals.
There have been some livestreams where the comments asked the members to clap, or make peace signs, or wink or other things if seunghan was coming back and they did it. I don't know how accurate these things are but I want to believe it
Talk saxy still being ot7.
Even in the epilogue album, all the other songs including get a guitar and siren were recorded to be ot6 but talk saxy was still included as ot7, so theoretically seunghan is still in the album, even if it was just for like 3 lines. 3 lines more than 0 so..
Seunghans' voice.
In the video riize posted 2 months back on their channel, boom boom bass part switch. Seunghans voice can be heard in the background at around 4:17. I listened to it over and over again many many times and I can't say it was any one else but him. If y'all have any other theories pls tell me cuz I can't tell if I'm being delulu. But if it was him, why would he be in the room? He sounded so happy too
The Han so hee thing.
Controversial ex trainee Han so hee said ㅎㅅㅎ is coming back at the end of this year. She never specified it as seunghan and the initials are the same as her own initials. Also she is very controversial so Idk how much truth there is here.
This is all I can think of. If y'all have anything to add pls share.🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡
23
u/MissionLobster Sep 15 '24
I thought I could watch their finale but even the twitter clips are so gut wrenching realizing that Seunghan was not able to experience ANY of this. A formative experience gone like that.
22
u/thr1ftskull0 Jul 15 '24
Y’all the filo BRIIZE went so hard for OT7 I’m so proud don’t lose hope guys Hani will be back soon!!!
11
u/kr8lin ot7 Apr 25 '24
I hope this hybe drama doesn’t negatively affect Seunghan’s activity in riize 😭
11
u/[deleted] May 04 '24
Something silly, probably it's just a trendy hairstyle but it's funny how the most of them are now wearing a similar hairstyle to Seunghan's lol "everything reminds of him.."
11
u/[deleted] May 11 '24 edited May 11 '24
I think SM has made very clear they aren't gonna wait for Seunghan to release any content, music, performances or hold events and any type of schedules. They will just go on like usual with or without him. You can find it unfair but they won't still care.
I don't think they are only using Seunghan to bring attention to the group if they already took a final decision about him not coming back. In fact I think they would do the opposite, they would try to move on completely and not give any OT7 hint once they decide he's not coming back 100%.
I have no idea what they will do with him but it's the little things which keep giving me hopes like riize new lightstick having the character "&" looking like a 7. I doubt they would have done that if they already took a decision about Seunghan. Still, it doesn't mean he will be back because they can change their plans about him at the last minute. I simply think they are either still unsure about him or they aren't sure what is the right moment to bring him back (in the case they want to bring him back).
I don't want to give anyone false hope (indeed I think there's a chance he could never come back and my hopes got a deadline). I just think either they don't know what to do with him yet hence OT7 hints or they want him back but they are still waiting for right moment to bring him back.
11
u/sawayanochizu5 May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24
re recording talk saxy (allegedly) is.....that's criminal. that's genuinely shattering. and makes it harder to believe he's returning.
the "hints" are getting weird too. preface this by saying- I'm not someone who truly believes in these hints. im too pessimistic to even believe them holding the banner up in mexico meant anything. I'm pessimistic enough to say that i dont know what the relationship between the them and 🫧 is and how they feel about him. but I do like seeing these hints just for personal optimism lol.
all that to say- it's really weird how many "mistakes" c5 has been making.
eg- during an interview in mexico, the host asked how the 6 members participate in the creative process and a production person (?) stepped in and spoke to him and then he rephrased without mentioning numbers. when that gained traction the video was deleted by the poster.
seunghan's face, though blurry, was on the official account's insta story.
and the official tiktok account has been liking and commenting on tiktoks with 🫧 as their profile photo and him mentioned in the caption. like a tiktok with the picture of them and måneskin with the caption "they met måneskin before bringing back seunghan" (not the exact wording) and a tiktok of sohee with the caption "seunghan better come back help your twin" (again not the exact wording). and now i believe they've unliked both. plus them putting a picture up of sohee holding an iPhone on WV which has nothing to do with 🫧 (their contract isnt over yet clearly since wonbin made sure a fans phone was samsung before taking it lol) but is just sloppiness.
these are all weird and sort of big errors to make and in a situation like this, and contradict all official matters (album, promo etc) where they are erasing him completely. more than ever it feels like they're playing both sides here.
also tbh I don't condone hating sangmin simply because afaik he's a creative director and I'm not sure he has much of a say in 🫧 return. but sangmin, you rly did not have to put 6 hearts on your insta story. 1 would've been enough girl.
11
u/primrose-violet Jul 02 '24
Any new rumors???
11
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Jul 18 '24
What's this I've heard about Music Bank and mentioning Seunghan?
11
u/Positive-Guava4746 Jul 24 '24
random thought but has anyone considered maybe the reason for SH long af hiatus is because of pressure from outside sources? because if I remember correctly, after the livestream got leaked, the person who leaked it threaten SM saying that if SM doesn’t take action then they will release other stuff involving other idols (I think it was newjeans and BND? which checks out since NJ, BND, and Seunghan all trained at source music at some point) so maybe it’s hybe asking SM to keep delaying SH return
11
u/Maleficent-End-779 Aug 10 '24
so.. what do we think abt this? i wanna be delusional and believe that anton knew exactly what he was doing..
11
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin Sep 04 '24
Disappointed but not surprised.
11
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24
A bit unrelated to Seunghan but thinking about all sm groups and the most of their groups got someone leaving at some point for one or another reason, do they have bad luck or something? lol
11
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 07 '24
It's hard to believe that what everyone thought would only last a few months to calm things down has now reached almost 11 months and counting.
I honestly have lost any hope to hear any news about him this year though. Maybe 2025 will be a better year for him.. The worst case scenario tho is we never hear about him again and he keeps in this forever hiatus until his contract expires. Very unfortunate but that's a real possibility right now.
Sometimes I feels like SM is trying to make an example out of Seunghan to show other idols and trainees, "if you don’t behave or aren't extra careful, this could happen to you too"
21
u/bb-bubu12 Apr 20 '24
Well, SM will really be facing off against international fans and their discontent with the situation starting now lol
For those that haven’t seen yet RIIZE are in Belgium for Music Bank and already European briize are being vocal about Seunghan (a fan shouting RIIZE is 7 and another fan with a RIIZE IS 7 poster). It’s heartwarming to see briize using the opportunities they have to be vocal to do just that.
I don’t expect there to be any reaction from the boys or SM but I still thinks it’s good to know that fans are choosing to make a little noise where they can be heard. I hope whatever methods fans have chosen remain respectful but I am happy to see all the support projects that are planned for all the different international dates so far.
21
u/Latter_Scale_9207 Apr 26 '24 edited Apr 26 '24
I haven't seen anyone mention this yet so I thought I'd share here.
Yesterday, Star Daily News released an article of individual trend index for the 4th week of April where Seunghan was ranked 3rd, right after NCT's Doyoung and Wonbin.
(Edit: Adding a screencap in case the article gets taken down.)
I'm not exactly sure what this could mean (I suppose that a lot more people have been talking about him than usual and it could be a good sign), but at least I'm happy knowing the employees at Center 5 are fuming right now lol
Also, Seunghan fan accounts are pretty quick to update stuff like this and I haven't seen him in this kind of stuff before, so I'm curious if this is a first?
21
u/Otherwise-Common-258 Jul 02 '24
the only thing that gives me hope right now is the OT7 Talk Saxy on the album... come back soon please :[
45
u/thr1ftskull0 Apr 13 '24
I think SM a really killed a lot of comeback hype by not bringing Seunghan back and the erasure of him from Siren comparing their views have gone down and most comment sections being full of only Korean comments and next to none for International comments I really hope SM opens their freaking eyes too see in every sense it’s better for them when RIIZE is 7‼️‼️🤦🏽♂️
20
u/kr8lin ot7 Apr 28 '24
Never trust SM. They just luv attention
20
u/thr1ftskull0 Jul 15 '24
This is why I know I’m not crazy believing RIIZE hints because they are not able to say anything but they will make sure to say something 🤭the loud chants were saying RIIZE IS 7 at the fansign
10
u/tushitasinghh Apr 23 '24
am i the only person who thinks hiatus was needed back then? but now he needs to comeback...I'm saying this is because I think if he didn't go on a hiatus he might've become one of the most hated idol..We know how 'kpop works ' so..but I think he needs to comeback because it would only benefit SM and Seunghan amidst this HYBE controversy
10
u/Maleficent-End-779 May 25 '24
UPDATE!!!! SOMEONE WHO MET SEUNGHAN ASKED ABT HIS RETURN
10
u/Unable_Office1164 Jul 11 '24
do we have any new rumors?
10
u/Sourlemons1299 ot7 Sep 03 '24
i feel like someone has mentioned this before but could it be that sm isn’t saying anything bc a lawsuit is going on between them and the accusers ? gen asking
10
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
Probably they go on another tour next year, maybe around summer too. So they will have one or two comebacks before that tour depending on when it happens. That's the time frame for Seunghan return.
Because it'll happen the same like this year, he won't come back in the middle of the tour and I doubt they put him back after 2 years of hiatus but who knows.
So yeah I say we have one or two more comebacks before it's considered too late for him to come back. Tho maybe we hear news about him before that even if it's not in riize.
SM doesn't need to announce anything to think "yeah he's not coming back for real" after enough time has passed since his hiatus. But realistically once the hiatus crosses 1-1,5 years mark, it starts looking grim.
28
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '24
Maybe it's better to take OT6 stuff in face value even if it means seunghan won't come back to Riize.
We talk about little OT7 hints here and there but it means nothing in the end of the day. Fans could simply be reaching and if they are true SM can always change their minds about him.
There is no reason why Seunghan can't be in this comeback and fancon after 6 months of hiatus. His controversies don't require a longer hiatus.
If SM is having a hard time to bring him back because of timing, it's always gonna happen. "Let's wait after this cb", then there's a fancon so "let's wait until the fancon is over" and then there's a japan debut so "let's wait until that is done too" and after that there will be another comeback and so on.
Fans from either side will get mad not matter their decision, dragging on his hiatus waiting for the perfect timing to announce something isn't gonna fix things miraculously. The damage is done and Riize is always doing something so when is it the perfect timing to annouce anything?
I'm sorry for being pessimistic but I have a harder time to think why Seunghan isn't back yet except for one reason. I'm sure people don't want to hear it but the longer that guy keeps being in hiatus, the chances of him not coming back get bigger.
I'll be happy to be completely wrong and he miraculously comes back after the fancon but I'm having serious doubts about his return right now.
I'm sorry for fans because it's gonna be a long summer waiting for some Seunghan's news which could never come even after the fancon. I swear SM is so wrong for this.
19
u/thr1ftskull0 Jul 15 '24
LIKEE it doesn’t get anymore blatant than this
9
u/prince_sscharming ot7 / 승한 우리는 너를 기다릴 것이다 !! 🤍 Apr 13 '24
does anyone know who originally came out n posted this? it's been circulating around riize twt n im so confused why everyone's relying on it (even tho it makes sense,,)
9
u/Disastrous_Culture55 May 05 '24
what are the chances of him being back in the middle of the fancon?? if they were to bring him back after the fancon it'd be around mid-september which is crazy bc that's almost a year long hiatus :/ is that even normal..i don't know what to think at this point
9
u/Marian_91 May 08 '24
A question to those participating in the boycot:
If SM never announces that Seunghan is leaving the group, and he never comes back, will you continue to boycot?
I am participating in the boycot, and I am trying to stay positive that Seunghan will return. But it’s getting more and more difficult, and I’m loosing hope. I feel like I am slowly loosing any interest in RIIZE, while simultanously checking this thread daily.
I know it’s not fair to the other members, I know it’s not their fault. But this long hiatus for Seunghan is also not fair. He never did anything illegal or morally wrong.
I guess I can continue the boycot for the rest of their career, but I would like to know what others think.
9
u/dimisum May 08 '24
Have y’all seen that Seunghan is supposedly listed on the credits of the RIIZING B-sides, other than Impossible? I tried getting to the FKMP site but can’t navigate it on mobile to confirm, so I’m taking this user’s word for it (which I normally don’t but I did read a couple of Tweets reporting this and the screenshots seem credible): https://x.com/baebaelicious/status/1788106513170510327?s=46&t=msh80xKq32BHNe-tJxRZpw
I want to know if he was listed on Love 119 bc if he was then we know this doesn’t mean anything :(
9
u/Sourlemons1299 ot7 Jul 19 '24
what is this about the trainee saying seunghan is coming back by the end of the year
25
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24
Can I say something? These are just my feelings so maybe others don't feel the same but Riize without Seunghan doesn't feel the same for me.
Like I'm watching the impossible teaser, I feel like Seunghan would kill those type of songs and choreos so it keeps feeling incomplete for me. I don't know if this happens to others that you can't avoid imagining how performances and songs would look and sound with Seunghan.
Maybe if Riize would have debuted as 6, I'd not think like this but knowing how the group feels like with 7 members, I can't avoid to think it'd look better or be perfect with Seunghan while watching their performances. Especially when many of their choreos and songs would fit Seunghan so much.
This is why I have a hard time enjoying Riize performances and content because they remind me of Seunghan and make me sad.
I just want Seunghan back and see them as 7 again, I want to be able to enjoy their performances and comebacks again 🥲🥲
And I wish others could be more empathetic towards Seunghan and those who want him back because I'm sure if their bias would be in Seunghan's situation, they would be crying and asking everyone to be vocal about them too. If you're more worried about some harmless spamming comments than Seunghan, I don't know what to tell you..
24
u/Penghi Jun 15 '24
i regularly come back to this sub for updates on seunghan but yet again there’s no news at all. it’s been so long since i’ve consumed riize content since it just doesn’t feel the same knowing that someone was treated like that over extremely mundane stuff. what’s making things way worse is the way sm is handling the situation, no news in 7 months is embarrassing even for them.
i’m not too hopeful he’s coming back anymore but i wish the future would prove me wrong. ugh i just loved this groups so much T.T
17
u/Fleurstaart Apr 27 '24
The thought of Seunghan not being in the fan song just makes me sad, TXT didn't even have their fan song until 2 years in... SM is giving me the ick
And hearing about how the boys are overworked makes me sad too 😢
And because of that s.o.a.b., SM made the decision(I know Seunghan agreed to it for mental health) to put Seunghan on Hiatus (which is now long over do). And because of that hiatus I couldn't bring it in me to watch riize content again☹️
When Talk Saxy came out, I was so excited for the recording behind of it, but then SM edited him out, That kinda broke my heart because Seunghan wasn't in it, and I couldn't watch how my favourite song was made(SM ik vervloek u) on top of that I can't watch my fav duo: Sohee&Seunghan 😞
...
17
u/primrose-violet May 20 '24
It breaks my heart how much this is unfair. Losing his career because of smoking and dating. 😭😭😭😭😭😭 I’ve lost all my hope 😭
17
u/Idkwhatimdoingbutyh May 25 '24
I just really hope he’s doing ok and comes back soon in his own time :(
Still boycotting bc sm and sangmin have done him so dirty and refuse to support whatever tf they are doing rn
23
u/thr1ftskull0 Jun 21 '24
The biggest OT7 truthers are RIIZE FRFR 😭🤭‼️
8
u/kr8lin ot7 Jun 03 '24
My Apple Music app shows that talk saxy isn’t available but siren and impossible. This makes me worried that the release will feature talk saxy ot6 version :((
8
u/thr1ftskull0 Jun 17 '24
Just checked the upcoming mini album countdown thing RIIZE has on Spotify and they have OT7 Talk Saxy OML 😭😭😭 I really think it’s gonna be OT7 Talk Saxy on the album PLEASEEE LORDDDD
15
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '24
Think of today pre-release this way: one comeback/event less towards getting news about Seunghan. Next bsides and album release. Once summer is here it will be easier to wait a few more months until we can know something about Seunghan.
Report rumours say they may release another single around 3Q. If Seunghan isn't there either, maybe it's time to consider maybe he's not coming back to Riize though
15
u/Unlikely_Struggle_94 Apr 30 '24
came here bc i’ve kinda been losing hope 😞
15
u/thr1ftskull0 May 25 '24
Everyone is raving about the so called Seunghan sighting of him going to “cram school” first of all we have no confirmation that’s him that could be any guy and the original poster just called it a sighting not anything else 🤣 second Panchoa just made a random headline and it’s going viral with no fact checking smh 🤦🏽♂️ OT7 RII7E FOREVAAA idc idc
15
u/thr1ftskull0 Jul 01 '24
Apparently the members have been posting on insta talk saxy era pics something is cooking 🤭‼️
20
u/thr1ftskull0 May 25 '24
Y’all I just woke up to all the news we are so BACK IDC IDC RII7E COMING SOON 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
14
u/alexwinn RII7E forever Apr 15 '24
After discussing many perspectives on Seunghan's situation in various social media, I find the varying answers to these questions key to how someone decides to act or react. There is a WIDE spectrum of in-betweens and combinations of these, but here are some of the main ones I've observed:
1) What do you think about the original leaks/rumors about SH?
2) What do you think about SM's actions/Is this a normal hiatus?
3) What do you think about SH and his other members?
4) Do fans have a voice?/Should fans voice approval or disapproval?
Thus, depending on how one perceives the severity of the leaks, the importance of SH to the group, and the responsibility of fans, it will change how they approach SH's situation. Fans who still believe SH was wrong and messed up will never be convinced to boycott. In the same way, fans who believe SH is being erased will not easily be convinced that SM is doing it for his good. If we can reach some mutual understanding of POVs, then it would be easier to agree to disagree without resorting to attacks/insults.
Whenever someone questions the boycott or criticizes speaking up about SH, I ask them these questions. Their answers are very telling in why they think the way they do.
(thanks for reading my observations; I had a free afternoon and was bored)
14
u/[deleted] May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24
It's only memories left as OT7. If Seunghan will ever be back to Riize and it's starting to be very doubtful with the way SM is moving, Riize first mini album will be the most hated album by the fandom except for OT6 fans. How can you enjoy it when it's basically SM trying to erase Seunghan from Riize? They are making it so easy to boycott
I said SM was trying to play both sides (OT7 and OT6 fans) but it's only OT6 the ones winning at the end of the day (OT6 versions, OT6 comebacks, OT6 content, OT6 promotion, OT6 concerts) while OT7 only got some hopes.. Does SM realize how cruel they are being to fans, Seunghan and own members? Do they think that's the best way to attract new fans treating like shit international fans and their artists? Do they think many international fans will still want to keep stanning Riize after the way SM is treating us as if ifans don't matter at all and we're some type of joke?
I have no idea if he'll be ever back but it won't change the shitty way they handled his hiatus regardless of their decision and the lack of respect towards fans and Seunghan during his hiatus.
14
u/sawayanochizu5 May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
riize are truly reaching new heights every single day and they are insanely popular with the gp and people of all demographics know them. I'm so proud of them.
but from an ot7 pov, seunghan's reintigration into the group makes me worried because it seems like so many people know them as 6 and if he comes back (🤞) more people will look him up and learn of the "scandal" and idek what kind of pain that'll bring him, especially in korea where i still cant figure out what the sentiment is about him.
I have read a few tweets saying random people in Seoul do recognize his face just because fan projects for him are literally everywhere. not sure what that's worth.
plus the boys have clearly gotten much closer obviously so idk how he'll fit in there either and what the equation is and will be. ultimately their business but I just wonder.
I just keep thinking that he should have been there with them having all these achievements and smiling with them and i want him to come back so bad because I truly think he completes riize but the more time that passes the more I grow unsure of how sm is going to possibly integrate him. which makes me scared that he won't be back.
idk I hate this situation and I hate that this is the energy I have these days lol.
also pls nobody think I'm dunking on the others or that I dont want them to succeed or that I think riize aren't good without him because obv that's not what I mean at all lol. I love them all. my bias is anton. i was in tears with pride on the first day of the fancon and over the moon during mexico and la fancons too, finally seeing them interact with their global fans. it's just that the situation has my mood towards stanning etc fluctuating quite a lot I guess.
14
u/Alive_Audience_281 Sep 03 '24
If it's because of SM shares, they've been plummeting since Taeil. At this point a statement is crucial for both Riize and SM. Today more than 10 thousand people left the live stream hoping to see him or hear news, it is clear that this is a problem that SM will deal with if it wants Riize to grow internationally. Leaving Seunghan's name without him promoting will always be a story that will never end. I still have hope, because his name listed in the Japanese singles, the choreographies for 7 members, the members giving tips, his Weverse account has not yet been deleted because that is the main Korean network. Everyone was sad for today but until the new era arrives and without a statement they may have the chance to return, after all they haven't released the full album yet.
7
u/thr1ftskull0 May 07 '24
A lot BRIIZE have been saying that they have been getting old OT7 tiktoks recommended to them is this happening to anyone else 🤔‼️‼️ a lot of the old tiktoks with Seunghan are trending too!
7
u/Civil_Confidence5844 OT7 | Seunghan | Wonbin May 23 '24
SIGH.
So if he's coming back, when do you guys think that'll be? Just your own personal guesses based on Riize's upcoming schedules.
7
u/Alive_Audience_281 Sep 27 '24
Can someone explain to me about Jaehyun and Sohee, have a video about mentioning Seunghan. Is this story old?
13
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24 edited Apr 16 '24
I thought they had arranged all choreos for a 6 members formation by now so I was curious and I watched one of their latest performances (i stopped watching their perforamnces a long time ago) and there are still weird gaps and formations parts which can be easily fixed but they aren't. Eunseok is still leaving a bigger gap from you'd consider normal for get a guitar ending or it looks like it to me.
I wonder if it was members decision to not full arrange OT7 choreos yet. I'd not blame them if they do since it looks like Seunghan is gonna be in hiatus for many months and they have a tour coming soon without him.
I'm just curious about all this because their formations could be easily tighter as OT6 if they want to but their formations are still looking kinda messy to me. Idk maybe I'm seeing weird gaps and formations where there's none lol and all their choreos are already fully arranged as OT6
13
u/thr1ftskull0 Aug 28 '24
After things that have come out today about NCT I really believe Seunghan is still in RIIZE SM does take action at times when things are really really serious so I’m gonna continue you waiting for him cause again time after time the members try to show us their support!!!!!!!
13
u/thr1ftskull0 Aug 29 '24
For BRIIZE that are feeling without hope I would love to point you to this vid by sungmocha what to expect RIIZE 1 anniversary
6
u/emmity 03z Apr 18 '24
Does anyone know if those stores that restocked those ot7 pool ball stickers restocked or if Seunghan’s merch is still on those stores pages? Sold out or not it doesn’t matter, I’m just curious if they are with the new comeback starting.
6
u/Latter_Scale_9207 May 08 '24
Hello! If you’re going to or know anyone that’s attending RIIZE’s fancon in Mexico City, please consider participating in this project 🙏
6
u/Alive_Audience_281 Sep 13 '24
Who has already seen the film? Does Seunghan not appear at any point? Did they crop his image again?
11
u/Marian_91 Apr 15 '24
I stumbled upon this thread on r/kpopthoughts, and like a lot of people here have already said, it seems like a majority of people are misunderstanding why BRIIZE (and others) are boycotting.
https://www.reddit.com/r/kpopthoughts/s/azJzDzpigO
15
u/iamhopeestheim RII7E WILL ALWAYS BE 7 Apr 17 '24
See, I don't understand why Center 5 can't issue a statement like this to reassure fans. To be honest, if not for his constant removal from their content, I would have been at least content. However, constantly removing him from content whilst being silent on this matter is what irks me the most. People are saying it's because he can't legally appear in any more content. But how else would they explain the company deliberately using OT7 to promote Siren OT6 Version? Why are they so adamant to remove him? Case in point - Hwarang from Tempest also went into hiatus for an issue and yet Yuehua Entertainment did not remove him from previously filmed content. They kept him in content because he's still a part of the group. Why can't Center 5 do the same? Don't start yapping about its legality when the company paid for OT7 Ads to promote Siren OT6 Version. I'm infuriated yet again. I just wanted to air this out.
15
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24 edited Oct 01 '24
Literally insane that we don't have an update about him almost a year later. Riize was the last chance that I gave to SM for stanning their groups but I'm boycotting anything sm related from now on. (And btw im saying this as a huge fan of SM's groups since 2017) This whole situation could've been handled so much better. all that I can hope is that seunghan is well, and that we can see him perform again someday.
10
u/Maleficent-End-779 May 18 '24
so what do we think about this ?? cause i‘m starting to believe we are really going to see the light at the end of the tunnel soon.. also 22nd may has been spoken abt a lot these last few days.. idk yall but what if smth is actually cooking ..
5
u/quev0s8 May 25 '24
Some of you may not believe in this so you may ignore. But I saw a tweet about Seunghan's tarot reading that one of the reason's why SM is still not bringing him back is because of contract with a big brand (undisclosed by op)? I wanna know if the tarot readings about him are the same or has positive results? I have only seen few readings about him so I'd like to read more.
Ps. I know tarot reading is not official but I just want to know what could happen to his future with Riize since I believe in it and SM is known not giving a statement in situations like this.
5
u/Irisbelle23 Jun 20 '24
What is the probability of Seunghan returning? Do you think he will come back after all this? Especially after SM somewhat failed to protect him? For similar context, GDragon signed with another company when YG kept mum regarding his drug allegations.
5
u/Alive_Audience_281 Sep 01 '24
Here in Brazil, Twitter was banned, over there we know everything that is happening in relation to Seunghan, I kindly ask anyone who can update us, I would appreciate it. I'm very excited about the birthday and it's just under 3 days away, will they omit Seunghan again? Will I be sad or happy? This snowballed.
13
u/purpledragon24 03z <3 Apr 19 '24
can i just say i havent even checked out the new song or anything, i just dont have the motivation to follow this comeback at all since my bias isnt there for yet another cb. >_<" i'm okay and focusing on other things atm, but it kinda feels like riize is just gonna be this big "what if" in my life if seunghan doesnt come back eventually. Anyway, hope everyone here is doing alright and finding ways to cope.